Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think the BBC removing room on the broom is a bit much

164 replies

InSlovakiaTheCapitalOfCourseIsBratislava · 14/11/2026 21:40

BBC have removed Room on the Broom from iplayer. Apparently David Walliams voiced the frog
It seems somewhat overkill

(Not inthe least because it seems unfair on Julia Donaldson - plus of course whilst he might be morally reprehensible he currently isn’t legally reprehensible)

OP posts:
Finallyseenthelights · 15/11/2026 08:22

ThreadGuardDog · 15/11/2026 08:15

This really. The BBC have enabled this shit for decades. Pulling a stunt like this doesn’t fool anyone. It’s too little, too late. A better idea would be to pull down the statue sculpted by Eric Gill that has stood above the entrance to Broadcasting House since 1933. Gill was a child abuser, had incestuous relationships with both his sisters and sexually abused the family dog.

The BBC has chosen to keep the sculpture in place citing its architectural status as a protected Grade II listed building facade, as the justification. In my view, the work of an acknowledged child abuser, and frankly all round pervert, should not be preserved and displayed in a public space, or have any connection with any British institution. In the name of ‘art’ doesn’t cut it any more.

OMG is that still up???? What the actual hell? Why hasn’t it been vandalised already? A few protests outside threatening the TV license would probably see it being screened off or removed to ‘safety’ out of sight. It’s disgusting it’s still there on public display

Lemieux7 · 15/11/2026 08:33

For heavens sake. Definitely overkill. Are they getting rid of Despicable Me, I do doubt it…

Sartre · 15/11/2026 08:34

I agree, I didn’t even know he was in it to be honest. Lots of kids love those adaptations and some with SEN rely on them for comfort. He’s just a voice in it, replace the voice if it's such an issue but don’t take it down entirely. He didn’t write the book (obviously, because it’s good…)

ClearFruit · 15/11/2026 08:38

nomas · 14/11/2026 21:53

I think it’s the right decision. Total cancellation.

Buy the DVD on eBay if you miss it.

Because everyone has a DVD player these days.

Lemieux7 · 15/11/2026 08:42

Sartre · 15/11/2026 08:34

I agree, I didn’t even know he was in it to be honest. Lots of kids love those adaptations and some with SEN rely on them for comfort. He’s just a voice in it, replace the voice if it's such an issue but don’t take it down entirely. He didn’t write the book (obviously, because it’s good…)

Yes, my dd is one of those. It’s still up on YouTube (atm).

Sartre · 15/11/2026 08:44

Lemieux7 · 15/11/2026 08:42

Yes, my dd is one of those. It’s still up on YouTube (atm).

My DS was with The Gruffalo for a long time so I fully understand. I think the BBC need to overturn it or just replace the voice which should be easy enough. They could dub over it.

purpleme12 · 15/11/2026 08:50

InSlovakiaTheCapitalOfCourseIsBratislava · 14/11/2026 22:36

THeyve taken down the episode of Dr Who (11th doctor and Amy and Rory - actually quite good) as well

I can kinda understand taking down his own original content - the Mr Stink and Gamgsta Granny and Little Britain , but places where he was just a voice or an actor seems a bit disproportionate- and really unfair on the other actors if the logic is so that there aren’t any royalties (not sure how it works with streaming)

(i also don’t believe his books should be being removed from school and public libraries . THey might be dross but they aren’t hateful and it does amount to censorship . Don’t have them on display but no need to remove them)

Yes agree

MassiveOvaryaction · 15/11/2026 08:59

Pinkflamingo10 · 14/11/2026 21:50

My kids fave Trolls the movie has Russell Brand voicing one of the trolls 🤮

Dh said that, I'd forgotten blocked it out that he was in it.
At least with animations these things can get pulled temporarily and re-dubbed.

Biddybobsleigh · 15/11/2026 09:01

ThreadGuardDog · 15/11/2026 08:15

This really. The BBC have enabled this shit for decades. Pulling a stunt like this doesn’t fool anyone. It’s too little, too late. A better idea would be to pull down the statue sculpted by Eric Gill that has stood above the entrance to Broadcasting House since 1933. Gill was a child abuser, had incestuous relationships with both his sisters and sexually abused the family dog.

The BBC has chosen to keep the sculpture in place citing its architectural status as a protected Grade II listed building facade, as the justification. In my view, the work of an acknowledged child abuser, and frankly all round pervert, should not be preserved and displayed in a public space, or have any connection with any British institution. In the name of ‘art’ doesn’t cut it any more.

Omg, I never knew this. Wtf??

scalt · 15/11/2026 09:06

This thread (and others) is like the Covid hysteria all over again. Mumsnet loves a witch hunt.

Grab your torches and pitchforks for:
The heretics who don’t clap on their doorsteps!
The selfish arseholes with naked faces!
The grandparents who have their grandchildren over!
Those who walk their dogs a second time in the day (and who have dogs at all)!
The shoppers who buy Easter eggs!
Those who walk in the country, when they should be cowering at home in front of the telescreen television for the next briefing!
The jab refuseniks!
The granny-killing tinfoil hat-wearing conspiracy theorists!
Those who don’t worship Boris Johnson!
The playground fence violators!
Cancel anyone who dares to speak against lockdown!

Stillreadingalot · 15/11/2026 09:07

BillieWiper · 14/11/2026 22:35

Jackson wasn't found guilty of anything I don't think? And many stations do totally boycott his music. Or play it extremely sparingly considering how popular he once was.

And that one guy from the Rolling Stones who married Mandy Smith, did he get done for that? I don't think the others were found guilty of anything?

DW hasn't been charged with anything nor been found guilty of anything. Do I think hrs a sleaze - yes but the only trial he's had is trial by media

scalt · 15/11/2026 09:09

YankSplaining · 15/11/2026 04:08

This is one of the many reasons why I think physical media is so important. Being able to access a movie isn’t the same thing as owning a copy you can hold in your hand.

We’ve got Despicable Me on DVD at our house, and it won’t disappear from the shelf no matter what Russell Brand is convicted of.

Can you say this ten times louder, please? Notice how we are stressing being nudged away from owning any physical media: precisely so that it can be cancelled and memory-holed out of existence when it suits the Ministry of Truth.

ThreadGuardDog · 15/11/2026 09:13

Biddybobsleigh · 15/11/2026 09:01

Omg, I never knew this. Wtf??

Gill was a sculptor and typesetter. After his death his diaries revealed the severe and long term abuse of his two daughters and the incestuous relationships with both his sisters. He also had a history of bestiality, including the family dog.

The BBC has long tried to separate the artist from the abuser, enabled by Historic England who have refused to cease cataloguing his works. Their statement to this effect, published in 2023 is below:

The revelations about Gill have led to a difficult re-examination of the artist and his work. Gill’s skill was recognised through Listing for several decades before his abuse became public knowledge and it is possible that we will continue to receive applications to list further sites that include his work.

As an organisation we have a duty to recognise Gill’s established reputation as an artist and to be open about what we have learned about his personal behaviour, which is why we have taken the decision to link to this statement from each entry on the National Heritage List for England which references him in due course.

We have a responsibility to protect and champion England’s built heritage, but also to provide suitable interpretation where there are connections to people whose behaviour or values are a source of great pain for many people and challenge how society perceives their work.

GreenOnio · 15/11/2026 09:19

I watched a movie the other day that had Brand (didn’t know that in advance) in it and I’ve heard several Michael Jackson songs this week so I think it’s overkill. I guess because he has been accused of trying to sleep with people under the age of consent they want to sever ties between him and children

XenaSharples · 15/11/2026 09:26

| hate all this cancellation bollocks.

trapdooragain · 15/11/2026 09:34

BillieWiper · 14/11/2026 22:35

Jackson wasn't found guilty of anything I don't think? And many stations do totally boycott his music. Or play it extremely sparingly considering how popular he once was.

And that one guy from the Rolling Stones who married Mandy Smith, did he get done for that? I don't think the others were found guilty of anything?

Correct although he did pay out on the civil suit he would have been advised to do so

Isobel201 · 15/11/2026 09:39

Lemieux7 · 15/11/2026 08:33

For heavens sake. Definitely overkill. Are they getting rid of Despicable Me, I do doubt it…

No, they can't just get rid of an entire film series based on something one actor did.

ChillWith · 15/11/2026 09:45

He probably gets royalties from it so it makes sense to remove it. You would think the voice could be digitally swapped but there must be more to it in contracts for example.

bettyrubble99 · 15/11/2026 09:50

My boys used to love watching Mr Stink & Gangsta Granny.
I always wonder what the BBC think of Huw Edwards been the one that announced the Queens death after what he did too.

InSlovakiaTheCapitalOfCourseIsBratislava · 15/11/2026 09:57

scalt · 15/11/2026 09:06

This thread (and others) is like the Covid hysteria all over again. Mumsnet loves a witch hunt.

Grab your torches and pitchforks for:
The heretics who don’t clap on their doorsteps!
The selfish arseholes with naked faces!
The grandparents who have their grandchildren over!
Those who walk their dogs a second time in the day (and who have dogs at all)!
The shoppers who buy Easter eggs!
Those who walk in the country, when they should be cowering at home in front of the telescreen television for the next briefing!
The jab refuseniks!
The granny-killing tinfoil hat-wearing conspiracy theorists!
Those who don’t worship Boris Johnson!
The playground fence violators!
Cancel anyone who dares to speak against lockdown!

Er… this thread is was it overkill for the BBC to have withdrawn the film “Room on the Broom” - an adaptation of children’s book by Julia Donaldson where David Walliams voiced the frog

Not sure how it relates to COVID

OP posts:
EmotionalSupportCuttlefish · 15/11/2026 09:57

noworklifebalance · 14/11/2026 21:56

Perhaps he receives some payment related to each time it aired? Or maybe simpler just to remove everything that featured him rather than trying to justify why some are allowed to remain.

This makes the most sense. He is getting royalties (is that the right term?) so they need to cut that off.

Tricksortreats · 15/11/2026 09:59

I hate this purist cancellation culture. He's an unpleasant man who is suspected of doing bad things, some of which may have been against the law. Doesn't mean we're all going to catch leprosy if we hear his voice. And I don't care if he receives payment from the frog voice in the future. He did the frog work - there was nothing illegal about that and presumably hearing the frog voice won't harm children in any way.

Tricksortreats · 15/11/2026 10:02

Why is everyone so desperate to stop him earning royalties for voicing a frog, using the inoffensive words of Julia Donaldson? Are nasty people not allowed to earn money for the rest of their lives?

InSlovakiaTheCapitalOfCourseIsBratislava · 15/11/2026 10:19

It also seems really unfair on Gillian Anderson, Sally Hawkins, Rob Brydon, Timothy Spall and Martin Clunes if the sole reason is to prevent royalties

As as I said upthread, I can kind of understand removing content that he created, - quite easy to justify in that not only did he write it and cameo in it but there is often some unpleasant attitudes being touted - but to take down a children’s animation? It’s a frog asking if it can hitch a lift

OP posts:
PuggyPuggyPuggy · 15/11/2026 10:22

I found this enthusiasm for involving a man who was essentially famous for being a massive obnoxious shagger in stuff for children very odd at the time. Were there not enough actors in the world who can do a silly voice in a cartoon, and who aren't likely to pop up unexpectedly on a child's screen, saying things we would all prefer children to not hear about? Very strange.

Swipe left for the next trending thread