Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

It’s a DIL one this time!

931 replies

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 22:53

Long time lurker, first time poster.
I know MILs get a rough ride on MN but I don’t know where else to go.
I really don’t believe IABU so probably the wrong board to post on and I’m sure some of you will say IABU but also hoping for some advice and also to vent.

DS has been with his wife for I don’t know maybe 20 years and married about 15. They have twin 10 yo DDs
Last year DS came to stay with us, saying his wife had kicked him out for cheating. We were upset but didn’t question him on it as he didn’t seem to want to talk about it. He stayed with us around 6 weeks and eventually went home to his wife and children, 100 miles away from us. I didn’t ask any info and he didn’t tell us any. Personally I think she’s a mug for having him back but apparently they’re having therapy and working on things, so I’ve not said anything.
Was having monthly calls with DS and DGDs after he left here but the wife wouldn’t show her face on the calls. We’ve had no visits from any of them.

Anyway DS has now called us with a barrage of abuse telling us what awful people we are and I’m shocked! We had him staying here when his wife kicked him out and never interfered. He says we’ve not been supportive, his wife has never liked us (first I’ve heard!) and DGDs find us difficult too (again, first I’ve heard!)
I can’t help but think DIL has poisoned DS and DGDs against us and I don’t know why she would, maybe embarrassment, but we’ve done nothing wrong. I’m now told we can’t speak to our DGDs until we take responsibility for our actions. What actions? We’ve done nothing. AIBU for thinking they can all fuck off! DS has pissed me off as well tbh for falling for this shit from his wife. My DD agrees with us and thinks they (mainly DIL) are the problem, so I don’t think it is us and it’s good to hear that it’s not just me and DH who think it.

Would be good to know what MNers think should happen next. I think it’s on DS and his wife to get in touch with us, but I just don’t know what to expect next. He put the phone down on me because he didn’t like that I was standing up for myself and not just apologising for made up accusations.
I know MILs are often hated on here, but remember some of us are good and sometimes DILs are not. So help on what to expect from them next and what might happen next for anyone who has been in a similar situation would be gratefully received.

Can give more info or background if needed, happy to answer questions if helps with context. We’ve always been a nice happy family, but looking back I have felt the distance from DS since he moved away to where his wife and her family are from. But interactions up until now have been fine, so I don’t know where this has all come from. Hence why I’m thinking DIL may have had a heavy hand in this.

Expecting some criticism, but hopefully more help that hate. TIA.

OP posts:
Chickpeacurrywithrice · Yesterday 08:42

Newyearawaits · Yesterday 08:25

Very unfair comparison, OP was attempting to navigate a very difficult position and has condemned her son for his actions.
Whatever OP did or didn't do, she would be in the wrong.
You describe your ex MIL as vile. That certainly doesn't apply to OP.

I don’t think you’ve read OPs posts! She condones her little soldier, because the little treasure wouldn’t have done it if he were happy at home.

She also “thinks” he saw his DCs maybe a couple of times, because again her little solider had no choice than to run back to mummy because “she kicked him out”, he could find no suitable accommodation between the two houses to stay and ensure he maintained a relationship with his no doubt traumatised DC.

Also had disdain for DIL “kicking him out”, I would’ve described this as “asked to be given some much needed space”, but she also
thinks that DIL is a fool for taking him back (she probably is to be fair), or she’s embarrassed for taking him back, which is why she’s “forcing” the little soldier to argue with his mummy!

It’s DIL who is the one that can’t do any right! Clearly!

comealongdobbeh · Yesterday 08:43

You are absolutely refusing to see this from your DIL’s side and not being very approachable. If you are like this in real life I can understand why she’d have problems with you.

Yes she kicked him out. She was right to do it.

You housed him while they split. You were right to do it.

You didn’t contact her during that time - this was wrong

You didn’t contact your DGCs during that time - this was wrong

Theyre now back together and you think DIL is wrong for taking him back - you are wrong here. Without speaking to her, how can you possibly understand why she did? My DH has made mistakes and I’ve taken him back for a whole plethora of reasons. I am not a mug.

Since they have been back together, you still haven’t checked in - this is wrong.

You haven’t offered her any support during a difficult period in her marriage and she is your DAUGHTER-in-law - this is wrong.

You haven’t tried talking to her to find out what is going on. Yes your DS called you in anger complaining about XYZ.

This may be new to you but it could also be things they have been discussing in therapy or arguing about and maybe he suddenly sees it. His manner of conveying it was very wrong. But your refusal to try to make contact and hear them out calmly is wrong. You are wrong here.

And if this is your reaction to it all - yes, you’re wrong and YABU.

Pipsquiggle · Yesterday 08:43

TBH @Muminturmoil0 you sound like you have a distant and passive relationship with your DS and DGDs and virtually none with your DIL.

1 phonecall a month!

You seem to have absolutely no curiosity about your DS's abhorrent behaviour when he stayed with you for 6 weeks - no questions, no guidance.

You also showed absolutely no support to your DIL. A text to her saying 'I am so sorry you are going through this. Whatever happens, you are the mother of my GC and I will always love you. Please let us know if we can help'

Your casual misogyny blaming her for his cheating is very telling.

TBH I have very distant in-laws, I tried at the beginning to be inclusive, get my DH to invite them to stuff but in the end I just gave up because it was exhausting and it should be my DH managing that relationship not me.

I am sure that my DH grew up in an emotionally starved house. Him and his siblings don't have a close relationship with his parents - similar to you, maybe 1 phonecall a month.

My mum and dad, we have a group WhatsApp and we're in contact everyday with messages and a video call once or twice a week - my DC are also on the WhatsApp group.

So you ask why your DS acts like this? Please look at your own behaviour and how you brought him up and maintain contact with him before blaming DIL.

AppleCerulean · Yesterday 08:44

SixtySomething · Yesterday 08:32

Since they're having therapy, perhaps they are using you as a scapegoat for their problems?

Or maybe the OP's history of bringing up her son's exes, criticising her DIL while pregnant and postpartum with twins, expecting them to travel and refusing to make the effort herself and unfavourably comparing them to her daughter has finally got to be too much?

Maybe it's not the DIL's fault or a therapist's fault but actually the OP isn't a completely perfect and blameless person?

birdinatree1903 · Yesterday 08:46

Muminturmoil0 · Yesterday 00:33

No I’ve had kids of my own and have been around babies all my adult life. DD has kids so I definitely am allowed to give advice to the woman carrying my grandkids! Whether she takes it or not is up to her, but don’t throw it back in my face years later after apparently holding it in until the time suits!

😂😂 sounds like they’re sick of your unsolicited advice and you wont take any accountability. You even implied it was your DIL’s fault your precious son cheated on her! ‘I haven’t done anything wrong’ , I really struggle to believe that! You sound a difficult person.

rainingsnoring · Yesterday 08:46

MyDeftDuck · Yesterday 07:54

Ooops! Beggin your I’m sure pardon m’lady!
Good to know that the MN police are promptly on duty this early on a Sunday morning 🤪🤪🤪

Why MN police. If you had bothered to even read the first post, you would know that this was a telephone call with the DS. It seems that you too were desperate to blame the DIL and excuse the DS.

dinglethedragon · Yesterday 08:48

TheRoyalEyeroll · Yesterday 07:43

Jesus, what a thing to do to your DIL and your grandchildren. In fact what you’ve said is so callous I’m hoping this thread is bollocks.

One of my sons and his wife are divorced, it’s his own fault, and 4 years on she’s still my daughter in law and part of my family. So is my son but it never crossed my mind once to cast her adrift once the marriage was over. She’s one of us.

my lovely ex-MIL was exactly the same. 15yrs down the line and she has never wavered in her support for me and the DC. Ex moved away and married his AP. During the lockdown period it was us making sure MIL was OK, could get food, meds etc. We have taken her to hospital appointments, I still get invited to family events. It took a few years before ex, his new wife, and I could be comfortably at the same event, but we were all determined it was going to work - which involved a lot of biting of tongues on all sides. So no, @Muminturmoil0, not everyone would behave the way you have towards a betrayed DIL.

EmBear91 · Yesterday 08:50

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:17

No didn’t contact her or the kids during that time, didn’t feel it was my place. Blood is thicker than water and all that and tbh I thought they would permanently split do didn’t think I’d see her again, and didn’t want DS to think I wasn’t supporting him (although I accept he was wrong to cheat)
Some might disagree with that, but I didn’t even think to get in touch with her. I’m sure in the same situation you’d do the same.
Once DS went back to her though I started up contact with the kids again, but as I say she never wanted to show her face.

This is absolutely insane. If I was your daughter in law, I wouldn’t want you in my life again either given that, after TWENTY years in your family and being the
other of your grandchildren, you dropped her like a hot stone immediately after your son fucked someone else and betrayed her (and by extension his whole family). It’s also insane to me that you didn't think you’d ever see her again - were you just planning to never have contact with your grandchildren?

Backpain2026 · Yesterday 08:50

So your son cheated. Moved in with you.

And never once did you contact the grandchildren to see how they were? You assumed that you would just never see their mother again. OK, maybe. But why didn't you check in on the children?

You make 100 miles sound like it is the other side of the world. You could have very easily gone and seen your grandchildren, even though their father didn't, and provide practical and emotional support. But it didn't even occur to you to do so.

It's clear that your complete lack of care in this really difficult period was the tipping point. Everything previously could be ignored. But this is just too much, and so the old stuff comes out.

If you want to try and repair then you need to accept that you may have said and done things which are upsetting, even if you didn't mean to.

Get in the car and go and see them and say you want to make an effort

rainingsnoring · Yesterday 08:50

butterpuffed · Yesterday 08:13

Were there problems before all this happened, as you say they hadn't been up with the DGCs for 2 years ?

How often have you been to visit them ?

Not at all, according to what @Muminturmoil0 has written. It's apparently not on her to travel all that way!

Globules · Yesterday 08:50

You could be my XMIL.

The blame is not mine.

The sun shines out of DSs arse.

It's your fault he strayed.

The other DGDs live closer so are favoured over my kids.

I'll comment on your pregnancy health, your care of your newborn and your ongoing parenting when it isn't asked for. I'll tut when I disagree.

Despite being your MIL for over 20 years, I'm not going to contact you at all to say I love you and I'm sad about what's happening between you and DS.

I'm not going to keep in close contact with my DGD when they're going through the hardest time of their young lives. I'll drop them a text every few months or so wth something inane.

My now adult children have nothing to do with their nan anymore. They've seen her for who she is.

Fiddlesticks1 · Yesterday 08:51

Having read all you’ve posted a couple of things spring to mind besides the fact you are very angry and upset.
In the posts you mention offering advice to DIL during pregnancy and when she had the children. Your son has an affair and moves in with you.
DIL has time to contemplate marriage etc. You speak to DGC but don’t really engage with DIL.
What seems to have happened is resentment over the years has built up culminating in this. Perhaps she felt that in the six weeks you might have explained that you couldn’t not have your son with you and that you wanted to remain neutral and didn’t condone what he had done. Did you ever ask her if she was OK?
One hundred miles is nothing and I would be pretty upset if the grandparents didn’t make the effort to make the journey.
The DIL has obviously explained her resentment to your son and he is reacting to it.
My suggestion would be to offer an olive branch- I’m sorry if I have caused upset - didn’t mean to etc. Otherwise the estrangement will continue and the only person missing out will be you.

ThatHeartyHelper · Yesterday 08:52

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:26

I’m not placing blame but a happy husband doesn’t cheat. I don’t know if they had marriage problems before but he’s not going to cheat if he’s happy at home is he! He shouldn’t have done it but it does make me wonder if she knew she’d in some way pushed him to this, because why else would she have him back? I would no way have my DH back if he had cheated. I just can’t understand any it.
I am annoyed with DS after his call, make no mistake, but it was just so out of character. Contact from him has dwindled since he moved back to her, but he’s never said any or things before that he’s said on the phone. Does make me wonder if she given him an ultimatum.
Might call him when I know she’s not with him in case he wants to condone a different issue. Or get my DD (his sister to call), maybe he will say or act differently and tell the truth as to what’s going on. Keep flipping between that and just thinking they can fuck off now. Don’t know if I’m more angry or upset.

Just your first line, unfortunately yes sometimes they do!

rainingsnoring · Yesterday 08:54

Newyearawaits · Yesterday 08:19

I feel for you OP. You were stuck between a rock and a hard place.
As the paternal MIL, you are always going to be the one who is in the wrong.
Fwiw, you sound like you have done everything you could have to try and make it OK for everyone.
Take care OP.

What exactly has the OP done to make things okay for everyone? She didn't even bother to contact her poor DIL or grandchildren once when her DS was staying for 6 weeks, after he had cheated on his wife. She never bothers to visit them, ever. She bitches about her DIL with her DD, who is clearly the favoured child. She feels entitled to criticise her DIL when pregnant and refers to her as 'the woman carrying our grandchildren'. Despite her DS 'abusing' her during the phone call, and being the cheat, she has decided that this is all wicked DIL's fault. She has done everything to antagonise and upset the DIL and has made no effort with her DC either.

GetOffTheBedCalicoCat · Yesterday 08:54

rainingsnoring · Yesterday 08:50

Not at all, according to what @Muminturmoil0 has written. It's apparently not on her to travel all that way!

Yes. The OP says it is easier for them to travel to her. 4 people including young children and parents who presumably work- but the road is easier in just one direction. Must be a more difficult and trickier drive the other direction I guess.

rainingsnoring · Yesterday 08:56

GetOffTheBedCalicoCat · Yesterday 08:54

Yes. The OP says it is easier for them to travel to her. 4 people including young children and parents who presumably work- but the road is easier in just one direction. Must be a more difficult and trickier drive the other direction I guess.

That must be the explanation! It's probably all the DIL's fault too.

FluffMagnet · Yesterday 08:57

Honestly OP, your dislike of your DIL comes across loud and clear in your posts, plus your feeling that she is very much an outsider to your family (after 15 years in it). It sounds as though your DIL has tried to improve the relationship from her side, ignore your criticism, favouritism, refusal to see her as anything more than a conduit to your blood relatives, and the cheating incident will have prompted some very blunt conversations between the couple of your son's behaviour, including his family's behaviour. The feeling of being an unwanted outsider would have been magnified by your refusal to contact her to check on her during a period of huge stress and upset caused SOLELY by your DS - how dare you blame your DIL for his poor decisions and breaking of wedding vows?! The fact you were immediately willing (and seemingly hoping) to break off all contact with her when you though divorce was on the cards tells her (and us) everything you need to know about your feelings towards her.

If you want to repair this rift, have a good, long look at how you have behaved to this family member over the years and take responsibility for your actions. Otherwise your son and granddaughters are likely to be lost to you - is cutting off your nose to spite your face really worth it?

Finally, 100 miles is nothing, "easiest" for you maybe to have the visits but undoubtedly not for them (surely the granddaughters weekends are full and they would like to show you their lives rather than being shoehorned into the lives of their cousins) and do dwell on the fact your granddaughters are picking up on favouritism - your DD's children being round the corner is absolutely NO excuse for playing favourites.

SpiralSister · Yesterday 08:57

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:26

I’m not placing blame but a happy husband doesn’t cheat. I don’t know if they had marriage problems before but he’s not going to cheat if he’s happy at home is he! He shouldn’t have done it but it does make me wonder if she knew she’d in some way pushed him to this, because why else would she have him back? I would no way have my DH back if he had cheated. I just can’t understand any it.
I am annoyed with DS after his call, make no mistake, but it was just so out of character. Contact from him has dwindled since he moved back to her, but he’s never said any or things before that he’s said on the phone. Does make me wonder if she given him an ultimatum.
Might call him when I know she’s not with him in case he wants to condone a different issue. Or get my DD (his sister to call), maybe he will say or act differently and tell the truth as to what’s going on. Keep flipping between that and just thinking they can fuck off now. Don’t know if I’m more angry or upset.

This attitude is why. It is deeply unpleasant. Your son cheats but it’s still her fault, somehow. Didn't make him happy enough.

See also ‘am allowed to give advice when carrying my grandchildren’. Advice to the vessel, who was silly enough not to take it, presumably.

I noticed how they didn’t visit for a year. How often did you go to them in that time?

You may imagine, and even sincerely believe, that you have always been sweetly reasonable, but these opinions leak. She’s had enough of you, and perhaps so has he. I don’t know what to suggest, other than a profound look at your values, judgements, and rigid sense of being right about everything.

LaAranaPequenita · Yesterday 08:58

I think this post is made up because it ticks every MIL faux pas box going, however I will bite.

I know exactly why your DIL is doing this, as I am in a similar situation.

My DH didn't cheat (not that I know of), but we did separate about 6 years ago with him still in our house, but spending a lot of time with and being supported by my in-laws.

I also have a MIL that gives her opinions and unsolicited advice, one that favours her DD over her DS and his DC, and one that regularly uses the phrase "blood is thicker than water". Over the years I have sucked it up with a smile on my face, done wifey stuff for them (organise Christmas, Easter, meet ups, holidays, presents etc.) I sucked it up for my DC and DH and over the years the resentment grew and grew.

During our separation my PIL did not speak to me or my DC, and my SIL actively encouraged my DH to finish it with recommendations of solicitors and other info. My MIL didn't think she was going to see me again too. I'm not blood, I'm dispensable.

Here is what's in my head. Where were they when I was on my knees in despair? Where were they when DC were crying for their dad, stressed and anxious as they knew there was something massive wrong? They were NOWHERE. I can understand me, but not my DC.

We stayed together, and I have not given my DH any ultimatums, or said anything about his family. I did once and he defended them.

The right way to go about things was to tell your DS that he is a cheat and a liar, and he can stay with you, but you will also be checking in with his wife and DGC as they are family too, and you will be offering your support to her for your DGC (not her). That is the morally correct thing to do.

My PIL are older now and becoming increasingly infirm. I refuse to lift a finger for them. I am not rude, nor have I cut them off, but I do nothing and as a result I see them once every 6 months, as it was all me organising things, not DH. My DC don't really like them much, but are polite. I refuse to have anything to do with my SIL and see her once every 2 years and when I do, I barely acknowledge her.

When someone tells you who they are, listen and I did listen. They told me that I am no-one to them, not blood, not family and that my DC don't really matter to them. Well, now I know where I should and should not spend my energy.

You haven't been a decent MIL or DGM and now your SIL doesn't want to know you. Your DS is a coward, a cheat and a liar (well done on bringing him up like that) and because his wife has said "nah, I'm not doing that anymore" he has got stressed out and he is blaming his situation on you.

My MIL has tried to bring me back into the fold, as she is missing out, by being nice and buying me presents (she never did before) but I don't want them. My DH is not happy that I have stepped back with a pair of Seven-league boots on but I don't care because when we separated it was his fault, and one of the things I took back when I agreed to reconcile was no longer being treated like a 2nd class citizen by his family.

Finally, I know a few cheating men. The reason why they cheat is because they think with their penis, not their brain and they have low morals. Maybe you should look in the mirror at yourself as a mother before you blame his wife and poor kids.

OneShyQuail · Yesterday 08:59

Muminturmoil0 · 14/11/2026 23:17

No didn’t contact her or the kids during that time, didn’t feel it was my place. Blood is thicker than water and all that and tbh I thought they would permanently split do didn’t think I’d see her again, and didn’t want DS to think I wasn’t supporting him (although I accept he was wrong to cheat)
Some might disagree with that, but I didn’t even think to get in touch with her. I’m sure in the same situation you’d do the same.
Once DS went back to her though I started up contact with the kids again, but as I say she never wanted to show her face.

You lost me when you said your son stayed with you because he cheated on his wife and you didn't ask any questions.

Didn't ask any questions?! If be doing more than that. Morally poor behaviour and you didnt pull him up on it?!

Then you further lost me when you said you didnt contact his wife and kids during this time? Not your place? She could have been going thru hell....you didnt even pick up the phone to offer some support?!

Your son is a prize cnt, you havent pulled him up on his shtty behaviour, your haven't supported the victims of this behaviour and now hes called you kicking off and its his wife's fault?!

Explains a lot why your son is a tw*t.

NotGerrysSneakyBeak · Yesterday 09:03

OneShyQuail · Yesterday 08:59

You lost me when you said your son stayed with you because he cheated on his wife and you didn't ask any questions.

Didn't ask any questions?! If be doing more than that. Morally poor behaviour and you didnt pull him up on it?!

Then you further lost me when you said you didnt contact his wife and kids during this time? Not your place? She could have been going thru hell....you didnt even pick up the phone to offer some support?!

Your son is a prize cnt, you havent pulled him up on his shtty behaviour, your haven't supported the victims of this behaviour and now hes called you kicking off and its his wife's fault?!

Explains a lot why your son is a tw*t.

Edited

This! Also Op, the more you post, the more you sound very unreasonable & not a nice MIL at all!

YourJoyousDenimExpert · Yesterday 09:07

I think you missed a key opportunity toshow some solidarity to DIL when your son turned up to stay. I would have contacted DIL to say I was not happy with him but couldn’t deny him a place to stay but that this did not mean I condoned what he had done.
I would also have expressed concern for DIL and DGC and said that I would like to still call regularly while things were being worked out.
You say you were annoyed at what your son had done - yet DIL would not have known that.
In your position now, I would call my DIL and apologise for how you handled the situation and see what she says.
Your son is clearly manipulative and untrustworthy-so do not rely on communication with him to improve the situation.

LaAranaPequenita · Yesterday 09:07

NotGerrysSneakyBeak · Yesterday 09:03

This! Also Op, the more you post, the more you sound very unreasonable & not a nice MIL at all!

That is why I think this thread is made up. She sounds like a terrible MIL.

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · Yesterday 09:07

She kicked him out (not saying that was the wrong thing to do, even though she did later have him back)

Im seriously questioning the veracity of this thread

Its like MIL bingo and this is dripping in judgement.

Why cant she take a few weeks space to decide whether she wants to try and salvage the marriage her husband blew up? its not simple and there are 2 children to consider....

Although strictly speaking he didnt blowup the marriage... she did.... because "happy husbands dont stray" 🙄

And you also wouldn't know anything about it because despite the fact your son blew up his life you were unable to have any kind of basic conversation about it in 6 weeks....

Its TOO rage baity

Takeoutyourhen · Yesterday 09:11

Sounds like once he returned they have been having heated arguments and some home truths have been shared and your DS has turned it into a DIL problem. Ultimately deflecting what HE has done.

Swipe left for the next trending thread