Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask for help understanding a Companies House financial statement

26 replies

PTSDpanic · 06/11/2026 16:17

Can anyone help me understand this financial statement (figures made up but they reflect the real situation)? The company appears to be in debt. Surely that means it is trading while insolvent?

Fixed Assets 2025. 2024
Tangible Assets. £2000. £2500

Current Assets
Debtors. £4000. £20k
Caah at Bank. £1000. £2000

Creditors
Amount falling due within 1 year

(£75k) (£110k)

Net Current Liabilities (£70k). (£88k)
Net Liabilities (£68k). (£88.5k)

Capital & Reserves.

Called up share capital. £100. £100
Profit & Loss Account. (£68k). (£85.5k)

Shareholders’ Deficit. (£68k). (£85.5k)

OP posts:
Coffeecakebakes · 06/11/2026 16:32

Technically yes, because the company cannot repay the £75,000 debt falling due, but that may be an amount due to a shareholder who has stated that they will continue to support the business, it may be a debt that will be rolled over ie the term extended. Is there no more detail in the notes to the accounts?

Clairey1986 · 06/11/2026 16:35

As above they have net liabilities but the directors need to assess if they have to pay the liabilities before they make more money and have obviously concluded they don’t. Were the financial statements audited? If yes the auditor had tested how reasonable that going concern assumption is too.

ColdAsAWitches · 06/11/2026 16:39

Just because they owe money doesn't mean they can't trade. They can continue to trade and pay down the debt over time. As you can see that they have been doing. Net liabilities are going down over time.

LiveLaughGoblin · 06/11/2026 17:05

Clairey1986 · 06/11/2026 16:35

As above they have net liabilities but the directors need to assess if they have to pay the liabilities before they make more money and have obviously concluded they don’t. Were the financial statements audited? If yes the auditor had tested how reasonable that going concern assumption is too.

This company is almost certainly too small to require an audit. The amount of current liabilities vs current assets looks less than ideal, but the business may have the option of a loan or further capital.

PTSDpanic · 06/11/2026 17:28

Thanks, everyone!

The accounts are unaudited. Nothing relevant in the notes.

The company has been going for 20 years. It’s one person providing a service although there have been other directors over the years. It seems to always be in debt with the amount increasing over the years until recently.

OP posts:
Tortephant · 06/11/2026 17:35

Amazon and Ocado for example were both in huge debt for years, actually part of a growth plan.

For effectively a sole trader then yes, there is reason for concern would, but this snapshot is out of context and no other years to compare against.

Too much missing information OP to answer in the way I suspect you are looking for.

Dreadingtheday · 06/11/2026 17:37

I’m glad you asked the question

I have seen some that it just says the number of shares and then we have no idea what they’re worth

That hundred pounds of shares what does it actually mean?

The costs are going to include salaries. I’m taking a stab here but I imagine a lot of hospitality accounts will look like that and then Christmas would be a bumper month

IsItSnowing · 06/11/2026 17:41

I assume it's a small company in which case it is probably shareholder capital. I.e. whoever owns the business has put their own money into the business in order to allow it to trade. That's not unusual. Probably bought equipment or whatever to start the business up.
It means that can be repaid in the future if the business becomes profitable without attracting tax as it's not earned money but money lent by the shareholder.

PTSDpanic · 06/11/2026 18:09

Thanks.

it’s one person working from home providing a professional service, although I believe they rented an office in the past. No stock, no equipment required other than a laptop and phone. No employees but there have been various different directors over the years.Since incorporation, the company made £50 profit in year 1, then made a loss in year 2 of £25k. The loss/debt increases every year until it reaches £200k, then drops to £40k,steadily rising back to £88.5k then £68k.

OP posts:
PTSDpanic · 06/11/2026 18:16

IsItSnowing · 06/11/2026 17:41

I assume it's a small company in which case it is probably shareholder capital. I.e. whoever owns the business has put their own money into the business in order to allow it to trade. That's not unusual. Probably bought equipment or whatever to start the business up.
It means that can be repaid in the future if the business becomes profitable without attracting tax as it's not earned money but money lent by the shareholder.

That was my interpretation but it makes no sense as to why they would do that. Or need to do that.

There are no assets, no stock, nothing to invest in, no employees, no product. It’s one person doing paperwork.

OP posts:
IsItSnowing · 06/11/2026 18:20

PTSDpanic · 06/11/2026 18:16

That was my interpretation but it makes no sense as to why they would do that. Or need to do that.

There are no assets, no stock, nothing to invest in, no employees, no product. It’s one person doing paperwork.

Yes, that does seem odd.

JKFan · 06/11/2026 18:26

Don’t forget that, as well as not being audited, those accounts are just a snapshot as at the financial year end. The latest they can refer to, going by the dates in your example, is 31st December 2025. They don’t provide much contemporary useful information to you.

Xanthippe1 · 06/11/2026 18:30

A company having negative net assets doesn't automatically mean it's trading while insolvent.
There are two important questions:

  1. Can the company pay its debts as they fall due?
  2. Do its liabilities exceed its assets, taking into account relevant circumstances?
The accounts suggest that liabilities exceed assets, but they don't tell us enough about cash flow, financing arrangements or the company's ability to meet its obligations.

Interestingly, the net current liabilities have improved from £88k to £70k, although that doesn't necessarily mean the company is financially healthy.

I'd be interested in whether the creditors include directors' loans, and whether those loans are repayable on demand.

So I'd be cautious about concluding that the company is trading unlawfully just from these figures.

Xanthippe1 · 06/11/2026 18:34

One further point worth considering:
accumulated losses and outstanding debts aren't necessarily the same thing.

You mention the company's losses reaching £200k before falling to £40k. That doesn't necessarily mean somebody lent it £200k and subsequently received £160k back.

The profit and loss reserve reflects accumulated accounting results, whereas the creditors figure represents liabilities owed.

Given that this is a one-person service business operating for 20 years, I'd be particularly interested in who the £75k creditors actually are.

Are they
directors,
HMRC,
external lenders
or suppliers?

That seems more useful to establish than assuming the negative shareholders' funds mean the company must be trading unlawfully.

AirborneElephant · 06/11/2026 18:35

PTSDpanic · 06/11/2026 18:16

That was my interpretation but it makes no sense as to why they would do that. Or need to do that.

There are no assets, no stock, nothing to invest in, no employees, no product. It’s one person doing paperwork.

The person is taking a salary, which is greater than the profits of the company. So they aren’t actually receiving the cash, they’re putting it straight back in as a shareholder loan. That might be for tax reasons to use up the personal allowance, or in order to put money into a pension. Nothing illegal or particularly uncommon about it, they’re not “trading while insolvent” unless the debt has repayment terms that can’t realistically be met.

AirborneElephant · 06/11/2026 18:38

If you could tell us why you care we might be able to provide more helpful advice. Does the company owe you money? Have you contracted with them and worry about their stability? Or is this an ex and you want to know how much the company is worth?

ScaryM0nster · 06/11/2026 18:40

Insolvent is different to in debt.

Otherwise everyone with a mortgage woukd be insolvent.

Coffeecakebakes · 06/11/2026 18:48

ScaryM0nster · 06/11/2026 18:40

Insolvent is different to in debt.

Otherwise everyone with a mortgage woukd be insolvent.

This is a company, not an individual.
A property is an asset.

GentleOrca · 06/11/2026 19:11

They have few assets, which is not unusual in itself, so why do they have so much in current liabilities? If it's a bank loan/overdraft, it could be used to finance their day to day operations, eg, paying suppliers, etc. Could be a director's loan, loan from a family member, etc. Could be money owed to HMRC.
It might help if we know what type of business activity they are engaging in. Eg, if they are operating an agency model, those current liabilities could represent money collected on behalf of third parties that hasn't yet been passed on.

PTSDpanic · 06/11/2026 19:45

AirborneElephant · 06/11/2026 18:38

If you could tell us why you care we might be able to provide more helpful advice. Does the company owe you money? Have you contracted with them and worry about their stability? Or is this an ex and you want to know how much the company is worth?

I am concerned about an elderly relative using the company and potentially losing a very large amount of money.

I have had similar thoughts to those that have been suggested but I’m not sure that they quite fit. Possibly something similar to the agency scenario suggested.

OP posts:
LiveLaughGoblin · 06/11/2026 20:27

GentleOrca · 06/11/2026 19:11

They have few assets, which is not unusual in itself, so why do they have so much in current liabilities? If it's a bank loan/overdraft, it could be used to finance their day to day operations, eg, paying suppliers, etc. Could be a director's loan, loan from a family member, etc. Could be money owed to HMRC.
It might help if we know what type of business activity they are engaging in. Eg, if they are operating an agency model, those current liabilities could represent money collected on behalf of third parties that hasn't yet been passed on.

An agency model would show the equivalent cash in the accounts as well as the liability, if that were the case. This company appears to have been making a loss for many years. Be aware that the owner could liquidate the company at any time and most creditors would lose their money. Personally i would be very cautious (former big 4 auditor).

PTSDpanic · 06/11/2026 21:25

LiveLaughGoblin · 06/11/2026 20:27

An agency model would show the equivalent cash in the accounts as well as the liability, if that were the case. This company appears to have been making a loss for many years. Be aware that the owner could liquidate the company at any time and most creditors would lose their money. Personally i would be very cautious (former big 4 auditor).

Those were my thoughts and concerns, @LiveLaughGoblin. It is a similar scenario to an agency collecting payment to pay another party but why isn’t there an equivalent credit to the debt? 🫤 Yet the accounts show the same year after year so why are they still trading if there isn’t a rational explanation for the weird accounts?

OP posts:
Dreadingtheday · 06/11/2026 21:57

Is it possible that this is a personal project?

I figured out the one I was looking at and it’s more than £1 million they’re put into it themselves

LiveLaughGoblin · 07/11/2026 06:49

Probably. The shareholder’s deficit shows the amount that the company owes back to the shareholder - caused by the accumulated losses over time. This may be wrongful trading under law if the company is not a going concern, but someone dealing with them could still lose money and not get it back.

Erin1975 · 07/11/2026 07:21

PTSDpanic · 06/11/2026 19:45

I am concerned about an elderly relative using the company and potentially losing a very large amount of money.

I have had similar thoughts to those that have been suggested but I’m not sure that they quite fit. Possibly something similar to the agency scenario suggested.

You cannot tell a great deal about the business from the snapshot small companies publish. The business is technically insolvent but that is very different from actual insolvency.

The company is profitable. The PnL deficit shrunk from -£85.5k to -£68k. This means the company generated a profit of £17,500 during 2025.

The key to the health of the business is who the debtors are. If it is suppliers or HMRC then it is in big trouble. But from the description you gave of the type of business, most likely the debt is directors loans in which case it is highly unlikely to have to repay them anytime soon.

The fact the accounts are unaudited is irrelevant. Until a business turns over £15 million it is exempt from statutory auditing.

Swipe left for the next trending thread