Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not have wanted to hire a cleaner?

4 replies

Camariad · 04/11/2026 18:41

Technically not relevant now as we broke up, but curious.

Me and my ex lived in a two bed apartment. Both worked full time. No kids, one dog. Lounge/kitchen, diner, study etc. Plus the two bedrooms, as mentioned.

I earned more than my ex, but he came from a wealthy family he could always fall back on. I have savings and a good job (solicitor), but I don’t like wasting money and grew up in a family with debt problems.

My ex wanted to hire a cleaner. I said no, because I thought it was a waste of money.

He said I was a cheapskate, I said we didn’t need a cleaner. For context, he owned the place in his name only. It was his apartment.

The cleaning got done. Our apartment was flawless. I also ENJOY cleaning.

YABU- should have hired a cleaner as you could afford it
YANBU- it was okay to see that as a luxury you didn’t need, and not want to ‘waste’ money that could be saved for the future

OP posts:
Pplareasthickasshit · 04/11/2026 18:50

If you work full time and can afford it, surely there are better ways to spend your time than cleaning. Not sure why you dug in over this issue. Academic though now, as you say.

EmptyCoffeeCups · 04/11/2026 18:55

What an odd hill to die on and even odder to still be wondering over it after you've split up.

He presumably wanted to pay for the cleaner so no I don't see why it would be a waste of money. Just because you didn't see the value in it doesn't mean it wouldn't have been a valuable addition to your day to day lives.

Perhaps he would rather have spent time doing stuff together instead of spending hours each week keeping the apartment to a flawless level of cleanliness.

JadeRocks · 04/11/2026 18:57

Did he want you to pay half for the cleaner? Did you want him to do half of the cleaning? If you were happy to do it all rather than contribute to a cleaner then definitely YANBU! And actually very generous and sensible. I’m sure you used your money on other time-saving things like food etc. at times. Cleaning isn’t a pain point for everyone.

seahorsessky · 04/11/2026 19:19

If you actually like it, fine. IF you just didn't want to pay, and expected him to do half of it when he was willing to pay, that's unfair. Same as if he wanted to cook and you insisted on take-out, and wanted him to pay for it.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page