Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask, what’s your genuinely unpopular opinion?

307 replies

OneCleverTealBee · Today 19:18

I mean genuinely unpopular. Not something that half the population already agrees with.

What’s an opinion you hold that you know would have people raising their eyebrows, judging you or outright disagreeing with you?

No topic is off limits. Relationships, marriage, parenting, work, money, friendships, social norms, anything.

I’m curious to hear what people really think.

OP posts:
BridgetAndJones · Today 21:05

I agree with surrogacy in certain circumstances and would consider being a surrogate myself if the money was right!

Happyindevon · Today 21:05

AlsoInDevon · Today 21:02

I agree with several of your unpopular opinions.

Whilst autism and ADHD do clearly exist at the extreme end, the vast majority of recent diagnoses are nonsense. When I see an OP mention their diagnosis or when posters start off down the "could they be ND?" route I read no further. There are fewer and fewer threads I read!

I believe that most of this 'neurodiversity' is due to external circumstances - poor parenting, broken families, lack of boundaries and a desire of older adults to excuse or explain a dissatisfaction with life that has nothing to do with neurology. And I think it is people with low agency who reach for diagnoses and themselves and for their children and it is harmful.

I agree about IVF. There is good evidence that there are more abnormalities in IVF children - whether due to older age, genetic issues which caused infertility in the first place is not known. Or wasn't when I looked into it some years ago. I don't think everyone has a right to have children and think IVF should not be provided on the NHS.

Trans people, like 'ND' people, are reaching for a non-toxic label to explain/excuse their bodily discomfort or sexual fetish (depending on the population). They do not have 'wrong-sexed' brains because that is not how neuroscience works.

Splitting up is terrible for kids and should be avoided if possible, by considering VERY hard about who to have kids with and trying much harder in relationships than is currently the trend. Marriage (or some other legal commitment) should come first and if you can't share your finances, you have no business sharing kids.

Love that you’re also in Devon!

Agree with all.

Staying in a boring sexless marriage until your kids are over the age of 18 is far better than splitting and carving their lives up just so you can get laid.

I would never ever ever have kids with more than 1 man and think it’s unacceptable in all but a small handful of rare scenarios (same goes for men)

waitinginwonderland · Today 21:05

AlsoInDevon · Today 21:02

I agree with several of your unpopular opinions.

Whilst autism and ADHD do clearly exist at the extreme end, the vast majority of recent diagnoses are nonsense. When I see an OP mention their diagnosis or when posters start off down the "could they be ND?" route I read no further. There are fewer and fewer threads I read!

I believe that most of this 'neurodiversity' is due to external circumstances - poor parenting, broken families, lack of boundaries and a desire of older adults to excuse or explain a dissatisfaction with life that has nothing to do with neurology. And I think it is people with low agency who reach for diagnoses and themselves and for their children and it is harmful.

I agree about IVF. There is good evidence that there are more abnormalities in IVF children - whether due to older age, genetic issues which caused infertility in the first place is not known. Or wasn't when I looked into it some years ago. I don't think everyone has a right to have children and think IVF should not be provided on the NHS.

Trans people, like 'ND' people, are reaching for a non-toxic label to explain/excuse their bodily discomfort or sexual fetish (depending on the population). They do not have 'wrong-sexed' brains because that is not how neuroscience works.

Splitting up is terrible for kids and should be avoided if possible, by considering VERY hard about who to have kids with and trying much harder in relationships than is currently the trend. Marriage (or some other legal commitment) should come first and if you can't share your finances, you have no business sharing kids.

I would rather my taxes fund IVF than treat the (often ongoing for many years) health problems of smokers, alcoholics, drug users, obese people, etc. Infertility is external and can’t be prevented but we willingly treat self inflicted health conditions for free.

Butchyrestingface · Today 21:05

MaggieBsBoat · Today 20:58

Is it the eyebrows and smoulder?

That's like asking which fresco in the Sistine Chapel most moved me.

Or caused me to scream uncontrollably, in time-honoured Mumsnet fashion.

AllJoyAndNoFun · Today 21:05

Happyindevon · Today 20:59

What’s wrong with sweetcorn ??

Can’t believe you have to ask but since you have 😂

it’s allegedly a vegetable but is sweet. Wrong

it passes undigested through a person. Not food.

it literally is cattle fodder

Happyindevon · Today 21:05

waitinginwonderland · Today 21:05

I would rather my taxes fund IVF than treat the (often ongoing for many years) health problems of smokers, alcoholics, drug users, obese people, etc. Infertility is external and can’t be prevented but we willingly treat self inflicted health conditions for free.

Well my friend who is undergoing IVF is also a smoker and recreational drug user…

Lhori · Today 21:05

Neveragainneveragain · Today 21:00

OK buckle up (and btw in real life I’m your average left-leaning Guardian-reading nice mum, honest!):

  • I can see that people present differently with traits that to a lesser or greater extent are on some of spectrum of what we call both ADHD and autism, but I think it represents personality and upbringing, not something real and defined called ADHD or ASD that we should make allowances for. Instead, parents need to learn how to parent properly- both in terms of boundaries and to teach their children that if they act in these ways that seem natural all to them, there will be social consequences.
  • I believe we might be heading for civilisation collapse and don’t want my grandchildren growing up in a Britain that is predominantly Muslim and non-white.
  • I think people who are anti-abortion should logically also be anti-IVF. I’m not anti-abortion or IVF but I don’t think anyone has an automatic right to a child so I don’t think the NHS should fund it.
  • I think some midlands and northern accents make people sound stupid.
  • I think names are a massive class indicator and I look down on Tylor, Riley, Kayden and Jayden in particular as I automatically think they will be trouble makers.
  • I think Nathan Cofnas wasn’t completely wrong in saying that if it was down to merit alone, black people would only dominate in sports and entertainment right now (NB that doesn’t mean I think some races are inherently cleverer - it just means that CURRENTLY there simply aren’t enough black people excelling academically - not because of inability but opportunity).
  • I think being “outstanding” either academically or in a certain skill can be a hindrance in life and being sociable and kind is more important. And yet nevertheless I’m still one of those normal middle class mums who really wants their children to excel.

I completely disagree with every single one of your points and I vote conservative.

GinaandGin · Today 21:06

VocalFried · Today 19:23

#bekind is a toxic pile of shit.

Most women would do far better to actively try NOT to be so kind all the fucking time.

Agree. There is a very good book called Unkind by Vicki Smith that argues this

JustSawJohnny · Today 21:06

Summer is the worst season by a country mile.

Research will prove a link between the boom in adhd/autism and generational consumption of ultra processed foods.

If single mothers began building villages for their kids by sharing living spaces they would get more support than they ever would have got in a relationship.

White fragility is what stops multiculturalism working.

MaggieBsBoat · Today 21:06

LondonPainter · Today 21:01

Suicide is quite different for men and women. In many cases a man is about to be outed as a paedophile, rapist, fraud or whatever and can’t live with the consequences of that. That’s why the rate is higher for men

Yes and David Walliams is still with us despite his shaky mental health. How very strange.

WarmHiker · Today 21:06

LondonPainter · Today 21:01

Suicide is quite different for men and women. In many cases a man is about to be outed as a paedophile, rapist, fraud or whatever and can’t live with the consequences of that. That’s why the rate is higher for men

Ooooh, that’s an interesting take, had not thought of it like that.

Happyindevon · Today 21:06

AllJoyAndNoFun · Today 21:05

Can’t believe you have to ask but since you have 😂

it’s allegedly a vegetable but is sweet. Wrong

it passes undigested through a person. Not food.

it literally is cattle fodder

I thought the fact it passes through is good for the system?

XenaSharples · Today 21:06

waitinginwonderland · Today 21:01

I don’t mind giving but dislike receiving which many of my friends can’t get their heads around!

But it's not their heads that are involved. 🤣

GinToBegin · Today 21:07

Football is more trouble than it’s worth, and fans who say things like ‘we won xxx’ are deluded. Yes Kevin, of course every time Moneybags FC wins a bauble, the whole team discuss how they couldn’t have done it without Kevin from Braintree’. (Also, Kevin has invariably got all the replica kit and yet has never been to a home game.)

Formula 1 is just pointing a car in the right direction and going faster than the other cars.

The absolute worst pizza topping is prawn. I love prawns, but I’d rather yeet them into the bin than eat them on a pizza.

GinaandGin · Today 21:07

Itiswhysofew · Today 19:40

I'm a people pleaser. I wouldn't reveal what might be unpopular opinions😁

Tell us yours OP.

People pleasers are fake as fuck
Want to be liked over being authentic and are a pain in the arse
They are disingenuous

catornotcat · Today 21:07

Chickpeasniper · Today 21:01

There is a growing social contagion of some people faking vague chronic illnesses, using sticks that they don’t need, pretending that they cannot do basic things, and making all of this their whole identity.

Sex is completely over rated and I think the world would probably be a better place if humans didn’t see it as such a big deal.

I thought sex was over-rated till I met a man who made me realise I’d just been having crap sex all my life. Good sex with a man you genuinely have a strong physical attraction to is amazing.

SukiFluki · Today 21:07

I liked the ending to Game of Thrones.

waitinginwonderland · Today 21:08

Happyindevon · Today 21:05

Well my friend who is undergoing IVF is also a smoker and recreational drug user…

Well that isn’t true though is it? 🤣 I’ve had two rounds of NHS IVF and you are screened for smoking repeatedly with a CO2 monitor or “Smokilyzer”. You aren’t eligible for treatment if you can’t score low enough to rule out any recent smoking.

GinaandGin · Today 21:08

1dayatatime · Today 19:41

I really hate barbecues. I mean why would anyone want to cook their meat over a fire with no guarantee that it is properly cooked when they have a 21st century kitchen available with an oven, grill, air fryer or microwave that can ensure that the meat is properly cooked.

And then to add to the risk it seems pissed up men think that they are expert cooks having singularly failed to cook any other meal all year.

Agree. I hate eating standing up. I want to sit at a proper table with cutlery. Not trying and juggle .. plate... drink.. napin

Newversion2FINAL · Today 21:09

I am going to be slated for this, but I don't understand why a mother with a baby has to get off the bus in order to make way for a wheelchair.

If you're able bodied and the bus is full, the bus is full. Wait for the next one.

Happyindevon · Today 21:09

waitinginwonderland · Today 21:08

Well that isn’t true though is it? 🤣 I’ve had two rounds of NHS IVF and you are screened for smoking repeatedly with a CO2 monitor or “Smokilyzer”. You aren’t eligible for treatment if you can’t score low enough to rule out any recent smoking.

She was smoking last time I saw her! And NOT legal cigarettes!

Gonners · Today 21:09

Alexisclarerose · Today 19:52

I don’t like the Beatles

That's not controversial. I am ancient and didn't like them more than 60 years ago.

Ienvypeoplewithbigkitchens · Today 21:10

And another one. I don't understand the obsession with dogs. Have a baby instead. It will eventually learn to use a toilet rather than shitting randomly in public places. Dogs in prams? WTAF is the point of a dog if it can't walk? Dog ice cream. Not just dog ice cream but a choice of flavours. Again WTAF? Do you ask which flavour dog would prefer before ordering? I despair.

likelysuspect · Today 21:11

Im not shy. I dont really care

Amy Winehouse was overrated
Same with Tom Hardy and Ray Winston, terrible actors
I dont believe in centering children all the time, I dont think the family unit should revolve around them all the time
I dont believe every single allegation of harm/assault should be automatically believed, we dont do that for any other crime, we investigate it and determine what should happen next
I dont believe in naming Palestine as a state
I dont believe in trans or gender
I dont believe that every feeling one has is valid or should be prioritised
Scone rhymes with gone and should have butter, then cream (clotted only) then jam
I like sweet with savoury
There should be a HUGE social housing building programme, bring back rail lines that were closed under Beeching (where possible), stop using 'shared spaces' to prove that you as a local authority or council have cycle and pedestrian routes because invariably they're too narrow for both to use
There should be a HUGE bus network programme introduced (see other tread about some poor woman trying to get to hospital with her daughter)
WLI should be available on the NHS easily, not jumping through hoops
Vaping should be banned.
All new builds should have mandatory solar roof panels.

I mean I could go on but I'll bore you to death.

waitinginwonderland · Today 21:11

Happyindevon · Today 21:09

She was smoking last time I saw her! And NOT legal cigarettes!

Is she between treatment rounds? She might get away with it if she leaves it long enough but my husband hadn’t had a cigarette in two years and still scored higher than me (I’ve never smoked) on the CO2. They said if we scored higher than a certain number treatment couldn’t progress.

Swipe left for the next trending thread