opinions on our shortlists please!

[oikopolis]

Your impressions? And which do you like best for each sex?

GIRL:

Sylvie Rose
OR
Eloise Rose
OR
Eloise Marie

BOY:

Dominic Guy
OR
Vincent Guy

I love Sylvie Rose and Dominic Guy.

Sylvie Rose and Dominic Guy

Same as the others. have always loved the name Sylvie. i do like Vincent as well though, especially Vinnie. but much prefer Sylvie to Eloise.

I prefer Eloise or Sylvia when said in English but Sylvie in French.
Like both boys names but slightly prefer Vincent.

Sylvie rose and dominic guy if vincent gets shortened it will be vinnie guy which sounds like vinegar!

Eloise and Dominic

Eloise and Rose are too similar in sound. Sylvie Rose or Sylvie Marie are lovely. Dont care for Dominic. Like the names Vincent and Guy. Hate Vinnie (reminds me of Vinnie Jones!) but Vince is good imo.

I prefer Eloise to Sylvie but agree that Sylvie goes with your middle names better. However, unless you are going to call your baby by both names, I don't think that matters and would go for Eloise Rose.

I like Dominic much better than Vincent.

Eloise and Dominic

Sylvie Rose & Dominic Guy here too

thanks all. my instincts have been validated i think. they're all nice names so whichever ones seem to fit when we meet her (possibly him) will be OK.

we are in a Francophone country so Sylvie-not-Sylvia would be considered legit, not a nickname iyswim.