Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think we should have more annual leave?

177 replies

Letschange · 15/11/2026 23:23

I already get 30 days plus bank holidays which I realise is generous.
This still leaves 220 days working a year about 6.5 times as much.
Should we not try move to a system where the government mandates 10 weeks a year annual leave a bit like school holidays.
perhaps some of the AI productivity dividend could be used here.

OP posts:
WrightSure · 16/11/2026 11:52

watchthetime · 16/11/2026 11:47

I agree with you op. The only thing we are given in life is time, it’s only humans that are forced to sell that that time to other humans.

Time needs to be spent surviving for all species. Because we are “intelligent”, over years we spent time bartering with other humans to help our survival. I catch fish, you catch animal and we share. Or I harvest vegetables and give up some if you help me with your knowledge of herbal medicine. Over time this evolved into money for services. So it’s not like if we all stopped working for money we’d all have tons of leisure time. Instead we’d be hunting and gathering food and water, making and washing clothes by hand, and building huts to live in etc etc. Then defending all what we’ve got from bad and lazy people who want to take it.

So humans are free to choose to not sell “time”. Instead they can live a fully independent life gathering and making EVERYTHING independently. But very few people would want that. You get zero annual leave from that.

XadenRiorsonforPresident · 16/11/2026 12:16

Anarchy99 · 16/11/2026 08:29

And it would cost money for employers to pay for more staff which would then be reflected in prices etc. Which would mean people would need to earn more money, so they would need to work more.

Also, what makes you think that we would have right skills within the unemployed to cover the jobs? Presumably there aren’t many unemployed doctors or solicitors for example, so there would be a disproportionate amount of medium to lower skilled people available.

Thats why said blue sky thinking. Wouldn't be nice of we could think big and long term instead always looking for the negative? The reverse of your point is a business streamlines, uses AI and saves money. Fewer people have jobs so don't spend money and the business folds. There's a balance to be struck. And fewer doctors etc could be addressed if much wider reforms were put in place around education and training and working conditions. If we got more creative with routes into some professions we could widen access. If we looked more holistically at education and social work so fewer children are lost to a meaningful career path by age 11. But everyone is so busy saying no.

watchthetime · 16/11/2026 12:24

WrightSure · 16/11/2026 11:52

Time needs to be spent surviving for all species. Because we are “intelligent”, over years we spent time bartering with other humans to help our survival. I catch fish, you catch animal and we share. Or I harvest vegetables and give up some if you help me with your knowledge of herbal medicine. Over time this evolved into money for services. So it’s not like if we all stopped working for money we’d all have tons of leisure time. Instead we’d be hunting and gathering food and water, making and washing clothes by hand, and building huts to live in etc etc. Then defending all what we’ve got from bad and lazy people who want to take it.

So humans are free to choose to not sell “time”. Instead they can live a fully independent life gathering and making EVERYTHING independently. But very few people would want that. You get zero annual leave from that.

No they couldn’t because all the land is apparently owned so you have to pay, you couldn’t just build a hut or hunt for food because society had made it so you cannot do that.
Land was here before anyone and will be here long after any of us, it was for all humans and species to use, not for someone to claim all of it and insist you pay them for it, food is not available for other humans but it should be, nature provides plants and trees that provide fruit for survival, the sea provides fish and the land has animals but you have to pay other humans for it because someone claims it all and sells it back.
You can’t just hunt and kill animals like all other species do because other humans won’t let you.
And why do you need to buy and wash clothes? Because other humans make us, we weren’t born with clothes, no other animals are forced to buy clothes or get arrested and again have their time taken from them for looking as nature intended the same as no other animal recognises that the land belongs to anyone because another human has said it does.
They don’t recognise this because it’s just an illusion but one we have no choice but to humour.

WrightSure · 16/11/2026 12:34

watchthetime · 16/11/2026 12:24

No they couldn’t because all the land is apparently owned so you have to pay, you couldn’t just build a hut or hunt for food because society had made it so you cannot do that.
Land was here before anyone and will be here long after any of us, it was for all humans and species to use, not for someone to claim all of it and insist you pay them for it, food is not available for other humans but it should be, nature provides plants and trees that provide fruit for survival, the sea provides fish and the land has animals but you have to pay other humans for it because someone claims it all and sells it back.
You can’t just hunt and kill animals like all other species do because other humans won’t let you.
And why do you need to buy and wash clothes? Because other humans make us, we weren’t born with clothes, no other animals are forced to buy clothes or get arrested and again have their time taken from them for looking as nature intended the same as no other animal recognises that the land belongs to anyone because another human has said it does.
They don’t recognise this because it’s just an illusion but one we have no choice but to humour.

My point was if it ALL stopped it wouldn’t be endless leisure time. If NO ONE owned the land or the animals how would you get food? Instead of paying someone for it you’ll have to spend time hunting it. I’m also pretty sure that even if clothes weren’t needed people would start trying to make them pretty sharpish when winter hit. We have evolved as a species to share and swap resources in order to survive. That has now evolved into working for “money” in order to buy what we want. Some people own land which is how they get their money. Others own animals. Others fish. Others cut hair. Others do surgery. It’s all still a way of sharing resources so we don’t have to do it all. Its likely everyone will need a surgeon at one point in their life. No one can do their own surgery. But in order to get a surgeon that person needs to give up time to train. They need someone to train them. Then they need to be compensated for their work. In these modern times this is by money rather than fish.

TeethAreImportant · 16/11/2026 13:03

Our work allows us buy up to 6 extra days leave, unpaid, on top of our current allowance, which is fairly generous. It's then pro-rata'd out across the year, so you don't miss it as much. I'd rather have the leave than the extra pay, so get an extra week. Suggest this to your HR or Union reps if youf work doesn't already do it? Our work introduced it to cut costs at a specific point in time, but it's been so popular all round, they've kept it.

AutumnOakTree · 16/11/2026 13:05

To quote Shakespeare,

"If all the year were playing holidays,
To sport would be as tedious as to work;

Anarchy99 · 16/11/2026 13:10

XadenRiorsonforPresident · 16/11/2026 12:16

Thats why said blue sky thinking. Wouldn't be nice of we could think big and long term instead always looking for the negative? The reverse of your point is a business streamlines, uses AI and saves money. Fewer people have jobs so don't spend money and the business folds. There's a balance to be struck. And fewer doctors etc could be addressed if much wider reforms were put in place around education and training and working conditions. If we got more creative with routes into some professions we could widen access. If we looked more holistically at education and social work so fewer children are lost to a meaningful career path by age 11. But everyone is so busy saying no.

Because the entire world would have to get on board with it. And while some are navel gazing about it, the rest will jump in and push the capitalism model even harder.

What sort of professions would you want to open up access for?

And businesses WILL streamline and have much more handled by AI in any case.

Blueseaurchin · 16/11/2026 14:00

Imdunfer · 16/11/2026 09:17

If we want to retain jobs not lose even more and end up with even more people on benefits when we live in a world that trades globally, please,

tell me how you think we have any option than to reject increasing our already generous leave entitlement.

And that's before we start talking about incentivising employers to invest in more robots and more AI.

Edited

You are choosing to ignore my points.

Places like China use human exploitation and poor work practices. Their competitiveness is based on human misery.

This is not a model that we should follow or praise or try to compete with.

Imdunfer · 16/11/2026 14:23

Blueseaurchin · 16/11/2026 14:00

You are choosing to ignore my points.

Places like China use human exploitation and poor work practices. Their competitiveness is based on human misery.

This is not a model that we should follow or praise or try to compete with.

We are not talking about taking on China's working practices, we are talking about not extending already generous UK leave.

Tiddlywinkly · 16/11/2026 15:12

I'd rather my salary increased. Professional wages in the UK are too low.

ExpectMore · 16/11/2026 17:37

Most organisations allow you to take more annual leave unpaid. Does yours not?

Cottagecheeseisnotcheese · 16/11/2026 18:07

Some businesses like production lines, construction etc rely on the whole team being there so this industries often have annual leave in compulsory blocks like 10 days at Christmas 2 set weeks in the summer
other industries need all hands on deck at certain times so you can't have annual leave in busy periods or you need to take at least 50% of leave in quiet periods

farm workers can't take leave during lambing / harvest etc. finance workers often can't take leave around tax return date 31st january or leading yupto year end around 5th April
if you work in tourism you might not be allowed to use any leave in June to August or have to take 2 weeks at end of january when it's dead

EU law is 20 days minumum it is up to individual coutries within EU whether public holidays are on top or part of the 20 days

MissConductUS · 16/11/2026 18:42

Newname17192864627 · 16/11/2026 06:12

The 10 days in the US is just insane to me. I just can't imagine only having 10 days off in a whole year, sounds so utterly miserable working all day everyday and never really having anything to look forward to.

I know salaries are higher, but meh I could never give up my 30 days for just 10.

Yank here. 10 days is what you get in an entry level job. As you gain experience and seniority, it goes up, usually every five years. When I retired last year I had 25 days of annual leave and 11 paid holidays.

The UK has low economic growth and low growth in labor productivity. More statutory annual leave will make it worse.

Aliceintheattic · 16/11/2026 20:56

Anarchy99 · 16/11/2026 13:10

Because the entire world would have to get on board with it. And while some are navel gazing about it, the rest will jump in and push the capitalism model even harder.

What sort of professions would you want to open up access for?

And businesses WILL streamline and have much more handled by AI in any case.

You realise we made all this up. Finance, employment, technology, everything. It's not like the laws of physics - we invented it. Why do we make ourselves slaves to it?

Anarchy99 · 16/11/2026 23:31

Aliceintheattic · 16/11/2026 20:56

You realise we made all this up. Finance, employment, technology, everything. It's not like the laws of physics - we invented it. Why do we make ourselves slaves to it?

Of course I am aware of that.
What have I said that makes you think I’m unaware of this?

You won’t abolish capitalism. The best you can hope for is that you benefit from it.

Its why people moan about self made billionaires. They would love to have had the skills, imagination and drive to come up with a business model that earns that kind of money. But they don’t so they grumble about those who have become successful.

catgirl1976 · 16/11/2026 23:35

I get 40 days plus bank holidays and bit another 5 which works out about 10 weeks. I also do compressed hours so I get every other Friday off on top. I realise I’m very lucky but honestly this feels about right especially at my advancing age. I’m more productive because I’m not exhausted. Well o am exhausted because I’m 50 and menopausal but not from work.

Anarchy99 · 16/11/2026 23:41

catgirl1976 · 16/11/2026 23:35

I get 40 days plus bank holidays and bit another 5 which works out about 10 weeks. I also do compressed hours so I get every other Friday off on top. I realise I’m very lucky but honestly this feels about right especially at my advancing age. I’m more productive because I’m not exhausted. Well o am exhausted because I’m 50 and menopausal but not from work.

I presume you have a highly skilled job that means the employer feels it’s worth paying (presumably) full time salary for 40-ish weeks a year of actual work though?

I am a few years older than you and think I would go insane with that much time off 😬

Imdunfer · Yesterday 08:28

Aliceintheattic · 16/11/2026 20:56

You realise we made all this up. Finance, employment, technology, everything. It's not like the laws of physics - we invented it. Why do we make ourselves slaves to it?

To feed, house and clothe 8 billion people.

Blueseaurchin · Yesterday 09:24

Imdunfer · 16/11/2026 14:23

We are not talking about taking on China's working practices, we are talking about not extending already generous UK leave.

For goodness sake...

You know full well my response was about the point made that we need accept crappy work conditions in the UK, which includes not asking more leave, if we want to compete with other countries, including the Far East ones .

My point is that these countries are only competitive because they exploit their workforce.

createsomemess · Yesterday 09:28

It’s silly. If we want people to have children then we need to restructure things.

WrightSure · Yesterday 09:31

createsomemess · Yesterday 09:28

It’s silly. If we want people to have children then we need to restructure things.

In what way?

Imdunfer · Yesterday 10:02

Blueseaurchin · Yesterday 09:24

For goodness sake...

You know full well my response was about the point made that we need accept crappy work conditions in the UK, which includes not asking more leave, if we want to compete with other countries, including the Far East ones .

My point is that these countries are only competitive because they exploit their workforce.

Edited

We were talking about increasing an already generous UK leave allocation and you quoted a post of mine and responded to it as if I had personally suggested we should reduce our standards to those of China.

If you don't want me to think you are responding to something I've written in future, then please don't quote my post.

Aliceintheattic · Yesterday 11:47

Imdunfer · Yesterday 08:28

To feed, house and clothe 8 billion people.

We have the technology to do that with comperatively little labour. Instead, we pour that money into increasing real estate prices and billionaire's pockets.

Aliceintheattic · Yesterday 11:49

Blueseaurchin · Yesterday 09:24

For goodness sake...

You know full well my response was about the point made that we need accept crappy work conditions in the UK, which includes not asking more leave, if we want to compete with other countries, including the Far East ones .

My point is that these countries are only competitive because they exploit their workforce.

Edited

There is no way the UK can compete with China. China is 1/5 of the world. Uk needs to do things its own way.

MissConductUS · Yesterday 13:37

Aliceintheattic · Yesterday 11:47

We have the technology to do that with comperatively little labour. Instead, we pour that money into increasing real estate prices and billionaire's pockets.

Real estate prices are a function of supply and demand, just like all goods and services. If you want lower real estate prices, you have to build more housing, which seems very difficult in the UK. If you can change that by "pouring money" into constructing new housing, prices will come down.

Most rich people became that way because they started businesses that provide goods and services people want. Those businesses also create a lot of jobs and pay a lot of tax. If you don't let people keep the money they make, they either won't start the business in the first place or they'll start it elsewhere. Many British entrepreneurs move to the US or other countries with lower taxes and more available capital. Then, unfortunately, the jobs they create and the taxes they pay go with them.

While it's tempting to blame not having everything you want on the evil billionaires, greedy landlords, and house sellers, this type of self-delusion only perpetuates the economic policies that caused low growth and productivity in the first place.