Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

To ask you for the silliest reasons your toddler has cried?

159 replies

HelenaWaiting · 15/11/2026 18:33

Having raised several toddlers over many years I offer a small part of my collected favourites:
Because I wouldn't let him go to bed in his new wellies;
Because the snowflake he was holding melted;
Because the filling fell out of his sandwich.
Because he wanted a cat. "But sweetheart we have a cat" "Not our cat, nuther cat."
Because the woman reading the news on the telly "went away".
Because his uncle had a torch.
Because my Dad asked him if he wanted a drink.

OP posts:
Empra123 · 17/11/2026 17:28

Because we drove past a yellow car but it was on her sister's side of the car. That tantrum has gone down in family legend!

anotheruninspiringusername · 17/11/2026 17:30

Because he waved a dog and the dog didn’t wave back..

scalt · 17/11/2026 17:58

I’m told I had a tantrum because when it was my turn to pin the tail on the donkey, I couldn’t see! Sad

HelenaWaiting · 17/11/2026 21:58

scalt · 17/11/2026 17:58

I’m told I had a tantrum because when it was my turn to pin the tail on the donkey, I couldn’t see! Sad

To be fair, you had a point.

OP posts:
PearlClutzsche · 17/11/2026 22:33

DD was hysterical on realising that the hard part of her elbow was a bone. She was totally freaked out by this, as she didn’t want a bone inside her.
She asked if we could take it out and give it to a dog!

LadybirdDaphne · Yesterday 05:50

My brother aged 3ish was also freaked out by the idea he had a skeleton inside him, because a skeleton was a sort of monster as far as he was concerned.

sightingday · Yesterday 08:11

She didn’t want toes anymore and I wouldn’t cut them off for her.
wouldn’t let her keep the mouse the cat brought in as a pet, it was dead.
wouldn’t let her take half a brick to bed to cuddle while she slept.
she’s an odd one.

scalt · Yesterday 08:54

sightingday · Yesterday 08:11

She didn’t want toes anymore and I wouldn’t cut them off for her.
wouldn’t let her keep the mouse the cat brought in as a pet, it was dead.
wouldn’t let her take half a brick to bed to cuddle while she slept.
she’s an odd one.

The toes one reminds me of another tantrum my mum told me I had. I once really freaked out when in summer, she buckled my Mary Jane shoes on to my bare feet, and I screamed "my toes are stuck!" (She said I often resisted shoes being put on me.)

HelenaWaiting · Yesterday 09:54

It's a family legend that I arrived home, age 11, in floods of tears because 'a policeman flashed at me'. Turned out he'd flashed his headlights (it was a dull January afternoon) to let me know it was safe to cross the road. For some reason I thought this meant my arrest was imminent. Absolutely not a toddler, definitely a drama queen.

OP posts:
SafeAndStranded · Yesterday 09:58

DD1 because she had nothing in her hands.
DD2 because she wasnt at my wedding 3 years before she was born and another time that she wasn't a cat

InveterateWineDrinker · Yesterday 10:02

I thought of this thread this morning. Came across two boys arguing over a stick. Each had one end of it and were in a complete stalemate trying to grab it. One was full-on bawling, tears streaming down his face, crying "But I found it! Finders keepers!"

These weren't toddlers. They were Year Six primary school kids walking to school by themselves, as they have done every morning since September. There were a further two of them looking on with expressions of utter disbelief, not to mention a couple of sniggering dog-walkers.

honeylulu · Yesterday 10:07

I've posted this one before but when my son was little he asked me to put his "bum on the front". Apparently this was because he wanted to poo standing up. He was apopletic with rage when I explained that this was not possible.

My daughter was actually worse with tantrums. I could see them coming and try to appease or distract her but that seemed to make it worse. One memorable conversation:
"Mummy, who is your favourite Twirlywoo?"
"Oh I don't know, I like them all."
[Back and forth with this for a while mummy tries to guess the least enraging option.]
"MUMMY, you have to CHOOSE!"
"Erm, OK, it's Big Hoo."
<daughter throws herself to the floor screaming and thrashing incandescently>
"MUMMY YOU CAN'T HAVE BIG HOO. HE'S MY FAVOURITE!!!"
<mummy enters padded cell>

randomchap · Yesterday 10:13

Gave him his favourite drink in his favourite cup. He wanted what another child had

BoredZelda · Yesterday 10:36

I couldn’t find the imaginary costume for the imaginary dance class we were running imaginary late for then I sat on them.

BoredZelda · Yesterday 10:37

InveterateWineDrinker · Yesterday 10:02

I thought of this thread this morning. Came across two boys arguing over a stick. Each had one end of it and were in a complete stalemate trying to grab it. One was full-on bawling, tears streaming down his face, crying "But I found it! Finders keepers!"

These weren't toddlers. They were Year Six primary school kids walking to school by themselves, as they have done every morning since September. There were a further two of them looking on with expressions of utter disbelief, not to mention a couple of sniggering dog-walkers.

That must have been a really good stick. To be fair, my dogs do the same thing!

BoredZelda · Yesterday 10:39

currentlybrunette · 17/11/2026 17:25

Because we clapped and said he was a good boy after doing something well.

My daughter had loads of these. See also: laughed when she said something funny.

hestilllovesthattrombelese · Yesterday 10:47

Because I flushed his poo away.

After that we had to have a goodbye poo ceremony each time. 'Float away home to mummy and Daddy poo...'

DoLallyTapMum · Yesterday 10:49

Because I put his muddy coat in the wash when he wanted it hung up
Because his popadom broke
Because he woke up

Abhannmor · Yesterday 17:15

Puppylucky · 17/11/2026 17:27

I sincerely hope you weren't watching Ren and Stimpey with a toddler! Adult stoner animation at its finest!

God yes....I thought it was a bit trippy alright. But they loved it ....they're always that bit more tuned in than we think?

Abhannmor · Yesterday 17:16

DoLallyTapMum · Yesterday 10:49

Because I put his muddy coat in the wash when he wanted it hung up
Because his popadom broke
Because he woke up

Now to be fair those are damn good reasons for a cry. Especially the last. Ruined a good dream I bet

BoredZelda · Yesterday 17:27

Geneticsbunny · 15/11/2026 18:54

Because he wanted to be a triangle. I never did get to the bottom of what that actually meant.

Edited

Like the year my daughter wanted a hokey cokey for Christmas……

GravitasPending · Yesterday 18:16

Pantsinthewash · 16/11/2026 05:34

Sorry, don't know how to link a thread, but have a look in Classics at the thread from 2011 about "the cutted up pear" by Allhailtheaubergine - it's brilliant!!

I thought of that thread immediately too Pants! Cutted up pear.

Sigh … those were the days!

EppingIsFun · Yesterday 18:51

She was swinging in the swing but only wanted to go forwards... not backwards.

SleeplessInWherever · Yesterday 19:08

My son’s most bizarre ones have to be:

  • We can’t turn the sun off
  • There’s an owl in a Gruffalo
  • He doesn’t want the speckled frogs to sit on the log
  • He’s finished his lasagne
  • I wear glasses with pyjamas on a morning (I do also wear them all day, but they’re apparently only acceptable with “day time clothes”.)

My nephew once cried because he didn’t want Santa to come into his house, because it’s his house not Santa’s, and he doesn’t know him so he’s not coming in.

TheNinkyNonkyIsATardis · Yesterday 19:59

Tonight, my son cried at bathtime because he wanted yesterday's bath back.

Swipe left for the next trending thread