Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s a DIL one this time!

931 replies

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 22:53

Long time lurker, first time poster.
I know MILs get a rough ride on MN but I don’t know where else to go.
I really don’t believe IABU so probably the wrong board to post on and I’m sure some of you will say IABU but also hoping for some advice and also to vent.

DS has been with his wife for I don’t know maybe 20 years and married about 15. They have twin 10 yo DDs
Last year DS came to stay with us, saying his wife had kicked him out for cheating. We were upset but didn’t question him on it as he didn’t seem to want to talk about it. He stayed with us around 6 weeks and eventually went home to his wife and children, 100 miles away from us. I didn’t ask any info and he didn’t tell us any. Personally I think she’s a mug for having him back but apparently they’re having therapy and working on things, so I’ve not said anything.
Was having monthly calls with DS and DGDs after he left here but the wife wouldn’t show her face on the calls. We’ve had no visits from any of them.

Anyway DS has now called us with a barrage of abuse telling us what awful people we are and I’m shocked! We had him staying here when his wife kicked him out and never interfered. He says we’ve not been supportive, his wife has never liked us (first I’ve heard!) and DGDs find us difficult too (again, first I’ve heard!)
I can’t help but think DIL has poisoned DS and DGDs against us and I don’t know why she would, maybe embarrassment, but we’ve done nothing wrong. I’m now told we can’t speak to our DGDs until we take responsibility for our actions. What actions? We’ve done nothing. AIBU for thinking they can all fuck off! DS has pissed me off as well tbh for falling for this shit from his wife. My DD agrees with us and thinks they (mainly DIL) are the problem, so I don’t think it is us and it’s good to hear that it’s not just me and DH who think it.

Would be good to know what MNers think should happen next. I think it’s on DS and his wife to get in touch with us, but I just don’t know what to expect next. He put the phone down on me because he didn’t like that I was standing up for myself and not just apologising for made up accusations.
I know MILs are often hated on here, but remember some of us are good and sometimes DILs are not. So help on what to expect from them next and what might happen next for anyone who has been in a similar situation would be gratefully received.

Can give more info or background if needed, happy to answer questions if helps with context. We’ve always been a nice happy family, but looking back I have felt the distance from DS since he moved away to where his wife and her family are from. But interactions up until now have been fine, so I don’t know where this has all come from. Hence why I’m thinking DIL may have had a heavy hand in this.

Expecting some criticism, but hopefully more help that hate. TIA.

OP posts:
SilverChristmasBow · Yesterday 17:17

What is most important to you?

Your relationship with your Son and Grandchildren?

Or being “right”?

Pessismistic · Yesterday 17:24

Bellyblueboy · Yesterday 16:02

OP has said she won’t apologise for anything. She has dismissed her son’s comments, and if she sends this note which completely ignores what her son told her then I think it will come across as very manipulative and passive aggressive.

There is clearly a lot of resentment following OP’s decision to give a lot of insularities advice to her daughter in law. OP can of course decide she won’t apologize for that - she believes she is entitled to say what she wants. That is fine, but her son has been very clear he wants an apology for her behavior.

I suspect this will end with her son nicer speaking to her again, until he next cheats and is kicked out of his house.

My post doesn’t say apologise I just think if op wrote directly to dil it might make it clearer but the op can do whatever she wants it’s just a suggestion.

HisNibs · Yesterday 17:25

Errmm, sorry for not being the echo chamber you wanted OP? 🙄
My mother would have kicked my arse for having an affair and would have been the first in line to support my wife, her DIL. She may not be perfect but your DIL is not the problem here. Don't expect anything to change, I'm sure she has the measure of you...

Differentforgirls · Yesterday 17:26

Letstalkaboutitxx · Yesterday 16:41

With all due respect nobody knows what goes on behind closed doors. Most cheaters are abhorrent. How do we know in this case the DIL wasn't a cruel bitch & this man looked for comfort elsewhere. The fact is we don't know so why always support the woman when we don't know the circumstances.

Well, supporting women isn't calling them 'a bitch'.

SmallWoodlandCreature · Yesterday 17:28

OP, That's it for me. I'm sure your DIL would frame this as MIL problems.
Your son cheated. Crawled back to stay with you. That must have been so incredibly upsetting for his wife and children. YOUR Grandchildren. And you didn't bother to contact them to see how they were, and suggested that others would behave exactly the same.
I'm gobsmacked and feel a little nauseous to be honest. I have 2 granddaughters and a SIL. They live in Spain so I don't see them as often as I'd like. But if my daughter turned up and said she'd been cheating, I'd be on the phone to him as soon as I could. Because I genuinely care for him. And my GDs.
So from what I read you don't, and never have had, a good relationship with either your DIL or your GDs.

FramboiseFraise · Yesterday 17:31

Letstalkaboutitxx · Yesterday 16:41

With all due respect nobody knows what goes on behind closed doors. Most cheaters are abhorrent. How do we know in this case the DIL wasn't a cruel bitch & this man looked for comfort elsewhere. The fact is we don't know so why always support the woman when we don't know the circumstances.

If she is that awful, why has he gone back to her? Why didn't he divorce instead of cheating on her? When you hear hoofbeats, don't look for zebras.

Kokonimater · Yesterday 17:39

So your son lived with you for six weeks. And during that time you didn’t contact your daughter-in-law to see if she was okay, and you didn’t stay in touch with your granddaughters? That is appalling! No wonder your daughter-in-law is now dead set against you. Sadly, you really didn’t use emotional intelligence to deal with the Problem even if your son was never going to go back to his wife you were still grandmother to those girls. Were you going to cut off contact with them for good then? How must they have felt? When their daddy was away? Sadly, your actions have caused this.

CatSquirrelDuck · Yesterday 17:41

I’m not placing blame but a happy husband doesn’t cheat. I don’t know if they had marriage problems before but he’s not going to cheat if he’s happy at home is he! He shouldn’t have done it but it does make me wonder if she knew she’d in some way pushed him to this, because why else would she have him back? I would no way have my DH back if he had cheated. I just can’t understand any it.

I imagine you'll lose most support on here with those beliefs .. must be the woman's fault if he didn't keep it in his pants, eh? Always the woman's fault.

Seriously, you deserve the outcome you've had here

Suay · Yesterday 17:48

None of you know me irl or any of the other people in this scenario….it doesn’t mean that you’re right about this.
WHY POST THEN?
WE’RE ALL OUT OF STEP APART FROM YOU? NO.

StrongCofffeeNeeded · Yesterday 17:54

TheFormerMrsTruelove · Yesterday 14:56

I know there are two sides to every story, but I’m going to ignore their side and accept everything you’ve said as fact.

You and your DH have raised a weak and pathetic man. You and your DH are utterly shit grandparents. You and your DH are shit in-laws. And what makes it worse is that you can’t even see what you’ve done wrong.

Your whole attitude seems to be that you can’t possibly have been an arsehole to your DiL because she never said anything to you before. Well obvious she didn’t. Many people have family members who they would quite happily beat to death with a shovel, but they bite their tongues just to maintain the peace and because the fallout wouldn’t be worth it. That doesn’t make her ‘a two faced actress’. It makes you lucky that she never told you to stick your advice up your arse and fuck off out of her house.

And guess what? You don’t suddenly become mum or grandmother of the year because your DD and her children think you’re ok. You very clearly have a different relationship with them than you do with your son and his family. The fact that it didn’t even occur to you to contact your DiL to ask her if she was ok and whether she needed anything is shocking. And your grandchildren going through one of the most horrible things that can happen and you didn’t think it was appropriate to contact them?!

There is something fundamentally wrong with you.

I agree with all of this. I have a son myself and I can’t believe the OP thinks she's in the right. Yes, their marriage is their problem. Yes, I would take DS in.

But this woman is the mother of your grandchildren, I can’t believe you didn't contact her immediately. I would have. And I would have also given DS a lengthy interrogation about what the fuck he's doing with his life the moment he stepped in my house.

Dandeloosha · Yesterday 17:54

Yeah, you might want to reflect on what you’ve said on these threads. You’re not exactly covering yourself in glory. Is even some of what your DS said accurate? It does sound as though it might be worth considering therapy to talk through the issues raised with someone impartial. Your DD agreeing with you and shouting at him is only going to make things worse. It looks like you’re sending in the flying monkeys.

maybemaybenot17363 · Yesterday 17:56

My in laws also thought "they had done nothing wrong". They had. Massively. They're probably better off without you angels.

Letstalkaboutitxx · Yesterday 17:58

As far as my views are concerned ultimately I feel its up to OP to eat humble pie & fix it. This couple have obviously been in turmoil & the op has been getting the blame despite trying to help & keep out of it

Letstalkaboutitxx · Yesterday 18:03

Why would a happy husband who felt fulfilled in every aspect of marriage look for sex & comfort else where. I understand this is a controversial question but nevertheless still interesting. 🤔

Holeymoley28 · Yesterday 18:05

Letstalkaboutitxx · Yesterday 18:03

Why would a happy husband who felt fulfilled in every aspect of marriage look for sex & comfort else where. I understand this is a controversial question but nevertheless still interesting. 🤔

Honestly often because they just can.

If they think they won’t get caught and it’s offered on a plate a bit of fun. A lot a hell of a lot of men would do it.

Those annon surveys come back time and time again that most men have or would cheat if they thought they would get away with it.

A bit like cheating on your diet, what’s the harm nobody will know and that chocolate cake just looks sooo yummy so I’ll just have one slice in secret.

Most men caught cheating don’t want to leave their wives.

OutAndAbouting · Yesterday 18:14

One word.

Obtuse.

BringmeHigherLove · Yesterday 18:14

Letstalkaboutitxx · Yesterday 18:03

Why would a happy husband who felt fulfilled in every aspect of marriage look for sex & comfort else where. I understand this is a controversial question but nevertheless still interesting. 🤔

You ask as if it’s possible to make someone else happy and fulfilled. Maybe it’s possible if they arrive healthy and happy in the first place. Most men that would cheat are already damaged before you’ve met them. You can’t fix another person, they have to do the work.

wildnwilde · Yesterday 18:25

If I was you as the mother of sons and believe it or not I’m usually quite MIL friendly (some can’t win) I’d of also housed my son . I’d of also made it perfectly clear I was disgusted in his behaviour, even if it’s a bad marriage (he’s gone back which leads me to believe she’s not a horrific wife) for whatever reason betrayal is unacceptable I’d of phoned my DIL to let her know he was with me but certainly not getting tea and sympathy and assured her my main concern was the children . I’d of moved heaven and earth to have contact with them through her . And my advice to him would have been to grow up and do the right thing which would be divorce and be an excellent co parent or go back and work on his marriage .

Onceuponatime32 · Yesterday 18:26

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:55

I did use to speak with her directly actually thank you! DS would rarely pick up because he was always busy at work so I’d call her instead and speak to DGC and she would have a conversation with me too. So things were fine before. Sometimes she would even make the phone calls herself for us to speak to DGC and she never hinted at having a problem with us then! So when DS tells me all these things we’ve apparently done wrong over the years but nobody has ever mentioned it before, I’m just not buying it.
He claims she’s been hurt by comments we’ve made, yet she’s still answered our calls, called us herself, visited us and never said a word of there being a problem. So she’s either making it up now about having a problem with us all this time or she’s a very good two faced actress!

Your son wasn’t too busy to talk to you. He couldn’t be arsed and dumped the responsibility for keeping in touch with you onto his wife. And she did it because she wanted her children to have a relationship with you.

Seems he’s too busy to keep in touch with you but manages to find time to cheat.

MaidOfSteel · Yesterday 18:31

Sounds like ‘therapy speak’ to me, OP. I’ve seen quite a few threads about people who’ve had therapy and they start to blame their parents for everything. Maybe it’s the fashionable thing to do nowadays, to avoid taking responsibility for their own failures or mistakes.

Tell your nasty son to put his money where his mouth is and explain, in explicit detail, instances where you’ve done things wrong.

BurnoutGP · Yesterday 18:33

MaidOfSteel · Yesterday 18:31

Sounds like ‘therapy speak’ to me, OP. I’ve seen quite a few threads about people who’ve had therapy and they start to blame their parents for everything. Maybe it’s the fashionable thing to do nowadays, to avoid taking responsibility for their own failures or mistakes.

Tell your nasty son to put his money where his mouth is and explain, in explicit detail, instances where you’ve done things wrong.

Except she doesn't blame her son...its all DIL fault

EasternEcho · Yesterday 18:33

MCF86 · Yesterday 17:01

So you maintained contact with an ex girlfriend, but didn't ring your grandchildren, or their mum, despite knowing she would have been going through a really difficult time?
I've sympathised more with her position with every reply you've posted.

OP admitted she never thought she'd see DIL again once the son left her and moved in with OP. OP doesn't like DIL and was probably glad the relationship was over at that time. Now she is miffed that son has gone back to DIL and out of her manipulative clutches. I sense a massive amount of projection onto the DIL of OP's own behaviour.

glitterpaperchain · Yesterday 18:34

Your posts are absolutely dripping with disdain for your DIL from the very first one.

To me it seems completely normal, if you're going to reconcile with a partner, to say OK let's lay it all on the table and discuss all of our issues. So it makes perfect sense why issues she would have tried to just let lie in the past would be brought up now. The fact you immediately see it as some kind of manipulation is telling.

  • 'Happy husbands don't cheat'
  • Didn't even occur to you to call her while your son stayed with you
  • It's not on you to go and visit your own grandkids (according to you)
  • The fact that you think it's 'easier' for them to do a long drive and lug all the stuff for an overnight stay with 2 kids shows a real lack of empathy
  • You don't seem receptive to any feedback given and are argumentative to some (you don't see how it's possible for well-intended advice to be taken badly postpartum? Really?)

Honestly if you read back everything you've said and still can't see how you may possibly have done ANYTHING wrong then I don't know what can help you. DIL is better off without you anyway.

bigboykitty · Yesterday 18:36

Letstalkaboutitxx · Yesterday 15:14

My opinion is given I'm always inclined to eat humble pie in situations like this due to considering the people giving me abuse are far more likely to have serious personal problems would be to do the following. I would send a card apologising for whatever they feel has ben hurtful while also mentioning you have no idea what it could be then hang low & wait to see what happens.

Yeah great idea, that would blow things up once and for all 💣

AppleCerulean · Yesterday 18:37

MaidOfSteel · Yesterday 18:31

Sounds like ‘therapy speak’ to me, OP. I’ve seen quite a few threads about people who’ve had therapy and they start to blame their parents for everything. Maybe it’s the fashionable thing to do nowadays, to avoid taking responsibility for their own failures or mistakes.

Tell your nasty son to put his money where his mouth is and explain, in explicit detail, instances where you’ve done things wrong.

Nothing the OP has said suggests that the son was using therapy speak. She's admitted that she stayed friendly with his ex girlfriend, criticised the DIL when she was pregnant and postpartum, expected them to do all the travelling for visits while they had young twins and cut off the DIL of twenty years without a single word or second thought when the son cheated on her - not even a text message to say something supportive to recognise this is a woman who has been in her family for two decades and borne two grandchildren and was suffering. It doesn't require a therapist to point out this is horrible behaviour, and while the couple are reconciling it's not surprising that they are looking at all their relationships and figuring out how to move forwards.

It's also clear that the son DID explain im explicit detail what he felt his mother had done wrong and rather than responding to what he said, the OP has blown up at him instead. She doesn't want to hear it!