You can only speak as you find @EvieBB . I don’t think I’d especially get on with either of them but I come to this with a fascination with media representation and bias.
The building up of Kate as an angel and Meghan as a demon is clearly use of binary opposition in narrative and if you want a theory (I’m sure you don’t, few share my interest in Critical Theory) it’s Claude Levi Strauss.
That’s not to say I’m impervious to each ladies’ charms or lack of them. I find K a bit cold for some reason but as someone else said, that could be a connotation I’ve picked up on because of a negative experience with someone like her. Maybe… not fully convinced.
You’re right, Meghan was dynamite on those early visits.
Or was she? Unless actually there, most of us rely on the media and that’s highly edited. A good example of this is when the police attacked the miners at Orgreave. The BBC (yes the BBC) switched it round to look like the miners attacked first. Simple and highly effective. They later admitted this btw.
The media tends to set agenda and then find the photographic evidence to back their points. So out of 100s snaps of Meghan you find the one of her looking a bit snarky or holding Harry’s hand and you anchor the image with a pejorative caption. Keep doing that and you’ve constructed narrative and public opinion. This is called cultivation theory and I’ve forgotten the theorist! … erm … Gerbner…
Anyway, my raison d’etre here is that the media changed their representation of the couple. I can only speculate on why. Maybe they didn’t play the game? Maybe William and Kate’s press officers briefed against them or maybe, media outlets discovered they could sell more clicks and copies by being negative?
I’d love to know.
No one in the anti Meghan camp will ever tell me, beyond Oprah, where they get their media from. I have asked but they won’t say. Maybe scared I’ll say something snarky if they say TikTok? I wouldn’t, all media whether the guardian or socials has its pros and cons.
You could say it comes down to Oprah but the couple were in USA by then, the shit sling fest had happened, that’s why they went.
What was the big bang that caused most of the media to turn against them? I think she didn’t play ball. Wouldn’t stand post partum on steps with a tiny baby that EVERYONE wanted to see the skin colour of to have her figure, hair and clothes criticised. For instance.
However, you mentioned the lies told on Oprah. The pre-marriage… no idea, it wouldn’t slightly surprise me if it wasn’t true because the royals work to totally different rules but I can’t work out why a pre-marriage would be necessary but they do happen, Charles and Camilla did just that. Was the A of C not willing to marry a divorced person in church? I wonder if we will ever know but it was weird for sure.
Who made who cry in the great Kate V Meghan row.? Well we have all had this happen haven’t we? Both sides claiming the other was mean? So I don’t call that necessarily a lie.
Next: Archie’s title. This seems discretionary and to an extent parents decide, as Princess Anne did. I think his title just hadn’t been decided and, along with everything else, the couple did read this as a slight. There seems to be A LOT of miscommunication from all sides of the RF here.
Did someone raise baby’s skin colour, of course they did. I’m no spring chicken but older people are awful at this. I had to gently remind an older friend not to use n word the other day. It was in connection to the film The Dambusters , she couldn’t see the problem and to prove it said the word! It is a generational thing and hopefully we’re getting better.
What else was in Oprah…lack of emotional and mental health support from RF. That rang true to me. The way they reacted after Diana’s death, the bundling their kids off to boarding school. That’s what they are like. It works for some and not for others. I come from the stiff upper lip school of thought myself and thought I could soldier on through anything, turns out I couldn’t but that’s another story. But to Meghan who came from an environment where dogs have therapists, it must have seemed odd. My employers’ had a wellbeing policy and it meant jack shit in practice.
Passport and keys? Well I’ve been in hotels where they take your passport. I would imagine the security rules were a big surprise if she wasn’t warned. I mean, hand up, I don’t KNOW but it doesn’t seem surprising.
Same for curtsying to your future mother in law. I think that’s about it for Oprah. It went on interminably but seemed to repeat every several times but I was kind of left with a few of wtf because it was a load of nothingness billed as seismic.
And lots of reaction shots of Oprah looking horrified. Have a trawl about on this site and find the family AIBUs where everyone has wound everyone up and can’t see wood for trees . That’s it.