I’ve recently ended an eight-year friendship and I’m starting to wonder whether I was right to do so or whether I’ve been unreasonable.
For context, I’ve always felt that this friendship was quite one-sided. Over the years, my friend (I’ll call her S) has regularly asked me for favours. Initially, I didn’t mind helping because that’s what you do for friends, but over eight years it gradually became a pattern of her constantly needing something from me.
Last October, I told her I was pregnant with my first child. Two months later, she told me she was pregnant with her second.
From that point onwards, she seemed very keen for us to experience motherhood together. She immediately started talking about us doing things together, sharing the experience and having this really close bond as mums.
Now, on paper, I appreciate that this sounds lovely. Other people even told me how nice it would be to have a friend going through motherhood at the same time.
But something about it didn’t sit right with me.
I think it was because of the history of our friendship. I’d spent years feeling that she expected a lot from me, and I started to feel as though she was trying to create this intense bond where everything I wanted to do for myself and my daughter would also become something she wanted to do.
I began noticing that whenever I’d mention an idea or something I wanted to experience with my daughter, she’d seem to adopt the same desire and suggest we do it together.
I appreciate that friends can have similar interests, and I’m not suggesting she’s not allowed to want the same things. But it started to feel like I wasn’t being allowed to have my own experiences without them becoming shared plans.
I felt like she was trying to pull me back into a role I’d occupied for years: being the friend who was always available, always helping and always accommodating.
I tried to give her the benefit of the doubt and started getting closer to her again, but while I was around five months pregnant, she asked me for money twice.
This really brought back all the feelings I’d had about the friendship for years.
I was pregnant with my first baby, preparing for a completely new chapter of my life, and I found myself feeling like I was still being put in the position of having to help her.
It wasn’t necessarily the money itself. It was the fact that it felt like the same dynamic was continuing, despite everything changing in our lives.
Eventually, I decided to end the friendship.
I think what I’m struggling with is that I don’t know whether I’ve interpreted her behaviour unfairly. Perhaps she was genuinely excited about us having babies at similar times and wanted to share that experience.
But I also wonder whether, after eight years of feeling that the friendship was one-sided, I was simply recognising a pattern I no longer wanted to be part of.
I don’t want a friendship where I feel obligated to share everything, constantly help or have someone attached to every experience I want to have with my child.
I want friendships that feel mutual, where there’s room for independence and where I don’t feel drained.
AIBU to have walked away? Am I overthinking the whole motherhood situation, or does it sound like this friendship had become unhealthy and that I’d simply reached my limit?