Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lodger wants to move evening meal time

525 replies

Proseccoisking · 13/11/2026 20:12

I have had a lodger staying Monday to Friday for about 5 months.

It was generally working out quite well.

He has his own large room, which has a sofa and TV, and his own bathroom.

We share the kitchen and dining room. I have a separate living room.

The arrangement started that I provided basic breakfast food items for him to prepare: cereal and bread, butter, jam, honey etc

An evening meal was not included in our agreement. I did tell him, however, that he was welcome to have what I’d cooked, or if I was out or he wanted something different he could have one of several ready meals, or use any food in the fridge or freezer unless it was earmarked for another meal.

I made it clear that I eat fairly early, normally around 6.00pm, and if he wanted the meal I’d cooked and he wasn’t home in time, I would plate it up and he could re heat it when he liked.

He was happy with this as he hadn’t expected any meals ( the rent is very low for the facilities provided in this area), and had only asked for space to store his own food.

He now has his own cupboard/ fridge space in case he wants something different.

I like to cook and the meals I provide are cooked from scratch and accompanied by fresh vegetables. If we are both there when the meal is ready we often eat together in the dining room.

He has recently mentioned a few times that he would prefer to eat his meal when it was hot, rather than having to re heat it. This is quite a change from when he first moved in, and told me that he often ate Pot Noodles as he couldn’t be bothered to cook.

I advertised for a lodger to help with the bills and am happy to let him share my food, but I am not running a hotel. I don’t want to eat later, nor cook a separate meal for him and be clearing up at up to 8.30pm. He arrives back somewhere between 5.30 - 8.15pm.

Our contract only states that I will provide basic breakfast items. I am under no obligation to provide any other meals, although I am concerned that it might appear so through custom/ practice.

I’ve already told him that I am not prepared to change the timing of my meal, but it hasn’t stopped him mentioning it.

I am considering withdrawing the offer of evening meals altogether.

I am posting here to try to get a balanced view.

In other ways he is a good fit as a lodger, although there have obviously been some niggles.

OP posts:
QuietChristmas2026 · 14/11/2026 20:24

@ensayers is that a typo or do you mean it?

You wrote ”ones been here 7 years and the other 17 years.”

If it’s correct, can you say more? That’s really fascinating, my impression of lodgers is that they don’t stay long, maybe a year or so, but that impression is based on…not actually knowing any lodgers 😆.

Why haven’t they moved on? Were they looking for a long term place? Were you looking for a long term lodger? Or that’s just how it ended up? Are they youngish? Older? What will you both do when they retire? You must get on fantastically well with both of them (and they with each other) to have lasted that long.

(Awaits to hear that it is a typo and you actually meant 7 and 17 months 🤦‍♀️😂)

Lavenderblue11 · 14/11/2026 20:24

Growlybear83 · 13/11/2026 20:27

As you made it clear that you eat very early, and didnt advertise that evening meals were included then I think your lodger is being unreasonable. But I can also understand why he wouldn’t want to eat so early in the evening.

I would say that 6pm is a pretty standard time to have an evening meal. The only exception being if you are eating out at a restaurant and then it's more usual to eat at 7:30 - 8:30pm.

Supernintendochalmers1 · 14/11/2026 20:27

Idk if I've misread the post... but if he arrives home between 5:30pm - 6:15pm and you have your dinner at 6pm. Why doesn't he just eat it as soon as he arrives home? 🤔

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · 14/11/2026 20:28

Supernintendochalmers1 · 14/11/2026 20:27

Idk if I've misread the post... but if he arrives home between 5:30pm - 6:15pm and you have your dinner at 6pm. Why doesn't he just eat it as soon as he arrives home? 🤔

Irrelevant. The lodger is no more.

Isobel201 · 14/11/2026 20:30

Gosh, eating at 6pm for children only? I guess I'd better be one then! I tend to eat evening meals 5-6pm and OP is entitled to eat when she wants to.
Just seen your update OP, glad you were able to get rid of him for a basic contract breach.

Supernintendochalmers1 · 14/11/2026 20:31

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · 14/11/2026 20:28

Irrelevant. The lodger is no more.

Oh my apologies! That sounds rather ominous 😅 I'll go back and read OP's responses.

BeUmberMember · 14/11/2026 20:41

Proseccoisking · 13/11/2026 20:21

Sort of. I’ve never had a lodger before and I wanted to find someone who agreed not to have overnight guests. It’s a bit more restrictive than some agreements, hence the price.

Absolutely, I suppose most lodgers would want their own lockable room confined to their own use only even if they weren't there full time 7 days per week. Not sure I'd want anyone else sleeping in my bed whilst I was away either. What you have is more like a house share situation, so can see why you charge less than the going rate for lodgers. Plus depends on your ages, if he is much younger, may see you as like a mother figure, hence not feeling it was cheeky to ask for dinner times to be changed. Plus why are you washing up and sharing food, it seems a bit unprofessional, more like when I had my adult grandson living with me. Dont be a doormat, he will walk all over you. Tell him to either accept the mealtimes as they are or cook his own.

CandidHedgehog · 14/11/2026 20:45

BeUmberMember · 14/11/2026 20:41

Absolutely, I suppose most lodgers would want their own lockable room confined to their own use only even if they weren't there full time 7 days per week. Not sure I'd want anyone else sleeping in my bed whilst I was away either. What you have is more like a house share situation, so can see why you charge less than the going rate for lodgers. Plus depends on your ages, if he is much younger, may see you as like a mother figure, hence not feeling it was cheeky to ask for dinner times to be changed. Plus why are you washing up and sharing food, it seems a bit unprofessional, more like when I had my adult grandson living with me. Dont be a doormat, he will walk all over you. Tell him to either accept the mealtimes as they are or cook his own.

You might want to read the updates.

Also, as multiple people have said, that’s not how M-F lodging works. If someone wants a 7 day a week room, they need to rent one.

Otherwise, clearing stuff into storage (and only having limited space to store items) so that the landlord can use the room at weekends is both normal and expected.

QuietChristmas2026 · 14/11/2026 20:45

@BeUmberMember no, the lodgers situation isn’t like that at all, read the posts. It’s not his room, he had no right to lock it, he doesn’t rent it all week. It wasn’t ‘his’ bed and it wasn’t a house share.

mondaytofridaylodger · 14/11/2026 20:47

I was once a Monday-Friday tenant.

The rent was a little lower than if I were there full-time. I had to pack my things away for weekends - I kept very little there though, so this was straightforward (I stripped the bed, took care of my own bedding).

I don't think the OP did anything wrong by offering to include meals, though perhaps it would have been better for the OP if they charged for it, say £5-£10 for dinner if they requested it by 8am that morning.

I kept a pasta bowl and mug in the kitchen, and had some space in the fridge. Keeping my own milk there from Friday to Monday didn't work for the family, because it made the fridge too crowded, so they suggested me adding a small amount to the rent to cover milk.

I felt very lucky to be there, and tried to be considerate.

I can't remember what I did for breakfast - I may have had it at work, or just had toast, bringing the leftover bread home each weekend. I think I used the washing machine very occasionally but usually just brought my washing home.

To sum up - you weren't being too demanding! Monday-Friday lets are 'a thing', where the lodgers have to accept less convenience in return for the lower rent. The smoking was outrageous and I'm sorry you were unlucky.

Grendel7 · 14/11/2026 20:48

Proseccoisking · 13/11/2026 20:12

I have had a lodger staying Monday to Friday for about 5 months.

It was generally working out quite well.

He has his own large room, which has a sofa and TV, and his own bathroom.

We share the kitchen and dining room. I have a separate living room.

The arrangement started that I provided basic breakfast food items for him to prepare: cereal and bread, butter, jam, honey etc

An evening meal was not included in our agreement. I did tell him, however, that he was welcome to have what I’d cooked, or if I was out or he wanted something different he could have one of several ready meals, or use any food in the fridge or freezer unless it was earmarked for another meal.

I made it clear that I eat fairly early, normally around 6.00pm, and if he wanted the meal I’d cooked and he wasn’t home in time, I would plate it up and he could re heat it when he liked.

He was happy with this as he hadn’t expected any meals ( the rent is very low for the facilities provided in this area), and had only asked for space to store his own food.

He now has his own cupboard/ fridge space in case he wants something different.

I like to cook and the meals I provide are cooked from scratch and accompanied by fresh vegetables. If we are both there when the meal is ready we often eat together in the dining room.

He has recently mentioned a few times that he would prefer to eat his meal when it was hot, rather than having to re heat it. This is quite a change from when he first moved in, and told me that he often ate Pot Noodles as he couldn’t be bothered to cook.

I advertised for a lodger to help with the bills and am happy to let him share my food, but I am not running a hotel. I don’t want to eat later, nor cook a separate meal for him and be clearing up at up to 8.30pm. He arrives back somewhere between 5.30 - 8.15pm.

Our contract only states that I will provide basic breakfast items. I am under no obligation to provide any other meals, although I am concerned that it might appear so through custom/ practice.

I’ve already told him that I am not prepared to change the timing of my meal, but it hasn’t stopped him mentioning it.

I am considering withdrawing the offer of evening meals altogether.

I am posting here to try to get a balanced view.

In other ways he is a good fit as a lodger, although there have obviously been some niggles.

You shot yourself in both feet here. First you tell him food is not included THEN you tell him he can eat with you,whatever you have cooked! I was confused reading your post,bet he was too.
You should have stuck to your original contract,because now you are off piste you can't go back.

Stelladid · 14/11/2026 20:48

Proseccoisking · 14/11/2026 19:07

I think this is sensible advice. I suppose I partly thought that it would be difficult for him to get everything he needed together to cook a full meal, etc.
I now think things like milk, salt, pepper and maybe herbs are reasonable things to offer, but nothing else, except to borrow and replace.

You don’t need to provide milk. Let them have a space in the fridge for their own. You are in danger of letting your kindness drag you into a grey area again.

Grendel7 · 14/11/2026 20:56

Proseccoisking · 13/11/2026 20:26

He rents the room from Monday to Friday only. I employed a cleaner for the first time when he moved in. She cleans the room every Monday morning.

Edited

Wait,you employ a cleaner to clean the room you need for a lodger because money is tight?? AND you feed him?
Your idea of being short of money differs from mine

TRIEDEVERYOTHER · 14/11/2026 21:07

Time for him to fuck off.

ensayers · 14/11/2026 21:08

QuietChristmas2026 · 14/11/2026 20:24

@ensayers is that a typo or do you mean it?

You wrote ”ones been here 7 years and the other 17 years.”

If it’s correct, can you say more? That’s really fascinating, my impression of lodgers is that they don’t stay long, maybe a year or so, but that impression is based on…not actually knowing any lodgers 😆.

Why haven’t they moved on? Were they looking for a long term place? Were you looking for a long term lodger? Or that’s just how it ended up? Are they youngish? Older? What will you both do when they retire? You must get on fantastically well with both of them (and they with each other) to have lasted that long.

(Awaits to hear that it is a typo and you actually meant 7 and 17 months 🤦‍♀️😂)

No its not a typo. The one thats been here 17 years is a man, now in his 70s that got divorced and needed a room, he leaves the house late morning, goes to work and comes home at 7 on the dot, hes quite fixed in his routine and not always chatty, but it means i know when ill have the kitchen to myself.
The other one much younger, plan was originally to stay 6 months, but theyre very easy to share with, and it has turned into years.
Sharing wont work for everyone, especially if theres partners in and out, but for singletons, that maybe can deal with a little less privacy, for those with spare bedrooms, or those needing cheap place to live then lodgings great

WhatHappenedToYourFurnitureCuz · 14/11/2026 21:09

BitOutOfPractice · 14/11/2026 16:50

Jesus wept. I was just stating a fact. I have no idea how or why that could be construed as bitchy. Like I say, you are welcome to take offence at a perfectly innocuous comment but good grief you’ve read volumes of meaning into what just wasn’t there! 🤷‍♀️ feel free to @ me again if you’re still feeling slighted but I’m out to a gig and won’t reply so you’ll have to seethe alone.

Nobody's seething. Just a bit embarrassed for you.

CandidHedgehog · 14/11/2026 21:13

OP, it occurs to me that if you are OK with providing this level of services with cooking / washing included, maybe you should look at hosting teenagers from language schools or some boarding schools (in the shorter holidays). It pays better and this level of attention / care is part of the agreement (and the cost is accordingly higher). You wouldn’t get every weekend while they were there but you would have breaks where they weren’t there to have your house to yourself.

Just a thought.

theushers · 14/11/2026 21:14

Are you nose blind, or perhaps it was a one-off. I would smell cigarette smoke immediately, not need to find the butts in a mug. Either way, problem solved.

QuietChristmas2026 · 14/11/2026 21:22

ensayers · 14/11/2026 21:08

No its not a typo. The one thats been here 17 years is a man, now in his 70s that got divorced and needed a room, he leaves the house late morning, goes to work and comes home at 7 on the dot, hes quite fixed in his routine and not always chatty, but it means i know when ill have the kitchen to myself.
The other one much younger, plan was originally to stay 6 months, but theyre very easy to share with, and it has turned into years.
Sharing wont work for everyone, especially if theres partners in and out, but for singletons, that maybe can deal with a little less privacy, for those with spare bedrooms, or those needing cheap place to live then lodgings great

So a very settled household! Do they stay all week?

ArtieChoke · 14/11/2026 21:26

Proseccoisking · 14/11/2026 19:07

I think this is sensible advice. I suppose I partly thought that it would be difficult for him to get everything he needed together to cook a full meal, etc.
I now think things like milk, salt, pepper and maybe herbs are reasonable things to offer, but nothing else, except to borrow and replace.

I had one lodger who was cooking at 10 o’clock at night and leaving the dishes, then chatting loudly on the phone. He lasted 3 months, he thought it was a house share. He lost his front door key and had to pay for new barrel and licksmith

i gave him notice and fortunately he left left 3 weeks before covid

I know make sure any lodger knows the kitchen is closed for use after 8:30pm and quite time after 10pm

I’ve had really good lodgers since, one was so quiet my daughter didn’t realise for a month after he left that he’d gone. He moved into the pub and was just short term for 6 months whilst they did his flat up

i tend to just have adhoc or short term, I’ve got those rules, no visitors, no smoking in the house and smoking costs left in the porch / generally though I spot the smokers and don’t take them

we all live and learn

Hollyhobbi · 14/11/2026 21:29

H202too · 13/11/2026 20:37

I think 6 is a standard time.

Not in Ireland. Unless you live 5 minutes from your work or are a teacher!

ensayers · 14/11/2026 21:37

QuietChristmas2026 · 14/11/2026 21:22

So a very settled household! Do they stay all week?

Yeah. This is their full time home.
Reading some other peoples experience of having lodgers ive realised that im laid back and flexible. I dont make "rules" if they do something i dont like then we have a chat like adults. I ask them to smoke outside and they do. We all keep the noise down when people are in bed, its just common sense and respect, i never need to chase payments, it works for me and i guess theyre happy too.

RafaFan · 14/11/2026 21:37

TheSnappyBluePoster · 13/11/2026 20:39

Really?

I was still sitting at my desk in the office at 6pm

I've just eaten now and it has gone 8:30pm.

Horses for courses... there's been discussions about this on MN before. Some people have their evening meal at 5.30pm, some have it at 9 pm. There is no normal, people do what fits their circumstances. The OP has hers at 6pm, it's really not abnormal.

In my household, we're all out of the house by 7am, and home by 5ish (and yes,I have an office job). My husband has a very physical job - there's no way he would be waiting until 8pm to eat!

InWithPeaceOutWithStress · 14/11/2026 21:39

Your lodging style is (was) so reminiscent of lodgings you read about in old books.

Seajaye · 14/11/2026 21:43

I think he needs access to the kitchen when he gets home from work. I suggest you tell him.the revised time doesn't suit you and you will stop preparing meals so he van revert to cater for himself for from.now on. Your good turn has made him think he is more entitled to change the arrangement than he actually is. Youigjt want to agree cooking time and a few expectations Terms of clearing up as well.

Swipe left for the next trending thread