Need a name for ds(3) that goes with William and James

[mummywiththree]

Help! I prefer much more traditional names, dh not English and wants less "stuffy" names (though these are generally ones I love). I particularly like more unusual names (ie uncommon but not bizarre: still traditional). Regal or Rugby playing names are good. I had a list (see below) I love lots of them on the list - dh has vetoed 90% of them... :(

(in no particular order)
Rupert
Harry
Benjamin
Benedict
Oscar
Edmund
Oliver
Caspar
Caspian
Nicholas
Alexander
Edward
Spencer

Be very grateful for suggestions!!!

Well if you go with Thomas then that's all my brothers covered.

Love Benedict and Edmund.
What about Simon or Guy?

Hugh?

Henry would be a really good fit?

Other suggestions:

Sebastian
Theodore (Ted)
Julian
Marcus
Anthony
Richard
Lawrence

I like George and Edward!

Anthony!!! But I would say that it's my sons name!

Matthew
Alexander (shortened to Sandy after the hurricane)
Luke
Daniel
Andrew

Thomas

Edward came immediately to mind when I read the title!

Thomas

Matthew
Alexander
Charles/Charlie

Edward (Teddy)
George
Luke
Thomas is my all time fave boys name

Rupert - the bear with the golfing trews
Harry - a nickname, prefer Henry
Benjamin - lovely
Benedict - lovely
Oscar - lovely
Edmund - lovely
Oliver - lovely
Caspar - ok
Caspian - lovely
Nicholas - lovely
Alexander - lovely but very predictable with William and James
Edward - nice
Spencer - not nice

I love Anthony and Thomas as suggested.

Would you consider
Patrick
Conrad
Michael
Dominic
Samuel
Thaddeus
Matthew
Owen
Casimir
Peter
Leo
Louis
Richard
David
Isaac
Frederick

Clement
Christian
Jonas

Daniel
David
Theodore
Samuel
Jeremy
Oliver
Richard
Thomas

Henry came immediately to mind

Jasper
Saul
Frederick
Michael
Laurence
Harold
Alfred
Archie
Vincent
Christopher
Arthur

Henry
Charles
Quentin
Jonathan
Hugh

Rupert yes ,
Harry no, too many
Benjamin yes
Benedict yes
Oscar no
Edmund yes
Oliver no , too many
Caspar friendly ghost
Caspian love this
Nicholas no
Alexander no
Edward prefer Edmund
Spencer no , absolutely no

Through in to the mix...
Hugo ?
Guy ?

Kings Richard and Stephen reigned in between William and James

Austin
Miles
David
Robert
Alexander
John
Peter

Elliot
Theo
Sedgwick

Alexander is nice