Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU and naive to be so flummoxed by people’s values on bullying?

43 replies

Naivemum2026 · 05/11/2026 20:22

DD is having some trouble with the mean girls at school. School have spoken to their parents and other kids in the class have confirmed to the teacher that the bullying is taking place, so there’s no dispute about whether or not it’s true. There has been lots of hand wringing from the parents but no action to make it stop. The mean girls are still inseparable. Other girls in the class are now starting to join the fringes of the group - presumably because they have calculated that it’s safer to be inside the bullying group than out of it.

I’m just totally flummoxed by how the parents can not think it’s their responsibility to make it stop. They seem to think there’s a magic anti-bullying fairy who will sweep
in and make the changes for them? The school can’t make them be nice human beings - only their parents can do that. All school can do is sweep up the mess when their parents choose not to do any parenting.

Am I the only person who thinks that this is rubbish parenting and a failure to step up to their own responsibilities? DH thinks that I am naive and that these days, there are very few parents who will do the right thing - he thinks that unfortunately many people these days are happy enough (or at least will accept) their kids being bullies
or hanging out in the bullying gang if it means that they are the popular kids? I’m particularly stunned because the parents of one of the ringleaders are very vocal about their Christian faith. Would you take action in this situation to stop the bullying by your own child or would you shrug your shoulders and be glad that your kid was in the popular gang? I can’t work out if I am hopelessly out of touch.

OP posts:
Naivemum2026 · 05/11/2026 23:18

They were told off in school but their consequence was that their parents were told, I think.

i absolutely agree that other people’s behaviour isn’t within my control. I’m not going to go around and try to order them to give their kids particular consequences, of course.

I’m asking more as a general question whether it is morally reasonable of them not to take any steps to do this, without anyone having to point it out to them. Those steps may not work, of course, but would it be the morally right thing for them to at least try, rather than doing nothing? It may be a theoretical question, but I’m still interested in what people at large think. Have I overestimated the level of decency that most people possess?

OP posts:
seahorsessky · 05/11/2026 23:39

Some parents do. In Slate, some parents were advised to move their daughter to another school because she was bullying another child-why should the victim have to move? They took her phone away (yes, maybe things would have been better if she'd not had one in the first place) and didn't give her any extras, and she had to start again at a school knowing no one. It made her a much better person and let the victim recover, the counsellor (?) who wrote the advice said. Whether these parents would do that is another matter, and if the bullies are moved together, it might not help.

Dontlletmedownbruce · 05/11/2026 23:54

You are not wrong OP but you don't know what they have or haven't done. They might be at wits end and nothing works, they might be overwhelmed with MH problems, they might be bullying the child themselves and it's all learned behaviour. There are many different scenarios. However if an issue is in school I think the first place to deal with it is in school. If the school tell you another child said your child said something and your child denies it, what is the best approach? The second hand word of a stranger over your own child, you could lose your kids trust in a serious way because kids lie sometimes. It might also be a two sided scenario, there are children with poor social skills who can misinterpret things and think everyone is out to bully them. You'd have to be sure your child is truly at fault before you enforce consequences. Even then it's tricky, you don't know the people involved or the context, or the severity of the situation or the character of the bully or the damage inflicted.

muggart · 06/11/2026 01:35

You aren’t wrong OP but many parents these days don’t seem to discipline their children at all, they just talk to them. Consequences/ punishment is a somewhat dated concept. It sucks, but it could just be a reflection of their generally inadequate parenting rather than their views about bullying specifically. That’s my theory anyway.

chilledwino · 06/11/2026 03:00

@Naivemum2026 if I was made aware that my dc was bullying I would come down on them like a ton of bricks OP. They would certainly know that the effects that bullying had on others by the time I was finished, so much so they wouldn’t dream of ever doing it again.

If on the other side, like you, I would support my dc by explaining how sad it is that xyz do not have a nice life to feel the need to squash others. I would then throw a party ( for any reason, xmas yay ) and invite all the class excluding the bullies. Cheer my dc up, whilst punishing the bullies.

Rustfinch · 06/11/2026 04:00

For me it would be down to trust OP. I don't trust people in authority just because that's where they are, too many people in positions of power are bullies themselves. Mostly though, I do trust my child. So if I wasn't seeing any signs of my child being a bully at home, with their friends etc then I'd be on the fence about it.

If I'm not there I can't know who's telling the truth or whether someone's version of the truth amounts to them being oversensitive or having a bad day or whatever. There's even people who, having failed to make someone do what they wanted them to do, will claim that the person who wouldn't comply is mean, nasty or a bully. All because their sense of entitlement and perception of what others owe them, is off.

At the end of the day I'm not punishing my child on someone else's say so, when I've no evidence they've done anything wrong. I'd speak to them about it, but whether it went any further than that would depend on what they said and how they seemed eg if they were lying etc. or if there were independent witnesses. I'm not ruining my relationship with my child who seems to be behaving fine, by risking punishing them unfairly just because someone else tells me that in their opinion my child is a bully.

I grew up with controlling parent who was forever acting suspicious of me and like I was up to no good, when in reality I never put a foot wrong. If you asked this parent they'd have said they suspected lying, theft, drug use and for all I know other things too, but I never did any of it 🤷 they're just a person with issues. Everything I owned was where did you get that from, said in an accusatory tone with a frown. I had a weekly allowance and bought things from that. Everywhere I went, eg to the corner shop when round a friend's house, I'd be sternly told I wasn't allowed to go there in future, as if I'd done something immoral or stupid. It was crazy and toxic. I'm not going to be that parent, however much someone else wants me to. I'd keep my eye out, but if don't see it then I'm not acting on it.

Granville82 · 06/11/2026 04:09

Another poster mentioned about exploring what you can do. Your daughter could just be unlucky but there is likely also some element of it not being random that the bullies are picking on her. There are different authors and perspectives on this, have you tried reading a bit to get some ideas flowing? This could end up being an opportunity for your daughter to grow. And if that doesn't work I would try to move her classes.

99bottlesofkombucha · 06/11/2026 04:49

Naivemum2026 · 05/11/2026 20:22

DD is having some trouble with the mean girls at school. School have spoken to their parents and other kids in the class have confirmed to the teacher that the bullying is taking place, so there’s no dispute about whether or not it’s true. There has been lots of hand wringing from the parents but no action to make it stop. The mean girls are still inseparable. Other girls in the class are now starting to join the fringes of the group - presumably because they have calculated that it’s safer to be inside the bullying group than out of it.

I’m just totally flummoxed by how the parents can not think it’s their responsibility to make it stop. They seem to think there’s a magic anti-bullying fairy who will sweep
in and make the changes for them? The school can’t make them be nice human beings - only their parents can do that. All school can do is sweep up the mess when their parents choose not to do any parenting.

Am I the only person who thinks that this is rubbish parenting and a failure to step up to their own responsibilities? DH thinks that I am naive and that these days, there are very few parents who will do the right thing - he thinks that unfortunately many people these days are happy enough (or at least will accept) their kids being bullies
or hanging out in the bullying gang if it means that they are the popular kids? I’m particularly stunned because the parents of one of the ringleaders are very vocal about their Christian faith. Would you take action in this situation to stop the bullying by your own child or would you shrug your shoulders and be glad that your kid was in the popular gang? I can’t work out if I am hopelessly out of touch.

Maybe you should go to their church. Sit there once a week and make sure they see you all…

tomorrowfollowstoday · 06/11/2026 05:00

many people these days are happy enough (or at least will accept) their kids being bullies
You are wrong to think this is something new that happens 'these days'.
Bullying has always happened, schools have improved but still tolerate too much.

Nat6999 · 06/11/2026 05:06

My ds was horrifically bullied at both primary & secondary school, it led to him becoming a school refuser. His primary school tried to blame ds for getting bullied, they said that due to his autism "he saw things differently & thought he was being bullied" He had come home from school with hand marks on his neck from being strangled & many instances of him being covered in bruises. I was up at school practically every week, I had the anti bullying protocol from the school website printed off & every time I went I asked them to prove to me they had followed their own procedures. At secondary after many instances & him ending up at A & E with a head injury I even involved our MP which managed to get me a meeting with the Head who told me that one of his bullies parents refused to answer the phone so there was nothing they could do about him & the other one their family was feral & they had to give them leeway because of it, you couldn't make it up

Hadalifeonce · 06/11/2026 05:22

I would go into school every single week, and make a real pain of myself until the school actually did something about it.
I am angry on your behalf; after DS left school, I discovered he had been bullied for 7 years, I was so sad he didn't tell me. Even though he had left the school I made appointments with 2 staff members and spoke with them about it. I wanted them to see the signs, which I had missed, I was able to join the dots at this point, and check on the situation.

NiaAndFar · 06/11/2026 05:40

muggart · 06/11/2026 01:35

You aren’t wrong OP but many parents these days don’t seem to discipline their children at all, they just talk to them. Consequences/ punishment is a somewhat dated concept. It sucks, but it could just be a reflection of their generally inadequate parenting rather than their views about bullying specifically. That’s my theory anyway.

It is kindvof tricky because punishing a child bully can have the opposite to the desired effect. It often just makes them dislike the victim even more.

WarmHiker · 06/11/2026 07:24

I know it’s not even everyone kid’s nature to be assertive, but as a parent, it’s your duty to teach your child to stand up for themselves also. If someone is bullying them, your a child make sure they are taught a lesson. It’s the only way to make them stop. You can play nice and roll over. But it won’t get you very far. These people don’t have a sense a fairness or decency. Not do their feckless parents, is else they would’ve be making your child’s life a misery.

Badbadbunny · 06/11/2026 07:32

Your focus needs to be the school and what they’re doing. School can’t abdicate responsibility to parents for what goes on in the school. OP needs to keep reporting every single incident until the school takes some proper action, I,e. Splitting the bullying group, punishments/sanctions, etc.

TheDevilWears · 06/11/2026 22:58

Both of my DDs were bullied in school. I spoke to several parents and it didn’t really help. The parents were obviously upset that about their child’s behaviour - racism, threats, exclusion, throwing DDs lunch on the floor … I spoke to the school. And DD was then labelled a snitch. Sadly once a child is bullied they become easy prey for others to jump on the bandwagon. I removed DDs from school and chose to home educate - we had for most of their education anyway. Several children contacted DDs after they left to say sorry they didn’t intervene but they too were being bullied and were just glad it wasn’t them … 😕 my eldest DD still has PTSD around groups of teens her age (she’s eighteen now). I don’t necessarily think it’s the parents faults … some kids are just mean!

Badbadbunny · 07/11/2026 12:40

@muggart

Consequences/ punishment is a somewhat dated concept.

Unfortunately, schools don't seem to bother much with consequences/punishment for anything really. For lots of kids, a detention isn't a big thing because they've nothing else to do anyway nor is isolation. Schools seem very reluctant to remove/move the bullies to other classes/forms etc. Given from my experience, the bullies were often the "cool kids" in school plays, choir, sports teams, etc., a far more effective sanction would be to remove them from such activities, but teachers won't do that because they want them on the team or in the play, etc., hence why the bullies know they can get away with it.

Bushmillsbabe · 07/11/2026 12:55

The school need to put in place consequences. Option may include loss of breaktimes, removal from schoolsports teams, not attending school trips/school discos, removal from being a prefect/school council or any other roles, mandatory attendance at pastoral sessions to reflect on their behaviour. My daughters junior school uses all of these, and there is no overt bullying now she tells me. There will of course see be the more subtle bullying- leaving people out etc, but this is cracked down on by teachers pairing children up for activities if they see hints of children being left out. I'm not naive enough to think this solves it all, but definitely helps

Dontlletmedownbruce · 07/11/2026 13:15

I also think its really important to help your child on how to cope with the bully. So often this approach is dismissed as just victim blaming but I think it should be about empowering. It's not anyone's fault they are picked on but they have the ability to change their behaviour too, it doesn't always work but often it does. Kids are told to just stand there and take it these days, they don't have to. Often their reaction to a minor bullying incident is what gives fuel to it escalating, we all have seen kids and quietly thought he / she is vulnerable to being bullied at school. I told Dd recently that sometimes it's ok to tell someone to go F themselves, or to call them nasty names in retaliation. She is a very polite people pleaser, so far she hasn't come under a bully's radar. Ds was bullied verbally for a long time and when a silly comment was made he'd get all upset so they kept going repeating it until he had a meltdown. Someone overheard the kids saying 'cmon let's make him lose it' and they'd start on him. When he learned to treat them with indifference they moved on.

A strategy that worked very well for DS was the teachers told the kids that whoever stood and watched were almost as bad, those who laughed were actually as bad. They said going forward if you laugh at the kids comment about another kid we will consider you to be equally responsible. The kids stopped laughing and after a few days of no audience the bullying stopped. They were only 10/11 but a great lesson was learned. As always the leader had their own issues, the kids who propped him up and enabled him mostly didn't other than a need to impress. This is where I think schools really need to step up.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread