Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Adult child as executor of our will - who to choose?

175 replies

Nimblethimble · 17/11/2026 18:14

If your adult child is an executor, is it the oldest or the one who lives nearest?

Need to redo our will. DH and I disagree about who to ask to be executor (both older DC happy to do so, we would rather not do joint executors as think that may be more problematic).

  • Eldest DC is mid twenties, lives a few hours away, doesn't drive, works full time, lives with gf.
  • Middle DC is slightly younger, lives at home, also doesn't drive and also works full time but in our home town, so if they move out they would still be nearish.

(Also have a younger DC but we both think they are too young for this.)

I think nearest DC should be the first choice. DH thinks the eldest.

YABU (chooses eldest)

YANBU (chooses middle)

And yes, we are encouraging them all to learn to drive but none seem very keen at present!!

OP posts:
FunGoldStork · 17/11/2026 21:29

ExecutorAttorneyAdvicePlease · 17/11/2026 20:27

Many charge a % of the estate so it is in their interest to increase the value of the estate.

Edited

Exactly never appoint a solicitor most take a percentage of the estate as the fee or on top of it!! If the executor needs help they can appoint a solicitor to undertake specific tasks at agreed prices.

SpaceAngel1999 · 17/11/2026 21:39

My husband and his 2 half brothers were executors of their mums will. Eldest didn’t want a part of it when she died so left it to the 2 of them. It wasn’t problematic. Personally I would do joint. You could really offend the other sibling. I know I would if if was in this position

CandidLurker · 17/11/2026 21:44

All 3 siblings executors. Practically I did 90% of the work as I am most suited to do that type of role/work and had the most time. Siblings had to occasionally sign things but not too much. We are reasonable geographically close though and it would have been more difficult when I needed signatures from them otherwise

Soontobe60 · 17/11/2026 21:53

In DH and my Wills, we have each other plus both our DC as executors. Obviously after the first one dies, then the survivor will just have DCs. We havent got a massive estate, and only the survivor inherits, then the DC for the last survivors death.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 17/11/2026 21:56

PeakyPol · 17/11/2026 21:05

Honestly elijahm
has the correct approach. Please don't exclude a DC because of age, competence or such. If your DC get on, they will be completely able to allocate appropriate roles between themselves. In my experience, whilst one is more likely to be able to handle probate etc. knowing their siblings are equally responsible is a huge reassurance.
Being an executor is usually the last thing we can do for a parent. It would be devastating to mark one of your DC as 'lesser'.
A solicitor or a bank is likely to take more than necessary from the estate.

Yes there are stories of banks (particularly) acting as executors, where they've charged a huge amount and dramatically SLOWED down the process of gaining probate and distributing the assets to the legatees....

Maray1967 · 17/11/2026 21:59

We have DS26 and not DS18.
DS26 will be assisted by our solicitor, whereas if just one of us goes, the other is the executor without the solicitor.

Chilly80 · 17/11/2026 22:13

We've appointed 3. BIL and 2 friends and have left them money as a thank you for doing it.

Vaxtable · 17/11/2026 22:14

All three of us siblings are executors for my parents. It hasn’t caused any issues

I would have at least two

saraclara · 17/11/2026 22:22

All three @Nimblethimble because you don't know what their circumstances will be when you die. If you just choose one, what if they're ill at that point? What if they're going through some kind of work stress/have moved to another country/have a new baby?

My brother and I were joint, but I did all the work because I was in a position to do so (even though I lived furthest away) and he was not. Also he'd had more of the burden of mum's care etc, so it was the least I could do. I kept him in the loop throughout, and despite being very different people, we navigated it all well.

avignon1234 · 17/11/2026 22:59

Jointly and severally, all 3 given the situation. You do not know your future circumstances, nor theirs, and as OP have said, much can be done online and the more practical things that a solicitor cannot do, will be done by one or more of your children - it makes no difference to the will. Unless you have a very good reason to cut one out, I think it would hurt. More importantly is LPAO for Health and Financial, as important, or even more important than a will. You are lucky in this, in that your have 4 contenders - your OH, and 3 children, I have 4 children (plus OH) so we are probably going to have to go down the line of 2 for one, 2 for the other as there is a strict limit of 4 in total. I'd also echo another poster when they say have a summary record of things, your assets, your income streams, your wishes, funeral plans, who to contact and so on. They are going to be sad, so don't give them jobs on top to try and work out what is what. Hope this helps x

Topseyt123 · Yesterday 04:24

PuffinIsle · 17/11/2026 20:07

Joint can be a bit of a nightmare. My sister and I were joint executors for our parents and the whole process took much longer than it should have. We love 400 miles apart and at one point I had to drive 7 hours to sign a piece of paper. Either one of us would have been better than both of us.

That wouldn't be an issue now. Legal documents can mostly be signed online these days.

I am sole executor for my DH's estate and joint executor (with my sister) for my mother's. There's plenty of distance involved but it isn't an issue. Many things arrived by email and were signed online without leaving my house. The very occasional thing that has needed a "wet" signature was sent by Royal Mail special delivery and really hasn't been a problem at all.

Mainlining · Yesterday 04:33

Do all three as joint executors. They can divvy the tasks up appropriately. People handle grief differently. I’ve seen people act totally out of character and ride roughshod over other siblings even when they’ve been joint executors.

user1492757084 · Yesterday 04:48

Make it all three (once youngest is 25) and any two of three can sign.
Most important to leave a file with all things relevant clearly contained.
Name of your accountant, your lawyer, where Will is kept.
List of all insurance policies, no. And addresses etc. Car rego details, investments, bank accounts, pensions and private medical insurance etc. Mortgages, car loans etc.
Include a list of what to do first - what to gather, which lawyer to involve. Make sure executer has access to funeral bonds.
Share funeral wishes with children.
In short, make it easy.

SuperSange · Yesterday 05:20

We split it; I live miles away, so I did the emailing stuff. My brother lives locally so he did the in person stuff. It’s worked well.

MyballsareSandy2015 · Yesterday 05:57

Don’t get a solicitor involved. They’ll charge a fortune for something most people could do themselves.

I did the probate for both my in laws, it’s self explanatory online and there’s a great helpline if you’re stuck.

You’d need to find all the financial paperworj/online statements etc to give to the solicitor … so once you’ve found that you can do it yourself.

Zanatdy · Yesterday 06:00

My mum put my brother as he is eldest but he won’t cope, i’ll end up doing it. Told my mum to change it.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · Yesterday 06:05

Hace you done Power of Attorneys {mention:Nimblethimble}@Nimblethimble?

Martin Lewis says this is even more important to sort than wills (we haven't yet😐)

newNannie2026 · Yesterday 06:06

it is irrelevant where one lives, drives/doesnt drive. They are all your children so unless one is totally incompetent they should all be joint executors.

HollaHolla · Yesterday 06:06

Having done this for three family members (an uncle, an aunt, and a grandparent), splitting it was a real boon. Having my brother, and my cousin - on different occasions - to help split responsibilities, and to also chat things over with, was really helpful. It's actually quite a stressful responsibility to carry out correctly, and therefore, the more help you can get, the better. Much of it was done remotely, but we did need to attend the solicitor's a couple of times to sign things, in person. I would ask both your children to share the responsibility.

SnowflakesandSlippers · Yesterday 06:25

HollaHolla · Yesterday 06:06

Having done this for three family members (an uncle, an aunt, and a grandparent), splitting it was a real boon. Having my brother, and my cousin - on different occasions - to help split responsibilities, and to also chat things over with, was really helpful. It's actually quite a stressful responsibility to carry out correctly, and therefore, the more help you can get, the better. Much of it was done remotely, but we did need to attend the solicitor's a couple of times to sign things, in person. I would ask both your children to share the responsibility.

You aren't required to attend in person, if you want to you can request this to be done by secure tracked post or via an online system. We did this as I don't have a job where I can book days off whenever I need them and I didn't want to have the faff of travelling around.

Fooshufflewickjbannanapants · Yesterday 06:25

My mum chose my brother as his name hasn’t changed like mine as I married in her head so they could definitely find him!

she lives with us 😂

QueenofQuilting · Yesterday 06:32

Myself & a sister are Executors of our surviving parent- we are the eldest & middle children of 3 siblings. Me & my husband also have 3 children & decided on our younger 2 as Joint Executors, they live more locally to us & can share the decisions that need to be made then
So I recommend your kids being Joint Executors

ThatMellowPinkSheep · Yesterday 06:36

I’d suggest joint executors (and, assuming you won’t need to invoke this will for a long time yet) then all 3 of them. If they don’t want to do it when the time comes they can always sign over their responsibilities to one of them or to a solicitor. That’s what we did with my late mum’s will.
The crucial issue though is have you asked them and did they agree?

TeensNoMore · Yesterday 06:44

The only admin thing DB and I have had to both be there in person for is setting up a joint bank account and then changing it to be an executors account. Otherwise we have been splitting things or if needed joining a discussion by zoom.

Billybagpuss · Yesterday 06:45

I helped dad with this for his brothers estate.

Put them down as joint executors then If one decides it’s easier to step back and let the other get on with it, they can ‘delay’ their power in writing. There’s a posh word for it which I can’t remember right now but they have to postpone it rather than give it up completely then if anything happens to the other one midway they can pick up where they left off without having any legal problems.