Are Eloise and Louisa too close to Luis?

[Sanjifair]

I like Eloise or Louisa for a girl (among a long list of other names). A close family member has a son called Luis (pronounced Lewis). Would these names be too close? I also like Lois, but that is definitely too close. The family members are the kind of people who find fault with everything they possibly can, and I don't want an argument.
What do you think?

Yes they are a bit too close. If its just a famy member wouldn't be too bad though!

If not siblings then not too close imo. I love louisa.

I don't think it really matters if you love the names. I have a good friend who named her son George despite the fact that her sister already had a Georgina and it's never been a problem for them (and she a lot of her sister's family).

• sees a lot of her sister's family!

Too close for siblings, not for cousins.

My son would have been Eloise, I love it. I agree, fine for a family member not for siblings.

I was going to say 'too close' thinking it was a sibling- however it is fine for cousins.

I'm with exoticfruits!

Perfectly fine. Eloise is v pretty.

Too similar for siblings but otherwise fine.

Thanks all. They would be cousins, not siblings, so general consensus seems to be that it would be OK.

Totally fine for cousins.

No not to close for cousins imo...

I think they are a bit too close but it should still be ok

It's your baby - go with what you want - fine for cousins.

Perfectly fine for cousins.

I think Eloise and Luis are sufficiently different.

Louisa or Lois are quite similar to Luis imo.