Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Benefits boundary at age 25

228 replies

TrappedByThisDesk · 13/11/2026 09:21

AIBU to think that any benefit which has an age threshold or boundary of age 25 is just wrong?
You are an adult at 18, but might be in college until 19 if you repeat a year. Or you might go to uni, so still not launched into 'adult life' until age 21, lets be generous and add in a gap year, so your adult life should start at age 22 at the very latest.
So where is the logic in assuming you don't need full adult benefits until age 25? Behind it is the assumption that you have family to prop you up and subsidise you until then.

I seem to recall the age 25 thing was brought in under Thatcher, with regard to paying B&B accommodation for homeless jobless young adults. It was restricted to only two weeks in any one location. Happy to be corrected if it was introduced before that.

Since then, there seems to be a default assumption that is it fine to treat adults age 22, 23, and 24 as if they were not "proper adults" with regards to benefits.

OP posts:
NettleTea · 13/11/2026 12:31

Octavia64 · 13/11/2026 09:37

i’m pretty sure students aren’t entitled to UC anyway. So anyone in education isn’t entitled to UC.

this is not true
IF you are disabled and have been on UC, and IF you get LCWRA then you will be allowed to keep your UC claim open. They will subtract the student loan maintanance grant from your payment, as it would be wrong for you to make money off the back of it, but it does allow some people to keep their claim open, especially with it being increasingly difficult to get LCWRA. It also means they get their full UC allowance during the long summer break.

My daughter needed it. As it was her health wasnt good enough for her to complete her course, so it was lucky she had that to fall back on as she is currently still unwell 10 months later. She is 26 now so wont come under the proposed rules, but she spent much of 2016, (when she first got PIP as transferred from DLA) to 2022 bed ridden. Under new rules she would not have received PIP, and would likely be penalised for not working. She MAY have come under the proposed 'worst case scenarios) I dont know. Its hard enough to get PIP, so how this will be judged I dont know. I expect it will be harder. The current LCWRA removes the pressure/sanctions for job hunting/application. If she didnt hit the target for the replacement then she would lose her UC if she was bed ridden and unable to work. Im a carer. I work around her. If I earn more than £204 (of which I only get £98 due to the reduction in UC) I lose all carers allowance. The proposed change in carers means I wont lose the carers allowance and risk huge fines, but until you ewarn more than £290, you wont benefit from earning any more money, as CA will be reduced £ for £, and Likely you will actually be worse off because UC will also be reduced.

My son receives PIP and he is at uni. He went directly from college so never claimed UC, so he would not be able to claim as a student. Under current guidelines he can keep his PIP whilst at uni as his issues are there and will remain there. He wont grow out of them. If the new rules come in, he will effectively lose that money. He doesnt claim UC. He doesnt need 'help to find a job' because he is doing what he is 'supposed to' as in, he is in education.

This really comes into the whole thing theyve been doing for a long time - connecting, in the publics mind, the idea that PIP is a means tested / UC related benefit thats given to people who wont work. Whereas of course it is not. It is a hard to get, medically backed up, evidence based award given to help support disabled people with their extra costs associated with their disability. And often is the difference between them actually being able to work or not.

Young people are having real trouble finding work as it is, even without disabilities. This is just going to put a huge amount of pressure on families to look after their disabled kids for even longer. Disabilities dont disappear between the ages of 16-25.

NettleTea · 13/11/2026 12:41

the entire system is a mess of different qualifiers and mismatched rules, often in contradiction with each other.

And the arbitary ages are a mess too.

BooHissScarySeason · 13/11/2026 12:42

That’s the crux of it though, we aren’t getting our young people to be independent - either from family or from the state. We need to rip most of it up and have a new deal for them.

BePeachNewt · 13/11/2026 12:48

TrappedByThisDesk · 13/11/2026 10:34

So there is another illogical and immoral cut off at age 35? This is even worse!
😡
So a 34 year old is expected to live in a room in a shared house, but a 35 year old can have a 1 bedroom flat.
Just why?
(apart from the obvious - another way to save money)

This is blatant age discrimination.

The vast majority of working twenty somethings / single people in their early thirties can’t afford to live alone, so why should we be paying for those who aren’t working to have a flat to themselves?

My kids, in their mid-twenties, are working and living in flatshares. I would be very angry if their taxes were being used to fund a better quality of life for people their age who aren’t working and depend on benefits.

TrappedByThisDesk · 13/11/2026 12:56

BePeachNewt · 13/11/2026 12:48

The vast majority of working twenty somethings / single people in their early thirties can’t afford to live alone, so why should we be paying for those who aren’t working to have a flat to themselves?

My kids, in their mid-twenties, are working and living in flatshares. I would be very angry if their taxes were being used to fund a better quality of life for people their age who aren’t working and depend on benefits.

Edited

That is very reasonable.
So why allow a 35+ person to have a one-bed flat? What makes that age special? Why can't they stay in a house share?

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 13/11/2026 13:02

Shamwee · 13/11/2026 09:49

I had my dc at 16 and moved out at the same time and I remember finding out people over 25 were getting a lot more UC than me. Which felt like a very high age.
Another thing that seems unfair is university loans am I right in thinking they assume everyone’s parents are helping their adult child and give less money based on parents income?
The whole thing is weighted towards assume everyone’s parents are bankrolling them.

PIP should have been ended for anyone with adhd, anxiety etc. but they didn’t have the balls to do that so now a 24 year old in a wheelchair won’t get it but a 26 year old with “adhd” will

Nobody “gets PIP for ADHD”. The payment is based on an assessment of need, not a diagnosis. A person will receive PIP if they meet the thresholds required in the very strict parameters for scoring. It’s this type of misinformation that has led to the demonisation of disability benefits and the clamour to remove them.

Stancherd · 13/11/2026 13:04

TigerRag · 13/11/2026 09:38

Do we really need another thread on this?

Why open it then? People who actively post on topics they are bored of, and whinge about it, seem so silly to me!

TheOldWhiteHorse · 13/11/2026 13:05

monkeysox · 13/11/2026 10:22

I think it's ridiculous that some young people are going and renting when they could be at home.
I think you are right though as young people without safety net of a supportive family are those who will suffer

Not all parents live where work opportunities are for young people.

My DS went to uni in a big city and now lives and works there. We live rurally with very few opportunities for young people. His housemates are in the same position, family homes in very rural or deprived areas with few prospects.

They were very, very fortunate to secure accommodation with only one of them working. Now they all have jobs and have launched successfully into independent lives.

How many others have had to return home and are isolated, unable to find work and not on the way to contributing to society for want of support?

monkeysox · 13/11/2026 13:06

TheOldWhiteHorse · 13/11/2026 13:05

Not all parents live where work opportunities are for young people.

My DS went to uni in a big city and now lives and works there. We live rurally with very few opportunities for young people. His housemates are in the same position, family homes in very rural or deprived areas with few prospects.

They were very, very fortunate to secure accommodation with only one of them working. Now they all have jobs and have launched successfully into independent lives.

How many others have had to return home and are isolated, unable to find work and not on the way to contributing to society for want of support?

Again you're right but I know of a couple of 18 year olds living together claiming pip and working cash in hand. Near enough to parent who had space to keep them

SoSoLong · 13/11/2026 13:57

There's plenty of age discrimination in the benefits system, starting with the biggest one of all, pension age. It might be messy, but they are not illegal because they are set by statute.

TrappedByThisDesk · 13/11/2026 15:08

SoSoLong · 13/11/2026 13:57

There's plenty of age discrimination in the benefits system, starting with the biggest one of all, pension age. It might be messy, but they are not illegal because they are set by statute.

What is discriminatory about pension age?

OP posts:
BoredZelda · 13/11/2026 15:12

monkeysox · 13/11/2026 13:06

Again you're right but I know of a couple of 18 year olds living together claiming pip and working cash in hand. Near enough to parent who had space to keep them

Of course you do…..

PIP isn’t a work related benefit.

Ohmygiddygirl · 13/11/2026 15:16

Dicedpumpkin · 13/11/2026 12:16

You dont get extra money for adhd.

You get exra money for meeting the threshold relating to difficulties on very specific care, communication and mobility activities.

You are really asking why does not being able to do those things cost money.

So do you get the money for ‘poor you, here’s some cash to cheer you up’. The cash must surely be given in relation to verifiable expenses otherwise why on earth are we handing it over?

Ohmygiddygirl · 13/11/2026 15:20

BooHissScarySeason · 13/11/2026 12:42

That’s the crux of it though, we aren’t getting our young people to be independent - either from family or from the state. We need to rip most of it up and have a new deal for them.

Young people aren’t living alone cause they can’t afford it, certainly not in the big city I live and work in. We need to move away from thinking athat parental responsibility ends at 18. It doesn’t these days. You should be expected to house your child, fund their uni and provide accommodation until they’re at least 25. All young professionals working in this city live with their parents if it’s commutable here. I can’t see why benefits claimants should be funded as though they NEED to be living independently. It’s simply not affordable.

monkeysox · 13/11/2026 15:27

BoredZelda · 13/11/2026 15:12

Of course you do…..

PIP isn’t a work related benefit.

Yes but they are capable of working and doing so under the radar

SoSoLong · 13/11/2026 15:50

TrappedByThisDesk · 13/11/2026 15:08

What is discriminatory about pension age?

It literally discriminates based on your birthdate. You can get it at 67, but not at 66. Regardless of how many years of NI contributions you've got, as long as it's more than 10. It's literally a made up threshold based on age, with no other basis than the financial cost to the state.

TiredShadows · 13/11/2026 16:00

There was a challenge back in the mid '00s on the age of 25 being used for student finance including to be eligible for the adult dependent grant.

Since then, you've been able to get it younger if you are married or in a civil partnership. To my knowledge, that's been the only concession.

There are a lot of things in laws that are a bit arbitrary.

It is not good for young adults to be trapped into an extended period of feeling like overgrown teenagers, dependent on their parents, when they need to be making their own way in the world.

The idea of leaving home entirely at 18 is the best is a very modern one in a handful of countries. It is the norm historically and in many places still culturally for young adults to remain with their parents or another trusted older adult while contributing to the household. That's never made them overgrown teenagers.

My DS1 in his early 20s has spent months consecutively working at sea and has been flown overseas by his employer to work. He has thousands saved, goes on trips regularly during his weeks off. That he lives with his father and I when he's not working or traveling does not mean he is either dependent or not making his own way in the world. He's not an oversized teenager, he's a contributing adult.

I had to leave my father's home and my birth country at 17. I only survived because I was fortunate enough to have others I could depend on. I'm very glad and grateful my kids can depend on me when they need to and can make their own way and own contributions to our household and the community while being able to make their own financial plans as to when to fully move out rather than it being based arbitrarily on how old they are.

Why do you need extra money for ADHD? What about the condition costs more?

Like most disabilities, it'll vary by person.

Using one example of one of my adult kids -- ADHD (and autism since that was mentioned earlier) can have a significant impact on balance and motor coordination. My DD1 does not have the coordination to drive though has never gone through the process to be officially medically refused. She can't ride a normal bike. She paid nearly £600 for a specially adapted adult trike so she could commute and do groceries independently, and the costs of maintenance needed regularly has not been cheap either.

She does not get any benefits -- she's chosen so far not to apply, largely because of the kinds of remarks on here that have entrenched a 'well others have it so much worse, I'll just handle it," mindset that at times can be heartbreaking. It was enough effort to get her to sign onto a programme that supports young disabled adults to gain and maintain employment.

What is discriminatory about pension age?

It's arbitrary, as are the laws around when a private pension can be withdrawn from, much like many of the laws around other benefits.

TrappedByThisDesk · 13/11/2026 16:08

Ohmygiddygirl · 13/11/2026 15:20

Young people aren’t living alone cause they can’t afford it, certainly not in the big city I live and work in. We need to move away from thinking athat parental responsibility ends at 18. It doesn’t these days. You should be expected to house your child, fund their uni and provide accommodation until they’re at least 25. All young professionals working in this city live with their parents if it’s commutable here. I can’t see why benefits claimants should be funded as though they NEED to be living independently. It’s simply not affordable.

I couldn't disagree more.
Society should be treating 18 year olds as adults, and treating them as fully financially independent from their parents (from the end of the term after they finish full time education after their 18th birthday, i.e. after they finish A' levels or whatever course at college or sixth form, which is what I believe the child benefit rules are now - happy to be corrected).

It is absolutely damaging to the growth and mental health of young adults to infantilise them and force them to remain dependent on their parents long after they should have flown the nest.
We should be fixing the housing and employment issues, not just throwing our hands up and saying 'we can't afford it, your parents will have to fund you'.

And if we can't currently afford to treat 18-24 year olds as adults, then something else has to be cut or taxed so that we can afford it.

OP posts:
TrappedByThisDesk · 13/11/2026 16:14

SoSoLong · 13/11/2026 15:50

It literally discriminates based on your birthdate. You can get it at 67, but not at 66. Regardless of how many years of NI contributions you've got, as long as it's more than 10. It's literally a made up threshold based on age, with no other basis than the financial cost to the state.

It is not discriminatory if everyone is treated the same. (It used to be discriminatory against men, but that is now fixed). The process of raising it from 65 to 68 necessarily includes a tapering, so some get it at 66 or 67, but that is not in itself age discrimination.

We need a fixed pension age for state pension. It may be arbitrary, or based on demographics and the nation's finances, to choose a pension age of 68, but it is not discriminatory. To suggest so is mangling the meaning of the word 'discrimination'.

OP posts:
Lhori · 13/11/2026 16:16

TrappedByThisDesk · 13/11/2026 11:01

If we as a nation voted / decided that the age of majority (adulthood) was 17 or 19, or 21 as it used to be, I would have no problem with that.
For all kinds of legal reasons, we do actually need an age in law when you switch from being 'child' to adult.

What I object to is having a legal age of majority, currently 18, but then making exceptions for benefits or student loans, creating arbitrary ages at 25 or 35 (35!!!) for no logical reason except to save money.
It is age discrimination.

I know there are other exceptions, such as ages for riding mopeds, driving cars, and driving HGV lorries, but these do have vaguely logical thought behind them.

We need to save money though. We are currently over spending.

TrappedByThisDesk · 13/11/2026 16:20

Ohmygiddygirl · 13/11/2026 15:20

Young people aren’t living alone cause they can’t afford it, certainly not in the big city I live and work in. We need to move away from thinking athat parental responsibility ends at 18. It doesn’t these days. You should be expected to house your child, fund their uni and provide accommodation until they’re at least 25. All young professionals working in this city live with their parents if it’s commutable here. I can’t see why benefits claimants should be funded as though they NEED to be living independently. It’s simply not affordable.

I can’t see why benefits claimants should be funded as though they NEED to be living independently.

They aren't. If they live at home with relatives, they get a certain amount, and if they live somewhere where they pay a landlord, they get a different amount.
If they are not paying a landlord, they don't get the extra.
I have no problem with this - it is perfectly sensible. And the principle of paying according to where you live is completely unaffected by the age of the claimant. (apart from the age 35 shared house thing, which is another issue)

What I object to is a 24 year old being paid less than a 25 year old in exactly the same circumstances.

OP posts:
Gwenhwyfar · 13/11/2026 16:38

"So a 34 year old is expected to live in a room in a shared house, but a 35 year old can have a 1 bedroom flat.
Just why?
(apart from the obvious - another way to save money)"

It's unfair, but I will say that it gets more and more difficult to share as you get older.

In some countries, young people can't necessarily access full benefits, but parents get child allowance for them while they're in their twenties if still dependent.

Gwenhwyfar · 13/11/2026 16:40

"If they live at home with relatives, they get a certain amount, and if they live somewhere where they pay a landlord, they get a different amount.
If they are not paying a landlord, they don't get the extra."

Those of a certain age will remember Bread. The main family lived in granddad's house and he lived in their house. That way, both households got housing benefit. (It was fiction).

Gwenhwyfar · 13/11/2026 16:41

"What I object to is having a legal age of majority, currently 18, but then making exceptions for..."

But there are exceptions for all sorts of things. You can drive at 17, etc.

Meadowfinch · 13/11/2026 16:44

What % of 25yos are still living at home with their parents? I think that's far more relevant. Someone who isn't paying gas, electric, council tax, water, tv licence, broadband, furniture, wear & tear etc does not need the same amount of benefits as somone whose parents have kicked them out.

I know where I'd rather the money went.

Swipe left for the next trending thread