Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hate my child’s primary school?

41 replies

Branchesrain · Today 12:30

Does anybody else absolutely loathe their child’s school?
Dreadful communication, feels very unorganised and changes plans last minute. We moved to the village so we would be in catchment for an outstanding primary School, before child started it was downgraded to good. We were obviously disappointed, but we do love the village and knew it was a possibility this would always happen.
There was administrative error with school applications and I really had to argue tooth and nail to get child’s place which was rightfully theirs.
I’m now feeling so deflated as I’m unhappy with the school and thought I made the right decision moving house to get child into school.

OP posts:
hardliquormixedwithabitofintellect · Today 12:31

Can you move schools?

thehistorymum · Today 12:32

I’d move them. Couldn’t send my child somewhere I hated every day.

Shalalaa · Today 12:33

Is your child happy there and are they learning to read well/ making progress? That’s all that’s matters

CousinBette · Today 12:34

It’s extremely hard to maintain outstanding status. Can you give more than one specific example of poor communication?

Anneleesa · Today 12:36

Yabu because I don’t think ofsted really tells you much and shouldn’t be the yardstick you measure the school by. I know that seems ludicrous but dd1 was at an outstanding school that was re-rated outstanding just after she left but it was awful - children bored, misbehaving and fighting, lack of space and facilities underutilised (eg swimming pool on site they only used twice in y6; IT room they didn’t use at all in Y6 due to bad behaviour).

IME they are all a bit disorganised and you just have to bear with it and rely on the parents WhatsApp to keep things straight.

If the worst thing about the school is the admin, then you’re very lucky!

redskyAtNigh · Today 12:37

Poor communication and organisation are annoying, but how much are they actually impacting your child? Are they happy there? Do they have friends? Are they making progress? Have you raised the issues and what was the school's response? If you've moved to a village for the local school, moving to a different school may mean that you become less involved in the local community, so I would make sure this is really the best option for your child.

Hugeandfedup · Today 12:37

Don't get too caught up on ofsted ratings.

What are your actual concerns?

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · Today 12:38

If the crappy comms is the only issue, then that's fine.

Is she happy, learning, making friends? Then that's the important thing.

Anneleesa · Today 12:39

ps how DD’s old school maintained outstanding status is unclear, but dd said there was outright bribery (children told to all raise their hands if a question was asked - left hand if you knew the answer, right hand if you did not - so that it would look good to the inspector; children told if they behaved perfectly when the inspectors were in school they’d get a bag of haribos each and a day of play and Tv the following week - they did! And so on.

BusyGreySnail · Today 12:39

How old is your child?

I get the impression that many parents expect too much of primary school in reception. They expect it to be an extension of nursery or preschool where they get lots and lots of updates and informations and handovers. They fail to udnerstand that school isnt' like that and instead of say 5 kids to every adult, there's 2 (max) to 30. You just are not going to get the same degree of communication and attention as you did in younger years settings.

Obviously OP you haven't given much context, but the above is worth thinking about.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · Today 12:39

thehistorymum · Today 12:32

I’d move them. Couldn’t send my child somewhere I hated every day.

There's no apparent reason she hates the school? Poor communication about events... Big deal 😆🤷

WandaTheGoat · Today 12:39

I wouldn’t take any notice of Ofsted ratings. My DC went to a Good primary and a Good secondary. If you had to fight for a place, someone else will be happy to take the place.

SJM1988 · Today 12:40

I think hate is a very strong reaction to some communication issues. Honestly I think every school is bad at communication to some degree. I'd be focusing more of how your DD is settling in, progression, learning, is she happy?

The downgrading from outstanding is disappointing but honestly means nothing in reality. Some outstanding school can be shockingly bad, some good school amazing. They just need to tick the right boxes.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · Today 12:42

You should try sending your kids to my sister's school, where the kids are throwing chairs, swearing and repeatedly I can attacking other pupils, low attainment and attendance.

PullingOutHair123 · Today 12:42

How long has your child been there? Just since September?

Whats an example of the poor communication? I ask as one mum in my kids class wanted the full nursery style end of day run down for her child every day, along with what they ate and drank in detail. Which was never going to happen!

BiggerIsAlwaysBetter · Today 12:45

I don't think you are, but I would say that a lot of people at my kids school moan about similar but they tend to be quite involved in childhood generally (so primary carer, reduced working hours, secondary income, very interested in "making memories"). Whereas I work full time, do my bit on the pta and generally just don't give it much headspace.

Neither way is right, but it's the same school and different levels of headspace.

I do think these days we tend to expect high service levels from everything, including schools, in a way that our parents didn't. So whilst I absolutely make my child do homework, music, extracurricular etc, I tend not to worry too much about how the actual school is run, as long as I'm doing my bit.

gurptinkerbell · Today 12:45

I mean, was the admin error the school’s fault or the council’s fault? Is it a church school, and they lost your baptism certificate, or something like that?

I think YAB a bit U. It sounds like it’s all been a massive and slightly anticlimactic faff and it’s brought the tone of your DC starting school down, which is fair, but ‘hate’ is a big reaction. I really like my kids’ school and they’re a PITA with last-minute changes and communication as well. But my kids are happy there and it’s close to our house and the whole feeling of the place is happy and I know they really care about all the children 🤷🏻‍♀️ Vibes are good, even where the volume of emails is not!

Icecreamandcoffee · Today 12:57

Did you visit the school/ research the school before you moved to the village? Never move house just for an outstanding school, as you have found, oftsed ratings change, schools change. You often only need a change in headteacher or a few teaching staff leaving and the school can change entirely.

As someone who taught for years, I put very little consideration into ofsted ratings for schools. Some head teachers are brilliant at ticking the right boxes and getting the right progress in order to get outstanding but actually have very little care for the emotional and mental well-being of the staff and students in their schools. High staff turnover, predominantly young staff - especially in management positions, lots of newly qualified teachers or early career teachers are huge red flags for me. I always look for long-term stable staff, a mix of ages in staff (older as well as younger teachers), I look at what kind of things get displayed and celebrated - are they displaying and celebrating the latest in fad with teaching? Or are they actually celebrating all students? I also visit in person - who takes me round, are the office expecting me, did I get a welcome pack/ information, did I get to visit the classroom and the teacher with children in it. I look at behavior policies and school uniform policies before I go - are the sensible. What does their SEND provision look like? What does their staffing look like.

It it is just communication then I'm afraid you may just be moving school for more of the same. Lots of schools are not great at the whole communication thing and are last minute. I also say you need to beware of expectations of updates if your child has been at day nursery/ childcare provision and moved to school nursery. Some day nurseries literally have 1 member of staff glued to an iPad all day taking pictures and updating records, this does not happen in school.

If your child is happy and settled I would stay where you are.

Coffeecakebakes · Today 12:58

How about becoming a school governor and being involved in helping the school to improve communications and you would also learn a lot about how and why a school operates and be more present in your community.
Small village schools have a rough deal as they do not have the pupil numbers to be financially resilient and this can limit the staffing.

ConsideringBaby2 · Today 12:59

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · Today 12:38

If the crappy comms is the only issue, then that's fine.

Is she happy, learning, making friends? Then that's the important thing.

Edited

^ this
You’re the adult, more importantly is she happy there and settled ?

DeftGoldHedgehog · Today 13:02

What's the teaching and pastoral care like? What's the ethos of the place? How supportive are the parents?

MyKindHiker · Today 13:08

Yep I felt like that towards the end of my son's old school. We moved him after relationship totally broke down - found out that leadership had straight up lied to our faces about things, very evasive. My son was involved in a major safeguarding issue (which they accepted was entirely their fault) which should have been reported to ofsted and we found out never had been. Thought about whistleblowing but didn't want the school put into special measures for the sake of the other pupils. Also galling as had fought hard for him to get in there. It was a pain but I'm glad we moved him - annoyed I hadn't trusted my instincts and moved him sooner.

Planesunflower · Today 13:11

Move school then....

Timeforanothernamechange3 · Today 13:13

How long have they been there? Have they just started reception?
Is the child happy, learning and making friends?

You may find that another local school is similar. It's much harder to get an outstanding rating nowadays; they are few and far between and many that used to be outstanding are now good.

I would move a child for: bullying; feeling they were unsafe in class; lack of SEN support/lack of understanding of their SEN; if I felt behaviour was so bad in the class that they were unhappy and weren't learning. I wouldn't move them on account of admin.

Timeforanothernamechange3 · Today 13:16

BiggerIsAlwaysBetter · Today 12:45

I don't think you are, but I would say that a lot of people at my kids school moan about similar but they tend to be quite involved in childhood generally (so primary carer, reduced working hours, secondary income, very interested in "making memories"). Whereas I work full time, do my bit on the pta and generally just don't give it much headspace.

Neither way is right, but it's the same school and different levels of headspace.

I do think these days we tend to expect high service levels from everything, including schools, in a way that our parents didn't. So whilst I absolutely make my child do homework, music, extracurricular etc, I tend not to worry too much about how the actual school is run, as long as I'm doing my bit.

Gosh, I am the former type of parent you describe and still don't get involved in the PTA! I would think poor admin is possibly more frustrating if you're working full time so have less time to redo things. For example, if sports day moves three times at least I can still probably make it whereas a full time working parent may not be able to rebook leave.