Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go on holiday when signed off work

30 replies

catandstring · Today 14:41

I assume this is permissible although I realise it may not go down well and won’t advertise it. But just want to make sure.

OP posts:
maowmaow · Today 14:57

Was it already booked in advance of being signed off work? And what are you signed off with?

Ive voted YANBU, as sometimes a change of scene can also be good for recovery. Being off should t mean you are stuck at home.

CherryBakewellParent · Today 15:02

I’d say it depends on the circumstances, more detail needed x

MagpiePi · Today 15:04

Being signed off work means that you aren't fit for work, but it doesn't mean you have to be house bound. Obviously if you've been signed off with a bad back and you go on a skiing holiday then it might not go down too well, but if you are off with stress then a week in the sun or sightseeing shouldn't be seen as taking the piss.

BusyGreySnail · Today 15:04

Yep, depends on why. If you, say, are signed off with the flu it's probably not a great idea.

DiNozzoComingBack · Today 15:05

Legally, I think it's probably fine but there's an ethical and perception issue here.

Personally, if you're signed off because you have significant mental health issues, I'd say going away is totally fine and could in fact be seen as helpful. If you're signed off because you have a bad back but you're doing a 5 day hike in the Himalayas, not so much.

Some people within your employers may not take the same approach and think any kind of sign off means you must stay home 24/7.

Bumcake · Today 15:18

Depends why you’re signed off and what sort of holiday it is.

GlitteryRainbow · Today 15:33

I was on long term sick leave for my mental health. Off for a year. I went on more than one holiday and many day trips. It was encouraged by my psychiatrist who would have backed me if I had a problem.

strictlybusinessuntildecember · Today 16:05

lots of people I know who were signed off on the Pat and Mick for “stress” “anxiety” and “depression” who were seen to be visibly living it up on foreign holidays and sporting events etc were the first to be made redundant as soon as there was a reason

duod · Today 16:08

Yes you can go but don’t go about posting it loads on social media

Heatedblankettime · Today 16:09

It depends why you are signed off.

SaraHoliday · Today 16:11

catandstring · Today 14:41

I assume this is permissible although I realise it may not go down well and won’t advertise it. But just want to make sure.

If you have been 'signed off/declared unfit for work' you should be OK. Are you able to say the reason for not being able to work (as in is it physical)? How long have you been signed off for?

I would not make it known you are going away. Are you staying in the UK or going abroad?

I would not post anything about it on social media either.

More information needed for a better answer.

Catza · Today 17:02

Being signed off work means that you are not fit to work. That's all. The rest of your life can go on as normal and there isn't legislation, policy or rule to say otherwise. So ignore all "it depends" comments. It doesn't depend.

Propagandalf · Today 17:31

strictlybusinessuntildecember · Today 16:05

lots of people I know who were signed off on the Pat and Mick for “stress” “anxiety” and “depression” who were seen to be visibly living it up on foreign holidays and sporting events etc were the first to be made redundant as soon as there was a reason

OP, I think it's ok, like others said if you already had something planned. If you're doing something big like abroad then just be discreet. Certainly do not mention the upcoming GTA6 game as that will be blatantly obvious!

We had someone (NHS) who posted photos on the open internet from Egypt, Spain and Jamaica while off on stress for 6 months. Then they would magically get better just before their full pay dropped to half pay. This pissed the rest of us off because we were working to facilitate someone else's lavish lifestyle. After years of this, the management finally woke up when a merger happened and that person was let go.

Ilovefoodandwine · Today 17:32

I did when having cancer treatment and dh did during serious illness. We didnt advertise it on social media though

DiNozzoComingBack · Today 17:38

Catza · Today 17:02

Being signed off work means that you are not fit to work. That's all. The rest of your life can go on as normal and there isn't legislation, policy or rule to say otherwise. So ignore all "it depends" comments. It doesn't depend.

From an employment law perspective, it mostly does not "depend" but from a moral perspective, it might. And ditto, in terms of how you are perceived.

Also, I imagine that a workplace could decide you are behaving in a fraudulent manner if, for example, you are off work because supposedly you have a terrible flu and are then pictured at your local rugby club's weekly social....

GintyMcGinty · Today 17:39

Yes it’s totally fine. You are not fit for work. But that doesn’t mean a holiday won’t do you the world of good.

miIkandhoney · Today 17:40

It might be legally permissible but I would judge you for it, not gonna lie.

I think its taking the piss

PaddyMcGintysGoats · Today 17:40

Well you haven't said what you're signed off with...so 🤷‍♂️

DiNozzoComingBack · Today 17:41

Actually, a very easy rule of thumb is probably this:
Is your illness one that genuinely means you can't work? Y/N.
Is your illness one that means you can't do other things? Y/N

If the answer to the above is Yes and No, then going away is fine. If the answer is really Yes Yes then that suggests that somewhere you are behaving in a way that is not entirely honest

Catza · Today 17:42

DiNozzoComingBack · Today 17:38

From an employment law perspective, it mostly does not "depend" but from a moral perspective, it might. And ditto, in terms of how you are perceived.

Also, I imagine that a workplace could decide you are behaving in a fraudulent manner if, for example, you are off work because supposedly you have a terrible flu and are then pictured at your local rugby club's weekly social....

All you are saying here is "keep your public image clean by not posting on social media about your holidays and socials" which is quite different from "don't go on holiday". I think most people can manage the former.

DiNozzoComingBack · Today 17:46

Catza · Today 17:42

All you are saying here is "keep your public image clean by not posting on social media about your holidays and socials" which is quite different from "don't go on holiday". I think most people can manage the former.

Well, yes, keep your social media clean if you don't want to be caught.

But I'd like to point out that really, my view is that actually, you shouldn't have to hide it if going away is NOT counter to being ill.

So, if you work in an office and are off for stress and burn out - going away would most likely be something your doctor or psychiatrist would recommend. Ditto attending a yoga or exercise class, walking the dog or meeting friends for dinner. You shouldn't need to hide it (although, irritatingly, from a "perception" perspective, you might need to.

If you work on a building site and are off work because you have broken your left arm, there is absolutely no reason why you can't go sit on a beach drinking cocktails while your arm is healing... as long as you are looking after your cast etc and not actively doing something that might slow healing glares at DS who put back his post-concussion recovery by insisting on working too hard at the gym

If you work in a school and are off because you have awful flu and need to be in bed with antibiotics etc, then no, you should NOT be going on holiday or be out at the pub and if you do, you should hide it because yes, you are acting in a fraudulent manner.

So yes, it depends....

Triphazardsareus · Today 17:55

I have to admit that I'd be so annoyed if I was covering someone's work while they were signed off and they were on holiday. It's so stressful when workplaces are left shortstaffed, particularly now that most workplaces are on skeleton staff as it is.

Catza · Today 17:56

DiNozzoComingBack · Today 17:46

Well, yes, keep your social media clean if you don't want to be caught.

But I'd like to point out that really, my view is that actually, you shouldn't have to hide it if going away is NOT counter to being ill.

So, if you work in an office and are off for stress and burn out - going away would most likely be something your doctor or psychiatrist would recommend. Ditto attending a yoga or exercise class, walking the dog or meeting friends for dinner. You shouldn't need to hide it (although, irritatingly, from a "perception" perspective, you might need to.

If you work on a building site and are off work because you have broken your left arm, there is absolutely no reason why you can't go sit on a beach drinking cocktails while your arm is healing... as long as you are looking after your cast etc and not actively doing something that might slow healing glares at DS who put back his post-concussion recovery by insisting on working too hard at the gym

If you work in a school and are off because you have awful flu and need to be in bed with antibiotics etc, then no, you should NOT be going on holiday or be out at the pub and if you do, you should hide it because yes, you are acting in a fraudulent manner.

So yes, it depends....

Edited

I think calling it fraudulent is a bit of a stretch. One may be recovered from the flu (you don't take antibiotics for a viral infection btw) but still not feel strong enough to return to a 9 hour shift. Or they may have lost their voice so can't actually do any meaningful teaching work but this wouldn't prevent them from sitting in a restaurant for a couple of hours. Where is the fraud, exactly?
If someone is bedbound with a cold, I can't think why they would even be interested to know if going on holiday is OK. Presumably, they are too unwell to care at that point.
But, as I said, the employer are not entitled to police or dictate what happens in my personal life just because I am signed off work.

Tiptoethroughthehallway · Today 18:10

It depends on what you are signed off with and how it affects your role.
Lots of things could mean that you can’t work but could go away. I’m off recovering from an operation, I can’t do my job but Dh is taking me off to a little cottage just for a change of scenery.

Bridgertonisbest · Today 18:14

Many years ago I was signed off sick for 3 months. Going on holiday towards the end of that period was the best thing I could have done.

I spoke to gp because I was worried about going and he actively encouraged it.