Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To find the whole ‘girl dad’ thing creepy as hell?

97 replies

ThatQuickLimePombear · 14/11/2026 08:04

I find the whole idea of men making being a father to daughters their entire personality really strange.

Why does having a daughter need its own special identity? You’re a father. Why does the sex of your child suddenly become such a defining feature of your parenting?

There’s also something about the way some men talk about being a ‘girl dad’, particularly when they suggest having a daughter has finally taught them to respect women, that really rubs me up the wrong way.

AIBU?

OP posts:
Norwaygirl · 14/11/2026 17:22

PollyBell · 14/11/2026 08:12

Well women say they only want a daughter so they can have a mini them and bond and be girlie and whatever so why is this any different

I have a friend who only wanted girls, finally got one with her 4th. I am sure she would have carried on until she had a daughter. My husband was treated completely differently to his older sister because his parents only wanted girls. His mother was horrified we had 2 boys and told me to abort and try again both times. Expected me to keep going until desired granddaughter was produced. So after much waffle I think I am trying to say there are far more women out there who think having a girl is the be all and end all and can't understand people who are happy with sons.

LasVegass · 14/11/2026 17:34

Never saw these terms so I haven’t given it any thought. My knee-jerk reaction is that it’s just a bit cringe, like other largely manufactured identities (in this case for social media rather than commercial motives). Interesting to read others’ opinions.

Hatty65 · 14/11/2026 17:40

I'm always bemused at people who use the phrase 'girl dad', 'girl mum' or 'boy mum'. You are a parent. It's not fucking special. Most people are.

I have only ever seen this on social media, however, and we all know that it's full of the utmost twaddle.

Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz · 14/11/2026 19:35

Hatty65 · 14/11/2026 17:40

I'm always bemused at people who use the phrase 'girl dad', 'girl mum' or 'boy mum'. You are a parent. It's not fucking special. Most people are.

I have only ever seen this on social media, however, and we all know that it's full of the utmost twaddle.

I find all the labels cringe, but boys and girls are not exactly the same.

I have an older girl, and now two boys with partner. It naturally would have been a slightly different if we were raising three daughters or three sons.

Similarly, growing up with brothers vs sisters, or a mix of both.

I don’t think it’s about being special, people want to label their experience and find others who are the same.

caringcarer · 14/11/2026 19:46

I recall Prince Harry wearing a T shirt with Girl Dad on shortly after Lilibet was born.

Mrcollinswave · 15/11/2026 12:59

Maybe it's because men have traditionally wanted boys, so this is like sticking two fingers up at anyone who feels sorry for them that they don't have a boy...same with the "boy mums" when women usually want daughters...look at all the gender disappointment threads on here when it's a girl! Maybe these women are determined to embrace having boys! certainly I feel I have to defend my boys all the time!
But surely we should be glad if men embrace having girls...isn't it a good thing? Why is it a red flag? Men can't do anything right 😆

Screamingabdabz · 15/11/2026 13:12

Mrcollinswave · 15/11/2026 12:59

Maybe it's because men have traditionally wanted boys, so this is like sticking two fingers up at anyone who feels sorry for them that they don't have a boy...same with the "boy mums" when women usually want daughters...look at all the gender disappointment threads on here when it's a girl! Maybe these women are determined to embrace having boys! certainly I feel I have to defend my boys all the time!
But surely we should be glad if men embrace having girls...isn't it a good thing? Why is it a red flag? Men can't do anything right 😆

Just interested (I also have a son) - what do
you feel you need to ‘defend’ your boys from?

BlueSherbet · 15/11/2026 13:50

I only have daughters and once (on holiday) a man from an eastern culture - completely out of the blue - tried to commiserate with me / cheer me up and was saying stuff along the lines of "never mind, maybe the next one will be a boy".

Looking back, I think he thought he was being nice but its actually pretty offensive.

At the time I was more concerned at how my wife would react at even the mere suggestion of having another child 😆 But It was a weird experience and later made me think what a shit culture they must have if they don't value their daughters. Fortunately my kids were v young and would never have picked up on the sentiment he was expressing.

When My wife was pregnant each time, I made sure not put my hopes on having a boy or a girl and didnt allow myself to even dream a little about it. My attitude was just that we would love and appreciate whoever God had sent, and be grateful for them. My only hope was everyone would be healthy 🙌

Im laughing at the "similar thread" suggestions here.

One says "boy mums" is misogyny, while here we have "girl dads" are creepy.

Its very difficult it seems for males to do or be anything, without somehow being offensive to women 😆

OneLoudPombear · 15/11/2026 13:57

ThatQuickLimePombear · 14/11/2026 08:25

Yes. I find that equally bizarre, particularly when women make being mothers to sons their entire personality. I don’t understand why the sex of your child needs to become a personality trait or a special parenting identity.

So why not also put this in your first post? Why was it just directed at men? It seems these days men are hated by women on this site, you all scream about how misogynistic men are but I think you all need to look closer to home, women really are not much better with what I’ve seen written on mumsnet.

Hatty65 · 15/11/2026 14:31

@Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz I have got both sons and daughters. They mostly didn't fit any kind of stereotype of 'girl' or 'boy' so I'm not sure what is different about raising them. I've got one boy who was a thuggish live wire, always covered in mud and spiders and one who is quite a gentle, creative soul with the diplomatic skills of a Nobel Prize winner. I've also got a very girly type girl who liked doing her hair and nails and is a kind hearted people pleaser and another girl who was like a stroppy urban terrorist who liked messing about with DIY and engines. Her favourite word was, 'Why?' (Mostly said belligerently).

Which sex they were made very little difference. They were pretty much all raised the same way, but have very different personalities.

PunnyJadeBear · 15/11/2026 14:40

It's a modern thing driven by social media so I don't take it that seriously.

Social media encourages people to come up with vague identities to fit a hashtag.

Same as Autism Mums/Dads Crunchy Mums/Dads and the like. So it comes across like they're making that their entire personality when really, it's just to claim being part of a 'tribe' for the purpose of social media.

ThreeLocusts · 16/11/2026 00:04

I think it's just cognitive dissonance management, same as with mums 'desperate for daughters'.

I spent six years as a mum of 'only girls' until ds came along, and I do remember a fair amount of condescension from parents of boys ('you must have it so easy'...). Societal stereotypes are stickier than we like to think; deep down multiple girls and no boys are still viewed as a disappointment by a fair few people.

So I find the 'girl dad' thing less creepy than desperate - protesting too much. If you were really at peace with having daughters not sons, you wouldn't make such a song and dance about it.

Autumnalhibernationisthedream · 16/11/2026 00:23

At the till the other day there were three men talking about a girl’s football team. One of them was a coach, the others parents. I think any parent taking an interest in their kid’s sports great (unless they’re the barges shouter on the sidelines, and none of the guys seemed like they’d be that guy!!!!)

Lavenderwindow · 16/11/2026 03:10

Oh yeah. I recently heard someone wanging on about being a 'twin parent'. I was just so confused but turns out they describe themselves as " nonbinary " and they now have twins.

Belweather · 16/11/2026 09:55

Lavenderwindow · 16/11/2026 03:10

Oh yeah. I recently heard someone wanging on about being a 'twin parent'. I was just so confused but turns out they describe themselves as " nonbinary " and they now have twins.

To be fair there are significantly different parenting challenges in having twins (or multiples) so that’s a bit different.

Parenting advice and guidance that works for one baby totally falls apart for two (or more). The first two years at least are very different for twin mums (and dads!) and even as they get older there are some key twin specific challenges.

Anywherebuthere · 16/11/2026 09:58

No different to the ridiculous 'boy mum' thing going on for years. Like it's some kind of flex. I've never looked at it as creepy.

Hydrangeblueeyes · 16/11/2026 10:07

ThatQuickLimePombear · 14/11/2026 08:04

I find the whole idea of men making being a father to daughters their entire personality really strange.

Why does having a daughter need its own special identity? You’re a father. Why does the sex of your child suddenly become such a defining feature of your parenting?

There’s also something about the way some men talk about being a ‘girl dad’, particularly when they suggest having a daughter has finally taught them to respect women, that really rubs me up the wrong way.

AIBU?

Absolutely agree with you. Dad daughter ' date nights'🙄for instance. Not suggesting that there is anything abusive going on, but an over investment in your daughter's life and friends seems unhealthy and performative to me. Mind you my Dad and I basically ignored each other during my adolescent, so probably not the best judge. Maybe something in-between?

thisismeithinkorisit · 16/11/2026 10:16

Lavenderwindow · 16/11/2026 03:10

Oh yeah. I recently heard someone wanging on about being a 'twin parent'. I was just so confused but turns out they describe themselves as " nonbinary " and they now have twins.

I'd argue parenting twins is by far more significantly difficult than parenting one regardless of their sex so I'd let them keep their title.

thisismeithinkorisit · 16/11/2026 10:21

Screamingabdabz · 15/11/2026 13:12

Just interested (I also have a son) - what do
you feel you need to ‘defend’ your boys from?

just look on the gender disappointment threads amongst many others on here.
boys - you'll never have similar interests, they're hard work, they'll get married and never see you again, you'll never have a relationship like you would with a daughter. this is in part because they are men and men are bad. not all men but most men. men are mostly all abusive. men are mostly all lazy. the same behaviour from a woman and a man is always worse from a man. men should be mainly. men shouldn't be manly. men are all prospective abusers. girls need protecting from all boys.

it's just generally seen as bad to be producing and raising one of THEM

bellatrixlaweird · 16/11/2026 13:16

It isn’t creepy. It’s creepy that you think it’s creepy to be honest.

MrsKateColumbo · 16/11/2026 13:45

One of the dads described himself as such at the school gate once which i found a bit weird. He told me he couldn't have a son because he liked doing makeup and hair too much (I didnt point out that he could have a makeup loving son!). Confused

DM told me recently that pre kids my DDAD really wanted a son. Which really surprised me as Dad would always say how glad he was to have only daughters, how girls were the best etc, so that probably was a bit of a defence from him. He's been an excellent Dad so it's not really negative, it made me smile more than anything as I know he wouldn't swap us for sons now.

Minasama · 16/11/2026 19:43

I find the whole need to identify and put labels on things a bit showy and unedifying.

My dad had two daughters (my sister and I) and has always been a great supporter of women and anxious about the behaviour of men, which he warned us about. He didn’t go about the place making performative declarations about this, he just got on with being the best dad possible in all sorts of ways. He was also a faithful and supportive husband to our mother.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread