Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Nintendo switch, playstation, Xbox or...none?

31 replies

Losoph · 05/11/2026 23:12

My two children, aged 12 and 11 have been asking for the above for ages. They both have a tablet on which they play Minecraft, etc (around 45min per day)
I have no idea what the actual difference between these game consoles is and which would be the best option for the preteens.
My DD,12 likes the idea of Nintendo as she worries PlayStation will have some content that is not appropriate (violent). Also, she wants something that can be enjoyed by the family.
Ds on the other, hand wants playstation, as then apparently he will be able to play remotely with his friends.
My worries are

  • whatever we get, they will play with it once and then ditch it
  • they will grow out of Nintendo soon-ish so money I'll spend
  • playstation is for older kids and the content can be violent particularly that I'm absolutely rubbish at setting up.parental controls on any devices

I would appreciate any recommendations from anyone with children at similar age -either of these three or...none and why?

OP posts:
Snorlaxo · 06/11/2026 10:06

It sounds like dd would enjoy the Switch and ds would enjoy the PS.

You need to ask your son what games his friends play because he’ll probably want to play the same games with them. These games might be violent eg GTA or CoD but might be fine like FIFA.

You can get non-violent games on PS. Games are rated like films by PEGI so you’ll know what is inappropriate and there will be games for kids.

brunettemic · 06/11/2026 10:28

We have a PS5, which is technically DH’s, DS has a switch 2 and DD has a switch (both paid for themselves). If I had to pick one for them I’d pick the PS5, other than Nintendo specific games there’s nothing it can’t do that the others can. With the switch I think some games you can’t play across different consoles, which is a problem.

brunettemic · 06/11/2026 10:30

OonaStubbs · 06/11/2026 00:18

Computer games should be banned. They are nothing but an expensive waste of time. Get your kids playing sport outdoors instead.

Except that’s a nonsense opinion. Excessive use isn’t great but there’s plenty of evidence disproving your statement.

Scarlettpixie · 06/11/2026 13:44

We got a Wii when DS was about 8, then later an Xbox. We had both in the lounge until he was into his teens and wanting to talk to friends online. At some point he also had a switch. This gets played less, although he does sometimes still play as his GF has one and they play the same games. She has the new switch. The wii had loads of play when DS was younger. Lots of wii fit, wii sport and Skylanders. He still occasionally digs it out. Later, he was more into the Xbox. He had game pass for a few years and played online with friends a lot. You could put parental controls on and timers (eg no 18 games and no gaming after 11pm or whatever you want). I also didn't allow him to play with strangers. No experience of playstation although for your DS getting what his friends have is likely the best way to go. Xbox and playstation seem similar whereas the Switch is a different beast. Nintendo games are really expensive but quite unique.

Sartre · 06/11/2026 13:46

Nintendo is great but they need to have an active interest in the games Nintendo offer e.g Mario, Pokemon and Zelda. If not, it’s a bit of a pointless console. In terms of accessing violent content, this will obviously only happen if you buy violent games…

Scarlettpixie · 06/11/2026 13:47

I also disagree that games should be banned. That is just ridiculous. I play them and I am 54! It's great escapism. It's sitting in your pants doing nothing but gaming that's a problem but that really isn't most gamers!

Oh and my son is doing Games Art at Uni. It's a growing industry.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page