Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lodger wants to move evening meal time

525 replies

Proseccoisking · 13/11/2026 20:12

I have had a lodger staying Monday to Friday for about 5 months.

It was generally working out quite well.

He has his own large room, which has a sofa and TV, and his own bathroom.

We share the kitchen and dining room. I have a separate living room.

The arrangement started that I provided basic breakfast food items for him to prepare: cereal and bread, butter, jam, honey etc

An evening meal was not included in our agreement. I did tell him, however, that he was welcome to have what I’d cooked, or if I was out or he wanted something different he could have one of several ready meals, or use any food in the fridge or freezer unless it was earmarked for another meal.

I made it clear that I eat fairly early, normally around 6.00pm, and if he wanted the meal I’d cooked and he wasn’t home in time, I would plate it up and he could re heat it when he liked.

He was happy with this as he hadn’t expected any meals ( the rent is very low for the facilities provided in this area), and had only asked for space to store his own food.

He now has his own cupboard/ fridge space in case he wants something different.

I like to cook and the meals I provide are cooked from scratch and accompanied by fresh vegetables. If we are both there when the meal is ready we often eat together in the dining room.

He has recently mentioned a few times that he would prefer to eat his meal when it was hot, rather than having to re heat it. This is quite a change from when he first moved in, and told me that he often ate Pot Noodles as he couldn’t be bothered to cook.

I advertised for a lodger to help with the bills and am happy to let him share my food, but I am not running a hotel. I don’t want to eat later, nor cook a separate meal for him and be clearing up at up to 8.30pm. He arrives back somewhere between 5.30 - 8.15pm.

Our contract only states that I will provide basic breakfast items. I am under no obligation to provide any other meals, although I am concerned that it might appear so through custom/ practice.

I’ve already told him that I am not prepared to change the timing of my meal, but it hasn’t stopped him mentioning it.

I am considering withdrawing the offer of evening meals altogether.

I am posting here to try to get a balanced view.

In other ways he is a good fit as a lodger, although there have obviously been some niggles.

OP posts:
CandidHedgehog · 14/11/2026 10:23

dottiedodah · 14/11/2026 09:08

Im guessing maybe you felt a bit lonely ? Like someone to eat with and cook for.Is he quite young .I think hes being cheeky ,but surely most lodgers would not be too happy with their room being used when they are not there either.I would say 6pm is the time ,Non negotiable .I think many people would like a reduced room rate with some meals as well

Most M-F lodgers know that their room being used on weekends is part of the deal. The OP even provides locking storage (I had an unlocked drawer and a tiny section of the wardrobe) which is exceptional!

Nobody forced me to rent a M-F room. If I had been ‘none too happy with my room being used when I wasn’t there’, I could have got a full time room for twice the cost and just not slept there on weekends. If I had, then I would have the right to be angry if the landlady let someone sleep in my bed when I wasn’t there.

CandidHedgehog · 14/11/2026 10:24

LancashireButterPie · 14/11/2026 09:37

It's a standard practice to rent a room for a certain amount of days a week. My DS did the same for a few months when he was working away. He worked Mon-Fri, came home at weekends and the landlady let his room as Air B and B for the weekend.
It's just like renting a hotel room.

A hotel room where you can leave stuff on the property on the days you aren’t staying there. Try doing that at a Travellodge!

Bestfootforward11 · 14/11/2026 10:24

You absolutely don’t need to continue doing evening meals. His request is a cheeky one. I think you just say not a problem that you like to eat later, and I’ll leave you to sort yourself out for meals. I know I can trust you to leave the kitchen clean when you’re done.
if he says oh no, it’s ok, I’ll eat earlier then, you just say to be honest I hadn’t thought through the cost so think it’s better we do our own thing anyway…

ViciousCurrentBun · 14/11/2026 10:25

DH and I had a lodger when we first bought our house and before we had kids.

He was an all week lodger so a bit different.

It was also a help yourself to basic breakfast and tea and coffee at all times. There was also an invite to eat with us and all home cooked meals but he paid per meal. He would eat with us a couple of times a week usually.

As well as it helping to pay the bills bought a very nice garden shed with the proceeds and named it after him. We needed the room back as I got PG, he didn’t want to leave and it was a bit uncomfortable. DH opened a bottle of champagne when he left. It’s money for old rope really but an agreement needs to be made and stuck to. No way would I have had a help yourself to anything food wise agreement.

DH lodged in a very grand house when he was a PhD student, the woman was an empty nester and always had three young men as lodgers. He has always said it was the easiest time of his life as she spoilt them all rotten. Chocolate on the saucer with his coffee every night. Her DH was the CEO of a company. They didn’t need the money she just liked looking after people.

Aluna · 14/11/2026 10:25

CandidHedgehog · 14/11/2026 10:16

This - my Dad lived in ‘digs’ as a young man. Most unmarried young men living away from home lived like this. There were strict rules as to meals (eat when served or go hungry), times to get home and visitors (none overnight, no unrelated women). People these days wouldn’t stand for it. This lodger can’t expect the good bits (free food!) while not being required to comply with the rest (being home on time to eat).

My Dad didn’t even have a house key. He got home before curfew or he didn’t get in that night.

They’d still have to pay for their food though which was included in the rent.

There’s never been a set up whereby you lived in someone’s house and they fed you for free!

CandidHedgehog · 14/11/2026 10:27

Realorsurreal · 14/11/2026 10:03

I’ve had a lodger for years. Don’t provide food at all. That’s not standard. And secondly, you shouldn’t let other people use the room when he’s not here. That’s particularly not nice. He should be able to leave his belongings out, not put them in a chest. It’s his room.

Not in a M-F lodging situation. The whole point is that the room reverts to the landlord / landlady on the weekend, whether because he/she wants the house to him/herself, family are coming or the room is going on AirB&B

Gwenhwyfar · 14/11/2026 10:28

Proseccoisking · 13/11/2026 20:19

The main niggle is that he has the room from 3.00pm on Monday to 11.00am on Friday.
I provided a lockable chest for him to be able to keep personal items in when he wasn’t there so he didn’t have to lice them back and forth.
He has started to leave items spread out in the room. It’s not that I want to let it out to anyone else over the weekend, but I sometimes have friends or family to stay and need to use the room.

OMG I couldn't live out of a box like that. Pretty normal to want to have his belongings around him.

Cherrysoup · 14/11/2026 10:31

Proseccoisking · 13/11/2026 22:56

The crossed out toddler meal time was pretty childish really, but maybe that also accounts for your lack of comprehension.
This is what I said about him getting his own meals

if I was out or he wanted something different he could have one of several ready meals, or use any food in the fridge or freezer unless it was earmarked for another meal.

He can use a ready meal for ease if he prefers. He can also use any other ingredients to make a meal.

Dinner is 6pm in our house, no dc.

I think he is unreasonable but he’s got used to being cooked for. I know it’s easy enough to do extra, but you’re eating (forgive the pun) into your own profits by providing food when you don’t have this in the price/contract. You’re already charging less than average because he stays Mon-Fri, but many lodgers do this for work etc. I would stop cooking for him and provide only very basic breakfast stuff, but again, this is extra to the usual lodger agreement. So again eating into your profits. Are you making enough to help with bills? You shouldn’t be doing his washing/tidying. He can clean his own room when you don’t have guests.

CandidHedgehog · 14/11/2026 10:33

Aluna · 14/11/2026 10:25

They’d still have to pay for their food though which was included in the rent.

There’s never been a set up whereby you lived in someone’s house and they fed you for free!

Absolutely. Also, nobody had a lot of money - those landladies priced those meals to the penny and made absolutely sure food was covered by the rent.

With all of the OP’s ‘extras’, I think she needs to sit down and add up the current costs of having a lodger (cleaner, food, utility bills) and see if she is actually making a reasonable profit.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 14/11/2026 10:37

Realorsurreal · 14/11/2026 10:05

No, it isn’t. It’s cheaper because he’s only using the room for 5/7 days. It does not mean other people can use it when he’s not here!

Thats EXACTLY what it means....

People have lodgers as a business arrangement... Lodgers have homes elsewhere... This is NOT their home...

Do you get upset is someone else uses a Airbnb /hotel room😂

CandidHedgehog · 14/11/2026 10:38

Gwenhwyfar · 14/11/2026 10:28

OMG I couldn't live out of a box like that. Pretty normal to want to have his belongings around him.

He has a home elsewhere! M-F lodgers live near work during the week. When I did it, the flat I lodged in was not as nice as my own home. I lived out of a drawer/suitcase Mon-Thurs and went home on Friday to my nice two bed flat where I lived on my own and where all my things were left out when I wasn’t there on the weekend.

Nobody is ‘living out of a box’ any more than they would be because they stayed in a hotel a couple of times a week.

Ixoral · 14/11/2026 10:39

Gwenhwyfar · 14/11/2026 10:28

OMG I couldn't live out of a box like that. Pretty normal to want to have his belongings around him.

Then he should take his belongings home with him, just as he would if he was renting a room in a bed and breakfast/hotel for the 4 nights a week.
OP has kindly provided a lockable chest so he can if he wishes he can leave some of his belongings in the chest instead of carrying them to and from his home address.

HoraceCope · 14/11/2026 10:42

my dm used to cook for our lodgers
it probably wasnt financially viable.
i dont understand how you cook without knowing whether or not you are providing for an extra mouth

Gwenhwyfar · 14/11/2026 10:42

CandidHedgehog · 14/11/2026 10:38

He has a home elsewhere! M-F lodgers live near work during the week. When I did it, the flat I lodged in was not as nice as my own home. I lived out of a drawer/suitcase Mon-Thurs and went home on Friday to my nice two bed flat where I lived on my own and where all my things were left out when I wasn’t there on the weekend.

Nobody is ‘living out of a box’ any more than they would be because they stayed in a hotel a couple of times a week.

Edited

But he's at the lodgings more than he is at his other home. I still couldn't live like that and I hope my work situation never obliges me to. I completely understand him leaving things lying around even if it's against the rules.

Gwenhwyfar · 14/11/2026 10:43

"i dont understand how you cook without knowing whether or not you are providing for an extra mouth"

A lot of single people cook more than one portion a time anyway. If you're alone, you have the other portion for another meal. It's a much better use of energy, your own and gas/electricity.

Unless I'm having an omelette or something, I never cook from scratch just for one meal.

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 14/11/2026 10:45

Gwenhwyfar · 14/11/2026 10:42

But he's at the lodgings more than he is at his other home. I still couldn't live like that and I hope my work situation never obliges me to. I completely understand him leaving things lying around even if it's against the rules.

Then he may get thrown out.... Lodgers should really be treating these rooms as a b&b(sometimes without breakfast though,🙃) where they need to cleared out when you stop paying...

I worked away a lot... I often had these arrangements in different areas of UK...

Mostly it was much more pleasant and cheaper than hotels /Airbnb.

CandidHedgehog · 14/11/2026 10:48

Gwenhwyfar · 14/11/2026 10:42

But he's at the lodgings more than he is at his other home. I still couldn't live like that and I hope my work situation never obliges me to. I completely understand him leaving things lying around even if it's against the rules.

But there is nothing to stop him renting a full time room! There is no rule you have to be there every night if you rent that way. He wants the best of both worlds - M-F rent but the privileges of a full time lodger.

It sounds like if you ever had to do this, you would think the trade off (more rent for full time exclusive use of the room) would be worth it. That’s fine. It’s when this lodger takes the deal for less rent but then doesn’t hold up his end of the bargain that there’s a problem.

TerfOnATrain · 14/11/2026 10:52

I think you have gone over and above OP, cut the evening meal out for him, if he wants to cook and clear up after himself at 8pm fine.

For the people on here that cannot comprehend that anyone eats before 7pm, there was a time when I ate at that time, then when I worked from home without a commute, I ate two hours earlier, now retired I eat my main meal at 4:30pm.

Not because I am a toddler, but because I only eat twice a day, because I get acid reflux if I eat late, because I am starving at that time, because I like to cook in an afternoon as a hobby, because my day starts at 4:30 AM, much as you don't want to be awake at that time when you don't have to be, you often are, because that's what happens when you get older.

Mealtimes change as your life changes. The OP should cook and eat when it suits her.

Ixoral · 14/11/2026 10:55

Gwenhwyfar · 14/11/2026 10:42

But he's at the lodgings more than he is at his other home. I still couldn't live like that and I hope my work situation never obliges me to. I completely understand him leaving things lying around even if it's against the rules.

And there lies the problem. Some people think they can do whatever they want and disrespect somebody else’s home and rules, even when they know they shouldn’t. He is a lodger for 4 nights, his home is elsewhere, so take his belongings home or put them away as he agreed to.

Gwenhwyfar · 14/11/2026 10:59

"Dinner is 6pm in our house, no dc."

I also eat at 6 and have no children. I finish work at 5 so...

It's considered early where I live on the continent, but I think it's quite normal in parts of the UK, probably outside the south of England.

NoisyMonster678 · 14/11/2026 10:59

He's taking advantage.

Go ahead and withdraw the offer of evening meals, like you said in your post OP.

The contract allows you the freedom to do that, this lodger attempting to manipulate the situation to suit him and after all, you have a lodger to help you with bills then he should also not be taking advantage.

He will have to sort himself out, chances are, he may just get a takeaway, but he does not leave the kitchen like a bomb site either so he should be told to leave the kitchen tidy when he has used it.

BillieWiper · 14/11/2026 11:02

You are being taken for an absolute mug.

He thinks his landlady's responsibility is to cook and feed him a hot meal?! I was buying and cooking my own food at 14 ffs.

Tell him the deal is off. Frankly you regret offering food of any sort and we are reverting to normal lodger rules. 'Which means you use and eat absolutely none of my food and solely supply and cook your own. When I'm not using the kitchen.'

Absolute joker. Him obviously. But you really need to not be such a pushover. Supplying food for lodgers is not normal. Let alone cooked fresh meals at a time of his choosing?!

Realorsurreal · 14/11/2026 11:07

IamtheDevilsAvocado · 14/11/2026 10:37

Thats EXACTLY what it means....

People have lodgers as a business arrangement... Lodgers have homes elsewhere... This is NOT their home...

Do you get upset is someone else uses a Airbnb /hotel room😂

No one is “upset”. I’ve always had M-F lodgers for years and the room is theirs permanently. I wouldn’t dream of going in their room and bathroom or letting my friends and family sleep there. They need to clean it and change the sheets etc. They definitely do not need to move all their belongings out every weekend. It’s nothing like a hotel or AirBandB. But I don’t do food or cook for them. They have full use of the kitchen and dedicated cupboards and fridge space. The cheaper rent for M-F is because they’re using fewer utilities and causing less wear and tear. It also gives the owner some privacy.

User3353821614 · 14/11/2026 11:11

H202too · 13/11/2026 20:37

I think 6 is a standard time.

It’s not unless you’re retired or don’t have a full time job.

zingally · 14/11/2026 11:12

Of course you're not being unreasonable. But you've massively muddied the waters with the evening meal, which wasn't part of the original agreement. I can just about get on board with the breakfast arrangements, which basically boil down to "this is what I've got, eat it if you want."

Plus, it's quite complicated. You're happy for him to eat with you, or you can put a plate aside for him to re-heat, or he can help himself to a ready meal, or he can eat anything not specifically labelled as being for something else, or he can cook for himself.

Is he contributing financially to all this food he's eating? Honestly, it sounds like he's massively landed on his feet with a lovely homecooked meal served up to him every night. When honestly, he was just here for a roof over his head.

A simple text will suffice. "Hi Dave, I don't want to change the time I have dinner. I'm happy to continue putting a plate aside for you to re-heat if you want. If you'd rather make alternative arrangements for dinner, that's not a problem."

Offer him the thing you're willing to provide, and don't even mention any thing else.