My shortlist - opinions please

[language]

We are expecting a girl, and we are looking for a nice name that can be used on English, French and German

Sophie
Alice
Julie
Helene
Mila
Valentine

I love Helene followed by Alice and Sophie although I prefer Sophia. Not keen on Valentine, Mila and Julie.

Sophie is my favourite.

Helene and Alice are ok, though not keen on the others.

Alice.

I suppose Valentine sounds pretentious.

I like Julie and Sophie best.

Love Valentine, although prefer Valentina - love that!

Julie would be Yulie in German.

Alice
have you thought of Lucie?

Are you pronouncing Mila like Millla or like Mia?

Like Alice but lots around

Like Julie but prefer Juliet

Love Valentine

I really like Milla. I am due soon (sex unknown) and my fav names are all French/German!

Like Helena. Helene would be sort of pronounced like this in German wouldn't it? Might have to consider Valentina for the same reason.

Sophie - too common (as in overused)
Alice - I like it
Julie - terrible 70s name
Helene - gorgeous. I would definitely go for this one.
Mila - ok
Valentine - prefer Valentina, but don't like it much.

Alice and Sophie the most interchangeable (and I think nicest...) of all of those in terms of all three countries...

Other suggestions that work in all three lnaguages: how about Anna or Emma (Ema)/Emilie/Emilia - or Laura?/Isabelle/Isabella

I consider valentine to be a boy's name, Sophie is top of the popularity lists, the rest I like, Helene and Julie are my faves from your list

I really like Valentine/Valentina as well as Helene/Helena.

Helene is lovely and I like Alice. Don't like Valentine or Mila at all, sorry. Julie isn't v nice but Julia and Juliet are.

I like Sophie, Alice and Helene.

Not keen on Julie, it's a bit 1970s. Julia nice though.

Mila and Valentine sound like boy's names

Hate Valentine. Don't like Mila. Julie is dated but ok. Love the others.

I like them all except don't like Valentine. I disagree that Julie is dated, I know Julie's of all ages. If I had to choose for my own child, I'd go with Mila, only because Sophie is so popular/overused, but they're all pretty.

I always thought Valentine was the male version and Valentina the female verison.
Helene is the best

In German (French) the female form of Valentina (Valentine) is Valentin.

Thanks for your opinions! It looks like Alice and Helene are the favourites of lovely MN ladies :-)