Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Aibu re SIL and wedding/pregnancy?

62 replies

weddingy · 07/11/2026 21:23

Hi all,

Fully prepared to be told IABU on this and that I need to give my head a wobble, but looking for some very objective outside opinions.

I’m due to get married to my fiancé in 2 years time, and SIL is 5 months pregnant.

Obviously I am super excited for her and it’ll be lovely for the in-laws to be first time grandparents etc. But since her announcement she’s come across to me as very entitled, in particular about our wedding.

Our wedding was initially intended to be child free, we don’t have children and we only know one person who we are close to with young children. The only exception to this is my (much younger) sister who is 4.

I am more than happy to make changes to this based on SILs baby, as she’s obviously closer family etc.

My suggestion was that baby comes to the ceremony and meal and then leaves for the reception. I was thinking they’d be tired by then anyway (they’ll be nearly 2!) and tbh we’d really like our reception to be like ‘big house party’ vibes, so don’t want to be worrying about a little one! To add, this is exactly what’s going to happen with my little sister with no issue

SIL has hit the roof about this. She’s firstly annoyed that the baby won’t be a ‘proper part’ of the wedding (I assume she means like flower girl/page boy). I think this stems from a previous issue where she was very upset she wasn’t a bridesmaid and if her baby was a flower girl etc then she’d effectively be a bridesmaid as she’d have to carry her down the aisle?

She was then annoyed that her baby isn’t welcome all day and said this is really unfair to her as she’ll then also have to leave. Which I kind of see, but also her DH could take the baby up to the hotel room if that’s the issue?

Theres also the issue of the meal. Our venue doesn’t have a children’s catering option, which is no issue as we don’t really have any child guests! I offered to organise some kind of packed lunch but she said this wasn’t fair either. I don’t really see why it’s a massive deal to bring their own food when baby surely won’t eat much at 1.5 anyway?

Also, if it makes any difference, SIL got married 2 years ago and had a completely child free wedding and wouldn’t let her friend bring a newborn as it ‘ruined the vibe’ so I think she’s being quite hypocritical!

I know this post makes it sound like I don’t like her, but we do generally get on well! However she’s very strong minded so I find it hard when she gets firm on something as there’s not much to say to change her mind etc.

So, Mumsnet, AIBU to say I’m sticking to my original plan re the baby?!

OP posts:
cestlavielife · 07/11/2026 22:03

Why 2 years? Just get married in 2 months before sil has the baby !!
what if you get pregnant before then?

Coconutter24 · 07/11/2026 22:06

What does your fiancé think?

ByTipsyShark · 07/11/2026 22:06

I think you’re both getting ahead of yourself - a lot can happen in 2 years!

Allswellthatendswelll · 07/11/2026 22:07

She might not want her child at the reception in two years. You probably won't notice if they are there or not anyway!
It's also, depending on your age, highly likely a load of your friends will have had babies by then anyway.
You need to chill out!

Talkingtomyhouseplants · 07/11/2026 22:08

ByTipsyShark · 07/11/2026 22:06

I think you’re both getting ahead of yourself - a lot can happen in 2 years!

Yes this. Very sadly not all pregnancies lead to babies, and not all engagements lead to weddings. 16 other things could happen to through a curve ball in your lives between now and the wedding which might mean you have to change course.

PeasOff · 07/11/2026 22:13

Yanbu and she's a massive hypocrite given her wedding was childfree.

What's good for your little sister is good for her child, it's not like you're treating them differently.

If she's that bothered about attending the reception she has plenty of time to arrange childcare given it's 2 years away.

Also the food is a non issue - she can give baby some food off their plates. It's not likely that a 1.5 yr old will be eating a full on kids meal anyway.

Elsvieta · 07/11/2026 22:15

Weddings need to be childfree or not - "exceptions" are beyond infuriating for those who have gone to great trouble to arrange childcare for a weekend (especially if the kids who do attend are brats). And if SIL had a CF wedding she's got no right to moan about it. Have you pointed that out to her? I mean, what could she say?

Gemstonebeach · 07/11/2026 22:17

I’d just leave the arrangements until closer to the time, she might find she wants a night out without the toddler by then. I do think she’s being a bit mental, when my DB got married all the family kids went home after the drinks and nibbles but before the meal including their own!

Schoolchoicesucks · 07/11/2026 22:18

Genevieva · 07/11/2026 21:47

Why would you wait two years to get married and simultaneously try to plan every fine detail now? If I were you, I’d relax and see how the baby is nearer the time. She isn’t even half way through her pregnancy yet and she’s a new Mum. It is all overkill. I promise you, that if the parents decide on the day how to manage their little one, it won’t spoil a thing. You will still be the bride. It will still be your wedding. A baby at a reception isn’t a problem.

This. Drama over an event 2 years away. It's ridiculous.

ThankYouNigel · 07/11/2026 22:20

I’m on the fence with this one.

When mine were that age, I would have decided myself to take them up to the room before it got rowdier, later, noisier, etc. Would you mind in future somebody telling you your child wasn’t welcome to the whole of a family wedding?

It does annoys me when people ban children like your SIL then complain when others do the same!

I do generally hate how child unfriendly weddings have become though.

BoredZelda · 07/11/2026 22:24

A dozen things will go wrong at your wedding. The 100% perfect day you are dreaming of will not happen. One small child at a wedding will make no difference to anyone other than their parents. To decide this is the hill you will die on, this far out from the wedding, is giving you and your family unnecessary grief. My SIL made it impossible for my sister to go to our brother’s wedding for the exact same reason. They divorced within three years.

I wouldn’t touch a venue with a barge pole if they insist they can’t cater for a child. The only reason they are unable to do it is their meals will be mass produced, cooking by numbers type food. We ended up having two children at our wedding unexpectedly. On the day, they approached the parents and asked exactly what the children wanted and cooked it. Any catering team worth their salt can do this.

pinksquash13 · 07/11/2026 22:28

I've been to lots of weddings and personally, I do not feel that a 4 year old and a 1.5year old will ruin party vibes, with presumably lots of other adult guests. You won't need to worry about them. All it does is stress out the people who have to leave with them because they will feel like they're on a clock and it isn't a particularly welcoming vibe for very close relatives. I think when you're older you'll reflect on this issue and wonder why you were so uptight about it but I do appreciate it's hard to see it from my point of view when you are young, child free and enjoy partying.

Topjoe19 · 07/11/2026 22:34

Barmy, the pair of you!

Agapornis · 07/11/2026 22:36

we only know one person who we are close to with young children

...and you're 100% sure that will still be true in 2 years because...?

HappyViewer · 07/11/2026 22:42

Tell her as her wedding was so nice you’ll also have a child free wedding (except for your DSis).

CheeryOP · 07/11/2026 22:44

You sound a bit over precious about the wedding.

KindlySurfiingPlatypus · 07/11/2026 22:47

You are putting far too much emotional energy into this. One toddler is not going to ruin any vibe. Neither you not SIL have the faintest idea what the issues will be in 2 years. The kid might be a massive insomniac or might be fine snoozing in a buggy. Might be happy eating a little bit of whatever the grownups are having or might eat nothing but weetabix. SIL might be 8 months pg with baby #2 and suffering from pregnancy complications that make it difficult for her to do much.

You are only 50% of the people getting married that day. She will want to be there to celebrate her brother getting married. She will participate as much as she can, to the extent that is possible compatible with the wellbeing of her child. You will end the day successfully married regardless of this kid's eating and sleeping arrangements, you do not need to care. Have your reception styled however you want it, if it's not compatible with the kid, the kid's parents are in charge of how to deal with that, not you.

Clonakilla · 07/11/2026 22:49

I wouldn’t call her hypocritical - she’s just experiencing what many people without much empathy find out when an experience they couldn’t imagine and didn’t care about happens to them. People with empathy get it before they have children.

I’m surprised a wedding venue fancy enough to need a two year lead-up can’t cater for one toddler.

But I certainly wouldn’t fall out now over something so far away.

RitaFires · 07/11/2026 22:49

It's really over the top to be so tightly planning the day and menu for a child who hasn't been born yet. There's no possible way to predict what this child will be like in 2 years time, they could be super chill eating only organic foods or a tantrum hurricane fueled entirely by pom bears.

Give SIL a break, she might be very difficult and imagining slights where they're not intended but there is no need at this point in her pregnancy to be stressing over the detail of when her unborn child is and isn't welcome at an event that is still years away.

HappyViewer · 07/11/2026 22:49

KindlySurfiingPlatypus · 07/11/2026 22:47

You are putting far too much emotional energy into this. One toddler is not going to ruin any vibe. Neither you not SIL have the faintest idea what the issues will be in 2 years. The kid might be a massive insomniac or might be fine snoozing in a buggy. Might be happy eating a little bit of whatever the grownups are having or might eat nothing but weetabix. SIL might be 8 months pg with baby #2 and suffering from pregnancy complications that make it difficult for her to do much.

You are only 50% of the people getting married that day. She will want to be there to celebrate her brother getting married. She will participate as much as she can, to the extent that is possible compatible with the wellbeing of her child. You will end the day successfully married regardless of this kid's eating and sleeping arrangements, you do not need to care. Have your reception styled however you want it, if it's not compatible with the kid, the kid's parents are in charge of how to deal with that, not you.

Or they can have a childfree wedding.

MyLimeGuide · 07/11/2026 22:54

Your being a massive bridezilla dick.

LVPLVT · 07/11/2026 22:57

Why do you give a shit if a toddler is there for the evening? You won’t hear them over the music and you won’t have to worry about them (their parents will do that).

ForLimeHiker · 07/11/2026 22:57

Give her time to realise that organising a babysitter on the day so she can have fun etc, not chasing after a toddler is a much better idea! Could grandparents on the other side step in to help? She will most likely come round on her own to realise she doesn’t want to be ‘mummy’ on the day. We adore ours, but we love time off for a wedding!

JLou08 · 07/11/2026 23:09

Have you even considered what the groom wants? I would not be happy if my DH tried to exclude my nephews from our wedding.
Your post is very me, me, me. You even talk about having to worry about a child. Why on earth would you be worried about a child who isn't yours at your wedding reception? I don't think SIL expects you to babysit, she will be there too.

BePeachNewt · 07/11/2026 23:29

Why on earth are you falling out with family members over the presence of a baby that hasn’t even been born yet at a wedding that isn’t happening for another 2 years? It honestly feels like you’re trying to invent problems.

Swipe left for the next trending thread