Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Am I being unreasonable for not making more effort with my pregnant sister-in-law?

85 replies

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:00

I'm trying to work out whether I'm being unreasonable or whether I'm right to feel the way I do. I'd appreciate some outside perspective because I feel like there's an expectation on me to make more effort with my sister-in-law, despite the history between us.

For context, she's my husband's younger brother's wife. They live about an hour away from us. I married my husband in 2023, and she married his brother two years earlier. Our relationship has always been a bit up and down. We had a major falling-out several years ago, and although things have been civil at times since, we've never been particularly close.

She's someone who can be perfectly pleasant on occasion, but she can also be quite dismissive and, at times, rude. When we're in the same room, she'll often make very little effort to have a conversation and seems to expect everyone else to carry it. We don't impose ourselves on her or expect her to go out of her way for us.

There have been a few incidents over the years that have stuck with me. Two recent ones. When I was around 33 weeks pregnant, her husband was staying at our house following an argument between them. Another sister of my husbands was also staying with us at the time. Rather than messaging me or my husband to say she was coming over, she contacted this relative to say she was coming over, despite the fact that we own the house. Why are you telling guests (yes, I know she's related to them to) that you're planning a surprise visit before telling us?

At around 35 weeks pregnant, one week shy of term my husband and I visited their house. She and her sister barely made any effort to speak to me throughout the visit. I was heavily pregnant and felt quite uncomfortable and ignored. She did send an apology afterwards, but by then the damage had already been done and it felt hollow.

Another thing I've noticed is that my own siblings have always been perfectly welcoming towards her. Whenever they've visited, they've made conversation, included her and treated her nicely, regardless of any issues I've personally had with her. I've never expected them to treat her differently because of my relationship with her.

After having my daughter, I initially did try to maintain contact and tried to remember that there were times that she did make effort. I even kept her updated when I was in hospital with an infection. However, over time, I stopped initiating conversations because I felt there was very little interest in how I was doing or how I was coping as a new mum and in that moment of postpartum sensitivity I remember her rudeness and the things she;s done over the years.. She rarely checks in, and get the impression that she only messages because my mother-in-law has prompted her. I've overheard my MIL encouraging her to contact me, and then, almost immediately afterwards, I'll receive a message.
I always respond when she contacts me, and I've thanked her for invitations to her house. I haven't ignored her or deliberately made her feel unwelcome. I've just stopped being the one to initiate everything.

Shortly after I had my daughter, my sister-in-law found out she was pregnant too. It was unexpected, and her relationship with her husband has historically been quite turbulent, with frequent arguments and difficulties. My husband hopes that having a baby might help them settle down and bring them closer together.

Since becoming pregnant, she's randomly messaged me asking about nappies and has also asked whether she can visit. I did find this a little surprising because they haven't historically made much effort to visit us and she's hardly ever asked about my daughter. I also wondered whether the renewed interest was genuine or whether she simply sees an opportunity for us to bond now that we're both having daughters around a similar age.

I appreciate that I might be reading too much into this. Perhaps pregnancy has made her think differently about family relationships, and perhaps she genuinely does want to reconnect. I don't want to assume the worst. But I also don't think having children of the same gender and similar ages automatically creates a close relationship or means the past should be forgotten.

The other issue is my mother-in-law. She insists that I should make more effort with my younger brother-in-law and his wife because I'm married to the eldest son. I feel as though there's an unspoken expectation that I'm responsible for maintaining family relationships and keeping everyone connected, particularly because my husband and his younger sister, who lives with us, aren't particularly talkative with his brother.

For context, my husband and I own our home, and we also have my mother-in-law, father-in-law and my husband's younger sister living with us. I contribute half the household bills, and we allow my husband's siblings to come and go as they please. I've never made them feel unwelcome or as though they're imposing on us. I feel I already contribute a lot to the family, both practically and financially, and I don't understand why I'm also expected to take responsibility for relationships that aren't mine alone to maintain.

My MIL has also suggested that my husband and I having a baby, after being married for two years, might have prompted my brother-in-law and sister-in-law to reflect on their own lives and start moving forward with their relationship. If that's true, then I'm genuinely happy if we've had a positive influence on them. However, I sometimes feel that this creates yet another expectation for me to include them, build a bond and help everyone move forward together.
I don't think that's my responsibility. Whatever changes they make in their marriage or family life need to come from them.

My husband is aware of the issues and agrees that his brother's wife can be rude and never made much effort with the family and he's seen this for almost 6 years, so it predates me. He's witnessed some of the behaviour himself and understands why I've become reluctant to initiate contact. He also thinks some of her rudeness during my pregnancy was down to jealousy that we'd been married for half the time they have and already starting a family.

I should also mention that my husband has helped his brother financially over the years, and I've noticed little comments from my sister-in-law towards him that I find quite unpleasant. I sometimes wonder whether there's an element of jealousy, as my husband has historically been more financially comfortable than his brother.

To be clear, I have absolutely nothing against her being pregnant. I genuinely wish her well, and I don't want to make what could already be an emotional time any harder for her. If she visits my house, I'm polite, welcoming etc.

I just don't feel I should suddenly have to pursue a close relationship because she's pregnant. I went through pregnancy, childbirth and the early stages of motherhood without feeling much consideration or support from her, so I don't see why I'm now expected to put in extra effort simply because her circumstances have changed.

My husband and I are also hoping to start trying for another baby in the new year. We're both excited about expanding our family and would love for our daughter to have siblings. I genuinely enjoyed pregnancy and am looking forward to that next chapter. I want to focus on my own family and the life we're building rather than feeling as though I constantly need to build bridges and buddy with my husbands brother's wife who hasn't historically shown much interest in doing the same. She might want to do that now but it's too late.
I don't want a falling-out, arguments at family gatherings. I'm happy for our children to know each other, spend time together and as cousins. I just want to maintain a polite, respectful relationship without feeling obliged to initiate conversations, constantly check in or manufacture a closeness that isn't naturally there.

So, am I being unreasonable for not making more effort now that she's pregnant?

OP posts:
JillsGills · 07/11/2026 10:47

Is this a very long winded way of saying should you let her come for a cuppa to chat about nappies?
I mean the relationship doesn’t seem that bad that this wouldn’t be tolerable - I’d accept the olive branch personally and see what happens.

Lkt32 · 07/11/2026 10:52

I admit I didn't read all of it but the examples you gave, of her coming over without telling you when her husband was staying there, of her and her sister not making much effort... sound... fine. I don't know. Not really anything. Other people live in your house and it is their home. Her husband was staying there.

I do find the pressure from others to be friends a bit unnecessary and would annoy me. You're an adult, you get to choose who you're friends with. But with her making more of an effort, it seems like it would just be kind to be a bit more receptive and friendly.

EdFupp · 07/11/2026 10:57

That’s a very long post. It sounds like maybe she just never felt she had much in common with you, but now that you’re both going to have young children you will have something in common. You don’t have to be besties, but it might be nice to have another mum to chat to, give and get advice etc.

CherryKerry · 07/11/2026 11:02

Why are you giving her headspace? Just ignore her, you don't need a relationship with her.

Smile politely at family gatherings but don't make any effort the rest of the time.

humanbehaviour2000 · 07/11/2026 11:39

these comments are hilarious. like a lot of these people would be happy with random relatives who have a habit of being rude just showing up unannounced at their in laws house especially during a sensitive exhausting time like pregnancy. she's a sister in law/daughter in law to those who live there. would we not expect people to demonstrate courtesy. why is it okay for OP to put up with it in the midst of a pregnancy?

As for your post OP which was so unnecessary long but I find it ridiculous that there's this expectation for women to have to make friends with their husbands siblings' wives just because both are woman and both have children. everyone has sex and gets pregnant. it's not particularly novel scenario. you don't have to be friends or make effort with anyone especially not with someone who you feel has been rude to you in the past. I don't message my SILs - if they come over with their kids I'm nice and cordial but I don't go out of my way to do anything. Life is so short, spend time and deploy effort where it's needed, ie children, husband. which i think is what you were asking. I think we ought to normalise not expecting the husband's wives to carry the burden of maintaining relationships.

humanbehaviour2000 · 07/11/2026 11:45

Tiredhappymum · 07/11/2026 10:19

This. I think some of your issues are coming from living with your in laws. Can you change this?

two things to add - I had a complicated relationship with my SIL until we had children at the same time and we are now very close. Both matured and our relationship is totally different now.

I’m from a SA background too and growing up my grandma lived with my uncle and his family. The entire family turned up at their house all the time, in fact it was a central meeting point. We are all very close as a result. It must have been tough on my aunt and my mum tried to help her out as much as possible, so I do see your point but we loved her and will always be grateful to her for enabling our relationships. Different times, but just another take on it. You’re not obliged to take this role.

I'm from south asian/mixed background but we're very very modern and actually what I see amongst my female cousins who are south asian is that no one really wants to take on this role/ this mantle anymore. your mum sounds lovely and loving towards your aunty but a lot of women who put up with this stuff deal with huge amounts of disrespect and the expectation is on them just to be a doormat and tolerate loads of stuff that wouldn't be the case is roles were reversed.

JLou08 · 07/11/2026 12:24

That was a lot of text about not much at all.
Your examples are pretty weak, I don't understand your issue with her.
You can make as much or as little effort as you like. You're not obliged to do anything, although it may be nice for your DC to have an opportunity to build bonds with their cousins.
It really wasn't worth a post. I sometimes wonder if people actively look for issues with their ILs to join in with the cliche of them being difficult.

Elsieandme · 07/11/2026 12:39

I’ll make this short . She’s toxic , she’s not your person. Unfortunately you cannot stop her coming to your home but hello and can I get you a drink is sufficient. Do not let others make you feel guilty about others behaviours,

WhatNoRaisins · 07/11/2026 12:45

It sounds like MIL really wants you all to be one big happy family and it's being a bit pushy about it. I do think with having a lot of different adults living together you're potentially dealing with the different ideas of what's normal for guests. Does this arrangement need a re-think?

momtoboys · 07/11/2026 12:45

I don’t really understand how everyone’s pregnancies are so important to the story. Your SIL and you don’t like each other very much. Your relationship is inconsistent (as is her relationship with her DH, apparently). Being pregnant seems to have nothing to do with the story.

LemonPuppyPorkChop · 07/11/2026 12:52

momtoboys · 07/11/2026 12:45

I don’t really understand how everyone’s pregnancies are so important to the story. Your SIL and you don’t like each other very much. Your relationship is inconsistent (as is her relationship with her DH, apparently). Being pregnant seems to have nothing to do with the story.

This.

Anyway, South Asian or not, your problems seem to mostly stem from being thoroughly enmeshed with your ILs, in part because you live with some of them. None of this would be an issue if you, your DH and your children had your own place.

Sweetandsours · 07/11/2026 13:05

Well clearly opening your home to your in laws was a mad wild idea and now the whole family treat the house as your inlaws.
Why you would agree to this is madness and has landed you in this situation.

Your MIL telling you what to do is wild too.
What were you thinking agreeing to all of this?
Time your in laws moved out.
Do not make any effort with your SIL, keep your distance.

Granville82 · 07/11/2026 13:14

It's better to feel guilt than resentment. Just don't do what you don't want to do. MIL is seriously out of line for lecturing you whilst living your house! Tell her to F off!

Itsthewoluff · 07/11/2026 13:14

It all does all seem a bit too intertwined. I get on well with both my sister in laws but we don’t message or do things outside the wider family gatherings.
If there isn’t a genuine connection, don’t force it. Just be polite but don’t get drawn into one to one get togethers. But I can see you are under pressure from other people so you either kindly tell them to butt out or you need to resign yourself to doing as you are told to a certain extent.
Maybe read up on how to assert some boundaries?

Mischance · 07/11/2026 13:14

We can't get on with all the relatives who come our way by marriage - I just let it all wash by me with mine - don't see them that often and, unless they actively tell me to F off, I just go with the flow. Live and let live .......

humanbehaviour2000 · 07/11/2026 13:19

WhatNoRaisins · 07/11/2026 12:45

It sounds like MIL really wants you all to be one big happy family and it's being a bit pushy about it. I do think with having a lot of different adults living together you're potentially dealing with the different ideas of what's normal for guests. Does this arrangement need a re-think?

What I'd say to anyone in this situation is that if you have valid reasons for not wanting a close relationship with your in-laws, that's perfectly fine, and you shouldn't feel pressured into one. In-laws can be incredibly toxic, and in South Asian family dynamics, there is often an expectation that daughters-in-law should tolerate behaviours and treatment that wouldn't be considered acceptable in almost any other relationship in any other cultural context. We need to normalise the idea that the responsibility for managing family relationships, setting boundaries and addressing difficult behaviour should fall, first and foremost, on the person whose family it is. It's not unreasonable to expect husbands to take responsibility for their own families rather than leaving their wives to navigate and absorb the consequences. Unfortunately, living with several members of your husband's family creates a significant barrier to achieving this, particularly when there is an expectation that you should simply learn to accommodate everyone.

If OP's husband's brother's wife has a history of being rude and inconsistent – friendly and pally on some occasions, then cold and dismissive on others – then, as far as I'm concerned, that's not okay. I would absolutely keep someone like that at arm's length whilst being friendly when your forced to interact. But why isn't the husband addressing this behaviour with his own brother?

Women like OP are expected to work, contribute equally to household bills, help provide for several dependants in this particular scenario and, on top of all that, navigate difficult relationships with members of their husband's family and manage their various attitude problems. This may be too Gen Z of me, but I genuinely could never. Take those expectations and tell them to shove it.

And as for those suggesting that what OP has described doesn't sound like much, if I were heavily pregnant and invited to a family member's home, only to be met with rudeness from the host, the likelihood of me accepting another invitation would be very slim. Pregnancy is demanding enough without feeling obliged to tolerate unnecessary unpleasantness from other people.

readingmakesmehappy · 07/11/2026 13:21

Let your DH keep up the relationship with his brother. You don’t need to maintain a relationship with SIL except perhaps to arrange for your children to play with their cousins.
Not everyone likes everyone. You can’t get on with everyone. Part of growing up is learning when to let that go.

humanbehaviour2000 · 07/11/2026 13:22

Sweetandsours · 07/11/2026 13:05

Well clearly opening your home to your in laws was a mad wild idea and now the whole family treat the house as your inlaws.
Why you would agree to this is madness and has landed you in this situation.

Your MIL telling you what to do is wild too.
What were you thinking agreeing to all of this?
Time your in laws moved out.
Do not make any effort with your SIL, keep your distance.

It's a common thing in south asian cultures and sadly isn't dying. the woman sometimes has to live with her husbands parents. insane stuff. and what if an elderly couple only have daughters but none of them can live nearby cause they have to live with their husbands family. unfortunately I've seen such examples.

JayJayj · 07/11/2026 13:23

I don’t even out that much effort with my husband’s sister. We’ve had the odd disagreement about things, but it’s mainly that we are very different people. And if I wasn’t married to her brother, we would never ever be friends.

I think it would nice to try and forgive and try and move on. It definitely could be that her pregnancy has put things into perspective. It’s whether it sticks or she goes back to her normal self. I don’t think I’d go out of my way, off my own back though. You do enough having the in-laws live there and still paying 50%.

Territories · 07/11/2026 13:35

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:19

We're south asian

Honestly I found your OP quite bizarre and weird, but the cultural angle makes it make a bit more sense. I couldn’t live like this though, there’s so much oddness.

personally I don’t really see what your SIL has done wrong? I think both of you have south asian cultural issues with pregnancy, it seems like both of you just want to irritate each other when you’re respectively pregnant like some power play? I can’t make sense of why you feel hard done by her, it just seems like you want to get your own back on her now that she’s pregnant after she didn’t fawn over pregnant you.

there’s so many unsaid expectations and pressure here, surely you can see it’s an unhealthy dynamic

OpheliaNightingale · 07/11/2026 14:34

I notice that there seems to be more sister-in- law drama in Asian families. Are there cultural issues at play here? I’m white British and although in laws may not get along, we tend to just let sleeping dogs lie. Maybe the issue in your culture is the expectation that you should have a close relationship with people who you wouldn’t usually give the time of day to. Just because the brother of the man you married chose her. Or didn’t as the case may be.

humanbehaviour2000 · 07/11/2026 14:42

Territories · 07/11/2026 13:35

Honestly I found your OP quite bizarre and weird, but the cultural angle makes it make a bit more sense. I couldn’t live like this though, there’s so much oddness.

personally I don’t really see what your SIL has done wrong? I think both of you have south asian cultural issues with pregnancy, it seems like both of you just want to irritate each other when you’re respectively pregnant like some power play? I can’t make sense of why you feel hard done by her, it just seems like you want to get your own back on her now that she’s pregnant after she didn’t fawn over pregnant you.

there’s so many unsaid expectations and pressure here, surely you can see it’s an unhealthy dynamic

The OP did mention that she and her SIL had fallen out previously, which I think is relevant.

I'm half Asian, and whilst the cultural situation might seem unusual, it's actually fairly common. This is also one of the more innocuous examples I've seen.

I suspect a lot of the OP's resentment stems from having her in-laws in her space while also footing half the bill. We're in a cost-of-living crisis. Would I be thrilled about paying towards accommodation for my partner's family? Probably not. Would I enjoy someone I don't particularly like inviting themselves along to stay in my home? Also, no. I live in a home with my husband. If my husband's sister wants to come over she lets us know beforehand.

People keep saying it's her husband's parents and sister's house too and therefore his brother's house, but that's precisely the faultline. It's treated as their shared home, yet the OP clearly doesn't like this. There's an imbalance in who gets a say and who is expected to accommodate others.

Ultimately, I also think the husband and his parents are also responsible for allowing this awkward dynamic to develop. Why don't they get their own space?

OP: Just get your in laws out and put an end to this nonsense. Right now you can't set boundaries.

humanbehaviour2000 · 07/11/2026 14:43

OpheliaNightingale · 07/11/2026 14:34

I notice that there seems to be more sister-in- law drama in Asian families. Are there cultural issues at play here? I’m white British and although in laws may not get along, we tend to just let sleeping dogs lie. Maybe the issue in your culture is the expectation that you should have a close relationship with people who you wouldn’t usually give the time of day to. Just because the brother of the man you married chose her. Or didn’t as the case may be.

yes, I am half pakistani and this is 100% the case. my white british side of the family have less drama

RisingSunn · 07/11/2026 15:12

ursulareadingbooks · 07/11/2026 08:18

As I mentioned in the post.

My husbands parents live with us. so does his sister. his brother and wife historically have come and gone as they please and never even tell us they're coming over.

They don't have to because its also their parents and sister's home. Unless I'm missing something.

LaurelCanyo · 07/11/2026 15:51

Hang on @ursulareadingbooksyou say you are ultimately responsible for clearing up after these uninvited guests as well as feeding them and sorting out staying overnight. No!! You are the LAST person responsible for DH’s family members. First it’s DH’s responsibility to host. If he doesn’t step up (and if not, why not?) then it’s down to all the ILs to look after their own family members. You are working, pregnant, don’t want them here etc so you are the LAST person to have this burden put on you. Speak up! Go and lie down! Leave them to it!

Swipe left for the next trending thread