Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Alesha Dixon & Amanda Holden

150 replies

Whattodoonarainysaturday · 14/11/2026 13:53

Do you think they were aware of what was going on?
Have they made any statements

OP posts:
Illalwayssayhi · 14/11/2026 14:54

What’s your AIBU? Or did you start your thread here to maximise attention?

SpidersAreShitheads · 14/11/2026 14:54

I’m not a fan of Amanda Holden at all. I think she’s a shitty person who will do practically anything for fame and fortune.

But having said that, I’m not sure what she could have done. David Walliams is extremely litigious- as we know - so she couldn’t speak out without dire consequences. And by that I don’t just being being blacklisted from the industry, also being sued for huge £££s.

Maybe she could have spoken to the bosses, but maybe she did. And maybe the culture of having 15,16,17 yr old girls brought to dressing rooms was so normalised, the bosses wouldn’t have cared.

So that leaves her with a dilemma - quit the job (that she seems to have loved) or just put up with Walliams on camera. I don’t know if there’s anything to suggest they were pally away from the camera?

I also don’t think that Walliams is the only man in the entertainment industry who’s behaved like this. He may have been one of the worst, possibly, but I’m certain that it was considered fairly normal and widespread. So I think women saw this kind of behaviour all the time and I don’t think bosses cared very much about- just look at the Russell Brand stuff, it was done in front of witnesses. No one cared, even when complaints were made by the victims.

And I suppose to some extent Holden et al might have thought “no harm done”. I know when I was 15, 16, 17, me and my friends were all dating or trying to date men in their late teens or early 20s. I briefly dated a 27 yr old when I was 16…. I wouldn’t have listened to anyone who told me I was too young for them. If a famous man in his mid-30s paid me attention, I can well imagine getting swept up in it. Amanda Holden was 22 when she started dating Les Dennis who was about 40. So if the girls went willingly and didn’t seem upset or traumatised - from what she saw - then she may just have thought it was harmless.

Obviously it isn’t harmless and at that young age you think you know everything, but in reality, you don’t always realise the consequences of your actions. So that’s why young girls and women need robust protection because they’re vulnerable to sexual predators, even if they seem to be willing participants. I’m just not sure that’s a view that’s historically been the common in the entertainment world - even among the women.

I really do think the behaviour was/is far more commonplace than we currently know and I suspect there are plenty of men worried about what might come out.

Junglejune · 14/11/2026 14:55

Snakeplanted · 14/11/2026 14:28

Of course, but why wouldn't they be? Their jobs are important to them in the same way anyone else's are. Would you really speak up if you were likely to never work in your industry again?

Yes there are some professions where word gets around. Show business, medicine, I’m guessing law? And people have the power to block you from getting another job. There was a whistleblower in the NHS who had to go to Australia to get a medical post as he was blackballed from any hospital in the UK.

Nurses who tried to report Jimmy Saville were threatened with the sack if they didn’t shut up about him.

HarlanCobenDogshit · 14/11/2026 14:56

Why not add Simon and Ant & Dec to your post?

Or Matt Lucas?

Or is it just up to women to police mens behaivours?

Whattodoonarainysaturday · 14/11/2026 14:56

FaceBothered · 14/11/2026 14:40

'Just worried'?

Well yes, I would have thought they'd be very worried.

Especially knowing that speaking up could finish their career, whilst the men continued to do exactly as they pleased.

You make it sound as though you think these women are to blame?

God, no, i'm just IF they knew and others, how could you not even attempt to do something about it? You could all get together collectively surely or do an anonymous tip off...I don't know, there has to be something?

OP posts:
UpbeatTime · 14/11/2026 14:56

I’m not sure that others do know.

Even with really strong safeguarding policies, lots of monitoring and checks, lots of staff and pupil feedback, a local headteacher was convicted of crimes against children.

Hindsight is a wonderful thing, it all adds up, afterwards.

Whattodoonarainysaturday · 14/11/2026 14:57

573bb · 14/11/2026 14:54

Those are the 2 that sicken me, they are at the top of their business - who on earth would have bought them down if they had the guts/morality to actually speak out?

No-one.

Yet we have never heard that they said anything or protected any young women. But it appears that they preferred to turn a blind eye.

Yes them too, if they knew

OP posts:
RikthePoet · 14/11/2026 14:57

Flamingojune · 14/11/2026 14:51

Better shut down mumsnet on those grounds

No, most threads rely on personal experience.

FaceBothered · 14/11/2026 15:00

Whattodoonarainysaturday · 14/11/2026 14:56

God, no, i'm just IF they knew and others, how could you not even attempt to do something about it? You could all get together collectively surely or do an anonymous tip off...I don't know, there has to be something?

And that's the problem with threads like this.

You don't know they didn't get together and give an anonymous tip-off.

None of us have any clue.

Whattodoonarainysaturday · 14/11/2026 15:00

Junglejune · 14/11/2026 14:55

Yes there are some professions where word gets around. Show business, medicine, I’m guessing law? And people have the power to block you from getting another job. There was a whistleblower in the NHS who had to go to Australia to get a medical post as he was blackballed from any hospital in the UK.

Nurses who tried to report Jimmy Saville were threatened with the sack if they didn’t shut up about him.

Yes but surely if you were a nurse and you knew those vile things that Saville was doing, as important as needing a job is, you would sacrifice that for the victims?

I also don't understand how Lucy B isn't being celebrated more?

OP posts:
Whattodoonarainysaturday · 14/11/2026 15:03

HarlanCobenDogshit · 14/11/2026 14:56

Why not add Simon and Ant & Dec to your post?

Or Matt Lucas?

Or is it just up to women to police mens behaivours?

Edited

God, no, not at all, it's everyone
I'm only wondering from the point of view of them being female and mothers and how most of us may have faced gross behaviour from men through our lives.
I would feel I would need to protect girls and children

OP posts:
Illalwayssayhi · 14/11/2026 15:11

You don’t know if they did say something or not

DeafLeppard · 14/11/2026 15:15

Most industries are cut throat at the best of times, and at the top they are populated by people who have looked at the price needed to pay to get there, and accepted it. The kind of people who feel the need to call out abuse are not the kind of people at the top of most industries.

I’d put money on them knowing and making the decision that they are comfortable paying the price in other women for their career.

Periperi2025 · 14/11/2026 15:18

I work in a traditionally male dominated profession and management are only just beginning to weed out the worst of the predatory males. We ALL knew, and I count myself in there, management knew and even people from outside the organisations knew.

But until someone but in a complaint AND agreed to make it official with a formal statement there was seemingly nothing that could be done about it (I was one of those who went official on behalf of a student and got one guy gone). The view from the victim was that management were not as supportive as they could have been towards her but she felt this was because they were so desperate not to fuck up this one chance to get him gone. My experience was that the moment I said the words 'I wouldn't be here talking to you if I wasn't prepared to go official' it took on a life of its own, escalating up the management structure almost instantanously.

HOWEVER, there were other younger staff who felt like they had been shut down and dismissed when trying to report themselves as direct victims, of other men, this was not an isolated problem. So it is far from straight forward.

I'm very open at work that I got this one guy sacked (I could have maintained my anonimity but thought 'fucked it that helps nobody'!) , and as such a lot of colleagues (male and female) have started opening up about their experiences around this one guy, stories going back 2 decades, both women who had been approached inappropriately by him and men who had witnessed it or were in relationships with female colleagues who had. They ALL knew and nobody did anything for 20 years.

Edited to add
I am mid 40s, well established in my career and have the power of perimenopause to make me just not care about any professional risk. Also in a decade it could be my DD who needs a uppity middle aged women to have her back!

DeafLeppard · 14/11/2026 15:23

@Periperi2025 agree that being senior enough to weather the storm it’s important. I always think about that when people say “oh, it was different times, inappropriate behaviour was fine then”. No, it wasn’t, it was always inappropriate, it’s just women didn’t have the power to speak out about it.

CliantheLang · 14/11/2026 15:23

You make it sound as though you think these women are to blame?

It's literally the first rule of misogyny: Women are responsible for what men do.

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/womens_rights/3236421-so-these-ere-rules-of-misogyny

Themaghag · 14/11/2026 15:24

That's right, despite the fact that most of the.men who mixed with Brand and Walliams doubtless knew precisely what they were getting up to, let's just blame the two women that Walliams worked with, because as ever, it's always a woman's' fault when men fuck up, isn't it?

For all we know Amanda Holden and Aleesha Dixon did approach Simon Cowell and the show producers about Walliams and their concerns were either simply dismissed or they were warned not to rock the boat.

I read yesterday that David Walliams never attended the the weekly press briefings for BGT because he didn't want to answer reporters' questions. And even though it was generally accepted that he was a predatory sleaze bag with a penchant for young girls, the msm didn't want to get involved due to his extremely litigious nature. In the case of Associated Media which owns the Times, the Sun and Harper Collins, the book publishers, reporters for the Sun and the Times reporters were told to lay off him as his childrens' books were top sellers and made a lot of money for Harper Collins.

There are always a lot of vested interests in these cases and sadly it never ends well for the whistleblowers. I've no doubt that everyone knew about Walliams, but if none of the more powerful men were willing to blab, I can quite see that Holden and Dixon probably thought they'd be sabotaging their careers to little purpose. However, it's obvious that The Guardian and ITN did speak to a lot of people during the course.pf.their investigation and we will.probably never know the names of everyone who contributed -.maybe Holden and Dixon were amongst them?

Snakeplanted · 14/11/2026 15:24

Whattodoonarainysaturday · 14/11/2026 15:00

Yes but surely if you were a nurse and you knew those vile things that Saville was doing, as important as needing a job is, you would sacrifice that for the victims?

I also don't understand how Lucy B isn't being celebrated more?

What about if you knew you'd be blacklisted and it was very unlikely anything would be done? Would you sacrifice your career, your family's livelihood then?

Whattodoonarainysaturday · 14/11/2026 15:25

Periperi2025 · 14/11/2026 15:18

I work in a traditionally male dominated profession and management are only just beginning to weed out the worst of the predatory males. We ALL knew, and I count myself in there, management knew and even people from outside the organisations knew.

But until someone but in a complaint AND agreed to make it official with a formal statement there was seemingly nothing that could be done about it (I was one of those who went official on behalf of a student and got one guy gone). The view from the victim was that management were not as supportive as they could have been towards her but she felt this was because they were so desperate not to fuck up this one chance to get him gone. My experience was that the moment I said the words 'I wouldn't be here talking to you if I wasn't prepared to go official' it took on a life of its own, escalating up the management structure almost instantanously.

HOWEVER, there were other younger staff who felt like they had been shut down and dismissed when trying to report themselves as direct victims, of other men, this was not an isolated problem. So it is far from straight forward.

I'm very open at work that I got this one guy sacked (I could have maintained my anonimity but thought 'fucked it that helps nobody'!) , and as such a lot of colleagues (male and female) have started opening up about their experiences around this one guy, stories going back 2 decades, both women who had been approached inappropriately by him and men who had witnessed it or were in relationships with female colleagues who had. They ALL knew and nobody did anything for 20 years.

Edited to add
I am mid 40s, well established in my career and have the power of perimenopause to make me just not care about any professional risk. Also in a decade it could be my DD who needs a uppity middle aged women to have her back!

Edited

Good for you, well done! 👏👏

OP posts:
Snakeplanted · 14/11/2026 15:25

There were people who could and should have done something who IMO were far better placed to do so and they didn't either, so I don't know why you'd single out these women.

BatchCookBabe · 14/11/2026 15:27

573bb · 14/11/2026 14:54

Those are the 2 that sicken me, they are at the top of their business - who on earth would have bought them down if they had the guts/morality to actually speak out?

No-one.

Yet we have never heard that they said anything or protected any young women. But it appears that they preferred to turn a blind eye.

??? WTH?

Where on earth did that come from?

Are we just dragging everyone down now who ever met David Walliams? Who, by the way, has not been charged with - or convicted of anything.

@Whattodoonarainysaturday YABVU to post this thread.

MagnoliaParks · 14/11/2026 15:28

Can we stop this?

If it turns out one of my colleagues has sex with a 16 year old years ago, or raped a woman, I don’t want there to be any inference that I was complicit.

I know nothing about my colleagues sexual preferences or history, and for the most part I don’t socialise with them and my working with them passes no comment on what I think about their morals.

I would speak up if I witnesses them harassing someone or if someone reported the harassment to me. I would consider what I wanted to do if I was the victim. I’m not sure I’d do anything if there were rumours about these things that everyone knew about but I had no direct involvement in - because it’s not for to perpetuate what might just be gossip, and if everyone knows then what’s the point of me repeating it.

Outside of that, being the colleague of a sexual predator is no reflection on me. So I’m not sure why it is for [insert celebrity name here].

BatchCookBabe · 14/11/2026 15:31

Whattodoonarainysaturday · 14/11/2026 15:03

God, no, not at all, it's everyone
I'm only wondering from the point of view of them being female and mothers and how most of us may have faced gross behaviour from men through our lives.
I would feel I would need to protect girls and children

So every person who has met any man - who has turned to be a bit dodgy/lecherous/creepy, should be called into question for not seeing it (and calling it out,) because they met him a few times, or worked with him?

Got it.

I pray you are NEVER on a jury!

.

Snakeplanted · 14/11/2026 15:32

MagnoliaParks · 14/11/2026 15:28

Can we stop this?

If it turns out one of my colleagues has sex with a 16 year old years ago, or raped a woman, I don’t want there to be any inference that I was complicit.

I know nothing about my colleagues sexual preferences or history, and for the most part I don’t socialise with them and my working with them passes no comment on what I think about their morals.

I would speak up if I witnesses them harassing someone or if someone reported the harassment to me. I would consider what I wanted to do if I was the victim. I’m not sure I’d do anything if there were rumours about these things that everyone knew about but I had no direct involvement in - because it’s not for to perpetuate what might just be gossip, and if everyone knows then what’s the point of me repeating it.

Outside of that, being the colleague of a sexual predator is no reflection on me. So I’m not sure why it is for [insert celebrity name here].

You might not be aware of your colleague's preferences, but if you were regualrly at events and parties where he was "chatting them up" you would be.

FaceBothered · 14/11/2026 15:33

Whattodoonarainysaturday · 14/11/2026 15:00

Yes but surely if you were a nurse and you knew those vile things that Saville was doing, as important as needing a job is, you would sacrifice that for the victims?

I also don't understand how Lucy B isn't being celebrated more?

I also don't understand how Lucy B isn't being celebrated more?

Her book has topped the best sellers list, she's being celebrated all over the internet.

Can you suggest how she could be celebrated more than that?