Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s a DIL one this time!

932 replies

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 22:53

Long time lurker, first time poster.
I know MILs get a rough ride on MN but I don’t know where else to go.
I really don’t believe IABU so probably the wrong board to post on and I’m sure some of you will say IABU but also hoping for some advice and also to vent.

DS has been with his wife for I don’t know maybe 20 years and married about 15. They have twin 10 yo DDs
Last year DS came to stay with us, saying his wife had kicked him out for cheating. We were upset but didn’t question him on it as he didn’t seem to want to talk about it. He stayed with us around 6 weeks and eventually went home to his wife and children, 100 miles away from us. I didn’t ask any info and he didn’t tell us any. Personally I think she’s a mug for having him back but apparently they’re having therapy and working on things, so I’ve not said anything.
Was having monthly calls with DS and DGDs after he left here but the wife wouldn’t show her face on the calls. We’ve had no visits from any of them.

Anyway DS has now called us with a barrage of abuse telling us what awful people we are and I’m shocked! We had him staying here when his wife kicked him out and never interfered. He says we’ve not been supportive, his wife has never liked us (first I’ve heard!) and DGDs find us difficult too (again, first I’ve heard!)
I can’t help but think DIL has poisoned DS and DGDs against us and I don’t know why she would, maybe embarrassment, but we’ve done nothing wrong. I’m now told we can’t speak to our DGDs until we take responsibility for our actions. What actions? We’ve done nothing. AIBU for thinking they can all fuck off! DS has pissed me off as well tbh for falling for this shit from his wife. My DD agrees with us and thinks they (mainly DIL) are the problem, so I don’t think it is us and it’s good to hear that it’s not just me and DH who think it.

Would be good to know what MNers think should happen next. I think it’s on DS and his wife to get in touch with us, but I just don’t know what to expect next. He put the phone down on me because he didn’t like that I was standing up for myself and not just apologising for made up accusations.
I know MILs are often hated on here, but remember some of us are good and sometimes DILs are not. So help on what to expect from them next and what might happen next for anyone who has been in a similar situation would be gratefully received.

Can give more info or background if needed, happy to answer questions if helps with context. We’ve always been a nice happy family, but looking back I have felt the distance from DS since he moved away to where his wife and her family are from. But interactions up until now have been fine, so I don’t know where this has all come from. Hence why I’m thinking DIL may have had a heavy hand in this.

Expecting some criticism, but hopefully more help that hate. TIA.

OP posts:
GetOffTheBedCalicoCat · Yesterday 11:07

KnittedPenguinHat · Yesterday 10:50

You are in fact an awful mother for getting your DD to take sides and call her brother to have a go on your behalf. Jesus.

Edited

yeah - the OP needs to look up the term flying monkey.

This is all as toxic as fuck and I hope the DIL runs far and fast.

2chocolateoranges · Yesterday 11:07

So, you’ve told your dd everything that happened and she’s furious! However she’s only heard your side of the story? Let her phone her brother and I’m sure he will explain all that’s been going on and why he’s taken this decision to have no contact.

maybe it’s your son that’s the controlling one and makes all the household decisions.

VioletsTale · Yesterday 11:09

Muminturmoil0 · Yesterday 10:44

My DD is furious at what’s happened so she’s going to call her brother and give him what for and find out what’s going on. I’m very close with my DD so just goes to show I’m not an awful mother like some of you are suggesting. And my DD agrees this sounds like it’s come from the mouth of DIL so whilst I appreciate (some) people’s input here, I’ll take more notice from someone who actually knows the situation and people involved.
You all seem to have ignored the idea that DIL could be controlling or even abusive! My DD has also said maybe she’s controlling him which I hate to think could be true, especially as she now seems to be calling all the shots and gate keeping whether we can see or even speak to our DGDs. You all seem to be worried about DIL, but she has her own family. I’m worried about mine, which is perfectly normal. But make no mistake that I’m disappointed in my DS’s actions in cheating and also having a go at me.

As for the visiting, it is easier and makes more sense for them to come here than us go there because my husband has a bad knee so finds it difficult to sit in the car for long periods and DIL has changed their spare bedroom into a home office so we can’t stay over. It’s a long way to drive (and uncomfortable for my DH) just for the day. Whereas if they come to us they can stay over and also wider family and friends are here who they can visit at the same time like my DD and other GCs. And yes they have not bothered to visit us for 2 years despite how much easier it would be for them to come here than us go there, yet according to some of you, I am the problem! And FWIW we’ve never had the DGDs alone, not to stay over, not even for an afternoon - we’d have been more than happy to, we’d have loved to, but that’s never been an option.

Does your DD know that you stopped all contact with DIL and your granddaughters during the 6 week separation? Did she do the same thing?

jonesonscam · Yesterday 11:09

Muminturmoil0 · Yesterday 00:33

No I’ve had kids of my own and have been around babies all my adult life. DD has kids so I definitely am allowed to give advice to the woman carrying my grandkids! Whether she takes it or not is up to her, but don’t throw it back in my face years later after apparently holding it in until the time suits!

Nope. No. You definitely are NOT allowed to give unsolicited advice to your DiL about anything. Your inability to see any fault whatsoever on your side is the whole problem.

LeebLeefuhLurve · Yesterday 11:10

If your daughter calls up and gives it 'what for' you can kiss goodbye to seeing your DIL and grandkids ever again, but given how combative and weird you're coming across here, it might be better for them in the long run.

permanently · Yesterday 11:10

When my ex cheated it would have completely out of character for my ex MIL to call me/take me out for a coffee, to show she cared, but it would have meant a lot. My world as I knew it had collapsed. So exposing. ‘Happy husbands don’t cheat’ is a horrible thing to say. I was pregnant. When I wrote and told my Dad what had happened, he wrote back ‘consider me dead to you,’ so just for context you don’t know what else your DIL was facing at that time. And is still facing. It has to come out somehow. If you can hold your hands up and admit there was more you could have done for her then, it might help fix things. Like you, my exMIL was doing things behind the scenes to help, but a handhold for the mother of her vulnerable grandchildren would have been very appreciated.

Chilly80 · Yesterday 11:10

Muminturmoil0 · Yesterday 00:58

It’s not like I completely ignored DGDs, I asked my DS how they were getting on when he spoke to them or he got updates from his wife. They didn’t know their dad had cheated thank god, just that he was visiting us or away with work I think. So they won’t have felt abandoned.
DS was only able to visit them a couple of times during that period so I didn’t want to call DGDs when they were with their dad and take away their time with him as it wasn’t much at that time due to the circumstances.
And like I’ve already said I don’t think it was my place to contact DIL during this time, although I see some of you disagree with that. Wonder if you would if you were in my shoes though? I doubt you’d be doing all the things you are virtue signalling and checking in with her.
It’s not easy for us to visit them when they live far away. It’s not on us to go all the way over there and it’s actually easier and makes more sense for them to come to us, but they very rarely would, maybe only once or twice a year. It’s been 2 years since they last brought the DGC over but yes of course I’m the problem!

Yes it is on you to go and visit them. I assume you are retired? While they have work and school. My dad lives far away and always travels to me.

Trottersup · Yesterday 11:11

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:26

I’m not placing blame but a happy husband doesn’t cheat. I don’t know if they had marriage problems before but he’s not going to cheat if he’s happy at home is he! He shouldn’t have done it but it does make me wonder if she knew she’d in some way pushed him to this, because why else would she have him back? I would no way have my DH back if he had cheated. I just can’t understand any it.
I am annoyed with DS after his call, make no mistake, but it was just so out of character. Contact from him has dwindled since he moved back to her, but he’s never said any or things before that he’s said on the phone. Does make me wonder if she given him an ultimatum.
Might call him when I know she’s not with him in case he wants to condone a different issue. Or get my DD (his sister to call), maybe he will say or act differently and tell the truth as to what’s going on. Keep flipping between that and just thinking they can fuck off now. Don’t know if I’m more angry or upset.

Only read up to this point. What a really offensive and stupid thing to say. I can see why DIL wants nothing to do with you. I'm assuming you are the sort of person that mouths off with your uneducated opinions constantly.

Holeymoley28 · Yesterday 11:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Passingthroughtwice · Yesterday 11:13

@Muminturmoil0 So what's your response going to be when your DS gives his flying monkey sister both barrels back and doubles down on how he perceives your behaviour? Are you prepared to lose him for good?

TheIntricaciesOfHarpUpkeepAndMaintenance · Yesterday 11:15

Muminturmoil0 · Yesterday 10:44

My DD is furious at what’s happened so she’s going to call her brother and give him what for and find out what’s going on. I’m very close with my DD so just goes to show I’m not an awful mother like some of you are suggesting. And my DD agrees this sounds like it’s come from the mouth of DIL so whilst I appreciate (some) people’s input here, I’ll take more notice from someone who actually knows the situation and people involved.
You all seem to have ignored the idea that DIL could be controlling or even abusive! My DD has also said maybe she’s controlling him which I hate to think could be true, especially as she now seems to be calling all the shots and gate keeping whether we can see or even speak to our DGDs. You all seem to be worried about DIL, but she has her own family. I’m worried about mine, which is perfectly normal. But make no mistake that I’m disappointed in my DS’s actions in cheating and also having a go at me.

As for the visiting, it is easier and makes more sense for them to come here than us go there because my husband has a bad knee so finds it difficult to sit in the car for long periods and DIL has changed their spare bedroom into a home office so we can’t stay over. It’s a long way to drive (and uncomfortable for my DH) just for the day. Whereas if they come to us they can stay over and also wider family and friends are here who they can visit at the same time like my DD and other GCs. And yes they have not bothered to visit us for 2 years despite how much easier it would be for them to come here than us go there, yet according to some of you, I am the problem! And FWIW we’ve never had the DGDs alone, not to stay over, not even for an afternoon - we’d have been more than happy to, we’d have loved to, but that’s never been an option.

I’m having difficulty believing this is real. Nobody is this lacking in self awareness, surely?

SharkPants · Yesterday 11:15

VioletsTale · Yesterday 11:09

Does your DD know that you stopped all contact with DIL and your granddaughters during the 6 week separation? Did she do the same thing?

I bet she did. This is "how some families are". Code for "absolutely toxic."
Protect your own, enable poor behaviour and blame the person who sees through it and won't tolerate it and then recruit others to turn against them. The OP is of course the victim, "my daughter-in-law is controlling", "she won't let me see my grandchildren," whilst overlooking the damage her son has done and that she believes can be justified.

GetOffTheBedCalicoCat · Yesterday 11:16

I rather hope the DIL is on here reading all this. If she ever doubts herself she can read back and realise that she was most definitely not the problem.

aurynne · Yesterday 11:18

"a happy husband doesn’t cheat."

A good man doesn't cheat.
There, I fixed it for you.

CatSquirrelDuck · Yesterday 11:18

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:17

No didn’t contact her or the kids during that time, didn’t feel it was my place. Blood is thicker than water and all that and tbh I thought they would permanently split do didn’t think I’d see her again, and didn’t want DS to think I wasn’t supporting him (although I accept he was wrong to cheat)
Some might disagree with that, but I didn’t even think to get in touch with her. I’m sure in the same situation you’d do the same.
Once DS went back to her though I started up contact with the kids again, but as I say she never wanted to show her face.

Supporting him? After he cheated on the mother of your grandchildren?

YABU and didn't think that through

TinnedBeans · Yesterday 11:18

I can see that this has come out of the blue for you, but the only way that any understanding will be truly made is with progressive, calm conversation.

Your son rang you sounding angry and made accusations.

Don't respond with anger. Respond with curiosity and wanting to understand more.

You need to keep your daughter out of it.

You might not agree with what your son said but you need to listen and respond to him.

You might not agree with your DiL or your granddaughters but you need to listen and respond to them.

Your son needs to take responsibility for the way he spoke to you but it's clear he's not going to unless you act. Act with example.

Getting your daughter to act on your behalf is not taking responsibility. It's simply causing more distress to more people within the family.

It's ok to be hurt and upset by what has been said- but if it were me I'd be making sure that MY voice was heard.

Take responsibility for your voice. Don't use someone else's.

You're getting your daughter to fight your battles when the relationship with your daughter has been mentioned as one that is causing a problem with your son and his family. Whether you agree with this or not, it's just going to add more fuel to the fire. I really don't advise this.

BluebellBeth · Yesterday 11:19

Not that I think you will take this on board

your dil has facilitated the whole family relationship with you whilst your ds never bothered. she's maintained the contact, done the phone calls, arranged for you to speak to the dgc, yet she's now controlling and abusive? And your whole family has failed to notice this for 20 years?
abusive controlling people don't maintain relationships on behalf of their partners. You are blaming her for your sons actions.

Your son cheated, no issue with you housing him, but to not check in with your dil was simply cruel. How would your ds know how the dgc were doing when he hardly saw them? You say happy men don't cheat, you are blaming her for your son's actions.

you rarely go and visit them and expect them (actually you expect dil) to make all the effort. Relationships are a two way thing. Again you are blaming her for your sons actions (or lack of).

you've made comments that have upset her but think it's ok because she was carrying your grandkids (that you make no effort to see).

you blame her for everything instead of acknowledging that your son is actually a bit shit, HE doesn't make contact, HE doesn't visit, HE cheats on her. Why do you think your grown ass son isn't responsible for any of HIS actions? Of course she's upset with you, who wouldn't be pissed off at getting the blame for things that are YOUR SONs fault.

I imagine in therapy they're discussing how checked out of family life he has been for years and this is why he's now saying you've upset his wife. He's finally realised he's never put her first, doesn't defend her when needed and that he needs to step up if he wants to keep his family.

HangrySloth · Yesterday 11:22

Italiangreyhound · Yesterday 02:53

@HangrySloth
Yes for real. If my adult child cheated on a partner, I would be very sad and upset. But i would not turn them away.

Her son is an adult why can’t he find his own place to live. My mil and I are very close so if her son cheated on me destroying our family I don’t think I would ever speak to her again if she condoned this by making it easy for him giving him a place to live. I wouldn’t give her the time of day unless she apologized to me. Is her DIL and the mother of her grandkids not family too

rainingsnoring · Yesterday 11:24

Muminturmoil0 · Yesterday 10:44

My DD is furious at what’s happened so she’s going to call her brother and give him what for and find out what’s going on. I’m very close with my DD so just goes to show I’m not an awful mother like some of you are suggesting. And my DD agrees this sounds like it’s come from the mouth of DIL so whilst I appreciate (some) people’s input here, I’ll take more notice from someone who actually knows the situation and people involved.
You all seem to have ignored the idea that DIL could be controlling or even abusive! My DD has also said maybe she’s controlling him which I hate to think could be true, especially as she now seems to be calling all the shots and gate keeping whether we can see or even speak to our DGDs. You all seem to be worried about DIL, but she has her own family. I’m worried about mine, which is perfectly normal. But make no mistake that I’m disappointed in my DS’s actions in cheating and also having a go at me.

As for the visiting, it is easier and makes more sense for them to come here than us go there because my husband has a bad knee so finds it difficult to sit in the car for long periods and DIL has changed their spare bedroom into a home office so we can’t stay over. It’s a long way to drive (and uncomfortable for my DH) just for the day. Whereas if they come to us they can stay over and also wider family and friends are here who they can visit at the same time like my DD and other GCs. And yes they have not bothered to visit us for 2 years despite how much easier it would be for them to come here than us go there, yet according to some of you, I am the problem! And FWIW we’ve never had the DGDs alone, not to stay over, not even for an afternoon - we’d have been more than happy to, we’d have loved to, but that’s never been an option.

What has this got to do with your DD favourite child? The fact that you are bitching about your DIL with your DDs does nothing to support what you say about being a good mother. The opposite, in fact.

So you haven't even bothered to see your own GC in 2 years and your excuse is that your DH has a bad knee? Seriously? You can't manage to make an effort to visit yourself even once in 2 years but yet you blame your DIL.
I am starting to think that this whole thread has been a wind up but, if not, then you are clearly the problem.

Goodgriefisthatrue · Yesterday 11:25

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:17

No didn’t contact her or the kids during that time, didn’t feel it was my place. Blood is thicker than water and all that and tbh I thought they would permanently split do didn’t think I’d see her again, and didn’t want DS to think I wasn’t supporting him (although I accept he was wrong to cheat)
Some might disagree with that, but I didn’t even think to get in touch with her. I’m sure in the same situation you’d do the same.
Once DS went back to her though I started up contact with the kids again, but as I say she never wanted to show her face.

No I wouldn’t feel the same - she is the mother of your grandchildren I would have called her and reached out…. I can’t believe you didn’t give your son a rocket up his arse either unless you and his Dad condone affairs!! Its not just his wife he has hurt he has hurt your GC!!

Whilst I agree that it’s your DS you should be annoyed at, I think you are right DiL is probably embarrassed but also cross that you didn’t have the compassion to call and say how are you? how can I help?

Edited to say, that I have just seen your post about not visiting them - theres trains, buses and hotels…. its a very poor excuse.

Notaninfluencertype · Yesterday 11:26

You sound like you are awful to your daughter in law, force advice on her that she doesn’t need (not sure I would trust the parenting of someone who’s brought up a son to cheat and both their children to shout abuse down the phone). She’s not going to want to travel and be trapped in your house in an area that’s not local to her, I wouldn’t want that either. At least at my own house I can escape your nasty behaviour and go meet my friends and family for a break from you.

XenaSharples · Yesterday 11:28

Your son cheats on your DIL, and then turns on you, but somehow it's her fault. 🙄

EveningSpread · Yesterday 11:29

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:26

I’m not placing blame but a happy husband doesn’t cheat. I don’t know if they had marriage problems before but he’s not going to cheat if he’s happy at home is he! He shouldn’t have done it but it does make me wonder if she knew she’d in some way pushed him to this, because why else would she have him back? I would no way have my DH back if he had cheated. I just can’t understand any it.
I am annoyed with DS after his call, make no mistake, but it was just so out of character. Contact from him has dwindled since he moved back to her, but he’s never said any or things before that he’s said on the phone. Does make me wonder if she given him an ultimatum.
Might call him when I know she’s not with him in case he wants to condone a different issue. Or get my DD (his sister to call), maybe he will say or act differently and tell the truth as to what’s going on. Keep flipping between that and just thinking they can fuck off now. Don’t know if I’m more angry or upset.

Happy people do cheat, sadly. Sometimes people are just opportunistic or foolish. And even if he wasn’t happy, who’s to say that wasn’t his own fault?

You keep blaming/speculating about DIL even though many people have pointed out that it’s your DS who has done all the wrong things here.

If you’re going to take the approach of not asking to be respectful, then you can’t also jump to conclusions about DIL.

I think it was probably wrong not to contact her during those 6 weeks - it may have appeared you were shutting her out.

My hunch is that you need to be a lot more open with your DS and DIL, and genuinely ask how to mend relations. Acknowledge the difficulties - different relationships with grandchildren because the others live so close; your attempts to be respectful by not getting involved may have appeared cold - and ask if you can move forward. Perhaps send DIL some flowers and tell her you have always cared about her.

It might be that you are being scapegoated for their family problems, but all you can do is try to mend things. It may not work, but that’s on them.

the7Vabo · Yesterday 11:29

jonesonscam · Yesterday 11:09

Nope. No. You definitely are NOT allowed to give unsolicited advice to your DiL about anything. Your inability to see any fault whatsoever on your side is the whole problem.

I generally hold myself back from giving unsolicited advice to anyone. For the simple fact that if they actually wanted my advice they’d ask. It can be a struggle the odd time as we all have different views on life but it makes for smoother relationships.

It baffles me that others don’t adopt the same approach, especially around what can be controversial subjects like parenting.

HangrySloth · Yesterday 11:29

PollyBell · Yesterday 03:09

You leave no idea what ahe ia like nor what she has done wrong in the relationship, you only know one side and this all women are saints and never do anything wrong and men are always to blame, maybe she cheated first and the son didn't want to tell anyone

There are 2 sides to a relationship and I will always stay neutral on any of my child's relationships, I can support them as a parent while not taking sides regardless of who did what, their relationship is between the parties involved only

Well we know he cheated and she has been her DIL for 20 yrs please spare me she doesn’t really know her speech at that point she is family and a DIL of 20 yrs should be like another one of your children! I’m sorry but my mil and I are close and if my husband cheated I’m not talking an amicable separation here but he cheated and my mil was aware and she took him in I don’t know if I would ever speak to her again unless she sincerely apologized. Also the sort where he SON picks up the phone her SON calls her and says these things and she blames his wife. He is the one choosing to pick up the phone and says these things to use words. He isn’t a 5 yr old little boy being told something and he has to listen. She is so concerned that her hard done by son is being forced by meanie wife to call mommy what about some concern that she raised a cheater a man who runs around on his wife and child. How about some concern for the woman who has been your DIL for 20 yrs the woman who is permanently a part of your family bc she is the mother of your GC? Guess only the son matters. She didn’t once not once reach out to her DIL. Hell even if they didn’t have kids strange to not reach out to the woman your son was with for 20 yrs. I could see if it was a bf/gf relationship with no children and they broke up amicably ok sure but she tossed her DIL aside like yesterdays garbage.