Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think I shouldn’t be potty training my brother’s DD?

214 replies

AmpleFish · 02/11/2026 22:00

My brother recently asked me to look after his DD (3 yrs 7m) while he and SIL go away for the weekend to celebrate their wedding anniversary. I of course said I would as she’s really no bother and they don’t really have anyone else. I jokingly said something about getting her potty trained by the time they come back as they haven’t given it a full-hearted go yet. DB got all defensive before basically saying why don’t you give it a go, which took me aback slightly. Half of me thinks I should for DN’s sake so she’s not still in nappies at 4, but AIBU to think I shouldn’t be potty training my brother’s child??

OP posts:
Givemethestrength · 03/11/2026 09:13

I understand your frustration with your brother but I don't think it's your place to potty train someone elses child. By the sound of it they wouldn't keep it up when they come back anyway!

Mulledjuice · 03/11/2026 09:15

AmpleFish · 03/11/2026 08:26

I think it’s a different situation. It’s not about infantilising, it’s about the fact that their lack of a backbone now means i, or anyone else who looks after her, has to change nappies on a child this old. DS’s bottle affects no one

except for DD, perhaps?

DeanElderberry · 03/11/2026 09:16

Why not make it a 'let's be a big girl/boy' weekend and include drinking from a cup (sippy cup if needed) as well as potty training.

Their schoolteachers next year will bless you.

TheAmberKoala · 03/11/2026 09:16

WhySoManySocks · 03/11/2026 09:02

It does most definitely affect his teeth!!

I dont know PPs situation, but bottles can also fill them up meaning they dont get the right nutrition from solids.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 03/11/2026 09:19

The other day I saw a FB post from an American kindergarten teacher, saying how many children were not now potty trained before starting school. But they ring the parents and tell them to come and change their own children, and have to provide a list of other people - relatives or friends - who can also be contacted,
I’m not saying it it necessarily 100% effective, but the nuisance factor of being constantly phoned - especially if you’re at work - must surely be an incentive.

IMO the ‘official’ advice I’ve heard of, about ‘waiting until they’re ready’ is responsible for a lot of the delay.

Depends surely on what is meant by ‘ready’. With my two (decades ago) I had read that they were not usually physiologically ready - as in physically able to hold on for a short time - until 2, so I waited until just after 2, and both times it took around a week.

By 3 a good many children have more forceful ideas of their own, as to what they will or won’t do….

Sweepingthetide · 03/11/2026 09:20

AmpleFish · 03/11/2026 09:07

I don’t treat him like a baby at all - he has one comfort, and it’s not like he’ll be drinking out of a bottle forever!

Your child is older than your niece. Taking a bottle away is easier because your child doesn't need to learn or do anything, you are simply removing something. You have been told that the bottle will affect your DS's teeth and choose to ignore it. You would rather damage your childs health than have to parent him when he becomes upset with the change. That makes you a lazy parent. You need to stay in your own lane. By vocalising your judgement of others, you bring your own parenting into the spotlight and when you do this IRL peiple will be talking about your parenting.

muggart · 03/11/2026 09:25

The bottle is more of an issue, surely? it will give them bad teeth long term.

My kid was potty trained around 3.5, i know it’s later than usual but why does it matter?

I’m also somewhat surprised by the comments about getting it done in a weekend. It took my kid a week and there were many accidents afterwards.

I suspect there is probably a reason that you are unaware of as to why it hasn’t happened yet. I delayed doing it, for example, because my child frequent diarrhea and i was suffering from severe morning sickness so just couldn’t face having to clear up poo from the floor. SEN isn’t the only thing that gets in the way!

Ohnobackagain · 03/11/2026 09:29

@AmpleFish why don’t you talk to your SIL? If I were her and you were discussing potty training with someone else I’d feel a bit left out. She might be grateful of your support, or she might be annoyed you’re over-stepping. Depends on your relationship I suppose.

EmeraldShamrock000 · 03/11/2026 09:30

AmpleFish · 03/11/2026 08:15

Yes I do so I know exactly what it takes to potty train a child! I get it’s not late in the grand scheme of things but to not have even really attempted training yet is crazy to me. Yes ever child develops differently but it’s not like she’s even half trained, she’s in taped nappies still 24/7! At least your DD is only wearing a pull up some of the time

It is not your first thread on this topic. It is none of your business. I am surprised that the child hasn’t attempted to remove the 24/7 nappy. Some children are slower than others and don’t show any desire to progress. Mine didn’t. DD was later diagnosed with a developmental disorder, it was obvious DS was ND from the off.
I sometimes get frustrated as they have no interest in learning anything naturally, everything has to be taught or forced. Your Niece may be delayed, she’s still too young to tell as girls hide developmental delays better. My DD was in her second year of school before the teacher suggested an assessment. I just assumed she was very easy going, away with the fairies.

PinkyFlamingo · 03/11/2026 09:31

AmpleFish · 02/11/2026 23:13

I suppose so but then I’m going to have to spend some of that time changing her nappies because DB and SIL cba to train her!

Well you said yes to looking after her knowing she was still in nappies.

BertieBotts · 03/11/2026 09:39

Honestly my DC are aged 5, 8 and 18 and the difference in parenting advice/attitudes in general over the last 15+ years is astonishing. It's like I've watched it in real time.

It used to be people got their advice from real people IRL like other parents, their own parents/siblings, their health visitor, the other mums at baby/toddler group etc. And there were books, some more controversial than others (SWMNBN Grin). Mumsnet obviously. The occasional TV programme. But even MN is (or was) discussion between (mostly) real people going through a similar experience to you IRL who are, or were, (mostly) fairly sane and sensible and 15-20 years ago it was posts displayed in real time without algorithms deciding which threads to display to anybody.

Barely any of this happens any more, because everyone is addicted to their phones and because social media aggressively targets attention (time spent on app, frequency of returning to app) and engagement (liking/sharing/commenting) and even traditional media like TV and news websites and so on are drawn into these kinds of loops about what content they prioritise (and we access most of that through our social media or are presented a personalised version of the news website).

Then in a chicken and egg sort of thing you get parenting advice coming onto those platforms, targeting people who are suddenly at home much more with much less opportunity to go out and meet people IRL, and the advice becomes ever more polarised and unhinged because polarising content for anything breeds engagement. And the slop. Dear lord the parenting advice slop!

The problem is that our brains don't really understand how to process the volume of "information" we are bombarded with. If you look at even 15 years ago you probably came across a fairly limited selection of views on parenting and most of them would broadly overlap - don't lock them in cupboards, do teach them to say please etc. When your Great Aunt Mary or the one unusually out of touch leader at playgroup suggested something batshit, it got compared to the general consensus of the other things you'd heard and got pretty quickly thrown out, and things sort of remained even. Change was pretty slow - it took decades for example for smacking to fall out of popular use after experts started advising against it in the 70s/80s, and the Back To Sleep SIDS prevention advice had a small effect at first and snowballed once the practices became much more widespread. But overall, everything maintained a sort of sense check.

This doesn't happen as much any more, because depending on which part of the algorithm has latched onto you, you get bombarded with endless variations on "Don't ever allow your child to experience a negative emotion, otherwise their mental health will be ruined for life" or "Baby sleep must be controlled scientifically and optimised to the minute otherwise you will be creating pathways for insomnia, obesity and ADHD" or "The world is full of risk, hazards and disease which can affect your child and maim or kill them" - and the problem is that you probably won't even notice that you're receiving so many of these messages, but your brain quietly absorbs all of them and builds the consensus, the one that 15 years ago was made up mainly of the parenting practices of your next door neighbour, your NCT course leader, your family members with DC, the books you were reading, maybe a few MN threads debating sleep training vs cosleeping.

Today, if you're on social media and the algorithm gets hold of the fact that you're a parent (esp a mum) at all, the volume of the batshit social media messages drowns out any kind of moderating effect from RL anecdotes/observations/experience. And there's a much lower bar for anybody wanting to create parenting social media content than somebody writing and publishing an entire book, or creating a name for themselves as an expert on TV/radio. It's become the norm now, so rather than ask for book recommendations, people ask for online course recommendations because every influencer is selling an overpriced video course which claims to have all the answers (they don't, of course) and it's become normalised.

Anyway all of this is a very long way to say that while I don't think it's as dire as the media tries to make out, parenting has become more passive and child centred in many ways because parents are increasingly being fed a load of slop which discourages actual involved parenting, to the point that a lot of parents are afraid to push issues with their DC in case it causes them discomfort, or because they have been sold a lie that it's somehow "better" or more organic if children do things for themselves, but as a result it tends to lead to DC who have excessive screen use and less time spent on more useful activities. I wouldn't even be surprised if media apps are detecting where multiple devices are being used to access the same account or in the same household at the same time and somehow sync both content which encourages passivity around parenting, and addictive screen based content for the DC at the same time, so that if parents try to change their DC's habits it becomes even more difficult and so the media companies win with more view time from both parent and child. I would have thought that was a mad conspiracy a few months ago, but I'm not convinced it's all that unrealistic now. It certainly wouldn't be impossible or hard for these patterns to be detected (though it might be more of a coincidence, and it's more that tech-addicted parents are tech-lax for their DC?)

So yes, I don't think it's especially surprising that parents could get to age 3.8 and have only had one half hearted attempt at potty training. You're right that it is their responsibility, but equally I expect it wouldn't be that difficult to train DC if you prefer that to changing nappies. Only you really know whether it's likely to be a wake up call to DB and SIL which might make them think oh, maybe DC is capable of more than we'd realised, or whether they are likely to think "Brilliant, completely escaped a nasty job, AmpleFish will do all the hard parts of parenting for us!!"

user47639820987 · 03/11/2026 09:40

I find this quite shocking that a NT child would be kept in nappies for the parent’s convenience at nearly 4.
My kids were 18mths old when they stopped using nappies in the day time - it was quite normal 20yrs ago. It was a pain finding a loo quickly when we were out and about but think of the money they must be spending on nappies!
Mine could also drink out of a glass from about a year old - a bottle is very bad for their teeth.

SouthLondonMum22 · 03/11/2026 09:41

AmpleFish · 03/11/2026 09:07

I don’t treat him like a baby at all - he has one comfort, and it’s not like he’ll be drinking out of a bottle forever!

Giving a 4 year old a bottle is absolutely treating him like a baby.

and I'm assuming your niece won't be weeing in nappies forever. Same thing. Both a lazy option.

godmum56 · 03/11/2026 09:42

Sweepingthetide · 02/11/2026 22:42

Don't use your niece as some kind of childish sibling rivalry. Leave them to parent their DD and just enjoy time with your niece as her Auntie. I see you have another thread running as your own child still has bottles and your brother commented. You and your brother need to grow up and stop commenting on one anothers children, or this will become toxic for the children when they get older and understand.

Edited

This totally this....I mean sibling rivalry is a thing (not a good one) but both of you should stop putting the kids in the middle.

zingally · 03/11/2026 09:43

You gave a veiled insult in the form of a joke. I'm not surprised he called your bluff and said you're welcome to try.

You can't offer, even in the form of a "joke", and not expect people to call you on it.

Yes, at 4 she absolutely should be trained. But you've called it out in a bit of an AH way.

ItalianChips · 03/11/2026 09:50

Reading the replies I’m judging both of you, a nearly 4 year old not being potty trained a 4 year old being given a bottle is both not great. Why are you giving your 4 year old a bottle, way too old.

Comeondoreen · 03/11/2026 09:54

BertieBotts · 03/11/2026 09:39

Honestly my DC are aged 5, 8 and 18 and the difference in parenting advice/attitudes in general over the last 15+ years is astonishing. It's like I've watched it in real time.

It used to be people got their advice from real people IRL like other parents, their own parents/siblings, their health visitor, the other mums at baby/toddler group etc. And there were books, some more controversial than others (SWMNBN Grin). Mumsnet obviously. The occasional TV programme. But even MN is (or was) discussion between (mostly) real people going through a similar experience to you IRL who are, or were, (mostly) fairly sane and sensible and 15-20 years ago it was posts displayed in real time without algorithms deciding which threads to display to anybody.

Barely any of this happens any more, because everyone is addicted to their phones and because social media aggressively targets attention (time spent on app, frequency of returning to app) and engagement (liking/sharing/commenting) and even traditional media like TV and news websites and so on are drawn into these kinds of loops about what content they prioritise (and we access most of that through our social media or are presented a personalised version of the news website).

Then in a chicken and egg sort of thing you get parenting advice coming onto those platforms, targeting people who are suddenly at home much more with much less opportunity to go out and meet people IRL, and the advice becomes ever more polarised and unhinged because polarising content for anything breeds engagement. And the slop. Dear lord the parenting advice slop!

The problem is that our brains don't really understand how to process the volume of "information" we are bombarded with. If you look at even 15 years ago you probably came across a fairly limited selection of views on parenting and most of them would broadly overlap - don't lock them in cupboards, do teach them to say please etc. When your Great Aunt Mary or the one unusually out of touch leader at playgroup suggested something batshit, it got compared to the general consensus of the other things you'd heard and got pretty quickly thrown out, and things sort of remained even. Change was pretty slow - it took decades for example for smacking to fall out of popular use after experts started advising against it in the 70s/80s, and the Back To Sleep SIDS prevention advice had a small effect at first and snowballed once the practices became much more widespread. But overall, everything maintained a sort of sense check.

This doesn't happen as much any more, because depending on which part of the algorithm has latched onto you, you get bombarded with endless variations on "Don't ever allow your child to experience a negative emotion, otherwise their mental health will be ruined for life" or "Baby sleep must be controlled scientifically and optimised to the minute otherwise you will be creating pathways for insomnia, obesity and ADHD" or "The world is full of risk, hazards and disease which can affect your child and maim or kill them" - and the problem is that you probably won't even notice that you're receiving so many of these messages, but your brain quietly absorbs all of them and builds the consensus, the one that 15 years ago was made up mainly of the parenting practices of your next door neighbour, your NCT course leader, your family members with DC, the books you were reading, maybe a few MN threads debating sleep training vs cosleeping.

Today, if you're on social media and the algorithm gets hold of the fact that you're a parent (esp a mum) at all, the volume of the batshit social media messages drowns out any kind of moderating effect from RL anecdotes/observations/experience. And there's a much lower bar for anybody wanting to create parenting social media content than somebody writing and publishing an entire book, or creating a name for themselves as an expert on TV/radio. It's become the norm now, so rather than ask for book recommendations, people ask for online course recommendations because every influencer is selling an overpriced video course which claims to have all the answers (they don't, of course) and it's become normalised.

Anyway all of this is a very long way to say that while I don't think it's as dire as the media tries to make out, parenting has become more passive and child centred in many ways because parents are increasingly being fed a load of slop which discourages actual involved parenting, to the point that a lot of parents are afraid to push issues with their DC in case it causes them discomfort, or because they have been sold a lie that it's somehow "better" or more organic if children do things for themselves, but as a result it tends to lead to DC who have excessive screen use and less time spent on more useful activities. I wouldn't even be surprised if media apps are detecting where multiple devices are being used to access the same account or in the same household at the same time and somehow sync both content which encourages passivity around parenting, and addictive screen based content for the DC at the same time, so that if parents try to change their DC's habits it becomes even more difficult and so the media companies win with more view time from both parent and child. I would have thought that was a mad conspiracy a few months ago, but I'm not convinced it's all that unrealistic now. It certainly wouldn't be impossible or hard for these patterns to be detected (though it might be more of a coincidence, and it's more that tech-addicted parents are tech-lax for their DC?)

So yes, I don't think it's especially surprising that parents could get to age 3.8 and have only had one half hearted attempt at potty training. You're right that it is their responsibility, but equally I expect it wouldn't be that difficult to train DC if you prefer that to changing nappies. Only you really know whether it's likely to be a wake up call to DB and SIL which might make them think oh, maybe DC is capable of more than we'd realised, or whether they are likely to think "Brilliant, completely escaped a nasty job, AmpleFish will do all the hard parts of parenting for us!!"

Lots of interesting things in your post, I completely agree.

I’d also like to add that say 5 years ago I was hearing a LOT of the child-led, “wait until they’re ready, wait for their cues” type advice from SW, HV and other HCPs (not just given to me personally, and I’m glad I had the life experience to ignore it, but due to my work and some volunteering at the time I was present when lots of new mothers were getting advice from HCPs, especially disadvantaged mothers). On potty training but also a whole range of parenting issues. I don’t hear it so much at all now, but I definitely did from about 10 years ago to 5 years ago. It’s a bit much to place the blame solely at parents’ doors, especially if they were already vulnerable families and ime that meant they were likely to take the last HCP they saw’s word as gospel. If I think of, for example, a very young mum with no family support, likely not very well educated, who waited “until their child was ready” because that’s what her HV told her to do, I can hardly feel much blame for her. Especially when I think of how many of these mothers were involved with SS and so would be scared to go against whatever they’d been told.

I do think useless, lazy parents exist, I’ve seen plenty. But it’s not the entire story for every family with this issue.

As I say, I have seen that most HVs and other HCPs no longer give this type of advice, but it was definitely prevalent enough that I noticed it years ago.

takealettermsjones · 03/11/2026 09:57

The irony of saying your BIL/SIL have no backbone! Potty training is a hell of a lot harder than chucking the bottle in the bin. The former requires backbone plus a lot of legwork. The latter only requires backbone. Take the log out of your own eye OP.

BertieBotts · 03/11/2026 10:00

I would add that I think often the social media drip drip of unhelpful parenting narratives is subtle but it creates a bias towards ideas like "It's better for them to do it in their own time" and "There's no point pushing a child until they are ready" and possibly an expectation of perfection or instant gratification, making people think if it's not instantly working, then they should stop, or encouraging use of unclear communication (because of wanting to avoid shame/negativity) which often sets DC up to fail. Combined with a natural human tendency to want to avoid unnecessary effort/conflict (which can also be personality based) it can lead to a state where you're thinking ah well it will happen eventually, worry about creating pressure in case it harms DC, or have several failed attempts and genuinely be at a loss to know what to do differently.

In the past there was much more overt judgement/pressure from outside to have a child toilet trained certainly before their third birthday, although not necessarily without accidents. For example DS1's nursery (preschool) would not accept children in nappies. They didn't have nappy changing facilities, as they were based in a school. This is not acceptable any more due to disability laws, which is a good thing for the DC who need this, but has removed that particular source of pressure on parents of DC who do not. It's tricky because barely any child who has the combination of being able to attend mainstream nursery/school but has needs impacting continence has an official diagnosis by the age of 3, so tying it to something official is not workable and it probably is the better way overall not to exclude children who need accommodation in this way.

Anyway I really really don't think it's as simple as laziness or fashion in terms of parenting trends. I think the majority of parents are doing the best they know how to do. I think the quality of advice and support is massively degraded and I think we need much more IRL contact both with "official" services like HV (family hubs sound great and I am glad they are being reintroduced) and with other parents and maybe we need to talk about the messages that we get from social media and actively counter some of these narratives which have become embedded into the norms we have about parenting today.

Restlessdreams1994 · 03/11/2026 10:01

You made a judgy comment about his parenting dressed up as “a joke” so I’m not surprised he got arsey with you.

I have a close relative who constantly does this and it’s horrible being on the receiving end. I wouldn’t mind if they had an issue and raised it in a caring and supportive way but it’s just repeated digs and snarky comments. Maybe think about why you felt the need to say that and whether that’s the kind of person you want to be, and let them worry about the potty training.

Looneytune253 · 03/11/2026 10:02

I can’t quite believe the hypocrisy in this thread once I’ve read your own DS has A BOTTLE at FOUR years of age. That’s 3 years behind ‘schedule’. That is shocking. You’ll happily judge your brother but don’t like it when people judge you for this. Jeez I’ve heard it all now.

To be fair I think you’re right in that the little one should have been trained but I also think that you are the last person that should be judging in this scenario. You both need your heads clanging together!!

OneShyQuail · 03/11/2026 10:02

@AmpleFish you really need to ditch that bottle for his teeth, jaw structure and emotional resilliance. Comfort comes from other places not just a bottle. Its in his best interests.

Your brother and his wife need to sort their act out too.

These poor children hampered by their parent's laziness/inadequacies 🙄

Soontoomuch · 03/11/2026 10:05

I never had to train my DD. She said she wanted to use the potty (Boxing Day) with lots of rellos around and in the sitting room! Lots of clapping and cheering as potty was full of both! She decided then that there wasn't enough audience until her 2nd birthday, 4 weeks later. Then never went back to nappies.

SapphireOpal · 03/11/2026 10:11

The fucking cheek of you commenting on other people's "lazy" parenting when you think it's appropriate to give a school aged child a baby bottle 😂

InSlovakiaTheCapitalOfCourseIsBratislava · 03/11/2026 10:11

Do it and prove him wrong (but don’t let on you’re trying until it’s worked)

Swipe left for the next trending thread