Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there’s a lot of defensiveness in the replies on here?

26 replies

RealNavyEagle · 06/11/2026 09:45

I’ve noticed that on quite a few threads, people seem to respond from a place of defensiveness rather than actually engaging with what’s been said. Someone will make a fairly general observation or ask a question, and some replies immediately become personal, hostile or focused on defending themselves against something that wasn’t necessarily directed at them. It’s almost as though people interpret an observation about a wider behaviour or social pattern as a personal accusation.

Obviously, disagreement is part of a discussion forum and there’s nothing wrong with challenging someone’s views. But I do think there’s a difference between disagreeing with a point and feeling personally attacked by it.

AIBU to think some people are far too quick to take things personally on here?

OP posts:
didntlikeanyofthesuggestions · 06/11/2026 09:50

I haven't noticed that. Certainly not from me anyway.

CalledNeededYoga · 06/11/2026 09:51

It really does make this place fucking tedious at times.

NotAnotherScarf · 06/11/2026 09:54

I think its due to the loss of the ability to debate. We have a society where the attitude is "I'm right, you're wrong, I'm not going to listen to anything you say and will shout over you". Plus the concept of main character syndrome, that they are the most important person in the world and they must be listened to and not disagreed with.

Its especially true of posters who come looking for vindication of what thry think and are shocked to be told that the world doesn't agree with them. Mrs Super Soaker I'm talking about you.

thatsgotit · 06/11/2026 09:57

Yep. Some people really cannot cope with being disagreed with.

Lookingforwardtospringnextyear · 06/11/2026 09:58

Oh my goodness how appropriate OP!

I made the mistake of posting a dissenting opinion on a thread in Chat this morning and I'm been given pelters by other pp for expressing an opinion different to theirs!

There are definitely some threads where discussion and opinion is not welcome at all.

ChocolateApples · 06/11/2026 10:03

There's a certain type of poster who loves to come along and tell you how wrong you are for making an observation, and how their, very specific circumstances don't align with your observation so your general point is therefore invalid. Rather than saying yes, you are right although occasionally we make exceptions for reasons xyz.

Bluffinwithmymuffin · 06/11/2026 10:03

I think you’re right to an extent, so YANBU, but it’s pretty much the same everywhere else ime, not just on MN. But I’d still like to think the majority of us aren’t like this.

Betterversionofme · 06/11/2026 10:06

Yes!

TwiceTwoDouble · 06/11/2026 10:10

I don’t think that’s specific to MN or the internet though.

I when I was pregnant with my twins (who are now adults) I mentioned I was planning to breastfeed. I had women at work insisting that I was absolutely ridiculous to even try, as they hadn’t been able to feed their baby so how did I expect to manage with 2.

I understand it comes from a place of wanting to be validated about the decisions you have made for your own family but all our circumstances are different, it’s ok for someone to make a different choice.

I had the same issue when it came to weaning, potty training, deciding to be a SAHM, and later deciding to go back to work.

The same woman who criticised me for becoming a SAHM was just as awful to me for deciding to go back to work full time some years later.

I’m not sure if it has always been this way, but there do seem to be quite a number of people who don’t understand that two people can make different decisions and both decisions be perfectly reasonable.

FriggadyDiggady · 06/11/2026 10:22

There's a significant minority of arseholes on here, and they attract each other. See the thread about the woman whose DS missed his bus and was stranded in Japan. At first people were basically supportive, saying that the DS would be OK because Japan is very safe. At some point the arsehole bat-signal went up and the thread turned and people started piling on, telling the poster that her DS shouldn't be so dependent on her. It was really interesting to see the social dynamic; it seems that most people who post go along with the general tone of the thread.

Passaggressfedup · 06/11/2026 12:31

We live in a society where no-one ever want to consider they might not always be right. Add the blame culture and you have it. No more discussions, it immediately rise to accusations and defensiveness, which leads to frustration and anger and never to any learning outcome.

Burningbud1981 · 06/11/2026 12:40

FriggadyDiggady · 06/11/2026 10:22

There's a significant minority of arseholes on here, and they attract each other. See the thread about the woman whose DS missed his bus and was stranded in Japan. At first people were basically supportive, saying that the DS would be OK because Japan is very safe. At some point the arsehole bat-signal went up and the thread turned and people started piling on, telling the poster that her DS shouldn't be so dependent on her. It was really interesting to see the social dynamic; it seems that most people who post go along with the general tone of the thread.

I agree. There was a post recently I think it was the one where DH told his wife he wasn’t happy with there sex life as they hadn’t had sex for 9 months. The initial comments were very measured very supportive. The thread had a nice tone to it even though some had gently expressed the op that DH may have a point. Then by page 7 it was like the witches had woken up and the comments turned absolutely vile

5128gap · 06/11/2026 12:42

Probably because there are so many threads attacking people. Most weeks we get attacks on people claiming benefits, people with disabilities, particularly SEN related, people of certain nationalities and religious persuasions, boomers, MiLs, women who are thought not to sufficiently cover their bodies, women who are thought to cover too much of their bodies, older people, overweight people. All disguised as concern and topics for debate. Stands to reason people in these groups feel moved to offer a different perspective.

FriggadyDiggady · 06/11/2026 12:52

Burningbud1981 · 06/11/2026 12:40

I agree. There was a post recently I think it was the one where DH told his wife he wasn’t happy with there sex life as they hadn’t had sex for 9 months. The initial comments were very measured very supportive. The thread had a nice tone to it even though some had gently expressed the op that DH may have a point. Then by page 7 it was like the witches had woken up and the comments turned absolutely vile

Edited

When the negative comments reach a critical mass, it seems that the volume massively increases. I'm sure there's a psychological name for this.
I understand the urge to be contrarian and in fact my posting history will show me doing it myself (though not in a cruel way to people asking for support, more to puncture a smug air of consensus that this place often has), but I don't get why people want to join a pile on.
Another interesting phenomenon is that threads on the same subject can often go one way or another from the start. For example, if someone posts about the difficulties of accessing additional support for ND DC (a popular and somewhat contentious topic), they either seem to get masses of support and helpful advice from the start or they get jumped on by people doubtful about these conditions. Once the tone is set, the thread generally continues in the same way.

FriggadyDiggady · 06/11/2026 12:55

5128gap · 06/11/2026 12:42

Probably because there are so many threads attacking people. Most weeks we get attacks on people claiming benefits, people with disabilities, particularly SEN related, people of certain nationalities and religious persuasions, boomers, MiLs, women who are thought not to sufficiently cover their bodies, women who are thought to cover too much of their bodies, older people, overweight people. All disguised as concern and topics for debate. Stands to reason people in these groups feel moved to offer a different perspective.

Yes, this is true and does get my goat. Particularly the faux-naive "just asking questions" threads. I think that's a bit different from someone asking for help/support who gets jumped on, though.

FriggadyDiggady · 06/11/2026 12:58

Passaggressfedup · 06/11/2026 12:31

We live in a society where no-one ever want to consider they might not always be right. Add the blame culture and you have it. No more discussions, it immediately rise to accusations and defensiveness, which leads to frustration and anger and never to any learning outcome.

Yeah, but there are deffo some threads on here that are more like propaganda than an actual attempt at honest communication and discussion. It's not worth engaging with those in good faith.

MaeshoweDragon · 06/11/2026 12:59

Was accused of being a bit defensive when I quoted terms and conditions that said something was valid. "Defensive" seems to be some users goto when you give a quoted rather than opinion based response. Hey ho.

KeyOfTheDoor · 06/11/2026 12:59

didntlikeanyofthesuggestions · 06/11/2026 09:50

I haven't noticed that. Certainly not from me anyway.

😂

5128gap · 06/11/2026 13:00

FriggadyDiggady · 06/11/2026 12:55

Yes, this is true and does get my goat. Particularly the faux-naive "just asking questions" threads. I think that's a bit different from someone asking for help/support who gets jumped on, though.

Yes I agree. The unpleasant comments directed to OPs like the son in Japan example aren't defensive though. They're just attacks.

FriggadyDiggady · 06/11/2026 13:03

5128gap · 06/11/2026 13:00

Yes I agree. The unpleasant comments directed to OPs like the son in Japan example aren't defensive though. They're just attacks.

True. I brought it up as an example of the pervasiveness of arseholes (which I think probably causes some of the defensiveness - people search for something to be defensive about, which in turn justifies their hostility) but maybe it's a bit off topic.

fuckeditupbadly · 06/11/2026 13:15

I know what you mean but I also am irritated if I disagree with a poster, state my reasons clearly and then get told 'I am protesting too much' so what I've said must be untrue or invalid in some way. Not sure how you are supposed to debate if your argument is dismissed in that way

MrsTerryPratchett · 06/11/2026 14:26

FriggadyDiggady · 06/11/2026 12:55

Yes, this is true and does get my goat. Particularly the faux-naive "just asking questions" threads. I think that's a bit different from someone asking for help/support who gets jumped on, though.

This. We hear the dog whistles.

Men on FWR asking faux naif questions are NEVER in good faith.

HarlotOTara · 06/11/2026 14:31

Totally agree, inability to think about something outside of personal experience, projection. Very irritating and tedious

MaeshoweDragon · 06/11/2026 14:35

fuckeditupbadly · 06/11/2026 13:15

I know what you mean but I also am irritated if I disagree with a poster, state my reasons clearly and then get told 'I am protesting too much' so what I've said must be untrue or invalid in some way. Not sure how you are supposed to debate if your argument is dismissed in that way

I don't engage, just shout arsehole (in my head if in public) and drop the rope. Life is too short to be irritated by strangers.

KaleidoscopeSmile · 06/11/2026 14:38

I've never understood why MN is held to different standards than any other wide-ranging public forum on the internet. Or posters who get quite annoyed that people aren't responding to other posters in the way that they deem acceptable.

And "you've just proved her/my point" is almost as lazy as a response as "^This" in case anyone's considering it