Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think removing phones from all children is a good idea, but...

93 replies

Redbags · 10/11/2026 12:09

You need to reinstate payphones.

I know from my own phone usage and the way I've wasted my entire morning that phones are addictive and their content harmful, but they are also now our only way to contact anyone, including emergency services.

Yes, I know we all managed perfectly well without them, but we were taught from a young age how to use payphones and always to have 2p for the phone in our sock.

OP posts:
bobiwien · 12/11/2026 11:15

x2boys · 12/11/2026 10:29

Diabetic children will need their phone during the day as their CGM links up with an app on the phone
It will be treated as a medical device.

Then they’d have a special exemption.

ShanghaiDiva · 12/11/2026 11:19

bobiwien · 12/11/2026 11:15

Then they’d have a special exemption.

Yes, I think a pp mentioned on this thread or another one on this topic that students who are diabetic have their phone in a pouch with a Velcro fastening so it can be accessed.

ShanghaiDiva · 12/11/2026 11:23

bobiwien · 12/11/2026 11:13

This is such a non issue. Phones will go in lockers or pouches so the children will have them before and after school.

Exactly! There are no issues re travel to and from school or children being able to contact parents. For an emergency in school the school will contact the parent and outside school hours the child has free use of their phone.

Growlybear83 · 12/11/2026 11:28

x2boys · 12/11/2026 11:14

Well Diabetic children will need their phomes with them at all times as its being used as a medical device and needs to be treated as such.

Yes, that’s why I said that a small number of children will need access to their phones during the day - such as children with certain medical conditions and young carers - but the vast majority of children won’t need them. Arrangements will be made for the small proportion of children who genuinely do need access to their phones.

Saturdaysfairies · 12/11/2026 11:59

Phones are handed in in the morning and signed out before the pupils leave school. It's not a bog deal at DC schools.

Yawningalldaylong · 12/11/2026 15:26

Saturdaysfairies · 12/11/2026 11:59

Phones are handed in in the morning and signed out before the pupils leave school. It's not a bog deal at DC schools.

So how does this work? Do your kids lose teaching time or is the school day longer? Do buses wait for the kids at the back of the queue? Who is responsible for the phones during the day?

ProfessorofDarkArts · 12/11/2026 16:03

I dont get why parents are making such a massive drama about this - if kids didn't mess about on their phones during lesson time there wouldn't be any need for it!

Nannamads · 12/11/2026 17:04

Its only while children are in school, which is right. Out of school you can allow your children to use a mobile phone as little or as much as you deem appropriate.

CrispySquid · 12/11/2026 18:39

bobiwien · 12/11/2026 11:13

This is such a non issue. Phones will go in lockers or pouches so the children will have them before and after school.

Exactly this. I have no idea why people are banging on about bus tickets and pay phones. Students can have a phone to and from school for their commute and for any other reason they desire, they just can’t have it on their person once they get in the school building so will have to either a) hand it in or b) put it in a lockable pouch that they are unable to access throughout the day.

They will have access to their phones again the second the school bell goes at the end of the day. Likewise, any student who needs an app on their phone for medical reasons such as to monitor blood sugar will be able to use it for this reason only.

There is absolutely no suggestion that children will be unable to use phones as medical devices or that students can’t have phones to get to and from schools safely.

You get to school with your phone. Hand it in or seal it up. You get it handed back to you at the end of the day or you can unseal your pouch. You go home with your phone.

Flabbergasted that so many people are struggling to comprehend this. If you need to contact your parent for any reason throughout the day that cannot wait till the end of the day, you go to the office at break time to ring your parent like every other child in history or get a teacher to email your parent. If you are in a medical or safeguarding emergency, the school would literally be calling your parent anyway.

Not a single reason you’d need access to your phone throughout the school day.

bobiwien · 12/11/2026 19:01

I want to see a venn diagram: IQ of parent and their opinion on phone use in schools

SalemsPl0t · 14/11/2026 04:28

So the phone companies want parents to buy their children their products, then government ban them 🤔

DeftGoldHedgehog · 14/11/2026 04:44

My DDs (Gen Z) are hardly on their phones and had phones since they were 11.

I don't think their generation are a problem, it's older adults who are more addicted to social media and phones in my experience. Plenty of people who are on Mumsnet, in fact.

I'm glad that some schools are being more sensible now and having a rethink about previous policy, though I do find them hypocritical. DD2's school in particular had an app for everything so they massively caused teenagers to be on devices much more than necessary. DD1 went to a superselective state grammar and they used phones in a directed way in lessons at times.

The elephant in the room is that the education system that changed under Michael Gove is not fit for purpose and it is this that is the huge problem, not phones per se.

OneZanyMintQuoter · 14/11/2026 04:46

I don't remember ever using a payphone for an emergency or even particularly at all except abroad.
I think the fact that almost every adult around will have a phone is helpful in that someone would call emergency service if required. I think we used to be told to go into a shop/ cafe etc if was a problem as they would have a phone.

PollyBell · 14/11/2026 04:51

bobiwien · 12/11/2026 19:01

I want to see a venn diagram: IQ of parent and their opinion on phone use in schools

To a point i agree with you but there is a lot pf apps some schools need kids to use in school so if schools get rid of the needs for devices then I say stop them being used in schools

Ponderingwindow · 14/11/2026 05:53

My government banned phones and told the schools they had to lock them up. Our school decided to treat the students like the responsible people they have always been. As long as the teachers don’t see the phones, the school doesn’t have to do anything about the phones. That solves the issue of getting to and from school. The phones just stay in bags and they aren’t a problem.

Maybe it’s because we don’t have huge behavior issues at our school, but a blunt policy is just cumbersome. The ban causes real problems during the day in higher years and there is no room for teacher discretion. This is something that schools should be able to deal with.

Littlecrake · 14/11/2026 06:54

NineteenSeventyThree · 12/11/2026 11:13

Rather than trying to bring back payphones, would it not be easier to allow children to have non-smart phones only - the old Nokia style that can't do much more than calls and texts?

That would make sense in

  • allowing children to make calls in an emergency
  • not being a target for muggers
  • Not inviting comparisons, one-upmanship, being bullied for having a not very good phone etc.
  • not enabling access to any imagery, videos, web browsing or social media
  • the battery on those phones lasts for ages without needing a charge

It’s the worst of all worlds. They end up “needing” 2 phones, they still faff and text and call during the school day but they can’t get on the bus, get into the gym, clock into work after school or sort their lunch out. They will still bring their smartphones with them. They will definitely still have them because they are useful to the point of necessary.

I don’t think this is a big drama. The school infrastructure is expensive but the government has said they will fund it. Kids lock their phones in the pouch at the start of the day with suitable exemption for those with a medical need, then they unlock them when they go home.

Ultraalox · 14/11/2026 06:58

ThreeMogsAndCounting · 10/11/2026 20:49

Nobody is saying they can't have phones before an after school. Just not at school.

My kids' school has had a phone ban during school hours for as long as they've been there. Its all fine.

Why so much handwriting and drama?

Our has banned phones from the school grounds entirely. Not even allowed in bags.
school bus is a credit card size thing, but guess what, half of the teacher still set homework on the school app! It’s such a joke.

Ultraalox · 14/11/2026 07:04

OneZanyMintQuoter · 14/11/2026 04:46

I don't remember ever using a payphone for an emergency or even particularly at all except abroad.
I think the fact that almost every adult around will have a phone is helpful in that someone would call emergency service if required. I think we used to be told to go into a shop/ cafe etc if was a problem as they would have a phone.

I used to walk to and from school every day as a teen. I’ve used a pay phone a few times.
A teen boy fell from his bike and was unconscious in the road, we called an ambulance from the pay phone. (Quiet road, didn't think to knock on a door as just a teenager).
friend didn’t turn up one morning and had to call her mum.
Friend felt really unwell one morning on the way to school and again called her parent.
yr 7 and got lost en route and called a parent from the nearest phone.
I guess nowadays kids would have to stop a passer by and ask to use their phone, or knock on a random door. I wouldn’t feel comfortable with my child doing this but there isn’t much of an alternative. Phones banned outright here

balkanscot · 14/11/2026 07:07

CrispySquid · 12/11/2026 18:39

Exactly this. I have no idea why people are banging on about bus tickets and pay phones. Students can have a phone to and from school for their commute and for any other reason they desire, they just can’t have it on their person once they get in the school building so will have to either a) hand it in or b) put it in a lockable pouch that they are unable to access throughout the day.

They will have access to their phones again the second the school bell goes at the end of the day. Likewise, any student who needs an app on their phone for medical reasons such as to monitor blood sugar will be able to use it for this reason only.

There is absolutely no suggestion that children will be unable to use phones as medical devices or that students can’t have phones to get to and from schools safely.

You get to school with your phone. Hand it in or seal it up. You get it handed back to you at the end of the day or you can unseal your pouch. You go home with your phone.

Flabbergasted that so many people are struggling to comprehend this. If you need to contact your parent for any reason throughout the day that cannot wait till the end of the day, you go to the office at break time to ring your parent like every other child in history or get a teacher to email your parent. If you are in a medical or safeguarding emergency, the school would literally be calling your parent anyway.

Not a single reason you’d need access to your phone throughout the school day.

Absolutely. In my DS secondary school (Scotland) they have lockable pouches that they put their phones in and that’s that until the bell rings at 3.25 pm. There are exemptions, of course. But for the majority it works. I completely agree there is no need for children to be on their phones during school hours. If I need to contact DS I can ring the school office and they will always pass a message on.

Porcuine20 · 14/11/2026 07:09

ProfessorofDarkArts · 10/11/2026 21:03

It’s only during school hours they won’t be allowed, nobody’s saying they can’t use them on the way there and back - how could that possibly be enforced?

There’s no reason I can think of that kids need a phone during school time apart from the example mentioned above where there’s a genuine medical need - I assume diabetes monitoring can require an app?

I’m sure a whole load of new and urgent ‘medical exemptions’ will suddenly appear though for all those who don’t want to follow the rules.

My child’s (secondary) school has completely banned smartphones - they’re not supposed to have them at all, even switched off and hidden away. They are allowed a brick phone, which he has but finds hard to use and PAYG these days is hard to buy and very expensive. I resent having to pay for another phone when he already has a perfectly decent smartphone with a cheap contract.

Ultraalox · 14/11/2026 07:10

balkanscot · 14/11/2026 07:07

Absolutely. In my DS secondary school (Scotland) they have lockable pouches that they put their phones in and that’s that until the bell rings at 3.25 pm. There are exemptions, of course. But for the majority it works. I completely agree there is no need for children to be on their phones during school hours. If I need to contact DS I can ring the school office and they will always pass a message on.

Pouches are such a good idea. Ours said - no time to police this and no lockers to store them. So helpful 😅

MsJJones · 14/11/2026 07:12

Littlecrake · 14/11/2026 06:54

It’s the worst of all worlds. They end up “needing” 2 phones, they still faff and text and call during the school day but they can’t get on the bus, get into the gym, clock into work after school or sort their lunch out. They will still bring their smartphones with them. They will definitely still have them because they are useful to the point of necessary.

I don’t think this is a big drama. The school infrastructure is expensive but the government has said they will fund it. Kids lock their phones in the pouch at the start of the day with suitable exemption for those with a medical need, then they unlock them when they go home.

This has actually worked well for us. DS (14) has a tiny switched-off Nokia in his bag at school which he just uses if he needs to let us know he will be home late or needs a lift. His smartphone (my old phone) stays at home and he can use it with WiFi. At weekends/holidays, he switches the SIM. He has a bus pass for the bus. Perhaps older ones face the gym/work issue you mention which I wasn’t aware of.

I agree that if phones are completely banned including brick phones then phone boxes will need to make a comeback - but there is no way this will happen.

Tickingcrocodile · 14/11/2026 07:13

The whole situation seems overkill. Just let them keep their phones switched off in the bottom of their bags and confiscate any that are seen. Buying a load of school pouches or lockers seems like a total waste of funding. My daughter has to catch a public bus to our village which leaves soon after school which she will miss if there are delays in opening pouches or getting phones out of lockers.

Porcuine20 · 14/11/2026 07:14

ShanghaiDiva · 10/11/2026 22:03

Exactly. The phones are stored eg in a yondr pouch during the school day so pupils have access to phones to and from school.

Not at my dc’s school - no pouches provided, smartphones are forbidden to be brought onto the premises and will be confiscated if found. They are allowed dumb phones as long as they’re switched off and out of sight. I wish they had phone pouches.

ithinkthereforeyouarewrong · 14/11/2026 07:15

My sons school they have lockable pouches that get reopened at end of day. Obviously some kids get round this by taking two phones in. I drop and collect my son so he leaves his phone with me