Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asked to contribute to Christmas Dinner… money instead?

308 replies

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 15:23

We are spending the festive period at SIL and BIL. They will have a full house with us, my PIL, between us 5 kids, and 2 dogs - not to mention 4 more adults from SIL side who are local and joining us on Christmas Day. Safe to say it will be hectic fun!!!

I have been asked to contribute to dinner, in principle I have no problem with this, it must be daunting, expensive, and exhausting to host so many people for multiple days, and I am a good cook. However, I have been asked to make a tiramisu for those of us who don’t like Christmas pudding to have as dessert on 25th. This leaves me with 3 options, none of which I like -

  1. Make the tiramisu and bring it with me. Since we are travelling on 21st I would have to make this on 20th and with it being so rich with dairy I worry about it lasting, and not sure the texture would be as pleasant after so many days? I have no idea how a massive tiramisu will fit in the fridge with all the other food. Plus we have a 4 hour drive with all mine, DH, and kids stuff and I just don’t know if I will have space for a huge cool bag.
  2. Make it there. I would have to go out to the shops and cook in an unfamiliar kitchen, all the while getting under SIL feet - an absolutely lovely woman, but quite highly strung.
  3. Buy one from a supermarket there. A serious a downgrade on a proper homemade one.

What I’m wondering is whether it would be acceptable for me to reply and ask if she would consider talking a monetary contribution instead. I was thinking £150 for my family unit - substantially more than ingredient cost.

OP posts:
Pherian · 16/11/2026 17:23

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 15:23

We are spending the festive period at SIL and BIL. They will have a full house with us, my PIL, between us 5 kids, and 2 dogs - not to mention 4 more adults from SIL side who are local and joining us on Christmas Day. Safe to say it will be hectic fun!!!

I have been asked to contribute to dinner, in principle I have no problem with this, it must be daunting, expensive, and exhausting to host so many people for multiple days, and I am a good cook. However, I have been asked to make a tiramisu for those of us who don’t like Christmas pudding to have as dessert on 25th. This leaves me with 3 options, none of which I like -

  1. Make the tiramisu and bring it with me. Since we are travelling on 21st I would have to make this on 20th and with it being so rich with dairy I worry about it lasting, and not sure the texture would be as pleasant after so many days? I have no idea how a massive tiramisu will fit in the fridge with all the other food. Plus we have a 4 hour drive with all mine, DH, and kids stuff and I just don’t know if I will have space for a huge cool bag.
  2. Make it there. I would have to go out to the shops and cook in an unfamiliar kitchen, all the while getting under SIL feet - an absolutely lovely woman, but quite highly strung.
  3. Buy one from a supermarket there. A serious a downgrade on a proper homemade one.

What I’m wondering is whether it would be acceptable for me to reply and ask if she would consider talking a monetary contribution instead. I was thinking £150 for my family unit - substantially more than ingredient cost.

It will be fine. It doesn’t need to be “huge”.

ThatsVertigo · 16/11/2026 17:24

I would update again saying the problem was solved almost 24 hours ago, but given the new posters aren't reading the thread, or searching for OP updates before replying I'm not sure it would do much good 😂

OP posts:
MostlyPeaceful · 16/11/2026 17:25

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 15:23

We are spending the festive period at SIL and BIL. They will have a full house with us, my PIL, between us 5 kids, and 2 dogs - not to mention 4 more adults from SIL side who are local and joining us on Christmas Day. Safe to say it will be hectic fun!!!

I have been asked to contribute to dinner, in principle I have no problem with this, it must be daunting, expensive, and exhausting to host so many people for multiple days, and I am a good cook. However, I have been asked to make a tiramisu for those of us who don’t like Christmas pudding to have as dessert on 25th. This leaves me with 3 options, none of which I like -

  1. Make the tiramisu and bring it with me. Since we are travelling on 21st I would have to make this on 20th and with it being so rich with dairy I worry about it lasting, and not sure the texture would be as pleasant after so many days? I have no idea how a massive tiramisu will fit in the fridge with all the other food. Plus we have a 4 hour drive with all mine, DH, and kids stuff and I just don’t know if I will have space for a huge cool bag.
  2. Make it there. I would have to go out to the shops and cook in an unfamiliar kitchen, all the while getting under SIL feet - an absolutely lovely woman, but quite highly strung.
  3. Buy one from a supermarket there. A serious a downgrade on a proper homemade one.

What I’m wondering is whether it would be acceptable for me to reply and ask if she would consider talking a monetary contribution instead. I was thinking £150 for my family unit - substantially more than ingredient cost.

You are a good cook, OP. I would make it fresh down there. Find a way, chat with other family members to come up with a plan to make it work, get help. They will appreciate a tasty, home-made tiramisu. Enjoy your chaotic, fun Christmas!

ruffles8080 · 16/11/2026 17:26

lol I never get people who don't read all the OPs posts before responding!

anyway, good outcome! Hope you all have a wonderful Christmas xXx

Ireallywantadoughnut36 · 16/11/2026 17:26

I think you're overthinking this a bit. Buy the ingredients before travelling, potentially even part make it (or make the elements) and pop it in their fridge, on the 24th layer it up and leave in the fridge for the big day. I'd never make a tiramisu on the day I'm serving, it's nicer if it has time to all infuse a bit! I also think you are majorly missing the point - it's absolutely draining cooking and hosting all those people on your own, organising and making and planning to ensure everyone is happy - I'm the host to between 7 and 13 every year. I always farm out puddings, starters and the Christmas eve meal, because it's just nice to not think about some aspects. If you give money, they still have to think, buy something, make something etc. It isn't the financial, it is the mental load and time commitment.

Don't make a fuss, don't ask any questions, accept the tiramisu is your problem and work it out. The fact you're even raising this gives an insight into the issue. They will also be going- how do we fit it all in the fridge, when do we cook vs serving breakfast, what about the vegetarian, what size turkey means everyone is full and means we then won't need to cook boxing day. For the love of God, don't add to their load by asking if you could not do the tiranisu but could you donate cash. It will not help!

ToastAndCoffee8 · 16/11/2026 17:28

Make it there and give her £150 anyway.

MeridaBrave · 16/11/2026 17:29

I’d say it won’t travel well so a crumble or choc pudding will be better as can make and freeze and travel cool bag. And then won’t take fridge space can do into her freezer and take out in the morning.

Soontobe60 · 16/11/2026 17:44

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 15:39

yeah, so the consensus here seems to be either just ask - I would be hoping that she might divert the task of pudding to her brother/his husband or her parents who are local and just coming for Christmas Day so avoids all of the logistical issues I have.

Or to make it there. While I appreciate the oven isn't switched on I don't find tiramisu low effort - the recipe I like is pretty involved and with loads of washing up, between whipping the whites, cream, and yolks + sugar over a Bain Marie it uses 3 bowls. I don;t have time between now and Christmas to recipe test, so would be sticking with my PITA but tried and tested delicious one.

This is my go to recipe - simple and delicious. TBH after a massive dinner I wouldn’t be too precious about having a fancy recipe. I also wouldn’t do it with eggs as some may be allergic.
https://www.bbcgoodfood.com/recipes/best-ever-tiramisu

Slice of tiramisu on a serving plate

Best ever tiramisu

Make our classic tiramisu recipe. This super-simple Italian dessert actually benefits from being made ahead, allowing all the lovely flavours to mingle

https://www.bbcgoodfood.com/recipes/best-ever-tiramisu

Delphiniumandlupins · 16/11/2026 17:46

Great resolution, enjoy the hot tub. (I would manage tiramisu and profiteroles though)

Bestbeforenow · 16/11/2026 17:46

Can you share your recipe @ThatsVertigo ?

QuaintRobin · 16/11/2026 17:57

You're being unreasonable. A tiramisu does not require 'cooking'. You assemble it in advance, there's no need to be under her feet, you don't actually technically need to even do it the kitchen once you've made the coffee.

Buy the ingredients and check the cream and mascarpone have a good sell by date. Put them in a small cool bag with ice blocks. Or if you're worried take the dry/non fridge ingredients and go to a shop and buy some cream and mascarpone when you get there, you're not doing a full Xmas dinner shop. Or ask her to put them on her big shop and make sure you reimburse it.

Use 2 or 3 small dishes rather than one massive one to make storage easier and ask her in advance to make sure there is room in the fridge for it.

Take your own electric hand mixer and mixing bowl if you're that bothered about an unfamiliar kitchen.

Your money alternative looks generous but it still pushes the job back on the host, which looks like you're throwing money around to get out of a job, but someone will still have to do it. & they have distributed jobs for a reason.

CleverKitten · 16/11/2026 17:59

QuaintRobin · 16/11/2026 17:57

You're being unreasonable. A tiramisu does not require 'cooking'. You assemble it in advance, there's no need to be under her feet, you don't actually technically need to even do it the kitchen once you've made the coffee.

Buy the ingredients and check the cream and mascarpone have a good sell by date. Put them in a small cool bag with ice blocks. Or if you're worried take the dry/non fridge ingredients and go to a shop and buy some cream and mascarpone when you get there, you're not doing a full Xmas dinner shop. Or ask her to put them on her big shop and make sure you reimburse it.

Use 2 or 3 small dishes rather than one massive one to make storage easier and ask her in advance to make sure there is room in the fridge for it.

Take your own electric hand mixer and mixing bowl if you're that bothered about an unfamiliar kitchen.

Your money alternative looks generous but it still pushes the job back on the host, which looks like you're throwing money around to get out of a job, but someone will still have to do it. & they have distributed jobs for a reason.

The thread has moved on.

MyOliveCritic · 16/11/2026 18:03

Onwardsandupwards3 · 15/11/2026 15:26

Bring the ingredients in a cool bag and make it there the day before it is needed.

Definitely this I think !

Cherish707 · 16/11/2026 18:05

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 15:23

We are spending the festive period at SIL and BIL. They will have a full house with us, my PIL, between us 5 kids, and 2 dogs - not to mention 4 more adults from SIL side who are local and joining us on Christmas Day. Safe to say it will be hectic fun!!!

I have been asked to contribute to dinner, in principle I have no problem with this, it must be daunting, expensive, and exhausting to host so many people for multiple days, and I am a good cook. However, I have been asked to make a tiramisu for those of us who don’t like Christmas pudding to have as dessert on 25th. This leaves me with 3 options, none of which I like -

  1. Make the tiramisu and bring it with me. Since we are travelling on 21st I would have to make this on 20th and with it being so rich with dairy I worry about it lasting, and not sure the texture would be as pleasant after so many days? I have no idea how a massive tiramisu will fit in the fridge with all the other food. Plus we have a 4 hour drive with all mine, DH, and kids stuff and I just don’t know if I will have space for a huge cool bag.
  2. Make it there. I would have to go out to the shops and cook in an unfamiliar kitchen, all the while getting under SIL feet - an absolutely lovely woman, but quite highly strung.
  3. Buy one from a supermarket there. A serious a downgrade on a proper homemade one.

What I’m wondering is whether it would be acceptable for me to reply and ask if she would consider talking a monetary contribution instead. I was thinking £150 for my family unit - substantially more than ingredient cost.

Get your spouse to sort it out.
I think it's unreasonable to ask a guest to contribute (especially obe arriving 4 days before the meal). If you cannot afford it, don't host. £150 would be too much.

Lamelie · 16/11/2026 18:09

24Dogcuddler · 15/11/2026 15:35

Check if you can have this delivered to her? You could add other items to the order.
Maybe make some other home made items to take or posh chocs or panettone from Sous Chef.

https://www.cookfood.net/products/tiramisu?srsltid=AYCX9vJH16LKuSiUD3Ao9XsGMs2Fcon9FwR4O8kKvLfJd5_hr4ue6eR5

This is the answer. Perfect world you pick it up en route, and put it straight in freezer/ fridge. There's cooking baking and then there's logistics. They both need taking into account.

Imisssleep88 · 16/11/2026 18:09

If your going that far beforehand surely she can't expect it to be made in advance and travelled..... Just say, no probs with doing a tiramisu but is it okay to make it there Xmas eve so it's fresh. I have only made one myself but I don't remember much "cooking" involved more just using a whisk and assembling.... So can't imagine you will be getting in the way too much and sure there is a local shop for the fresh bits you need, the other bits you can take with you.

Lamelie · 16/11/2026 18:12

I didn't rtft.
Good resolution @ThatsVertigo

OhYeahOhYeah · 16/11/2026 18:16

ThatsVertigo · 15/11/2026 16:26

I've already said that we will be getting them wonderful Christmas presents (of course that includes the nieces and nephew, and their dog!). AND a host gift - that's not what I am enquiring about.

I was asked to contribute to the meal in the form of a tiramisu, I was wondering if SIL might not actually prefer a meal contribution in the form of £150 rather than a dessert. This has nothing to do with the host gift.

And because the suggestions on this thread that myself and DH are being tight are making me aggy, the host gift we have planned is a bottle of Louis Roederer Cristal, and a vocuhers for full day inclusive of two treatments each at a lovely local spa. I think that is more than suitable to show our gratitude for being hosted.

Edited

People are taking your post totally out of context.

It sounds like you have a decent relationship with your SIL, so I’d perhaps just pick up the phone and say that you are v happy to sort that pudding, but it’ll be a soupy mess by Christmas Day, if you make it before you leave. Therefore SIL, I’m very happy to buy and bring all the ingredients and I’ll make it at xyz o’clock on Christmas Eve, if that’s ok, or would you prefer if I buy a super duper fancy shop bought tiramisu and a few other lovely treats? I don’t want to add to your load but don’t want to inconvenience you either!

Your host gift sound very generous and a nice bit of a treat after a busy few days for them xxx

jetlag92 · 16/11/2026 18:22

millymollymoomoo · 15/11/2026 15:27

Just make a tiramisu there. Hardly loads of cooking !

yes, it will only take about 20 minutes. You can always take your own bowls utensils with you.

Wilnis7 · 16/11/2026 18:26

Tiramisu is just assembling right? I agree that a 5 day old one is not great

Where are you going to be? How about I make one deliver it on Christmas eve and you give me £150?

mysittingduck · 16/11/2026 18:31

An excellent solution, what could be better!
FWIW, I was going to suggest taking a freshly made tiramisu and freezing until needed.
Nothing worse IMO than a guest being asked to bring a dish then expecting to construct it in situ. I have never forgiven my SIL for agreeing to bring a salad then arriving on Christmas morning asking to borrow a chopping board, bowl , knife and french dressing ingredients when I was cooking dinner for 12. . I didn't ask her to bring something in order to avoid paying for a bloody lettuce and cucumber. Grrr.

nomadmaident · 16/11/2026 18:35

Speaking as someone who doesn't like tiramisu and/but is usually too full, after Christmas dinner, to manage Christmas pudding, I'd be offering to provide a fine cheese platter (+ fig or quince jam & vg crackers), and/or a sorbet mix (lemon/mango/blackcurrant). All of which can be ordered in advance and taken with you to pop into DSIL's freezer.

ivy4iona · 16/11/2026 18:39

Make it, freeze it , take it frozen safe to travel

Horsedatives · 16/11/2026 18:44

frozen is the best idea.

I asked SIL to make a pud once, and she brought everything to make crumble with homemade custard, very long winded. She didn't tell me until it was time to eat it that she had all the constituent parts in her tupperware boxes and dishes - they were just not necessarily in the right order!

Very annoying and loads more washing up which she didn't think they needed to help with because they had cooked!

Also asked another person to bring the nibbles and canapes - they just brought Celebrations.

So lesson learned - communication!

Swipe left for the next trending thread