Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

DD15's illicit party & then burglary: AIBU to ask for help from insurance experts!

115 replies

IllBiteYourLegsOff · 05/11/2026 18:19

Shameless follow up: I'm hoping for advice or tips from any of the wonderful & wise people who helped me so much in the aftermath of my daughter's party and subsequent burglary at the end of August.

Loss adjusters are coming tomorrow. I'm down £30k now, ignoring the damage from the party.

This is really for people who already know the story, as it is a bit long and boring...

Does anyone have advice about how to navigate the fact that randoms came to the party (uninvited and not known) and stole house keys, then let themselves in the following night?

If there is a way I can word this while being truthful. I'd love to know!

Thanks for any help x

OP posts:
NotAnotherScarf · 06/11/2026 07:07

HingesHingesHinges · 05/11/2026 22:51

Oh dear. Well she won’t be the first or the last 15 year old to sneak out and have a party. I still don’t think it’s a reason for the relationship to change.

No but the major damage and loss of about £30k of items might cause a little friction in my house.

Magnummum1 · 06/11/2026 07:19

Thinking of you OP - hope it goes well today. Keep us posted.

NotAnotherScarf · 06/11/2026 07:27

IllBiteYourLegsOff · 06/11/2026 04:59

I can't prove it but I have phone records showing the time of s 30 minute video call with my daughter the next day, when she toured the house. I checked the jewellery. The hoover was there.
The next day my cleaner came but the hoover was gone.

Well thats proof then. Seriously, given you have video of the stuff being in situ before the 2nd "event " it does support your version of events.

Insurance is a contract based on a few major things the most relevant here:
You suffer financially from the loss of a thing.

That you have right to insure it.

The insurance company indemifies you to be put back into the position you were in pior to any loss.

You always act as if uninsured and mitigate any loss (the police failure to secure the house is not your error here)

And the most important in this case, utmost good faith. That you tell the insurance company the truth and you trust them to pay the claim.

Therefore, the Financial Ombudsman and before them the Insurance Ombudsman has always placed a strong emphasis on insurance companies paying unless there is a definite to say the claim isn't covered.

In your policy book there will be information about how to complain. The Financial Ombudsman is the last step.

When you meet the loss adjuster do have any documents re the items as someone has already said. But also make sure you show them that video. I would email a copy to myself immediately for security. That is vital evidence

AlohaRose · 06/11/2026 08:12

How are you going to prove that the police left the house unsecured and that caused the burglary? From the sounds of what you have written (maybe I have misunderstood though), the party was on, say, Friday night, which is when drunken daughter, crowds of randoms, police called etc happened. The police (apparently) left two windows open that night. The next day your daughter videos the damage and jewellery and hoover are in place. She (or your ex) then leave the house still without securing it properly and that night you are burgled. So whatever happened or didn't happen on Friday night with windows is irrelevant.

Bobcurlygirl · 06/11/2026 08:49

Nothing to add about insurance but I live in Chandler's Ford so just be glad the uninvited people didn't bring knives.... It could have been worse.

IllBiteYourLegsOff · 06/11/2026 08:50

EmeraldShamrock000 · 06/11/2026 07:00

None of this makes sense. You better get your story straight before the insurance assessment. First you said you didn’t notice days later until you realise the keys were missing. No you are saying you assessed the place by video call.

Edited

It makes sense. And my story is straight. This is an abridged version. The video call didn't survey the spare keys or lack of, that was discovered after my return.
There is a link to the full story above.

OP posts:
IllBiteYourLegsOff · 06/11/2026 08:52

Bobcurlygirl · 06/11/2026 08:49

Nothing to add about insurance but I live in Chandler's Ford so just be glad the uninvited people didn't bring knives.... It could have been worse.

This was utterly horrific. I have friends with teens here too. Awful.

OP posts:
Roseshavethorns · 06/11/2026 09:02

I have experience of being burgled twice in a matter of weeks and dealing with loss adjusters (although many years ago).
In my case it was all ok and a fairly straightforward process. The loss adjuster asked some fairly probing questions but was actually very nice. My best advice is to tell the complete truth no matter how bad it sounds. You won't contradict yourself (and come across as making it worse than it actually is) if you tell the truth.
The thing that strikes me as being an issue is the very thing that you have as evidence of a burglary - the stolen hoover and the jewellery. The thieves ignored valuable computers etc (presumably because they were big or difficult to sell on) but stole a big vacuum. You also said that jewellery was stolen during the initial party and then a second lot was stolen during the burglary. The loss adjuster will (from experience) be very interested in that.

roundaboutthehillsareshining · 06/11/2026 09:12

@NotAnotherScarf No - it was a video call, not a recorded video. She has a record that a video call between her and her DD's number took place, but no record of what was actually displayed on the video.

Candleabra · 06/11/2026 09:18

Hope it goes ok today.
My experience with two recent insurance claims is that they will do EVERYTHING to not pay out. I think it probably cost my insurance company more to refute the claim than it was worth in the first place but they were so aggressive (and appointed ‘independent’ experts to assess the damage etc). So try and stay calm if it doesn’t go your way first time, just keep going, and then complain, refer to the ombudsman etc. They bank on you giving up when it gets hard.

Aluna · 06/11/2026 09:28

WonkyIvy · 06/11/2026 06:21

So what? This thread is about insurance. Not how great you were when you were fifteen and much better than a fifteen year old who is living decades later with phones and social media.

You had a party that wasn’t spread about on social media, which hadn’t been invented, congratulations.

How naive to think you need social media for word to spread among teens. I even mentioned the fact that I’d been at parties where police were called. For exactly that reason.

The thread is about insurance following significant losses through through DD’s negligence. They’re unlikely to get a payout due to the circs. Personally I’d insist DD gets a job to repay a fraction of it.

drspouse · 06/11/2026 09:54

DH, ex insurer, says "it's a grey area", check for the "forcible and violent entry" clause and escalate to the ombudsman. He says if it's the police that didn't secure the property (I think you have video) then the insurance company should pay and sue the police and if they don't, and you have legal expenses cover, YOU sue the police.

drspouse · 06/11/2026 10:00

Also - though you suspect the burglars took keys either during the party or by climbing in the window, this could be a red herring. They could just have climbed in to steal the jewellery (and taken the keys for a possible return, maybe with a van for the computers).

rainbowstardrops · 06/11/2026 10:01

I’ve just read your other thread and bloody hell, I’d be absolutely devastated!
I have no advice re insurers etc but I sincerely hope that your daughter realises just what she’s done. I’d be absolutely furious with her.
Also, if there was 100 people in the street, why on earth did nobody at the party - or the neighbours - ring the police sooner?!

NotAnotherScarf · 06/11/2026 10:02

roundaboutthehillsareshining · 06/11/2026 09:12

@NotAnotherScarf No - it was a video call, not a recorded video. She has a record that a video call between her and her DD's number took place, but no record of what was actually displayed on the video.

Bugger I miss understood that! Technology isn't my thing

However, should the op have to present the case to court (the ultimate end of the process although if the FSA finds against her I doubt any lawyer would encourage it) she at least can evidence that the daughter inspected the property prior to the subsequent break in and give evidence that items were still there.

One thing to point out that the loss adjuster's role is to be a claims handler on the ground, the eyes of the insurance company and its good one is being sent to discuss things face to face. Ignore the name its a dreadful old fashioned term. My company had in house staff called Claims Advisors Surveyors as they helped with difficult/large claims and surveyed potential new customers risks.

DeftGoldHedgehog · 06/11/2026 10:15

HingesHingesHinges · 05/11/2026 22:51

Oh dear. Well she won’t be the first or the last 15 year old to sneak out and have a party. I still don’t think it’s a reason for the relationship to change.

Indeed. How long does someone have to be in the doghouse for, the rest of their life?

BillieWiper · 06/11/2026 11:00

Well basically they 'broke in' twice presumably?
The first time they snuck into the house uninvited to steal the keys and the second with keys to do the burglary.

I don't know if you need mention a teenage party. Just a general gathering.

If the person was a stranger they shouldn't have been there regardless of it was a teen rave, a wake, or a four year olds tea party?

TinyOcelot · 06/11/2026 11:01

drspouse · 06/11/2026 10:00

Also - though you suspect the burglars took keys either during the party or by climbing in the window, this could be a red herring. They could just have climbed in to steal the jewellery (and taken the keys for a possible return, maybe with a van for the computers).

But she knows they didn't take the jewellery the night of the party because she saw it the next day on the video tour her daughter gave her to assess the damage, and she knows there was a burglary the night of the video tour day because the hoover disappeared.

It does seem very likely that things happened as OP has deduced. Although insurers probably aren't going to go with what seems likely if they can find a way to weasel out of it.

DontEatTheMushies · 06/11/2026 11:03

If they were meant to be at dads, where did he think she was?

Id be tempted to see if you could claim on his home insurance as it was his not keeping tabs that meant the party occurred. Even if you are divorced he should have driven back to the house that night with her to check it over and make sure it was all locked up (maybe I am too nice a person as this is what I would do given it was a residence my child lived at).

ChasingRainbow5 · 06/11/2026 11:03

DontEatTheMushies · 06/11/2026 11:03

If they were meant to be at dads, where did he think she was?

Id be tempted to see if you could claim on his home insurance as it was his not keeping tabs that meant the party occurred. Even if you are divorced he should have driven back to the house that night with her to check it over and make sure it was all locked up (maybe I am too nice a person as this is what I would do given it was a residence my child lived at).

A sleepover, the original thread said that.

Mumtobabyhavoc · 06/11/2026 11:32

I don't think OP will get very far without pushing for charges through the police. People know what happened, who's involved, etc, but are not talking. That could include dd.

Divebar2021 · 06/11/2026 11:32

drspouse · 06/11/2026 09:54

DH, ex insurer, says "it's a grey area", check for the "forcible and violent entry" clause and escalate to the ombudsman. He says if it's the police that didn't secure the property (I think you have video) then the insurance company should pay and sue the police and if they don't, and you have legal expenses cover, YOU sue the police.

Good luck with suing the police. We have no idea how secure the house was left because the OPs daughter and ex went in the following day to inspect. At that point no one can say how secure or insecure the house was but it falls to them and not the police. I’d also add that house keys were stolen so unless you want every window and door “sitexed “ then I’m not sure how anyone could be prevented from gaining entry. At some stage the home owner has to take over the security of their own property.

Pinkgorilla101 · 06/11/2026 13:32

Only just read your original post. Bloody kids eh. Hopefully she has learned her lesson. One little thing that stands out for me. Your ex turned up at the house the night the party was shut down. Had the police secured it by this point? And did he change the locks? Feel for you, must be horrible

drspouse · 06/11/2026 13:40

TinyOcelot · 06/11/2026 11:01

But she knows they didn't take the jewellery the night of the party because she saw it the next day on the video tour her daughter gave her to assess the damage, and she knows there was a burglary the night of the video tour day because the hoover disappeared.

It does seem very likely that things happened as OP has deduced. Although insurers probably aren't going to go with what seems likely if they can find a way to weasel out of it.

No indeed, they know the jewellery was there the night of the party BUT they don't know whether the thieves stole the keys by coming in the window or just stole the jewellery and took the keys to come back.

drspouse · 06/11/2026 13:43

Divebar2021 · 06/11/2026 11:32

Good luck with suing the police. We have no idea how secure the house was left because the OPs daughter and ex went in the following day to inspect. At that point no one can say how secure or insecure the house was but it falls to them and not the police. I’d also add that house keys were stolen so unless you want every window and door “sitexed “ then I’m not sure how anyone could be prevented from gaining entry. At some stage the home owner has to take over the security of their own property.

I believe there are photos/videos after the supposed "making secure" which on subsequent inspection showed an open window, not spotted by the very shaken teenage DD.
But we do need a few clarifications by OP, I agree.