thoughts on our current list of possibilities please

[Caip]

I'm only 17 weeks so have ages to go but finally got DH to discuss names at the weekend. What do you think of the below?

Sadie
Polly
Robyn
Libby
Not sure about a middle name but I seem to gave a thing about Primrose!

Johnny
Lawrence (Laurie)
Henry
Caspar
Middle name again not really discussed yet but poss Alexander

Surname is one syllable starting with M

Thanks

I like Sadie, not really keen on any of the boys names but Henry is OK. Please don't call her Polly Primrose!

I like Robyn! In fact, I like Primrose Robyn.
Lawrence Alexander is nice.

Ha! I hadn't tried Primrose with Polly in my head, no I wouldn't do that. I think Sadie Primrose works though

Sorry not keen on your girls names. To me, they are a bit wishy washy. Polly Primrose, sounds like an extra in bally shoes! Sadie is terrible.

However boys are fab.

Johnny Alexander would be marvellous.

Caspar is lovely, underused name IMHO. Henry is a solid name but not as fab as the others.

Like Robyn and Libby (but would Libby by short for something? I think it's good to give them a name with options, for when they're older). Like all the boys names, but Henry is v popular. Lawrence is my fav.

Love Sadie, Robyn, Lawrence an Henry

I have a Johnny Alexander and a Henry so obviously I love those .

For girls I like Sadie and Libby. Love Primrose as a mn for either of them!

I love Primrose

I actually like them all, although I would go for Elizabeth and Jonathan with Libby and Johnny as nns, personally.

Congratulations on your pregnancy.

I love Sadie and Polly but, as has already been mentioned, Polly Primrose isn't great! How about Molly Primrose?

Henry is my favourite out of your boy's names, Henry Alexander is a great name!

Loulou - is your Johnny a Jonathan? I'd want to just go with Johnny. I also wouldn't want Libby to be Elizabeth (Libby is DH's suggestion, not my favourite anyway)
I agree Polly Primrose is awful! No idea what middle name we'd go for with Polly. I don't like Molly at all

I don't like any names that end in y or ie just seem silly and too cutie for me. I am speaking as someone with a nice name who people love to shorten then lengthen again with an ie.

No he is just a John actually. Not many of them around strange as it seems!

John is the greatest name in the world

I love liberty for a girl...dh said no!

Like Robyn and Libby

Really dislike Sadie - sorry. It just sounds "hard" to my ears
Polly is a bit twee for my taste

What about Frankie/Francesca - seems to fit your taste
or
Cassie/ Cassandra

I like Lawrence, but would spell it Laurence

John is really nice. Don't like Jonathan for some reason I can't fathom

Don't like the girls' names, sorry - but like Libby as nn for Elizabeth.

Love Laurence/Laurie.