Can't decide on boy's name. Help

[MrsArchchancellorRidcully]

DC2 due next week. We already have DD (Charlotte) and expecting a boy this time.

We are struggling with names we like/agree on. John would be middle name after my late dad.
Currently luke warm on:

Matthew
Daniel
Nathan
Thomas (DP worries name will be Thomas John...)
Henry (I like, DP not keen)

Surname is unusual and beings with S and rhymes with hake.

All very widely used already - personally I find them a little dull. But if I had to choose, then Henry or Nathan. I'd avoid Thomas John .

I know, they are all a bit mainstream. Problem is, I can't think of any nice boys name that are not mainstream but also not too off the wall. I do like traditional names but unlike girls, there doesn't seem to be much we can come up with. If it was a girl, we'd already chosen Lily and both loved it.

I'd be up for any suggestions anyone has for a boys name.

We both dislike Joshua, Isaac, Oliver, Joseph.

Edwin
William

Or maybe celtic/welsh versions of classic names?

They are all good strong names. I like them all. I would avoid Thomas for the reasons you have given and would also avoid Henry as Harry is very common and your Henry might be shortened to Harry. I would probably.use Matthew as this is a lovely name which is not used a.lot.at the moment.

Have you considered Edward? Edmund? George? Gregory or Arthur?

Edwin is lovely. I'd avoid William because the one I know gets teased with Willy a lot. How about Dominic, Gregory, Quentin, Theodore, Nicholas?

Harrison
Aaron
Peter
Zachary
Gabriel
Michael
Adam

Laurence

Laurence is the female version of Laurent, just like Florence is the girls version of Florent. For a boy I'd use Lawrence.

I love Henry... What about Harry? Jacob? George? Samuel?

What about Christopher, that goes nicely with Charlotte

Nathaniel good strong name and not used to much.

Your due next week wow that's gone quick.
I like Matthew and Henry from your list.

I like Matthew and Henry from your list.

Or maybe Edward? Freddie? Benedict? Rueben?

Henry John - lovely.

Charlotte and Matthew go the best together in my opinion though my fav name is Nathan.

Or how about Benjamin, Edward or Jacob?

Thanks all for the suggestions. I think my favourite is Matthew, although I do like some of the others but DP likes Nathan. Nathaniel is good too.

I think we are going to wait and see what he looks like when he arrives but I think it'll be Matthew or Nathan.