Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think HR are even worse than estate agents?

16 replies

CleverTealGoose · 03/11/2026 13:41

I genuinely think HR is one of the most unnecessary, parasitic functions in the modern workplace. At least estate agents are fairly transparent about whose interests they serve. HR, on the other hand, operates under this carefully cultivated image of being there to support employees, promote fairness and ensure people are treated properly.

In reality, HR exists primarily to protect the organisation and its interests, often at the expense of the very employees it claims to support. What makes it particularly insidious is the language of wellbeing, inclusion, psychological safety and employee engagement, which can disguise some incredibly cynical and self-serving practices. And the amount of bureaucracy, corporate jargon and unnecessary processes they generate is extraordinary.

I’m not suggesting employment law, payroll or proper workplace protections are unnecessary. Quite the opposite but I question how much value the modern HR function actually adds.

AIBU to think HR is one of the most overrated and fundamentally dishonest professions going?

OP posts:
Octavia64 · 03/11/2026 13:44

HR is there to stop the company losing legal cases ie to make sure as far as possible they stick to the law as it relates to employees

OakElmAsh · 03/11/2026 13:46

I'm not in HR but I don't feel like there's anything insidious about it - any HR function I've ever worked with have been very transparent about what they do and what they don't do.

People in general though assume an awful lot - HR can't do an awful lot about what an employee thinks HR should be doing, rather than what's written down in black & white.

MaybeMoving2025 · 03/11/2026 13:46

I think everyone knows what they’re actually there for to be honest. And that role is needed.
HR probably differs at each organisation, but on the whole, I find the HR department at the company I work for to be generally helpful and fair. I don’t feel like they’re trying to do anything particularly sneaky.

Pearlstillsinging · 03/11/2026 13:47

YABU
It is in the employees' interest that the company follows the law

SweatySpider321 · 03/11/2026 13:47

Agreed. Fucking useless. I got an email from a member of HR where l work the other day, about a grievance l raised in November 2025. They apologise in a performative fashion for “the delay”, then rapidly start getting shitty saying they would “always support grievances being considered informally in the first instance, if we progress to formal then this will limit your rights of appeal”. I opened as a formal grievance from the get go so no point in saying that 🤣. Plus you’ve nothing to sort it in the last year so why would you now

skilpadde · 03/11/2026 14:01

Yes, the function of HR is to protect the organisation. That’s not a secret.

What is strange is the expectation that HR (the majority of whom are female) should be a supportive, cuddly function, or a substitute friend/mum to employees, when nobody expects that of finance, legal, audit, governance, or any other corporate function.

The other thing that’s largely unknown is that HR spends inordinate amounts of time behind closed doors nudging, coaching, coercing or outright strong-arming shitty managers to be less shitty to their employees. Yes, this is to protect the organisation, not to give the employees a stroke on the head, but somehow when employees are disgruntled it’s the fault of HR, rather than the fault of their shitty managers.

If you’re unhappy… join a union. Join a support group. Heck, start a support group!

InveterateWineDrinker · 03/11/2026 14:02

I find that HR is like many corporate support functions such as facilities or procurement - they're useful to good managers who know how to use them, but work badly with bad managers, often because they are brought into situations too late to positively influence the outcome.

chirrupybird · 03/11/2026 14:09

HR is an arm of the business so there role is part of the business. As said above they are there to make sure the business handles it's employees in a way that complies with employment law, and also provide a buffer between management and employees so you can discuss any problems outside your line management. But they are not your friends or social workers. Get a union rep in if you want someone on your side.

Don't know why EAs got dragged into it.

GeorgeMichaelsCat · 03/11/2026 14:13

No HR team I've ever been a part of or worked with are "for the people". They try and work with both but it is not always straightforwards. Poor management is usually to blame. By the time a formal grievance is raised, the relationships connected are usually unsalvageable. Also sometimes it is impossible to get the actual facts. He looked at me and laughed, she said this when no one was around. You can't take hearsay as fact and discipline on that hearsay.

They navigate difficult waters and do far more than you see or give credit for.

Minna84 · 03/11/2026 14:15

I voted YABU because everyone knows they are just there to protect the organisation and not you. Having said that, most HR in my place is now losing their jobs to AI bots

Overthemoun · 03/11/2026 14:18

Ours are professionals at making mountains out of molehills. I avoid at all costs.

Their concern is fake, it’s all about how it might affect the business rather than genuine care. They are so black and white they’re not human.

Flibberyjibbert · 03/11/2026 14:23

I've never felt that HR are here to protect me, their role is to protect the employer.

Join a union if you want to have someone in your corner.

dracn · 03/11/2026 14:29

i now sit near HR in our new office set up and they generally spend their days having little parties and group meetings.

Every day it seems someone has reason to have balloons on their desks and the need to clear a shared space to make room for loads of crisps and cakes and sweets. Recently a couple of the women there got up and were paid handsomely to put stickers up around the office and Pride flags on all the tables in the canteen.

There’s a manager who strolls in at 10am and asks “how are we all?” which I find quite obnoxious. She always tends to leave before 4, too.

I’m under no illusion as to what HR’s function is and if you mistakingly think they’re there to protect you then that’s on you.

But I also think it’s interesting that none of the recent redundancies I’ve heard of affect HR in any way. I also think there’s a huge amount of bloat in HR with a lot of people who don’t seem to ever be particularly busy. And I can’t believe the pay bands are largely the same as the equivalent for qualified professionals.

Our Head of HR also talks in pathetic cliches whenever she has to talk that no one else would get away with.

FairyInTheMossGarden · 03/11/2026 14:46

I worked in HR. I spent a large part of my career training and encouraging management to treat staff better than the standards required by law. I carried out tasks like redundancy with a total focus on ensuring every individual was treated fairly and with dignity at every stage of the process.

I've visited people at home to support them during long term sickness, sat with employees when they've received appalling news from visiting police officers and have broken up physical fights between staff. Much of the work was pushing for better conditions for staff partly because it would make employees lives better but also for the benefit of the company via retention, attraction, commitment etc.

Done well it's the kind of job that makes businesses thrive and improves working lives. It's the sort of work 90% of the staff at a company never see.
Done poorly then you've probably got a point OP.

Isitmyluckyday · 04/11/2026 11:00

YABU to believe that HR are there to support employees rather than employers. That is what unions are for. HR are there to keep human resources matters running smoothly, hopefully to the advantage of both parties, though it isn't always like that.

LibertyBustop · 04/11/2026 11:04

I assume you’ve had bad experiences with both HR and Estate Agents but that’s not a good reason to demonise whole professions.

In both roles, people are just trying to do their jobs. As with any role some people will do it better than others.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page