Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How would you handle friend hinting for money

18 replies

Breezeynites · Today 05:20

I should start this by saying I know the friend through the church, there is a big group of us and we take turns having prayer groups and meals at each others houses. All good and I have always done more than my share of this. But there is a spiritual context to the 'problem.'

Friend, let's call her Jane, has recently got divorced, her circumstances have changed a lot. She has moved from the family home which was a massive house with an acre of land and stables, into a small, cramped three bed bungalow which houses her, three adult children and her severely disabled 14 year old son. I feel for her, she has a lot on. Lots of appointments for her son etc. I feel I have tried to be generous (gave her a little cash, have paid for meals, have dropped in a number of gifts and care packages.over the years) but am starting to feel she is hinting regularly for money - could I pay for church gatherings in community spaces to attract more people, also her adult kid needs a deposit for a flat, her youngest needs this toy for Christmas. My husband and I run a business together, we are busy but there is just the two of us. Jane has asked to do some part time work for us several times, has told me how much she can be paid etc.

I have mentioned to my friend that she could now the divorce is sorted try and get some work to do at home, when disabled child is at school also I have mentioned friend can ask ex husband for additional money for kids. Jane says ex husband is a bully and it is traumatic asking for money which I do get.

I don't do well being asked for.money tbh. My husband and I don't have much leisure time because our business is all consuming and exhausting. I feel uncomfortable being asked. I am happy to offer when it works for me but not like this, it feels as though she could become dependant. My husband isn't sure about friend either, says she only talks about herself and is not interested in me but husband isn't someone who really has friends so sees it from a different angle.

It's making me want to put distance between myself and jane tbh.

Any advice welcome! Thanks. I shouldn't have given Jane a little cash that first time she hinted, so I think this is partly my fault.

Do I just keep dodging the hints, do I address this directly when she hints or do I move away from Jane a bit?

My concern is that without working - friend is on UC and disability benefits - this is going to be a long term problem, sadly x

OP posts:
PollyBell · Today 05:24

Another thread with a grown adult acting like a child, just tell her no, she needs clear direction and to be told what is acceptable

sirana · Today 05:25

Do not do it. She isn’t your responsibility in any way and her adult children certainly aren’t.

Tbh in your position I would start to distance myself a little.

Breezeynites · Today 05:27

Thanks for posting. I am not going to do it but just wondering how to handle it... I think distancing might have to be the answer thanks.

OP posts:
justasmalltownmum · Today 05:41

Yes distance yourself. People like this don’t understand hints back.

sirana · Today 05:42

You start from today. If she messages you take much longer to reply (go from same day to 3 days later). If she suggests meeting you are busy but will get something in the diary for when it’s less hectic - maybe after Christmas. If you see her at a church event you must pop to the loo or must just grab a quick word with Michael. If she outright asks for money you respond “I’m sorry, that doesn’t work for me. I no longer lend any money due to our personal circumstances (if she asks you look her directly in the eye and say “it’s personal- I’m sure you understand” and give a smile to demonstrate that you’re not being horrible but the topic is closed. If she says “Lisa really needs a deposit for a house.” You say “ah make the most of having them close for now - time with family is such a blessing” If she says “Oliver really wants an x box but I can’t afford it and he will be so sad” you say “kids are resilient - oh gosh did you hear about Sue’s leg I must just ask if it’s ok” (I find you can get away with a complete change of topic if the thing you’re talking about is clearly more important). She will give up.

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · Today 05:43

If she is just hinting, I might be inclined to just play dumb and pretend I hadn't noticed. If it continues or gets more explicit, then I think I would just say something simple like "I'm sorry, I'm not in a position to help you financially".

If she won't let it drop, then definitely distance yourself. And tell her why if necessary. You are not responsible for her.

RancidRuby · Today 05:46

She lives in a household where she is one of four working age adults, do any of them work?

Belweather · Today 05:46

Are the 3 adult children working? Why not?

The ex should be supporting care for the disabled child.

I’d offer to help with a job search, I wouldnt fund her.

She’s asking ypu be side ypu are easier to ask that her ex. Don’t be.

Betty91 · Today 05:48

I'm sorry she's having a hard time but I think your DH has nailed it. You aren't her cash cow - and I am all for supporting friends but it's not up to us to rescue. I would recommend polite indifference and changing subject. Focus on other people, your business and your own life for a bit. Those subtle shifts are often enough to signal you're not able to provide financial support.

Detemum · Today 05:51

Breezeynites · Today 05:20

I should start this by saying I know the friend through the church, there is a big group of us and we take turns having prayer groups and meals at each others houses. All good and I have always done more than my share of this. But there is a spiritual context to the 'problem.'

Friend, let's call her Jane, has recently got divorced, her circumstances have changed a lot. She has moved from the family home which was a massive house with an acre of land and stables, into a small, cramped three bed bungalow which houses her, three adult children and her severely disabled 14 year old son. I feel for her, she has a lot on. Lots of appointments for her son etc. I feel I have tried to be generous (gave her a little cash, have paid for meals, have dropped in a number of gifts and care packages.over the years) but am starting to feel she is hinting regularly for money - could I pay for church gatherings in community spaces to attract more people, also her adult kid needs a deposit for a flat, her youngest needs this toy for Christmas. My husband and I run a business together, we are busy but there is just the two of us. Jane has asked to do some part time work for us several times, has told me how much she can be paid etc.

I have mentioned to my friend that she could now the divorce is sorted try and get some work to do at home, when disabled child is at school also I have mentioned friend can ask ex husband for additional money for kids. Jane says ex husband is a bully and it is traumatic asking for money which I do get.

I don't do well being asked for.money tbh. My husband and I don't have much leisure time because our business is all consuming and exhausting. I feel uncomfortable being asked. I am happy to offer when it works for me but not like this, it feels as though she could become dependant. My husband isn't sure about friend either, says she only talks about herself and is not interested in me but husband isn't someone who really has friends so sees it from a different angle.

It's making me want to put distance between myself and jane tbh.

Any advice welcome! Thanks. I shouldn't have given Jane a little cash that first time she hinted, so I think this is partly my fault.

Do I just keep dodging the hints, do I address this directly when she hints or do I move away from Jane a bit?

My concern is that without working - friend is on UC and disability benefits - this is going to be a long term problem, sadly x

Tell her i haven't got to give it to her.

Some churches have discrete hardship funds anyways they can offer to you if you're struggling.

TheExcitersBlowingUpMyMindNSoul · Today 05:55

Don't give her anything,it will be ok the boilers went,the car needs fixed etc,so what if her adult kid needs a deposit for a flat so do thousands of other young people.
Make sure the bank of cash cow stays firmly shut.

Mumtobabyhavoc · Today 05:56

I can't work out how three adults living with her aren't helping. Surely she isn't supporting them on her meagre income and looking to friends to pick up the shortfall?

Maisymouse2 · Today 05:57

Tell her no to look for a part time job and that like everyone we all have to provide for our own families.
No idea what the Uc is in the Uk but it is not one elses problem but her own to sort.
If she is that needy I am sure she can ask her ex....without the toxic story it is either a yes or no isnt it

ItsMeee00 · Today 05:59

Distance yourself or make it clear you are not in a position to help/money tied up in the business etc. What do her adult children do to help? Her position is a shame but not your responsibility. Be firm!

Breezeynites · Today 06:01

One of the adult children works, the other two are in and out of part time jobs, they are also in further ed. Jane needs to find an income I have said that to her several times now.

OP posts:
Error404FucksNotFound · Today 06:02

Ignore hints, say no thank you to requests.

SaySomethingMan · Today 06:05

It doesn’t sound like she’s asking you for money? Paying for a church hall isn’t money for her?
She sounds like she’s venting about her financial in front of a friend. Why would she want you helping with a flat for a deposit for her child. Surely not! The child could ask their own father, it doesn’t need to come from her

Bananalanacake · Today 06:06

If her adult kids are working they should be paying towards bills and food.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page