Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kelly Bryant on paid fertility leave

215 replies

Thosedogsarenoisy · 05/11/2026 21:09

Did anyone see this discussion today on Loose women (I know, I know)
I found her views just so insensitive and bizarre
As someone who struggled for nine years to conceive, had multiple miscarriages, an emergency ectopic, was prodded and poked for years, three rounds of ivf, sickness and emotional upset-all whilst working full time and two jobs, it's upsetting

OP posts:
LetsDillyDally · 06/11/2026 13:25

BoredZelda · 06/11/2026 13:18

Isn’t that an argument for better sick leave policies generally, rather than an issue specific to IVF?

In an ideal world sick leave would be more flexible according to individual circumstances but I guess that opens up a very large can of worms. I can imagine it would be very difficult to create a policy which needs to encompass so many variabilities.

I don’t know what the answer is, but I’m not mad about the idea of IVF leave for those who could benefit from it. Just as I’m not opposed to a more flexible policy for people with chronic conditions.

LetsDillyDally · 06/11/2026 13:27

I also personally wouldn’t be fussed if it was paid or not to be fair. But I do think a lot of people would benefit from it in regards to a formal policy which doesn’t impact their sickness record.

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 13:36

Bushmillsbabe · 05/11/2026 21:47

Infertility is a medical condition.
Many medical conditions are treated not because they are life threatening, but to improve a person's quality if life, their mental health etc. IVF comes under this.

Those of us who can conceive naturally should count ourselves fortunate that we do not have to go through the traumas and tests and treatments which women who struggle with their fertility go through, through no fault of their own, to acheive the same outcome.

Having children isnt a medical condition- its a choice.
You dont choose to have to get cancer treatment, but you DO choose to have IVF.

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 13:50

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 13:36

Having children isnt a medical condition- its a choice.
You dont choose to have to get cancer treatment, but you DO choose to have IVF.

But infertility isn’t a choice. IVF is the treatment. So you’ve used one condition and one treatment in your example.
Infertility isn’t a choice. But the treatment, IVF, is.
Cancer isn’t a choice. But having the treatment, chemo, is.
Now obviously I understand that of course people would want to have cancer treatment because they want to live. But they don’t have to. It is still a choice. So I don’t think using the choice example really works. No one chooses infertility either. It might not be life threatening of course. But it’s not a choice.

SerenaCat93 · 06/11/2026 14:12

BoredZelda · 06/11/2026 13:17

It is though. People with chronic conditions have to manage working and being ill. My daughter has CP, should there be CP leave for the days she is so exhausted she can barely move? This will be lifelong for her. Or, should we deal with all of these things in a sympathetic way, using the normal sick leave procedures, taking into account that for some it will be sporadic.

The women needing fertility leave aren't ill. They are attending medical appointments. Sick leave is totally separate and if a woman is sick from IVF she will be off sick. I assume you don't take sick leave for going to a medical appointment if you're not actually sick and will be back at the office later that day.

Also infertility treatment will end at some point so it is clearly different from being sick with something for these rest of your life. I also don't see what chronic illness has to do with it?

Watchoutfortheslowaraf · 06/11/2026 14:27

Pollyanna87 · 06/11/2026 11:29

She could have simply not had a baby.

But that’s true of everyone getting pregnant. So not really a useful counter argument.

my friend is not infertile so she could have simply had a baby the usual way instead.

but she chose to ensure the best possible outcome for her baby despite the impact of ivf on her.

nothing about having a baby via ivf is simple. Maybe you don’t have children as you seem to have a huge lack of understanding here

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 14:30

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 13:50

But infertility isn’t a choice. IVF is the treatment. So you’ve used one condition and one treatment in your example.
Infertility isn’t a choice. But the treatment, IVF, is.
Cancer isn’t a choice. But having the treatment, chemo, is.
Now obviously I understand that of course people would want to have cancer treatment because they want to live. But they don’t have to. It is still a choice. So I don’t think using the choice example really works. No one chooses infertility either. It might not be life threatening of course. But it’s not a choice.

You can live without IVF.
You can't live without cancer treatment.
As a taxpayer...happy to fund cancer therapies.
IVF- nope.

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 14:31

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 14:30

You can live without IVF.
You can't live without cancer treatment.
As a taxpayer...happy to fund cancer therapies.
IVF- nope.

Edited

I know. I said that. I’m referring to the choice part of it. Any treatment for any condition is still a choice. The condition itself is not.

SweatySpider321 · 06/11/2026 14:34

ThisOliveKoala · 05/11/2026 21:19

So who’s supposed to pay? The taxpayer again? I’m assuming most of the people are already getting IVF on the nhs. It’s a lot that is expected from public funds, yes you didn’t choose to be infertile but you can adopt, or foster. The taxpayer is already so burdened.

Calm down. In a lot of places people get 0 rounds or 1 on the NHS. Despite the fact NICE guidelines recommend 3 cycles. So the majority are paid for rather than via the NHS

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 14:35

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 14:30

You can live without IVF.
You can't live without cancer treatment.
As a taxpayer...happy to fund cancer therapies.
IVF- nope.

Edited

Are you happy to fund breast implants for mastectomy patients? That’s a choice. The mastectomy is needed to live. The breast reconstruction is not. What about prosthetic limbs? They aren’t life saving. The NHS funds many many things that are not just life saving. It’s fine if you don’t think any of it should be funded. But IVF is just one other treatment of a condition that no one asked for.

Arbourimage · 06/11/2026 14:37

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 14:30

You can live without IVF.
You can't live without cancer treatment.
As a taxpayer...happy to fund cancer therapies.
IVF- nope.

Edited

The vast majority of the NHS isn’t “life saving” so that’s not an argument that makes sense.

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 14:40

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 14:35

Are you happy to fund breast implants for mastectomy patients? That’s a choice. The mastectomy is needed to live. The breast reconstruction is not. What about prosthetic limbs? They aren’t life saving. The NHS funds many many things that are not just life saving. It’s fine if you don’t think any of it should be funded. But IVF is just one other treatment of a condition that no one asked for.

Not being able to get pregnant cannot be compared to cancer ( or the effects of its treatment ) or missing limbs.
The implants are to help with the psychological impact of cancer.
The prosthetic limb... I don't need to explain that to you.
These issues are not comparable.
You can't always get what you want, and certainly can't expect others to pay for a 'want' rather than a clinical need.

exhausted100 · 06/11/2026 14:42

ThisOliveKoala · 05/11/2026 21:19

So who’s supposed to pay? The taxpayer again? I’m assuming most of the people are already getting IVF on the nhs. It’s a lot that is expected from public funds, yes you didn’t choose to be infertile but you can adopt, or foster. The taxpayer is already so burdened.

Wow! Find out your facts first!! How insensitive! You clearly have NO idea!

Cece92 · 06/11/2026 14:42

I don’t have fertility struggles but take my tax for IVF if it means you get your family! Not everyone is able to adopt or foster either. I looked at fostering and due to being a single parent earnings and the size of my home I couldn’t.

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 14:42

Arbourimage · 06/11/2026 14:37

The vast majority of the NHS isn’t “life saving” so that’s not an argument that makes sense.

Life prolonging and risk-reduction in the main...if not 'life saving'.
Although I would argue that low-level actions such as prescribing antihypertensives ARE life saving, unless you want to die of a massive CVA.
.
Pregnancy does neither of those things...in fact it is a risk to life. .

Hoops123 · 06/11/2026 14:43

Thosedogsarenoisy · 05/11/2026 21:24

Wow

wow? Being infertile is very sad but it’s not the same as life saving things that the NHS needs to pay for and struggles to do so. Having children is not a right

thebrowncatisback · 06/11/2026 15:03

@Paganpentacle

what about cancer treatment for smokers or obese people or anyone who has substance abuse?

how about if i break my leg skiing. Is that ok cos skiing is my choice

Notasbigasithink · 06/11/2026 15:11

ThisOliveKoala · 05/11/2026 21:19

So who’s supposed to pay? The taxpayer again? I’m assuming most of the people are already getting IVF on the nhs. It’s a lot that is expected from public funds, yes you didn’t choose to be infertile but you can adopt, or foster. The taxpayer is already so burdened.

Wow!
You complete and utter disgrace of a human for saying that.
How dare you tell people to simply just 'adopt or foster'?!
As someone who has been through years of (self funded because apparently I didn't qualify for one single NHS round even though I've paid taxes since I was 16!) IVF that has got to be the most insensitive comment I have ever read on MN.

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 15:15

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 14:40

Not being able to get pregnant cannot be compared to cancer ( or the effects of its treatment ) or missing limbs.
The implants are to help with the psychological impact of cancer.
The prosthetic limb... I don't need to explain that to you.
These issues are not comparable.
You can't always get what you want, and certainly can't expect others to pay for a 'want' rather than a clinical need.

Ok so we’ve established it’s not actually just life saving things you think should be funded like you said. Fertility treatment could help women struggling mentally not being able to have children. Would that be ok if it helps the psychological impact of infertility? I’m going to take a stab in the dark and guess that you are still going to say no…..
Basically you think pretty much everything other than fertility treatments should be funded as they all help something and/or aren’t a choice. Infertility, despite not being a choice, should not. Got it.

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 15:19

Notasbigasithink · 06/11/2026 15:11

Wow!
You complete and utter disgrace of a human for saying that.
How dare you tell people to simply just 'adopt or foster'?!
As someone who has been through years of (self funded because apparently I didn't qualify for one single NHS round even though I've paid taxes since I was 16!) IVF that has got to be the most insensitive comment I have ever read on MN.

Don’t worry it turns out she also started the initial part of private IVF herself before conceiving naturally. Hasn’t really given a reason why she didn’t consider adoption or fostering first other than agreeing it isn’t the same. Basically everyone else should but not her.

SerenaCat93 · 06/11/2026 15:30

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 14:40

Not being able to get pregnant cannot be compared to cancer ( or the effects of its treatment ) or missing limbs.
The implants are to help with the psychological impact of cancer.
The prosthetic limb... I don't need to explain that to you.
These issues are not comparable.
You can't always get what you want, and certainly can't expect others to pay for a 'want' rather than a clinical need.

The psychologic impact of infertility is huge. 42% of women facing long term infertility felt suicidal and more than half of couples going through infertility divorce. It ruins lives. It's not just a "want" like wanting a cake FFS 🙄

AmIReallyTheGrownup · 06/11/2026 15:32

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 14:42

Life prolonging and risk-reduction in the main...if not 'life saving'.
Although I would argue that low-level actions such as prescribing antihypertensives ARE life saving, unless you want to die of a massive CVA.
.
Pregnancy does neither of those things...in fact it is a risk to life. .

Actually there’s evidence that pregnancy and breastfeeding are health protective for women. Pregnancy substantially reduces the risk of uterine cancer and reduces the risk of ovarian cancer. Breastfeeding is protective against the same two cancers plus offers reduced risk of breast cancer, Type 2 diabetes and hypertension.

So there is an argument that having children is also risk reduction for women’s health.

I will always remember a manager of mine who got breast cancer having been unable to have children, and an additional source of grief was being told that part of her increased risk was because she’d not been able to have them.

Bushmillsbabe · 06/11/2026 15:34

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 14:40

Not being able to get pregnant cannot be compared to cancer ( or the effects of its treatment ) or missing limbs.
The implants are to help with the psychological impact of cancer.
The prosthetic limb... I don't need to explain that to you.
These issues are not comparable.
You can't always get what you want, and certainly can't expect others to pay for a 'want' rather than a clinical need.

How about a women who has to use ivf and doner eggs to conceive due to ovarian cancer? A side effect of cancer/cancer treatment. Do you see them as deserving?

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 15:35

thebrowncatisback · 06/11/2026 15:03

@Paganpentacle

what about cancer treatment for smokers or obese people or anyone who has substance abuse?

how about if i break my leg skiing. Is that ok cos skiing is my choice

We cant really leave you with cancer or a broken leg can we?
You can function without being pregnant.

Thwilp · 06/11/2026 15:36

Paganpentacle · 06/11/2026 15:35

We cant really leave you with cancer or a broken leg can we?
You can function without being pregnant.

You can function without breasts but you said that was needed to help people psychologically so that was fine?

Swipe left for the next trending thread