Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s a DIL one this time!

930 replies

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 22:53

Long time lurker, first time poster.
I know MILs get a rough ride on MN but I don’t know where else to go.
I really don’t believe IABU so probably the wrong board to post on and I’m sure some of you will say IABU but also hoping for some advice and also to vent.

DS has been with his wife for I don’t know maybe 20 years and married about 15. They have twin 10 yo DDs
Last year DS came to stay with us, saying his wife had kicked him out for cheating. We were upset but didn’t question him on it as he didn’t seem to want to talk about it. He stayed with us around 6 weeks and eventually went home to his wife and children, 100 miles away from us. I didn’t ask any info and he didn’t tell us any. Personally I think she’s a mug for having him back but apparently they’re having therapy and working on things, so I’ve not said anything.
Was having monthly calls with DS and DGDs after he left here but the wife wouldn’t show her face on the calls. We’ve had no visits from any of them.

Anyway DS has now called us with a barrage of abuse telling us what awful people we are and I’m shocked! We had him staying here when his wife kicked him out and never interfered. He says we’ve not been supportive, his wife has never liked us (first I’ve heard!) and DGDs find us difficult too (again, first I’ve heard!)
I can’t help but think DIL has poisoned DS and DGDs against us and I don’t know why she would, maybe embarrassment, but we’ve done nothing wrong. I’m now told we can’t speak to our DGDs until we take responsibility for our actions. What actions? We’ve done nothing. AIBU for thinking they can all fuck off! DS has pissed me off as well tbh for falling for this shit from his wife. My DD agrees with us and thinks they (mainly DIL) are the problem, so I don’t think it is us and it’s good to hear that it’s not just me and DH who think it.

Would be good to know what MNers think should happen next. I think it’s on DS and his wife to get in touch with us, but I just don’t know what to expect next. He put the phone down on me because he didn’t like that I was standing up for myself and not just apologising for made up accusations.
I know MILs are often hated on here, but remember some of us are good and sometimes DILs are not. So help on what to expect from them next and what might happen next for anyone who has been in a similar situation would be gratefully received.

Can give more info or background if needed, happy to answer questions if helps with context. We’ve always been a nice happy family, but looking back I have felt the distance from DS since he moved away to where his wife and her family are from. But interactions up until now have been fine, so I don’t know where this has all come from. Hence why I’m thinking DIL may have had a heavy hand in this.

Expecting some criticism, but hopefully more help that hate. TIA.

OP posts:
rainingsnoring · Yesterday 21:10

VioletsTale · Yesterday 21:04

She didn’t speak to her grandkids for 6 weeks!! She was just going to wait until her son got visitation (from 100 miles away?!?) since she fully believed there was no reconciliation possible. Cry me a river.

And she never bothers to visit the GC at all, and hasn't seen for 2 whole years! Apparently that's all their responsibility and her DH has a dodgy knee.
The affair was likely the DIL's fault because happy men don't cheat, although she was also 'a mug' for taking him back.
The DS 'abusing her' on the phone is also, apparently, the DIL's fault and she must be controlling her precious son.
Not contacting the GC for 6 weeks is only a small fraction of this MIL's terrible behaviour.

Poppyfie1ds · Yesterday 21:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Hokeyjokey · Yesterday 21:11

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

rainingsnoring · Yesterday 21:12

SixtySomething · Yesterday 20:42

Let's hope your future DIL feels the same way when the time comes!

Why would she not when @KellyK2026 has such a kind and positive attitude towards future DILs?

timeforachangeagainagainagain · Yesterday 21:12

I’ve read through all of OPs posts and it does sound like she favours her DD and therefore her kids. They have a closer relationship. The son and his wife are further away so likely a more distant relationship.

the not calling was the thing that jumped out at me. My MIL would definitely contact me and my children. Yes she asked if them, but the kids and wife didn’t know this. From her POV she took her son in and didn’t make contact. She’s already said that she didn’t even think to call!! I think that’s awful actually. Plus add in the fact she’s friends with the ex. No wonder DIL is fed up. Plus all the unwanted advice in pregnancy. Having had kids doesn’t give you the right to give unwanted advice!

I don’t know where the idea has come from that DIL is controlling? Where’s the evidence of this? I think that’s an excuse. It was son that cheated and then shouted over the phone. DIL is probably trying to re build her life and likely feels like that side of the family didn’t care about her or the kids. Did his sister call and ask about wife and kids?

sounds like MIL doesn’t like DIL and DIL is trying to protect her family to me.

CycleBreaker68 · Yesterday 21:13

It sounds as though your son has explained why he is upset with you and doesn’t want his children seeing you, yet you’ve conspicuously avoided explaining his reasons. Is it because you’ve dismissed his feelings, don’t care about the hurt you’ve caused, or are embarrassed to admit your own part in what has happened?
Your post suggests a real lack of emotional maturity. You show no empathy for your DIL, instead blaming her for being cheated on and calling her a mug for taking her husband back. You also show no curiosity about what your son and his family were going through during the six weeks they stayed with you.
Perhaps your son is now in therapy, reflecting on his own behaviour and beginning to understand where he learned some of the toxic patterns that contributed to his cheating. That doesn’t excuse his behaviour, but understanding where those behaviours come from is part of taking accountability and changing them. Perhaps you should consider doing some of that self-reflection yourself.
I also wonder whether your resentment towards your DIL is really about struggling to accept that your son has grown up, moved away and built an independent life with his own family.
The most disturbing thing about your post is the complete lack of self-awareness. Your victim-blaming, internalised misogyny and apparent inability to take accountability are palpable. Perhaps instead of focusing on what your DIL has done wrong, you should consider why your son no longer wants you in his life.

timeforachangeagainagainagain · Yesterday 21:14

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Oh yes - I’d forgotten about the blame. Not happy at home means it’s ok to cheat?!!!!

Coconutter24 · Yesterday 21:18

Muminturmoil0 · Yesterday 00:33

No I’ve had kids of my own and have been around babies all my adult life. DD has kids so I definitely am allowed to give advice to the woman carrying my grandkids! Whether she takes it or not is up to her, but don’t throw it back in my face years later after apparently holding it in until the time suits!

You gave unsolicited advice, she may of been carrying your grandkids but that doesn’t mean you get a say on anything. She took your unsolicited advice as criticism, someone that wanted to make amends would apologise for making someone feel a certain way. You sound stubborn in your replies maybe that’s a reason DIL doesn’t like you.

EveningSpread · Yesterday 21:18

Hm OP, a couple of things jump out here.

When your DS stayed for 6 weeks it was “just basic pleasantries” - it sounds like you are really distant with him. Do you test [edited: treat] him with kid gloves? You make it sound like he was sort of a lodger whom you couldn’t get too close to or ask questions. But this was your son! Potentially going through a marriage ending situation! It’s barmy that you wouldn’t broach the subject with him at all. You might think that’s respectful; to many it seems really cold and odd.

As does not picking up the phone to DIL during that time. You say it just didn’t occur to you - again that in itself is barmy, and a testament to your efforts with her all along.

By your own account, it sounds like you’ve been extremely poor at forging and maintaining closeness and the relationship with your son and DIL.

Sons do sometimes get treated like these special, important creatures one must not question, while daughters get different treatment: could that be the case with your children?

I agree with previous replies that unsolicited advice is always criticism - especially during pregnancy and with young children.

This all sounds like such an horrendous, sorry mess, and some of it is so clearly of your own making - and that’s even with you telling your side of the story!

EveningSpread · Yesterday 21:19

And what’s your DH doing to fix his dodgy knee? Has he got an op or physio booked? He shouldn’t have had it for so long. Doesn’t he want to visit his son?

FortyHeffalumps · Yesterday 21:19

Reverse thread

ThisLivelyRaven · Yesterday 21:21

I feel for your DIL! From your posts you sound completely unaware of your behaviour! Try and look at your past behaviour and analyse it!

Twobigbabies · Yesterday 21:33

Very difficult to tell but I wonder if there might be some truth in the 'playing favourites' your DIL/DS are accusing you of. Has your DD always been the golden child- and therefore are her children by extension the golden DGC? As per a previous poster something may have come up in the couples therapy they are doing. Why did DS cheat? Because he has low self esteem. Why does he have low self esteem? A mother/ parent who always preferred his sister? Just a thought, could be wrong. This would also explain why your DIL has suddenly taken against you and also why your DD would be on your side. It's a very common family dynamic which seems to crop up on here all the time.

HangrySloth · Yesterday 21:34

FortyHeffalumps · Yesterday 21:19

Reverse thread

Either way mil is still wrong

JustanotherManikMumday · Yesterday 21:35

I would ask him what actions your expected to apologise for. Is it taking him in when he was made homeless(maybe shes pissed he had a roof over his head), or for not being judgemental when told he cheated, for not taking sides. It's easier to apologise if you know what its for. Then when he can't name a reason, you know his being a twat.

SixtySomething · Yesterday 21:36

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

‘what grown woman doesn’t know not to offer unsolicited advice to new mothers under any circumstances?‘

This is so strange.
The older woman likely has looked after 2 or more children, perhaps hundreds or thousands if it happens to be her job too.
She sees the new mother struggling. I’m sorry but to offer a suggestion designed to help is totally normal and it’s batshit to consider it a social crime.
Tact is required, yes, but it’s a difficult tightrope being a MIL and we are allowed to get it wrong in our new role. We should not be told to issue these strange apologies and promises of improved behaviour if we don’t produce the desired behaviour. Not to mention threats of going NC .😫

Woodfiresareamazing2 · Yesterday 21:41

LifeIsAMeatball · Yesterday 21:04

Where do you see your relationship with each of them in three years time and how can you help that?

Your defensiveness comes across so strongly
and it has created a lot of responses on here. I wonder if you are able to look beyond the hurt of the here and now, to not be defensive, not fight fire with fire via your daughter, not create more drama?

Some big reflection could save your relationship with them all. Lots of luck.

I would say that OP hasn't got a relationship with her GC now, let alone in 3 years time.
Quite apart from callously not even thinking about calling her DiL and GC while their husband/dad/her son was staying with her for 6 weeks -
they only live 100 miles away, and yet OP hasn't seen them in 2 years!

Her argument is it's "easier" for her son, DiL, and twin GCs to come visit them, because her DH has a bad knee so doesn't want to drive that far.
Oh, and DiL unilaterally decided to turn the spare room into a home office (nothing to do with OP's DS, obviously 🙄), so they can't stay there.

No thought that she could go up herself by train or coach, or maybe even drive herself there to spend time with them. She could stay in a Travelodge for very little money, or an air bnb. But oh no, she's not prepared to put herself out at all, so it must be that she doesn't really care about them.

No, "it's not on us (OP and her DH) to go all the way up there" - such off the scale entitlement!

She has her DD living just along the street with her kids, so OP has GC on tap. That's why she's not bothered about the others...

ForthCo · Yesterday 21:41

I'd have told my son to book himself a hotel if he cheated on his wife and left home. Then I would have rang dil right away to say I still loved my grandchildren and wanted to be part of their lives if possible. I would definitely not have let my grown son off with no questions and let him use my house as a refuge and then accepted abuse from him while blaming his poor wife who's seeing her life fall apart.

TheYorkshirePudding · Yesterday 21:42

"a happy husband doesn't cheat” I know anyone with half a brain knows this is utter nonsense but really some men will never be happy as long as the have a hole in their arse. Please. The onus is on the person committing the act, not the other person caught up in their shit.

SixtySomething · Yesterday 21:43

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

And how exactly are you qualified to diagnose personality disorders?

You’re happy to make a series of damming judgements about another person’s character, too.
Doesn’t sit at all well with me.

Are you like this IRL too?

Jaxhog · Yesterday 21:47

My suspicion is that your DiL has given him both barrels and he's taking it out on you. You only have his word that all this vitriol is coming from her.

I'd be tempted to call her when he's not there and say to her that you're very confused about what he's said. I suspect you'll get a very different picture of what's going on. Your DD calling him is a good idea too, as she may be able to tear him off a strip in a way only a sister can.

AppleCerulean · Yesterday 21:47

SixtySomething · Yesterday 21:36

‘what grown woman doesn’t know not to offer unsolicited advice to new mothers under any circumstances?‘

This is so strange.
The older woman likely has looked after 2 or more children, perhaps hundreds or thousands if it happens to be her job too.
She sees the new mother struggling. I’m sorry but to offer a suggestion designed to help is totally normal and it’s batshit to consider it a social crime.
Tact is required, yes, but it’s a difficult tightrope being a MIL and we are allowed to get it wrong in our new role. We should not be told to issue these strange apologies and promises of improved behaviour if we don’t produce the desired behaviour. Not to mention threats of going NC .😫

How ridiculous, when any of us upset someone even totally unintentionally of course we apologise and don't do it again! That's just normal human behaviour in relationships - we don't want to hurt the people we care about, if they tell us we have hurt them of course we change what we're doing? Why would MILs be exempt from that?

Woodfiresareamazing2 · Yesterday 21:47

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

boringperson123 · Yesterday 21:49

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:17

No didn’t contact her or the kids during that time, didn’t feel it was my place. Blood is thicker than water and all that and tbh I thought they would permanently split do didn’t think I’d see her again, and didn’t want DS to think I wasn’t supporting him (although I accept he was wrong to cheat)
Some might disagree with that, but I didn’t even think to get in touch with her. I’m sure in the same situation you’d do the same.
Once DS went back to her though I started up contact with the kids again, but as I say she never wanted to show her face.

This logic is honestly mental to me. Didn’t think you’d ever see her again so immediately discarded her and her feelings even though she birthed and raised your grandchildren who you supposedly love.

AppleCerulean · Yesterday 21:50

JustanotherManikMumday · Yesterday 21:35

I would ask him what actions your expected to apologise for. Is it taking him in when he was made homeless(maybe shes pissed he had a roof over his head), or for not being judgemental when told he cheated, for not taking sides. It's easier to apologise if you know what its for. Then when he can't name a reason, you know his being a twat.

He's given the OP a list of reasons - a lot of them relating to her behaviour when DIL was pregnant/postpartum. If you read all the OP's posts you'll see she knows fine why he's angry with her as he's told her on the phone exactly what the problems are. She just didn't want to hear it and refuses to accept any of it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread