I think the rules are often good, but not the hysteria that often goes with them, on places such as Mumsnet, and in the news which absolutely revels in spreading fear and panic.
While I often rant about "'elf and safety", one way in which rules can be a positive is that even though things like rollercoasters can feel very frightening, they have to pass very high safety standards: you can feel the fear of going on one knowing that they are actually very safe. Ditto flying: much safer than being in a car, precisely because of the very strict safety procedures. Accidents with these are extremely rare; when they do happen, they make big news, and the "hysteria mob" is always out in force saying "I will never, ever fly again!!!!!! It's too dangerous!!!!!" The problem is not dangerous flying, it's the news whipping up fear and panic.
Schools and other institutions such as churches are now much safer for children than they used to be, because of measures such as safeguarding, DBS checks, and so on. Yes, these measures can be irritating, but they make everybody feel safer; and probably some of the staff feel safer from being accused as well, if they know they are following the procedures.
I think it's possible to have these procedures, and still be fairly "detached" about them, even when you have to enforce them; saying things like "Yes, I know it's a pain, but those are the rules". I am a netball umpire, and it's my job to enforce petty rules such as players having short nails and no jewellery, while still being friendly and approachable.
I do think it's a shame that all this has crept into entertainment, though: it's no longer an escape from our increasingly Orwellian world. Leaving aside the recent crucifixion of David Walliams without trial, we're not allowed to laugh at shows like Little Britain any more: lots of people found it incredibly funny at the time, but it has not survived the culture shift. The TV show of Malory Towers was clearly ticking lots of boxes in order to be broadcast now: ethnically diverse cast (not representative of how English boarding school would have been in the 1940s), and every time the pool was shown, the unseen "lifeguard" had to be mentioned: this was clearly a box-ticking exercise. The modern Crystal Maze has "we will edit a safety helmet on to your head". I hardly watch TV at all now; it often feels that there's an agenda behind something that is supposed to be entertainment.
The worst of this was the complete and utter madness of 2020, when the whole world panicked, and the fear and hysteria spread round the globe within minutes. The government tried to legislate for just about every eventuality, down to whether people could buy Easter eggs or not. Roolz were thrown at just about everything, all with the goal of "appearing to be doing something". I think it would have been much better if there had been a more common sense approach, more "keep calm and carry on"; but because the baying hysterical media and Mumsnet had stoked up SO MUCH fear and panic, the government thought they would give people "what they wanted", with the nonsensical roolz, the extremely damaging restrictions, and deliberately frightening the pants off the public (their words, not mine); I think they thought that roolz and mandated face rags would "make people feel safer". So many of the public swallowed this hook, line and sinker, that I despaired of us ever getting out of this hysterical mindset: I think that to some extent, Partygate angered people back to normality (much as I like the idea, I don't think that was planned, though). For the moment, I am cautiously relieved, but I still think that worse could happen in the future.