Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

For not giving my toddler sugary snacks?

6 replies

Novbugsy · Today 19:44

I went to a 2nd birthday party yesterday with my 2,5 year old. There’s a group of 8 of us who all have kids between 2 and 2,5.

I was given a hard time by a few of the mums because when offered a fruit shoot I said no thanks and when offered chocolate and cake I also said no thanks. Two of the mums in particular were quite forceful saying it wasn’t fair on my son missing out when his friends were enjoying these things.

I didn’t explain myself to them and my son was quite happy with his water, macaroni and watermelon (served by the host).

He’s had cake on his own birthday and my birthday, the odd packet of party rings and the odd drink of apple juice but other than that I don’t tend to give him sugary snacks or drinks. He’s extremely high energy as it is and I notice that when he’s had something like cake he’s even more hyper and his sleep is terrible that night.

Also to add he doesn’t have a perfect diet and will eat things like sausage rolls, crisps etc so it’s not that I’m against ‘bad’ foods!

AIBU for not being a bit more relaxed about it him having a sugary treat a birthday party?

OP posts:
ToKittyornottoKitty · Today 19:46

Not letting him have cake at a birthday party is a bit mean yes

Shatteredallthetimelately · Today 20:05

Not letting your DC have a fruit shoot and chocolate is fine but as he doesn't have any of these things regularly a small square of cake to celebrate the birthday child's day would have been something id have allowed.

Novbugsy · Today 20:27

He was busy playing when the cupcakes were being passed around so didn’t even notice!

OP posts:
Freshrain · Today 20:50

At this age, I think YANBU.
As you say, he doesn't notice, nor miss these things which he really doesn't need.

As long as you are prepared to revisit as he gets a bit older, then I think YANBU at all. It gets harder with a 2nd or 3rd child, but whilst you only have one, there is no point in introducing things to them they don't need to encounter for now.

Placematsarenotapresent · Today 20:52

Just don't forget that food is a social thing and as he gets older it's a bit of a faux pas to turn down cake at a birthday, unless he has allergies.

Bunnycat101 · Today 20:56

Keep to the water as long as you can. The longer they’re happier with that the easier for you in lots of ways. Eating out has got much more expensive now my 10 year old would like a sprite with dinner. Until she’s was 8 she was happy with tap water. My 7 year old is the same. Cake is something I was more relaxed with from an early point but if your little one wasn’t that bothered, I wouldn’t be trying to force it. You might find it easier to present it as your toddler being fussy rather than you not allowing it. The latter starts to sound a bit judgey and people get defensive. No-one will bat an eyelid at a fussy kid.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread