Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to be sick of being big sister!!

24 replies

BitterHarvest · 06/11/2026 15:45

PLEASE DO NOT PUT ON FACEBOOK.

I am the eldest of two daughters. I was always the one who had to do errands. Do chores. Be sensible. Then when dad didn’t turn up for a meeting I was sent to look for him. I found him dead. I stepped in to pay mums bills then because she wasn’t able to manage. I took her to hosp appointments because she wanted me too. Now I’m her default carer. I had to take on her dog when she was unable to mind him. I’ve just taken that dog (who has been living with us for two years) to the vet and had to let him go. He’s been put to sleep. I now have to tell my kids that.

I will likely be the one who is there when mum dies and I’ll have to organise her funeral the way I did dads.

im feeling very bitter today because my sibling who does visit mum regularly will regularly tell anyone who will listen how stressful the whole thing is and how her mental health is suffering!

now don’t get me wrong. My mental health is fine at the minute but I’m becoming increasingly resentful especially after today that I’m the one who is default for all of this stress! Sibling is single and works and has a very time consuming hobby which she is utterly dedicated too. We are 6 yrs apart in age. I’m in my 50’s. There is this expectation when mum finally goes that I will “look after” sister!!! Why? Like she’s is a neurotypical adult woman! She has more time for her friends and their kids than for us. I sound bitter? I feel bitter! AIBU? Of If I am help me out with advice! AIBU

OP posts:
seahorsessky · 06/11/2026 15:52

The eldest sibling stereotypically has more expectations on them. Not always true, and not fair. Ideally talk to her, and explain how you feel. When people say "look after her", point out what you have just said here-she is an adult too. It'll be hard now if it's always been a certain way, but speak up and challenge gently any unfairness.

BrilliantBetty · 06/11/2026 15:55

No one can force you to do anything. Take a break from being the carer and when you’re ready to go back to helping, do so at a reduced level. Your mum will have to fund carers and taxis and whatever else she needs if she needs it. I’d never expect my kids to do all this stuff for me, I wouldn’t want them to. A good parent has provision in place for their later years so it doesn’t ruin their kids lives.

BitterHarvest · 06/11/2026 16:02

I can’t not do it! She’s end stage dementia. There is no one else. If I don’t do her meds pay her bills mind everything no one else will do it. I can’t just stop. I tried asking sibling to do more but she did such a spectacularly shit job I had to tell her not to bother. It actually ended up meaning I had to spend more time fixing her mess. She’s a disaster. I’m dreading telling her about the dog because the drama that will fall out from her grief wil be award winning. I’m exhausted. Learn from this people. Learn from this! I will be making sure none
of my kids have to do this. Especially not one over the others.

OP posts:
DoYouSellBuckets · 06/11/2026 16:17

Oh, I feel your pain and frustration. I'm in the same position. Default replacement parent to my younger sisters (despite being adults with jobs, houses, kids etc) and Dad who is hopeless now Mum has gone. And yes, I was the physical and emotional crutch for Mum at the end and everyone else afterwards. I've always made sure I had enough money to 'rescue' my sisters if it came to it. They both got used to being looked after by our Mum and now I've inherited them. I'm fed up of being the grown up for everyone!

We should form a band of disgruntled big sisters and frolic care-free to somewhere sunny and behave reprehensibly. 'Sorry, you'll have to shoulder your own mental-load this week, kiddo. I'm off to the South of France to drink wine in a hot tub with strangers from Mumsnet and grumble about how having a later bedtime 30 years ago DOES NOT compensate for being expected to be the nominated adult forever'

biggreenbows · 06/11/2026 16:20

Have you looked in to getting external help with her care (if you don't already). If she doesn't have the funds to pay the council should fund it if social services say she needs it (which she will in end stage dementia) but you'd need to be very clear that you can no longer do X, Y Z so she needs funded help.

Even if you decide that you will continue helping your mum I think you need to address the fact that you think it's expected that you will look after your sister. You don't necessarily need to tell her directly but need to be prepared to have, and defend, boundaries.

I have a similar situation so know it's not easy. My mother also has dementia but until she became physically unable to do so was providing a lot of practical support for my (perfectly fit and well) sibling. Despite her increasing age and health problems sibling had not made any attempt to arrange things to be able to manage without Mum's help and it became apparent the expectation was that I would take over from Mum.

Hatty65 · 06/11/2026 16:27

I feel sorry for you, but I also think there's a whiff of burning martyr about you. You are doing things out of habit and expectation by the sound of it. But every time you do so you are making an active choice. No one is forcing you to take over 'looking after' your sister. No one is forcing you to contact her, or take on her 'grief' over the dog.

You say she stepped up, but made a poor job and you told her not to bother. Well, more fool you. You should have just left her to it and then said vaguely, 'Well you are sorting that, aren't you?' when it went wrong.

When you tell her you've had the dog put down and she wails just say sharply, 'Oh don't be so silly, Jackie. You didn't want the dog, which is why we took it on. The kids are sad enough that he was so ill he was put to sleep. I don't need your fake tears as well'. Call her out if you think it's performative.

If your mother is end stage dementia then she's presumably in a home and you can arrange the bills via direct debit. The only thing you need to do is visit as and when you feel able - or NOT if she doesn't recognise you and you don't want to. Presumably her money is currently covering care.

Sweetandsours · 06/11/2026 16:38

You certainly do not have to have contact with her once your mother is gone.
It is one of the blessings in life to decide what contact you want.

As for the funeral, go as simple as possible.
You sound absolutely burnt out.

You have every reason to be fed up.

Perhaps some therapy would help you to assert yourself and say no to everyone around you.

It can be done and is very rewarding.

BitterHarvest · 06/11/2026 16:54

@Hatty65i want to sincerely say thank you for that. I am going to keep that with me
when I tell her about the dog. Sadly
mum isn’t in a home because we promised her when she was well that we wouldn’t put her in a home. I have carers 4 times per day and spend
most of my day there and the odd
night too. I will not be minding sister when mum goes. My husband has massive tolerance issues with her so there is no way he would support that. Even my children get fed up with her. We are a deliberate low drama family. We like it that way. She is an over sharer and there is little happens to her without a drama or long story attached.

I agree in theory she is the wise one acting daft here. She knows I’ll want things done right and if she half asses them I’ll do it myself. It was always done that way because if mum had left us chores when we were younger if they weren’t right I’d have got the bollocking for it because I was older and should know better.

OP posts:
LemonPuppyPorkChop · 06/11/2026 17:25

BrilliantBetty · 06/11/2026 15:55

No one can force you to do anything. Take a break from being the carer and when you’re ready to go back to helping, do so at a reduced level. Your mum will have to fund carers and taxis and whatever else she needs if she needs it. I’d never expect my kids to do all this stuff for me, I wouldn’t want them to. A good parent has provision in place for their later years so it doesn’t ruin their kids lives.

This. I’m also the eldest daughter and was thrust into a parental role very early. I stepped away as soon as I realised no one was forcing me.

Natty13 · 06/11/2026 17:30

BitterHarvest · 06/11/2026 16:02

I can’t not do it! She’s end stage dementia. There is no one else. If I don’t do her meds pay her bills mind everything no one else will do it. I can’t just stop. I tried asking sibling to do more but she did such a spectacularly shit job I had to tell her not to bother. It actually ended up meaning I had to spend more time fixing her mess. She’s a disaster. I’m dreading telling her about the dog because the drama that will fall out from her grief wil be award winning. I’m exhausted. Learn from this people. Learn from this! I will be making sure none
of my kids have to do this. Especially not one over the others.

"If I don’t do her meds pay her bills mind everything no one else will do it. I can’t just stop."

With all due respect, what do you think happens to people in your mum's situation who have no children/able bodied relatives/family in the same country? You totally can just opt out...there's no law forcing you to step up and lots of people choose not to take on thst level of responsibility. You might not want to because of feelings of guilt and like you have to but nobody can change the way you feel but you.

Lyinginbed2 · 06/11/2026 17:33

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Lyinginbed2 · 06/11/2026 17:35

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Lyinginbed2 · 06/11/2026 17:36

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Maisymouse2 · 06/11/2026 17:40

Perhaps get some therapy, yes you are bitter.
Realise some people have a low threshold to dealing with serious life stuff or stress.
Life happens and you have no control of how your sibling is or spends her time with.
What a attitude.

Sweetandsours · 06/11/2026 17:50

So what if you promised your mother no care home.
Its you and your poor family being impacted.
Time to rethink this.

I would start pulling away from your sister.
I am quite tough but I really think that if one part of a couple allows a toxic sibling cause their husband and children grief, it is a reason to walk away from a marriage.

It sounds as if your awful family have negatively impacted your husband and children, especially if you are spending your days doing it all at your mother's house.

I think you don't owe her this.
I think your loyalty should be to your husband and children who are losing out.

biggreenbows · 06/11/2026 18:05

When you say 'we' promised not to put your Mum in to a home, did you both actively agree to this and did you properly discuss it (eg. how you would manage care and work/family if needed, what would happen if she had a high level of care needs or couldn't live alone)? I think it's a very risky thing to promise, but also that if it's just a passing 'don't worry, we'll look after you' when the parent is well and without further discussion it's unreasonable for anyone to hold you to it when the parent develops dementia.

I think you need to carefully consider how long you will continue this way. Your sister clearly does not intend to share the work involved and I don't actually think that's unreasonable unless she actively agreed to do so. But I do think you should consider residential care- dementia is awful and it's very likely that there will come a time where she needs (or at least would be far better with) someone with her 24/7. Your Mum's wishes are important but so is your life and your time with your DH/DC. This could go on for years and you could miss so much time (and have no energy for) your children. I say this with sympathy, as someone also dealing with a parent with dementia.

BitterHarvest · 06/11/2026 18:10

I’m worried the details wil out me that’s why I have t it too much in. About 3 yrs ago I wanted to put her in a home. This was when her physical issues started. I looked at homes and did the financial assessment forms etc. because we have joint POA I needed sibling to sign. She refused and continued to say it was because we promised mum. She aterndisclosed that she is dependant on the money from the house she will inherit. I was made to feel very guilty that I’m in a different and more secure position. I really did feel sorry for her at that time so I arranged home care. I did a split of care duties between us and it started off ok. But then slowly things were passed off onto me. For example she couldn’t get a day off to be there for a dr visit so I did it. Then al visits going forward were left to me. She was supposed to be the cleaner. But she just didn’t do it right and I needed up doing that too. For example she would empty the bin but not clean it so it was really smelly as you came in the door. Or she would mop floors but not change water so tiles were grotty. Only minor examples but the light time it was all left to me. We have joint POA but she refuses to deal with any bills or household issues so for servicing
of heating and all repairs I have to arrange and be there to facilitate them.

How do we get on. She’s very immature and not aware at all. I tend to just give her a wide hearth and we rarely see each other. She will phone me from time to time when she needs something but we are not close at all now. Mum doesn’t know how I am. She thinks I’m one of her nurses and so asked for my sibling all the time. Sibling will sit and chat to her and tell her an about her job and her hobby. Mum loves that and wil say she misses her if she hasn’t been for a while. Since dad does I’ve hosted Christmas. Sister would come for dinner but leave to go see friends after. We would have mum with us for few days. This is the first year mum isn’t well enough to be moved if she makes it to Christmas. Sister says she has accepted invitation to go to friends for Christmas so I will have to go there for the day otherwise mum will be alone.

OP posts:
MyDpsanarse · 06/11/2026 18:52

If it helps @BitterHarvest I was the youngest of three and I still ended up being the one who cared for my DM through dementia

QuietChristmas2026 · 06/11/2026 19:30

I looked at homes and did the financial assessment forms etc. because we have joint POA I needed sibling to sign. She refused and continued to say it was because we promised mum. She aterndisclosed that she is dependant on the money from the house she will inherit.

A question for anyone reading the thread rather than you OP - what would happen if OP wanted to force the issue - can she? What about calling social services, explaining the financial situation and letting them take over which may include selling the house or putting a charge on it if they think OPs mum would be better cared for in a home?

Mum doesn’t know how I am. She thinks I’m one of her nurses

So why are you going for the day and describing it as ‘having to’ go? Do the carers work as normal on Christmas Day? What will you do at your mums house on Christmas Day if the carers are working? What about your husband and children? Don’t they matter?

And just want to point out the obvious, which is that if this breaks your relationship with your sister then that’s fine.

BitterHarvest · 06/11/2026 19:37

Carers will go at Christmas. I think maybe me hub and kids could go and visit for an hour then go home. I don’t think we need to spend whole day. But I couldn’t in good conscience leave her alone on Christmas Day.

I live about 40 min drive from her sis lives a Fee mins away or a 10 min walk. But her friends al live 30 mins away so she going to stay with them at Xmas.

I think our relationship is gone. I just need to grow a pair and start standing up to her. She knows if she doesn’t do something I will. I need to stop plugging her gaps.

OP posts:
QuietChristmas2026 · 06/11/2026 20:02

Re the dog, why would you have a conversation with a sister you barely talk to about your dog? It’s none of her business.

Your sister doesn’t clean properly, so get a cleaner, and your sister will inherit less 🤷‍♀️. So what? She could always do what I do when I don’t want to spend money, which is do it myself.

I have carers 4 times per day and spend most of my day there and the odd
night too

Why? Genuinely, what are you doing there?

But I couldn’t in good conscience leave her alone on Christmas Day

If you want to do these things for yourself then acknowledge that. There is no need for you to tell your husband and children to spend 2 1/2 hours (travel and an hour there) with someone who has no idea who you are on Christmas Day. That isn’t love, that’s guilt or obligation or being performative or something. Use the money, pay for help, invest in your relationship with your husband and be realistic about what needs to be done. Why can’t you see your mum (I realise it’s for you, not her) another day when the Christmas rush has cooled down a bit?

And yes to everything Hatty said.

GrumblingGeek · 06/11/2026 20:34

you sound exhausted. it’s time to think of yourself.

id not tell any of them about the dog. it achieves nothing

however i would speak to your sister and say “remember we agreed to keep mum out a care home for as long as possible, well the time has come to get her into one. she doesn’t even know who i am. we have to put her welfare first and i know you want your inheritance but in the meantime we need to keep her safe. her dementia is bad. im doing everything. im exhausted. i can’t do it all any more so the time has come to sign the forms whether we want to or not. it has to be done to keep her safe”

then dont take no for an answer. threaten to put mum in the car with a suitcase of clothes and meds and drop her at your sisters if necessary.

in the meantime why dont you look up respite care? it’s a way to get a rest and she will be looked after in a care setting for a short “holiday”.

Hatty65 · 06/11/2026 20:45

@BitterHarvest I've realised that sounded a bit more blunt than I intended, but I still think that you are putting too much pressure on yourself and sound burnt out.

I absolutely agree with @QuietChristmas2026 that you are doing far, far more than you want to because either your Mother, your sister, or your lifetime of conditioning has trained you to pick up the pieces for everyone. And honestly, go at Christmas if you want to see her - but by the sound of it she won't know it's Christmas Day or what is happening, so she won't be devastated if you don't and you have a peaceful day at home with the kids.

YES - to getting/paying for a cleaner. It's not your job and you are 3/4 hour drive away - so that adds another 1.5 hours on to every time you go. If your sister won't do it then someone needs paying to do so.

YES - to having a conversation with someone medical about 'I cannot do this any longer, we need to look at a care home'. I would imagine that 4 times a day carers are expensive. If sister inherits less that is not your problem.

It sounds like Mum would be better off with professionals taking care of her and is really needing 24 hour a day supervision at this point. It's daft to say 'we promised her not to'.

My own DMIL was in a care home, with Alzheimers, for her last years when it became clear that she couldn't continue to live alone, even with people going in. I know it's not what she wanted. She lived to be 102, OP. And she was in the home from about 86. I was really fond of her (fonder than I am of my own DM) but we couldn't have provided her with the same standard of care.

How old is your Mum? Think about her living to be over 100. I don't wish to be unkind, but dementia patients can linger for year after year, even when they don't know anyone, when they need to be spoon fed, when they are doubly incontinent.

You can't keep going like this.

BoredZelda · 06/11/2026 21:08

On the joint POA, it’s really easy. Give her the option, either you take her name off it and you make all the decisions, or your name comes off it and everything is left up to her, you are stepping back and not doing anything. Make whatever decision is right for you and she just has to live with it.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page