Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lodger wants to move evening meal time

525 replies

Proseccoisking · 13/11/2026 20:12

I have had a lodger staying Monday to Friday for about 5 months.

It was generally working out quite well.

He has his own large room, which has a sofa and TV, and his own bathroom.

We share the kitchen and dining room. I have a separate living room.

The arrangement started that I provided basic breakfast food items for him to prepare: cereal and bread, butter, jam, honey etc

An evening meal was not included in our agreement. I did tell him, however, that he was welcome to have what I’d cooked, or if I was out or he wanted something different he could have one of several ready meals, or use any food in the fridge or freezer unless it was earmarked for another meal.

I made it clear that I eat fairly early, normally around 6.00pm, and if he wanted the meal I’d cooked and he wasn’t home in time, I would plate it up and he could re heat it when he liked.

He was happy with this as he hadn’t expected any meals ( the rent is very low for the facilities provided in this area), and had only asked for space to store his own food.

He now has his own cupboard/ fridge space in case he wants something different.

I like to cook and the meals I provide are cooked from scratch and accompanied by fresh vegetables. If we are both there when the meal is ready we often eat together in the dining room.

He has recently mentioned a few times that he would prefer to eat his meal when it was hot, rather than having to re heat it. This is quite a change from when he first moved in, and told me that he often ate Pot Noodles as he couldn’t be bothered to cook.

I advertised for a lodger to help with the bills and am happy to let him share my food, but I am not running a hotel. I don’t want to eat later, nor cook a separate meal for him and be clearing up at up to 8.30pm. He arrives back somewhere between 5.30 - 8.15pm.

Our contract only states that I will provide basic breakfast items. I am under no obligation to provide any other meals, although I am concerned that it might appear so through custom/ practice.

I’ve already told him that I am not prepared to change the timing of my meal, but it hasn’t stopped him mentioning it.

I am considering withdrawing the offer of evening meals altogether.

I am posting here to try to get a balanced view.

In other ways he is a good fit as a lodger, although there have obviously been some niggles.

OP posts:
CloveRinse · 14/11/2026 07:11

@BitOutOfPractice why do you say he is being dictated to? He is being given options. He can cook for himself if he likes - OP is not stopping him.

ETA give over with the "toddler meal time" comments. Some people like to eat early and digest their food before bed.

SuddenDaredJelly · 14/11/2026 07:24

H202too · 13/11/2026 20:47

Baffling. 'Very early', What on earth? You are acting like its 4pm.
You must all go to bed on a full stomach. Surprised you don't get indigestion.

Most people work 9-5.30 outside of the home.

How on earth can you travel home from work AND get a freshly cooked hot meal on the table within 30 minutes?

Most people i know arrive home between 6& 6.30 and eat at more like 7, which is the earliest they can get the meal prepared by.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · 14/11/2026 07:25

BitOutOfPractice · 13/11/2026 22:46

either both or neither of you is being unreasonable

Yiu like to eat early. They don’t want to eat that early. Neither do I - in my world 6pm is for young children only.

This leads to reheated food. Which he hasn’t chosen. And in my experience reheated plated up dinners are rather grim. So he’s not being U either there imo.

What puzzles me is a. Why you started offering this and b. Why you say he’s only allowed to eat ready meals if he doesn’t get in for your designated toddler mealtime.

Edited

I eat by 6. We're all different..no need to be insulting to others.

Blessedbethefruitloopss · 14/11/2026 07:41

I would message him over the weekend, so he has the chance to pick up food for Monday night.
”I’ve done a bit of online reading, and I completely understand now that you can’t eat when I eat, and don’t what a reheated plate, so probably want to sort your own meal of choice when you get in. So I’ll just cook for me, and you can sort yours when you get in.”

RancidRuby · 14/11/2026 07:49

GoldenRetriever8 · 14/11/2026 06:14

Stop saying he can use any of your ingredients to cook something else too!

Yes, this is so odd. I get the sharing of a meal for the company, but why on earth would you also offer up free rein on everything in the fridge.

LaurieFairyCake · 14/11/2026 08:01

There’s just too many people on here who don’t understand LODGER. Is it because you’re all too young? Don’t remember Rigby or Mrs Jones?

Lodgers have ZERO rights and ZERO responsibilities. And both of those are equal! They are usually short term, this suits both landlord and lodger.

and a Monday to Friday lodger even FEWER rights as they have a MAIN HOME elsewhere. They literally don’t bloody live there!

I’ve had lodgers twice. Contractors who were wealthy and had a big detached house with acres in the midlands and rented a room Monday to Friday in London.

Of course they weren’t allowed strangers (to my family) to stay overnight. I had young children so I allowed no one at all to come round the house. The lodgers had their own annex and shared kitchen/diner with me.

It’s NOTHING like a house share arrangement, often the people lodging are much wealthier than the persons house they’re staying in as they’re hospital consultants, finance geeks or IT professionals.

It’s not some ‘poor person’ thing where people have to feel sorry for them. Back when I did this they could have had a £39 travel lodge room which was almost cheaper than my place, but they didn’t want to as it was noisy and they couldn’t cook.

SethAndReubenTooSendGaloshes · 14/11/2026 08:03

Lightmare · 14/11/2026 06:44

Is this because you dont want to pay business tax on any earnings?

You don't pay tax on rent from a lodger!

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 14/11/2026 08:04

@Proseccoisking
I have had lodgers.

You need to kick him out and "start again"
Hes comfortable and entitled.
The "deal" has gone bad now and you cant salvage this.

Basically when you are too generous people get entitled and then.. get resentful and think it's muggy if you try and move boundaries AND he is a boundary pusher.... Not happy with a free meal he isnt forced to eat he wants to dictate when its served to him.

Serve notice and re-advertise.
This isnt the only person in the world looking for a mon-fri rental.

Lower price is fine.
Mon - Fri times are is fine
No visitors is standard on mon-fri lets.

Next time.
Lockable chest use is non negotiable .
They strip the bedding Fri AM. You will supply fresh bedding weekly.

They get one fridge shelf and one cupboard.
No breakfast and no dinner. No smelly food allowed.

This keeps it more "contractual" and the lines less blurry.

VeganStar · 14/11/2026 08:12

If you’ve changed your mind about certain aspects of the contract would it be possible to make another one omitting offers of breakfast.
you could also raise the rent a little.

when you present it to him you could say the current one isn’t working for you and that he could either sign the new one or leave.

if you still wanted to have the same arrangement with the evening meal and the extra you might cook you could stipulate that 6 pm would be the time you personally would be eating and if it was inconvenient for him or if he preferred his food hot then he would have to provide his own.
Plus I would withdraw the offer of ready meals.

Stress the importance of him changing the sheets and putting his things away.

I don’t know if what I’ve suggested is legal about redrawing the contract maybe you could get some advice.

He’s beginning to take the mick and it should be nipped in the bud asap.

All the best for a good outcome in your conversation with him on Monday OP.

DecafCoffeeIsPointless · 14/11/2026 08:15

YetAnotherAlias62 · 13/11/2026 23:02

I think it's a bit odd that you do so much for him tbh.
He is renting a room for part of the week - he should be providing his own food, doing his own washing, getting his own breakfast etc.

Agreed.

I can't image you are making any money from this after paying for food for him plus a cleaner weekly.

How long is your contract? Id revert to exactly what that says for now, so no evening meals and then change it to no food when you can.

DecafCoffeeIsPointless · 14/11/2026 08:21

SuddenDaredJelly · 14/11/2026 07:24

Most people work 9-5.30 outside of the home.

How on earth can you travel home from work AND get a freshly cooked hot meal on the table within 30 minutes?

Most people i know arrive home between 6& 6.30 and eat at more like 7, which is the earliest they can get the meal prepared by.

The location I work has 12 separate office buildings with about 4000 people. Most people leave at 4pm. It can take ages to get out the car parks.

Everyone/everywhere is different.

squarecrow · 14/11/2026 08:27

This sounds like classic “give ‘em an inch and they’ll take a mile” mentality. He was surprised and grateful at first, but now he’s trying to push you to give him exactly what he wants when he wants. I’m glad you’re going to have a frank conversation with him and I hope it goes well.

Aluna · 14/11/2026 08:34

SalmonOnFinnCrisp · 14/11/2026 08:04

@Proseccoisking
I have had lodgers.

You need to kick him out and "start again"
Hes comfortable and entitled.
The "deal" has gone bad now and you cant salvage this.

Basically when you are too generous people get entitled and then.. get resentful and think it's muggy if you try and move boundaries AND he is a boundary pusher.... Not happy with a free meal he isnt forced to eat he wants to dictate when its served to him.

Serve notice and re-advertise.
This isnt the only person in the world looking for a mon-fri rental.

Lower price is fine.
Mon - Fri times are is fine
No visitors is standard on mon-fri lets.

Next time.
Lockable chest use is non negotiable .
They strip the bedding Fri AM. You will supply fresh bedding weekly.

They get one fridge shelf and one cupboard.
No breakfast and no dinner. No smelly food allowed.

This keeps it more "contractual" and the lines less blurry.

Edited

I agree. I’ve never had lodgers but a good friend always has a couple of Mon-Fri lodgers for preference.

It would have been good if OP had looked more into standard lodger set ups before launching hotel services for free.

I might give him the option of notice or a completely new contract. But even if he reluctantly agrees he may be resentful.

If OP’s in London, or another major city, she won’t have a problem finding a replacement.

Soontobe60 · 14/11/2026 08:37

ilovepixie · 13/11/2026 20:23

I wouldn’t be happy if I was renting a room and someone else was sleeping in it at the weekend. Do you thoroughly clean the room and bathroom after someone stays?

I’m sure she lets her guests sleep in the sheets that the lodger has slept in all week 🤣🤣🤣

Dontevenlookatme · 14/11/2026 08:38

JMSA · 14/11/2026 06:26

Oh my days, this will be the reason the rent is so low!!
You are not being unreasonable with the food, but you are MASSIVELY unreasonable here.
’Don’t mess up your room in case my family want to use it.’
What the actual fuck?! 🤯😆

Eh? Do you never stay in hotels? It isn’t “his” room. He’s not her teenage son. It’s the OP’s room which he rents for four nights. It’s a perfectly normal arrangement!

Sartre · 14/11/2026 08:45

Basically you’ve given an inch… He’s a pisstaker. I didn’t realise lodgers could be PT but suppose it makes sense for folk working away. I’d say you have been more than generous, he has a private bathroom for starters which is more than he’d get in a hostel! He’s also basically getting two meals a day free but now complaining because -shock horror- he has to re-heat it!

With the food and cleaner, are you making any money?

Proseccoisking · 14/11/2026 08:46

Growuppeople · 14/11/2026 02:05

What is this!? It’s so weird, you asked the council about your council tax but didn’t research anything about having a lodger and thought you needed to provide services of washing and feeding him!? This can’t be real

I researched all of the legal aspects, Council Tax, Income Tax, electrical safety certificates ( I don’t have gas), etc. The contract I downloaded was quite specific for the financial aspects and notice periods, etc but I had to put in my own answers for services provided. It gave little information.

I think my idea of a lodger, however, must have been formed from seeing the arrangements in old films or similar.

OP posts:
notacooldad · 14/11/2026 08:50

SuddenDaredJelly
Most people work 9-5.30 outside of the home.

YOUGOV survey disagrees with you.

Overthe population it is quite a small percentage who work traditional hours.

You aren't taking into account shift workers such as care workers, NHS staff, emergency services, hospitality, shop workers etc who make up a large portion of the workforce.

rwalker · 14/11/2026 08:53

He wasn’t unreasonable to ask and your not unreasonable to stop the offer as it not working
I get not wanting your tea at 6 and also some food doesn’t reheat great
just revert to you each making your own

whilst in the face of it your doing him a massive favour if it’s not at a time you’d eat and reheated it’s not really the great deal it’s been made out to be

just stop making his tea also foods expensive

Swmk · 14/11/2026 09:00

OneZanyMintQuoter · 14/11/2026 00:25

For children possibly

Rubbish. Lots of people follow a 14 hour fast diet so eat at 6.

CandidHedgehog · 14/11/2026 09:01

JMSA · 14/11/2026 06:26

Oh my days, this will be the reason the rent is so low!!
You are not being unreasonable with the food, but you are MASSIVELY unreasonable here.
’Don’t mess up your room in case my family want to use it.’
What the actual fuck?! 🤯😆

This is how M-F lodging works. Of course it’s not unreasonable to have the landlady use the room on weekends. That’s the point of a M-F rental. It’s not the lodger’s home (he/she has one elsewhere), it’s somewhere to sleep near work where you don’t have to haul all your work stuff back and forth each week (though it has to be tidied away), there are kitchen facilities and it’s cheaper than a hotel. This is going on in multiple cities all over the UK. It is not being a normal lodger and the rules are completely different.

squarecrow · 14/11/2026 09:06

It is literally irrelevant what time most people eat their dinner - OP has hers early. She’s kind enough to make enough for the lodger and plate it up for him so he can reheat it later.

He is a CF expecting OP to bend over backwards to accommodate him any further.

autumn1638 · 14/11/2026 09:07

You need to just provide a lodger with an empty cupboard and a shelf in the fridge and freezer. That’s all. Lodgers will take the piss and most of them think they have a rental contract rather than a lodging contract. If you give an inch they will take a mile. You also shouldn’t be providing breakfast stuff. It’s not worth it financially and it’s supposed to boost your income. You also need to give boundaries around bills, water and heating use.

BitOutOfPractice · 14/11/2026 09:08

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · 14/11/2026 07:25

I eat by 6. We're all different..no need to be insulting to others.

Where was in insulting? I said in my world only young children eat that early. Most people are still at work or travelling home at that time in my world. Merely pointing out that everyone one - including the OP’s lodger - Is different.

Lots of people clearly touchy about that. I have no idea why.

dottiedodah · 14/11/2026 09:08

Im guessing maybe you felt a bit lonely ? Like someone to eat with and cook for.Is he quite young .I think hes being cheeky ,but surely most lodgers would not be too happy with their room being used when they are not there either.I would say 6pm is the time ,Non negotiable .I think many people would like a reduced room rate with some meals as well