Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WTAF?!!!! A "nonce or not a nonce" round in an online quiz?!

55 replies

PyongyangKipperbang · 20/11/2026 23:48

Before everyone asks, yes I have left the quiz and complained to the company owner. But my hands are shaking and I am in tears. I have been the victim of rape and sexual assault.

Apparently its "funny" to answer questions about whether a famous man has been convicted or merely suspected (or died in the case of JS) of committing sexual crimes against women and/or children.

I literally feel like I want to vomit, it is a physical reaction. This is a community that I have been a part of since online quizzing became a thing in March 2020, and I am so disgusted that the quiz host (who I know quite well) would do this. Surely anyone with any sense would accept that (given the stats) there would be several women in the room who have been raped, sexually assaulted or been the victim of CSA?!

And what is worse, some of the people who were laughing it off are people I considered to be my friends. This community was the biggest part of my social life (single mother, working and a carer for my parents) and now that's gone.

I said in the zoom chat "I am leaving this quiz now, as a rape survivor I am appalled that this is happening. I have complained to [company owner]"

OP posts:
Waitingfordoggo · Yesterday 21:48

LivingDeadGirlUK · Yesterday 18:13

I think it was a real 'know your audience' topic, not suitable for a public ticketed event at all. Fine for a group of friends who know each other well and like some dark humor. I don't blame you for walking out OP and your friends should be understanding enough to know it was a line for you if not for them.

I agree. I could see how this might be accepted humour within a very small, closed group who know each other very well indeed, and where the quiz is an informal thing, rather than a public event charging money to participate.

As it is, it’s awful. Sorry OP.

Lomee · Yesterday 21:53

Only truly low /sewer class people use the word nonce as a joke. As a PP said, trash clearing itself out.

NewDogOwner · Yesterday 22:00

Shit. I know your posts and your style. You always seem strong and don't take shit. People perhaps were not expecting you to have a sensitive centre. I'm so sorry this happened. The person you messaged is shit. They prob don't mean harm but have not been through this themselves and don't understand. That was so ignorant.

Thinking of you x

watchingthishtread · Yesterday 22:01

I understand your reaction. However, I'm wondering if it might be an option, rather than leaving entirely, to use this as an opportunity to give them a wake up call to cop on to themselves and learn to do better. If you walk away they might choose to see it as a you problem and continue on as they were.

footiefann · Yesterday 22:11

Schrodings · Yesterday 21:37

Not funny, I agree. But you’re being very dramatic about it.

Agree with this. It isn't nice or funny. I have been raped and have been in situations where I've been uncomfortable about the topic of conversation, however to leave a community you once felt a part of because of a tasteless quiz round seems quite a disproportionate reaction. One thing I have learnt is you just cannot expect everyone to share your reaction to things like this. In your situation I would likely have contacted the quiz company and explained to them why it was inappropriate. It is one thing to be offended and upset, but to feel like you're losing your social circle and to feel like you are going to vomit makes me think, kindly, that you need some professional support.

Flamingojune · Yesterday 22:54

As a victim of sexual assault it would not bother me in the least. Gallows humour and all that

PyongyangKipperbang · Yesterday 22:59

Some have called it "dramatic". I call it "Standing up to be counted".

Until we start "dramatically" and publicly calling out things like this, it will keep being trivialised. So I am happy with my reaction in the moment.

What has upset me is the reaction of a so-called friend. What he said was utterly vile. That and the fact that the (small, one man) company hasnt bothered to respond to my email, not even an acknowledgement. I wont give my money to someone like that.

OP posts:
footiefann · Yesterday 23:35

PyongyangKipperbang · Yesterday 17:41

You are entitled to your opinion, but I was there and I stand by my actions.

Sounds like you would fit right in there.

This is such a snarky comment too op. Nothing this poster said was mean or mocking. There is no need for it. When you are unhappy with something, you should raise it in a way that is calm and factual. It sounds like you have completely flown off the handle. I am a survivor of sexual abuse and I have learnt the hard way that you have to deal with your own trauma in order to make your way through the world without having these huge reactions. I thought it was harsh when someone said this to me at first but it has genuinely helped me in the long run.

PyongyangKipperbang · Today 00:10

footiefann · Yesterday 23:35

This is such a snarky comment too op. Nothing this poster said was mean or mocking. There is no need for it. When you are unhappy with something, you should raise it in a way that is calm and factual. It sounds like you have completely flown off the handle. I am a survivor of sexual abuse and I have learnt the hard way that you have to deal with your own trauma in order to make your way through the world without having these huge reactions. I thought it was harsh when someone said this to me at first but it has genuinely helped me in the long run.

How was it snarky? It was factual. They thought it was ok, she thinks it was ok, ergo she would fit right in.

OP posts:
Acommonreader · Today 09:38

HowNowBrownCow33 · Yesterday 18:08

Honestly I think its a poor joke, bad taste yes. But vomiting, never speaking to your friends again, no.

The feeling that you are going to vomit is a trauma response. As a result of trauma I’ve had panic attacks and retching when I think of the events.
With therapy I’ve controlled the panic attacks and live happily. I still get the sudden retching/ sick feeling sometimes and have to control it with breathing exercises. I’m glad you have never experienced this as it’s horrible.

Acommonreader · Today 09:44

Schrodings · Yesterday 21:37

Not funny, I agree. But you’re being very dramatic about it.

Dramatic! Have you ever considered the absolute horror, the pain, humiliation and fear that the victims of a ‘nonce’ go through? It’s not something that people ever really escape from. Just trivialising the name for these perpetrators is disgraceful.
Making it a topic for humour or trivia is shameful and cruel.

ErrolTheDragon · Today 09:49

The fact that some of us wouldn’t experience a trauma response still doesn’t make this subject funny and suitable for a light sociable entertainment event. This wasn’t a biting satirical comedy gig.

BillieWiper · Today 09:51

I just don't see the connection. I've been raped loads of times. They aren't taking the piss out of rape victims. They're taking the piss out of men who could be perverts. It's at the expense of the fact that many male celebs have been done for such things. Not the victims.

I understand you were hurt which is not ok. And I'm sorry you were. But once the organiser apologized I really don't think leaving permanently and losing friends over it is necessary.

Laulon · Today 10:52

ErrolTheDragon · Today 09:49

The fact that some of us wouldn’t experience a trauma response still doesn’t make this subject funny and suitable for a light sociable entertainment event. This wasn’t a biting satirical comedy gig.

Exactly. It was very poor judgement and the subject matter means it’s likely some people may have very strong reactions.

For my money, it’s the response that makes it unacceptable. It doesn’t matter if an individual thinks someone is overreacting or dramatic (especially easy to think if you haven’t been affected), but unusual delays in responding from the owner and a ‘get over yourself’ from a so-called friend would have me leaving this group. They aren’t going to learn from this, and the friend sounds thoroughly self-centred and insensitive.

HowNowBrownCow33 · Today 11:02

Acommonreader · Today 09:38

The feeling that you are going to vomit is a trauma response. As a result of trauma I’ve had panic attacks and retching when I think of the events.
With therapy I’ve controlled the panic attacks and live happily. I still get the sudden retching/ sick feeling sometimes and have to control it with breathing exercises. I’m glad you have never experienced this as it’s horrible.

Op said it was from disgust, not a trauma response. Which I stand by is very dramatic

You can absolutely call them out, explain why its poor taste and not an acceptable topic to joke about in a public quiz, but I dont think its cut your friends off forever and be about to vomit with disgust bad.

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 11:06

PyongyangKipperbang · Yesterday 22:59

Some have called it "dramatic". I call it "Standing up to be counted".

Until we start "dramatically" and publicly calling out things like this, it will keep being trivialised. So I am happy with my reaction in the moment.

What has upset me is the reaction of a so-called friend. What he said was utterly vile. That and the fact that the (small, one man) company hasnt bothered to respond to my email, not even an acknowledgement. I wont give my money to someone like that.

I thought it was strong to make your statement. If people want to make light of very serious and painful subjects, they have to understand they will upset some people.
Then they can choose what type of person they are.

tomorrowfollowstoday · Today 11:08

HowNowBrownCow33 · Today 11:02

Op said it was from disgust, not a trauma response. Which I stand by is very dramatic

You can absolutely call them out, explain why its poor taste and not an acceptable topic to joke about in a public quiz, but I dont think its cut your friends off forever and be about to vomit with disgust bad.

Using the cheap insult 'dramatic' is offensively dismissive.

BunkBedsArePeopleShelves · Today 11:08

ErrolTheDragon · Yesterday 00:43

I’m so sorry. CSA isn’t a topic for light entertainment, these people treating it as if it is should be ashamed of themselves. Flowers

You should hear in mind that in the venn diagram of survivors and those who find such a quiz funny/aren't offended by it...there will be significant overlap.

We're not a monolith

Acommonreader · Today 12:15

HowNowBrownCow33 · Today 11:02

Op said it was from disgust, not a trauma response. Which I stand by is very dramatic

You can absolutely call them out, explain why its poor taste and not an acceptable topic to joke about in a public quiz, but I dont think its cut your friends off forever and be about to vomit with disgust bad.

You are missing the point. The language has the potential to cause real physical and mental reactions from victims. To trivialise and joke about abuse is disrespectful and belittles victims.
I’m very glad the OP wasn’t experiencing a physical trauma response.
Do you know if anyone else in the group was? Maybe you can let us all know how dramatic they are allowed to be?

IAmKerplunk · Today 13:48

I hate the word ‘nonce’ it’s on par with ‘kiddie porn’ - trivialises something that shouldn’t be.

OP I hope you can find a new community who don’t find paedophilia funny, and you make new friends with people who don’t call you dramatic for calling them out.

It’s one thing going to a comedy night or such knowing the kind of material the comic uses, it’s quite another to make jokes about child sex abuse on an online quiz with no warning.

I make jokes about suicide to those who know me best, because my mum died in that way and that is how I cope. I wouldn’t make jokes like that in public without knowing if my ‘audience’ was aware they would be hearing those kind of jokes.

Bunnychubbers · Today 13:55

Totaldramallama · Yesterday 21:45

Sorry I think we absolutely do have the right to joke about the awful things in the world, if we can't then all we'd do is cry. I would quite enjoy that round in a quiz

I agree with this. And I have been raped. I also have a dark sense of humour. I’d find this funny. That in no way means that I don’t think male violence and sexual abuse is a problem and I’ve also been involved with activism around that. I also think nothing is beyond poking fun at and those two stances can coexist. You’re not wrong for feeling how you feel OP as nobody can dictate your emotions but I don’t think it’s a universal response.

IAmKerplunk · Today 14:02

Bunnychubbers · Today 13:55

I agree with this. And I have been raped. I also have a dark sense of humour. I’d find this funny. That in no way means that I don’t think male violence and sexual abuse is a problem and I’ve also been involved with activism around that. I also think nothing is beyond poking fun at and those two stances can coexist. You’re not wrong for feeling how you feel OP as nobody can dictate your emotions but I don’t think it’s a universal response.

But allow people to know there are going to be those kind of jokes/questions? Of course you can’t do that about every single aspect but CSA jokes should have a warning.

AlphaApple · Today 14:47

YANBU OP. Yes, CSA can be a subject for comedic entertainment but only in the hands of a very skilled comedian/performer who is directing the comedic element at the right targets. And an online quiz is not the place for dark comedy. I’m not a fan of performative trigger warnings but if humour is going to dark or adult places they should be in place.

Stand your ground. You are not alone.

IAmKerplunk · Today 14:54

AlphaApple · Today 14:47

YANBU OP. Yes, CSA can be a subject for comedic entertainment but only in the hands of a very skilled comedian/performer who is directing the comedic element at the right targets. And an online quiz is not the place for dark comedy. I’m not a fan of performative trigger warnings but if humour is going to dark or adult places they should be in place.

Stand your ground. You are not alone.

Well said.

ErrolTheDragon · Today 15:40

BunkBedsArePeopleShelves · Today 11:08

You should hear in mind that in the venn diagram of survivors and those who find such a quiz funny/aren't offended by it...there will be significant overlap.

We're not a monolith

Of course. But in such cases anyone with an ounce of empathy and frankly common sense will weigh the potential of hurt to some as far more important than amusing (or at least not offending) others.