Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christmas plans with ex now new partners are in the mix

25 replies

TheBlueZebra · 07/11/2026 07:11

Bit worried about being flamed but interested to hear thoughts.

Background: Divorced 5 years, two tween DDS. We have always done Christmas together. Christmas Eve with his Mum (and we alternate between us who hosts, it’s his turn this year). Christmas Day with my parents. Includes nights.

it’s not perfect and sometimes we irritate each other buts it’s generally okay, kids super happy and both of us very happy we don’t need to miss anything. I really get on well with his Mum and ditto my parents with him. We do other events together like Sports Day and birthdays. Like I say, sometimes we are pretty irritated with each other - I sometimes find him entitled and he says I’m aggressive. Nothings perfect - we muddle through and there’s very little drama.

This year It is his turn to host and we both have partners. His girlfriend does not have kids this year and he suggested he leaves Christmas Day at 3pm to go and be with her. I was absolutely fine with this, if anything it’s nice for me to concentrate on my parents as my Dad is dying of cancer.

I thought about it & thought how nice it would be if I saw my partner Christmas Eve in a similar way. Full disclosure, there is also a big financial disparity with my Ex & I have kids more of the time. We both work full time but his career prioritised etc etc so he has lots of abroad holidays and his massive house has been extended to include a gigantic riverside kitchen. I have a galley kitchen. Honestly - , I wouldn’t swap that time with the kids for his money and I do okay. But sometimes it grates.

Anyway to get to the point. He said if I didn’t want to be there Christmas Eve he would invite his girlfriend who would stay over and be there Christmas morning. I said great for Christmas Eve but I wasn’t ready to share Christmas morning yet in this way (I haven’t met her) and he said I couldn’t tell him what to do.

Arguably he’s correct I can’t, but this is a big change and I thought, I don’t know, maybe he’d be sensitive since we usually do it altogether . I wouldn’t make him spend Christmas morning with my boyfriend.

So now I have this mental picture of rocking up on Christmas morning to his massive house with Christmas in full swing and a woman I haven’t met opening presents with my kids in her nightie. I feel like such an outsider.

I know Christmas is complicated and I don’t know if I should just suck it up this year.

tell me your thoughts!

OP posts:
PaisleyElephant · 07/11/2026 07:14

Maybe it's time to do separate Christmases and that's ok. Things evolve, the kids are older now. They might even be pleased.to do Christmas twice.

romdowa · 07/11/2026 07:14

These kind of arrangements only work until they dont. Its starting to get messy now so id start doing separate Christmases , at tween age you arent missing much and theyll understand why the change is happening

Givemeausernamepls · 07/11/2026 07:15

Maybe it’s time to change up how you do Christmas? I’ve been separated over 10 years 15 and 12 year old DC. I’ve always alternated Xmas day with their dad and still don’t feel like I’ve missed out cos we just celebrate Boxing Day. We both do Xmas very differently and my ex is very grinchy/ selfish at Xmas and it was a massive bonus being away from that so we’ve never shared Xmas day Tbf. Do sports day etc but stopped birthdays after his new girlfriend

TheBlueZebra · 07/11/2026 07:15

I did wonder this. I’m not feeling very welcome for Christmas Eve at all tbh.

I think the kids will be very disappointed- they are very used to this.

OP posts:
Moonnstarz · 07/11/2026 07:15

Sorry but you have gone on for too long doing joint Christmas events. A lot of the who has more money Vs who has the children the most is just a distraction here.
The kids aren't young, they know you aren't together and they must know of the new partners. Make new arrangements now for how you split the days.

TraitorOrFaithful · 07/11/2026 07:16

I wouldn't want to spend Christmas morning with my ex and his new girlfriend. I agree with pp that it may be time for separate Christmases (taking turns). But kudos to you and your ex for making it work for so long!

WeirdlyNorm · 07/11/2026 07:17

It's lovely it has worked before, but I agree with PP it's time to move forward and start splitting the time properly rather than having joint time - the kids will be fine!

OtterlyMad · 07/11/2026 07:17

It sounds like your existing arrangement may have run its course, and it is time to come up with a new arrangement that is more suitable now you both have partners in your life. One parent gets Christmas Eve and Christmas Day morning, and the other gets Christmas Day afternoon and Boxing Day? Then alternate each year.

TheBlueZebra · 07/11/2026 07:18

Thank you - yes, this is making me think.

i know the money this is a distraction, I shared it because it makes me feel even more of an outsider. This lifestyle that is so different to the one I have with this kids.

OP posts:
TraitorOrFaithful · 07/11/2026 07:19

The kids may be a bit disappointed, but this has to happen sometime. It sounds like this is the year.

wordsfromthebathroom · 07/11/2026 07:23

Maybe ask to meet the girlfriend sometime soon for a coffee, the three adults. That should give you a sense of if you can be comfortable with an hour or two together Xmas morning

Arbourimage · 07/11/2026 07:23

With the kids being slightly older and out of the Santa stage there’s really no need for you both to be in the same place on Christmas morning. It’s getting to the point where it’s getting messy and complicated.
He’s not being unreasonable to have his gf stay over at his home on Christmas Eve, several years post split. Equally you aren’t wrong to feel like an outsider in the house, the reality is you would be.

Sartre · 07/11/2026 07:24

The kids are getting older and you two don’t really get along, as much as you try to claim you do in the OP, the irritation and aggression suggests otherwise. I would not want to spend Christmas Day with my ex and his girlfriend, I don’t know many who would. I think it’s time to separate Christmas. One of you gets Xmas Eve, one gets Xmas day or you alternate years.

Moonnstarz · 07/11/2026 07:25

TheBlueZebra · 07/11/2026 07:18

Thank you - yes, this is making me think.

i know the money this is a distraction, I shared it because it makes me feel even more of an outsider. This lifestyle that is so different to the one I have with this kids.

Is that why you like doing it together? Surely when younger the kids wouldn't notice these things as it's more about the magic of Christmas, not who has the fancier house.
Be more confident in what you do! Talk to the kids about how this year will be different. Ask them what they would like Christmas to be like - maybe go pizza instead of traditional dinner if that's what they fancy. Start making your own traditions rather than relying on your ex.

cooldarkroom · 07/11/2026 07:26

He does one day with gf
You do the other with bf
Done

TheBlueZebra · 07/11/2026 07:30

You’ve all given me a lot to think about. My conclusion is even if we do some version of Christmas together this year, it’s the last. It will likely all be different next year with my Dad gone anyway.

The poster who said the reality is that I would be an outsider, but that equally he’s not wrong to have his girlfriend to stay is spot on.

I much prefer the years when I host Christmas Eve as I can really get into it. I guess he must feel the same.

OP posts:
TheBlueZebra · 07/11/2026 07:31

And also yes, @Sartre i think you’re right… I’m saying we get along but it’s not feeling like that anymore.

OP posts:
Coconutter24 · 07/11/2026 07:36

He’s telling you in a roundabout way he doesn’t want you there, he wants his gf there. Which is understandable as it’s her he’s with. If your two children are tween age they are old enough to understand you’re not together anymore and things like this will be done separately.

Autumnalhibernationisthedream · 07/11/2026 08:46

Ah op I feel for ye all. My friend has the ‘best’ divorce ever (her words), but talks about Christmas being the one thing that makes it all fall apart

OneCheekySwan · 07/11/2026 12:14

I would take the opportunity to reshape your Christmas now. My kids have had 2 Christmases since their Dad and I split when they were 11 and 9 and like the double whammy. Even better now that they get Christmas Eve and morning just with me and my husband before his kids come home and we have big blended Christmas.

just because it worked before, doesn’t mean a change will be any less special. Or anyone will like it less. Don’t wait until next year. Think about what is most important to you and then roll with that. Christmas morning with your parents and then kids back for Christmas lunch and hearing all their stories of Dads house. Sometimes hearing about it second hand is just as good, as you miss the bits where your ex annoyed you or you felt uncomfortable.

Whatthefork1 · 07/11/2026 12:19

First of all I wanted to say how great I think it is that you’ve always had this arrangement for Christmas and you are great parents for keeping it special and putting your differences aside for the kids.
However it does now sound as though things have changed, both having new partners, your children are tweens, so not like they are super young still. You definitely need to start having separate Christmases- I don’t think many people, yourself and your ex and also your new partners would feel comfortable all being together for the sake of your children and that isn’t a dig, but if they have their own children as well, then just how exactly is it all going to work??

I know a few couple do a spilt Xmas. So one partner has the children Christmas Eve til mid morning Christmas Day and then the other parent takes over and has them mid morning to Boxing Day.

Seahorsesplendour · 07/11/2026 12:23

This was many years ago when I was younger but my parents did the same for years after they split, the first couple it was fine but by the end it was just awkward tbh and all 3 of us (by then teens) were just grateful when it changed!!!) worth chatting to your kids I reckon & letting them know times change. They know you’re not together & they survived that big change! They’ll be ok ❤️ you can make new traditions which will feel special over time

EmmaB1309 · 07/11/2026 12:37

Yes, you have made fantastic efforts to have joint time all these years and that’s commendable, but it’s time to make separate arrangements. Your kids are old enough to understand that families change and evolve and you can sell it to them by being very positive and how they get two lots of celebrations etc…..

Whatthefeckk · 07/11/2026 12:54

Hats off for doing joint Xmas all this time.
But it seems the time has come to split things.

Couldn't one of you have kids Xmas Eve and have the excitement of Xmas morning ..then the other parent collects kids early afternoon and has kids for dinner, overnight xmas night and into boxing day?

Where does your new partner come into the arrangement?

Yes it is hard knowing a stranger is going to be around your kids on sentimental occasions, but you're not together so it was going to happen at some point.

TheBlueZebra · 07/11/2026 13:39

Thank you for all these suggestion!

My new partner will spend Christmas Day with his kids and ex wife and some family from both sides. I would say they are properly amicable and kids much older.

i will see him Christmas Eve, which is great.

Im tempted to suggest to ExDH that we split it this year however he has now said that while he’ll invite his girlfriend Christmas Eve, she will leave quite early Christmas morning so not part of the family stuff. After stockings we’ll head to my parents and I will breathe a sigh of relief.

We’re also talking about doing it very differently next year.

So I think this might be as good as we can get it. I’m still pondering all your suggestions of how to split it - thank you all so much.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page