Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I complain about Costa not serving me?

220 replies

cottoncandy260 · 14/11/2026 17:31

Opening hours on door said it closes at 5pm. My daughter and I went in at 4.38pm. Only one barista in there, cleaning up, most of the machines already shut down. My dd wanted a frappé to take away. We were told this wasn’t possible as the machine was now cleaned and turned off. I said that the opening times said 5pm so there were still 22 minutes left to serve. The barista replied that she started closing machines at 4.30pm. I said the times on the door should therefore say 4.30pm or at least highlight that there’s a cut off for ordering. She then said dd could have a hot chocolate if she wanted but she didn’t really want that so we just left.

I want to complain but it’s my local Costa and I don’t necessarily want the barista to get into trouble. However, I just feel annoyed that we’d made the effort to get there in time (it was a treat for my daughter after she’d just done a competition) but we were technically refused service. AIBU?

OP posts:
ilovepixie · 14/11/2026 21:19

Say a restaurant closes at 9. Would you go in at 8.55 and expect a full cooked 3 course meal? I’m just wondering how it works. I used to work on a deli and we closed at 5 but were paid to 5..30 to clean up.

Cobrakainerd · 14/11/2026 21:21

In OPs case, by all means suggest to the company they need to reorganise staff hours to include paid cleaning time, spoiler they won't, as they think closed=not making any money. Set up/ clean up is wasted customer footfall time in company eyes. Staff have to work within that framework, if cleaning takes 30 minutes, then 30 minutes before closing is when it starts. They would have to pay for longer staff hours. That won't happen.

I'm in retail, Im paid to work say 8-5,say 5 we close, at 5.01 I'm out the door, very occasionally a idiot customer rocks up just before 5, making us late leaving, the music off, tills shut down, lights off, make it clear we are closing! 8-5 you will get the best customer service I can give, before and after is my time, not company, not customer. I make it clear to boss that I expect either the time back next day or overtime logged. Im not paid enough to be a martyr. We aren't paid enough to think oh other professions stay after hours. Its completely irrelevant. Theres no career ladder to think of, its a job, just not enough to cover bills!
Shops/ cafes/bars are open long hours, 6or 7 days a week, none are so essential to your life that you cant plan visits to purchase/ consume within the hours and using critical thinking that the staff need to be out on time.

Brawsome · 14/11/2026 21:26

So why don’t the shops close when the cleaning cycle begins? Serving day is over, peace for staff to clear up. That would be my ideal (coffee shop) world.

OrangeBlouse · 14/11/2026 21:29

This thread shows up exactly why companies get away with expecting staff to do extra unpaid work.

The OP is annoyed she couldn’t get served 20-odd minutes before closing. People are queuing up to tell her she’s unreasonable because the waitress might not get paid beyond 5. Obviously it’s the OP’s fault for even daring to order a drink at that time! And she absolutely must not complain in case the company punishes the waitress.

Why isn’t it the company’s fault for trying to con their staff into extra work? Why make it the OP’s fault for complaining, rather than the company’s fault for there being something to complain about? Saying the OP must absolutely not complain in case the staff member is punished is letting the company off the hook. You’re essentially giving them permission to keep on behaving that way.

SilenceInside · 14/11/2026 21:34

The easiest and simplest way to “complain” is just not to go to that chain any more. They don’t offer the service that you would prefer, so don’t use them. I’m sure there are lots of other coffee shops who operate more to your liking. Not giving them business will be more effective than writing to head office to complain.

SomethingYum · 14/11/2026 21:39

PigeonsAmongstTheCats · 14/11/2026 17:43

You weren't refused service. You were told that a menu item wasn't available and you're being absolutely ridiculous.

The world has gone to pot, good and proper

UnintentionalArcher · 14/11/2026 21:43

Clarabell77 · 14/11/2026 18:12

She couldn’t get coffee. At Costa Coffee. Hardly ridiculous.

Yes. I expect that multiple, if not most, menu items were unavailable on that basis.

It’s annoying when a large brand whose success is based partly on consistency - same drink everywhere, good availability, good hours - closes down so early. It’s part of the unspoken contract that they are consistent with things like opening (though of staff absence would be outside their control I suppose). People expect a small, independent coffee shop to have a last orders fifteen minutes before closing policy but not Costa. They should pay their staff properly to clean when they are actually closed, or at least allow for a paid buffer time in case customers come in at the last minute.

I think previous suggestions to complain about the company’s poor policies around this and treatment of workers is the best option. I would even suggest just saying you went into a Costa in whatever town/area you’re in (if there’s more than one locally) so there’s no chance of it being taken out on the specific employee.

intrepidpanda · 14/11/2026 21:44

CurledHairAndRoses · 14/11/2026 20:46

They will be paid until 5 pm

That's rubbish. I used to work in a supermarket and was paid 30min after closing to clear out and clear up.

Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz · 14/11/2026 21:45

ilovepixie · 14/11/2026 21:19

Say a restaurant closes at 9. Would you go in at 8.55 and expect a full cooked 3 course meal? I’m just wondering how it works. I used to work on a deli and we closed at 5 but were paid to 5..30 to clean up.

OP was asking for a takeaway coffee from a coffee shop within opening hours, not a sit-down cooked meal though

cottoncandy260 · 14/11/2026 21:45

Those that say go elsewhere or that Costa is crap are absolutely right. I only went there because it was the only place still ‘open’ and my daughter particularly likes the frappes. I was just annoyed as we’d literally rushed there to try and get there before it closed and I honestly thought 20 minutes to spare would be enough time to get a takeaway drink. We were not intending to drink in.

But I agree, complaining about the barista per se is not the way to go and I do understand why she would start shutting things down in order not to have to work in her own time. I was just frustrated that the opening times aren’t really the opening times.

OP posts:
SatansFavourite · 14/11/2026 21:51

I think it's easy to assume you're being a bit of a princess here, but you are not. Costa staff get paid to stay beyond the closing time of the store and I'm really not sure why anybody assumed they would stop getting paid dead on store closing time. There are 2 people on at closing and one HAS to be a manager or team leader. Regular staff members are not authorised keyholders. There is not a chance in hell this girl was closing the store by herself. Even if she was the manager/TL, there would have been someone else in the back, too. In the very unlikely event that she was alone, she should would be getting paid for cleaning after. They typically get 45 mins to an hour to clean after closing.

My guess, which I have seen happen countless times during my working life, is that they wanted to go home early so started closing everything down early. No, I don't blame them for wanting to go early, but it is a paid job working for a business that they decided to sign up for. They're getting paid to run the store and should do so in accordance with how the business want it ran. That means serving drinks until closing and not shutting down equipment pretty much half an hour before that time. I mean honestly, she would have just been better off telling you it was broken.

So yes, instead of assuming the worker is a victim and making excuses for her poor conduct, you should complain. It will do her a favour in teaching her that that sort of behaviour will not fly in any workplace. You get paid to do a job, do it how you're supposed to, regardless of how many excuses you think you have.

mediummumma · 14/11/2026 21:55

I wouldn’t complain. I would expect the staff to be trying to head out the door as close to closing time as possible so it’s obvious that some clean up/shut down would be in progress near to the end of business. Have you never seen a retail business pull the shutters part-way down or have a staff member at the door to prevent new customers entering the shop about 15mins before the stated closing time? This allows the staff to finish work at their finishing time, as they should.

Loloblue · 14/11/2026 21:57

PrettyLittleRose · 14/11/2026 21:05

🙄

🙄 yourself.

SilenceInside · 14/11/2026 21:59

Honestly, all this thought about complaining, contacting head office…. Surely you just consider that it’s not the kind of service you think is up to scratch and give them a wide berth in future. A fraction disappointing for you and your dd who was prevented from having the promised treat, but not exactly something that you wouldn’t shrug off in a moment.

HRTtoHeart · 14/11/2026 22:01

I was just annoyed as we’d literally rushed there to try and get there before it closed and I honestly thought 20 minutes to spare would be enough time to get a takeaway drink

From a bit of real-life experience, if the place has been very quiet and there's not been any call for frappés (because it's so damned cold) that day, it's very common to shut down the machine if you're on your own.

It's not ideal but it's practicality because they aren't paid for enough of a post closing time clean.

OrangeBlouse · 14/11/2026 22:05

mediummumma · 14/11/2026 21:55

I wouldn’t complain. I would expect the staff to be trying to head out the door as close to closing time as possible so it’s obvious that some clean up/shut down would be in progress near to the end of business. Have you never seen a retail business pull the shutters part-way down or have a staff member at the door to prevent new customers entering the shop about 15mins before the stated closing time? This allows the staff to finish work at their finishing time, as they should.

I have indeed seen that, and I hate it. The same shops who do that then complain that everyone is shopping online and they’re not making any money.

cottoncandy260 · 14/11/2026 22:05

HRTtoHeart · 14/11/2026 22:01

I was just annoyed as we’d literally rushed there to try and get there before it closed and I honestly thought 20 minutes to spare would be enough time to get a takeaway drink

From a bit of real-life experience, if the place has been very quiet and there's not been any call for frappés (because it's so damned cold) that day, it's very common to shut down the machine if you're on your own.

It's not ideal but it's practicality because they aren't paid for enough of a post closing time clean.

It was actually quite busy

OP posts:
mynextchapter · 14/11/2026 22:22

I’m so shocked to learn staff don’t get paid after closing hours if they are required to stay and clean equipment. Why on earth are Costa (and others) allowed to get away with this. Why can’t the staff refuse to do it unpaid? They can’t contractually have to work unpaid? Surely not?

PrettyLittleRose · 14/11/2026 22:31

mynextchapter · 14/11/2026 22:22

I’m so shocked to learn staff don’t get paid after closing hours if they are required to stay and clean equipment. Why on earth are Costa (and others) allowed to get away with this. Why can’t the staff refuse to do it unpaid? They can’t contractually have to work unpaid? Surely not?

Nothing to be 'shocked' about. Of course people get paid for the extra 30-40 minutes it takes to clean down the equipment and clean the store. (After it closes...) As if people would close the cafe at 5pm, then stay til 5.40pm without getting paid for it. No-one is doing that.

CorkedWellbeing · 14/11/2026 22:34

It would have really annoyed me as well, OP. A local health food store does this at random times i.e. they advertised that the café is open until 4.30pm, but sometimes they've cleaned the coffee machine at 4pm, sometimes 3.45, and sometimes they will happily still make a coffee at 4.45 for a friend. It is maddening!
In the grand scheme of things it really doesn't matter, but I do struggle to be cool about it in the moment. Especially as the manager of this store is always on Instagram banging on about supporting local! I'm bloody trying to, Bruce! 🤣

Dragononawagon · 14/11/2026 22:58

PrettyLittleRose · 14/11/2026 22:31

Nothing to be 'shocked' about. Of course people get paid for the extra 30-40 minutes it takes to clean down the equipment and clean the store. (After it closes...) As if people would close the cafe at 5pm, then stay til 5.40pm without getting paid for it. No-one is doing that.

You’re wrong, this is exactly how it happens in most major coffee chains. If service is busy till close, there isn’t enough time left to complete all the tasks, so you end up working over, and you don’t get paid for it.

HobgoblinNorFoulFiend · 14/11/2026 23:00

PrettyLittleRose · 14/11/2026 22:31

Nothing to be 'shocked' about. Of course people get paid for the extra 30-40 minutes it takes to clean down the equipment and clean the store. (After it closes...) As if people would close the cafe at 5pm, then stay til 5.40pm without getting paid for it. No-one is doing that.

Nope I had a retail job after I retired. Took us at least 35 minutes to close and clean and we weren’t paid past the 5.30 time the door closed.

Tryagain26 · 14/11/2026 23:12

Dollymylove · 14/11/2026 18:15

Whats minimum wage got to do with it? The wages paid are not the concern of the customer. If you accept a job at minimum wage there is no get out clause saying you dont have to do certain things

It's not just that they are on a minukum wage they only get paid until 5pm. They are also expected to clean the coffee machine before they leave..So if they don't want to work for free (and why should they?) they have to turn the machine off at 4.30 to clean it before leaving.
The store closes at 5 but it doesn't mean they will serve everything until 5pm just as a restaurant may close at 11pm but they probably wouldn't take someone's order for a three course dinner at 10.30.

Heggettypeg · 14/11/2026 23:18

They should be upfront, on the door, about the time they stop serving. It would be better for the customers, and better for the staff, who would have to deal with fewer pissed-off customers feeling they have been misled.

MotherofTeenDragons · 14/11/2026 23:21

How is this anything other than mildly irritating?