Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to think of you're re-gifting you should at least put a bit of effort into presentation?

41 replies

MrsDeaconClaybourne · 02/11/2026 20:21

Happy to be told I'm being precious and to get a grip etc etc but aibu to be a bit hurt by this?

Received a birthday gift recently that was so obviously a regift - imagine someone telling you they're going on a diet and need to clear their cupboards then giving you a random collection of biscuits and chocolates. I wouldn't even mind that - they were nice things - but literally just random stuff shoved in a (posh!) carrier bag. No wrapping, no ribbon, tissue or anything personal at all - just like they'd emptied a shelf into the bag.

I'm not really someone who makes a fuss about birthdays or anything but it just feels so thoughtless. If they'd just given me one of the items in a nice bag with a tag and a bow I'd not have given it another thought. It's.a close friend - no money worries. It's made me a bit sad - do I need to just get over myself?

OP posts:
Vitrolinsanity · 02/11/2026 20:52

Bit shit granted but why are you giving this any further thought than putting the kettle on, scoffing the biscuits and downgrading them to a Bayliss gift set with no bow for Christmas 😆

MrsDeaconClaybourne · 02/11/2026 21:03

Vitrolinsanity · 02/11/2026 20:52

Bit shit granted but why are you giving this any further thought than putting the kettle on, scoffing the biscuits and downgrading them to a Bayliss gift set with no bow for Christmas 😆

I think I just feel a bit taken for granted in several relationships at the moment - just middle age no big back story so it's touched a nerve and hurt my feelings! Less effort going forward is good advice. Thank you 😊

OP posts:
Wavebreaker8 · 02/11/2026 21:15

I was regifted the exact toiletries collection I had given to a relative for her birthday several months prior. The store discontinued the range shortly after I'd bought her's so knew she couldn't have bought it specially for me and it most certainly wasn't a money issue as she is loaded. At least if you are going to regift, then don't give it back to the sender. It is hurtful when there is so little effort OP. X

redskyAtNigh · 02/11/2026 21:31

They thought you might like the items and gave them to you.
It sounds like they gave you the gift personally so they spent their time coming to see you.

So your view is that giving you a gift + coming to see you = no thought
but putting the gift in a gift bag with a ribbon = thought and personal?

Wavebreaker8 · 02/11/2026 21:41

redskyAtNigh · 02/11/2026 21:31

They thought you might like the items and gave them to you.
It sounds like they gave you the gift personally so they spent their time coming to see you.

So your view is that giving you a gift + coming to see you = no thought
but putting the gift in a gift bag with a ribbon = thought and personal?

Or they didn't think the OP might like them but instead needed a gift so stuck the contents of their decluttered cupboard into a bag with a "this will have to do" attitude. At least taking some time to wrap the items would have shown an element of thoughtfulness and care for the OP. 🤷

MrsDeaconClaybourne · 02/11/2026 21:48

redskyAtNigh · 02/11/2026 21:31

They thought you might like the items and gave them to you.
It sounds like they gave you the gift personally so they spent their time coming to see you.

So your view is that giving you a gift + coming to see you = no thought
but putting the gift in a gift bag with a ribbon = thought and personal?

They didn't come to see me - they gave it to me at a night out we were all going to in advance. I then opened it on the day. I don't think there was any though beyond MrsDeacon eats biscuits - here are some biscuits they'll do. They weren't something I particularly like. The example of ribbon etc was just a suggestion of a way of making a gift feel a bit personal not that I'm actually bothered about that in itself.

OP posts:
Iloveitalianfoodyum · 02/11/2026 21:48

I would feel the same at the obvious low effort gift. Some people just don’t think!

I once received from my brothers girlfriend a shower gel and soap gift set where the seal had been removed from the shower gel lid and it looked 3/4 full - and the soap that I assume had once been wrapped in paper or something was just loose in the bag with scratches on it.

MrsDeaconClaybourne · 02/11/2026 21:49

Wavebreaker8 · 02/11/2026 21:41

Or they didn't think the OP might like them but instead needed a gift so stuck the contents of their decluttered cupboard into a bag with a "this will have to do" attitude. At least taking some time to wrap the items would have shown an element of thoughtfulness and care for the OP. 🤷

Aw thank you. That's expressed what I was trying to say better than I did! ❤

OP posts:
redskyAtNigh · 02/11/2026 22:03

MrsDeaconClaybourne · 02/11/2026 21:48

They didn't come to see me - they gave it to me at a night out we were all going to in advance. I then opened it on the day. I don't think there was any though beyond MrsDeacon eats biscuits - here are some biscuits they'll do. They weren't something I particularly like. The example of ribbon etc was just a suggestion of a way of making a gift feel a bit personal not that I'm actually bothered about that in itself.

So they gave you a gift (that you seem to like) and spent time with you?

I'd appreciate a friend doing both of these things.
I wouldn't value the friend any more becuase she'd spent a bit of time wrapping the present in nice paper (or whatever).

"love languages" gets over mentioned but this does sound like a prime example.
You wanted something that your friend didn't realise was important to you.

Cleo65 · 02/11/2026 22:05

I've got a close someone who does this, she's even told me about the box she keeps especially for stuff she's received & doesn't want.
Every birthday & Christmas I carefully choose something for her - & I get a regifted gift bag full of regifted unwrapped crap. Socks with budgies on, a joke book about guinea pigs, an ornamental flamingo etc etc....
This year I've said we should stop with presents altogether & treat each other to 'an experience' eg afternoon tea, a nice brunch out or even a beach picnic .... fortunately she agreed!

MrsDeaconClaybourne · 02/11/2026 22:22

redskyAtNigh · 02/11/2026 22:03

So they gave you a gift (that you seem to like) and spent time with you?

I'd appreciate a friend doing both of these things.
I wouldn't value the friend any more becuase she'd spent a bit of time wrapping the present in nice paper (or whatever).

"love languages" gets over mentioned but this does sound like a prime example.
You wanted something that your friend didn't realise was important to you.

It's more that it's a collection of random generic stuff rather than anything I particularly like. If it had been ooh, we've got a box of those biscuits MrsD really likes we might as well give her those then put them in a bag with say, a mug because she drinks a lot of tea or fluffy socks because she's always cold it would have showed some thought. It's more like MrsD eats food - here's some (admittedly nice) food in a bag. Like a PP we do often just do a joint experience or nice meal out instead of gifts but when I do buy a gift I try and put at least a bit of thought into it to make it personal.

OP posts:
greenmacchiato · 03/11/2026 03:00

The gift should be decent looking, I agree, but it also depends on what do we call "decent". I'm so so bad at wrapping that I never bother and always give out gifts put in nicer bags. Some things are being regifted, that's true, but I make sure their boxes look good, the tags are in place, etc. I don't thing rhe lack of wrapping makes the gift looking worse than, but telling you you were given something the giver doesn't want is yikes.

Tamtim · 03/11/2026 03:04

No effort - just don’t bother at all is what I think. I’d rather not receive a gift.

MyManinCaracas · 03/11/2026 03:10

I’ve never regifted anything and don’t understand the mindset of trying to pass it off as something you thought they would like and so you went out and bought it. It’s like fraud. Gifts under false pretences 😆

furrysocks · 03/11/2026 06:36

Well, that’s someone to strike off your present buying list. Clearly it doesn’t matter to them so just save your money.

redskyAtNigh · 03/11/2026 07:33

MrsDeaconClaybourne · 02/11/2026 22:22

It's more that it's a collection of random generic stuff rather than anything I particularly like. If it had been ooh, we've got a box of those biscuits MrsD really likes we might as well give her those then put them in a bag with say, a mug because she drinks a lot of tea or fluffy socks because she's always cold it would have showed some thought. It's more like MrsD eats food - here's some (admittedly nice) food in a bag. Like a PP we do often just do a joint experience or nice meal out instead of gifts but when I do buy a gift I try and put at least a bit of thought into it to make it personal.

You see - this is what I mean about "love languages".

I'm not a person whose "love language" is gifts. I wouldn't consider a box of biscuits (that I like) and a mug (because I drink a lot of tea) to show any particular thought. They both just sound like generic gifts and I probably get given a lot of both of them. I don't consider wrapping it in pretty paper or adding a ribbon to show any particular more thought, just that the giver is one who thinks that presents should be wrapped (I couldn't care less). I might actually prefer a random selection of stuff because there is a good chance that there are things in there that I've not tried before.

I do appreciate people spending time with me, so I'd be happy that the friend went on a night out. And I'd be pleased to know that the friend thought of me when she was clearing out the random things in the cupboard.

Like I say, different people prioritise different things. Maybe tell your friend how you feel, so she can get it "right" next time? If she's like me, she probably thought she got it right this time.

Ella31 · 03/11/2026 09:28

I dont mind regifting at all, I dont do it personally as I'm paranoid someone will judge me. The oddest one I got was a baby gift from my neighbour when my son was born. They had a baby boy the year before and they dropped in a gift bag. The babygro tag had a lovely message to their now 1 year old son, as did the gift bag and the greeting card in the bag. I'd say they never checked it, just grabbed and gave it to me. The card had been opened though. I've yet to hand it back as I'm as uncomfortable as they would surely be if I did. I think the lack of effort irked me. We had given them a lovely gift the year before. Nothing pricey, just thoughtful.

Bleachedjeans · 03/11/2026 10:22

MyManinCaracas · 03/11/2026 03:10

I’ve never regifted anything and don’t understand the mindset of trying to pass it off as something you thought they would like and so you went out and bought it. It’s like fraud. Gifts under false pretences 😆

I agree. I have given away unwanted gifts but I say something like ‘X gave me this but it doesn’t suit me/I won’t use it - would you like it?’ I don’t pretend it’s a gift.
My DHs cheapskate daughter regifts. A few years ago, for my birthday just after Christmas, she gave the exact gift my daughter had given her for Christmas.
I said, in a cheerful voice, ‘Oh, thank you! This is what my DD gave you for Christmas! I’m so glad it’s not been wasted’
😄

Wavebreaker8 · 03/11/2026 16:32

@Bleachedjeans

"My DHs cheapskate daughter regifts. A few years ago, for my birthday just after Christmas, she gave the exact gift my daughter had given her for Christmas.
I said, in a cheerful voice, ‘Oh, thank you! This is what my DD gave you for Christmas! I’m so glad it’s not been wasted"

Love it! 😂😂😂😂
Yes, I am very much in agreement with those who think regifting is a cheapskate thing to do. To give away a gift because you don't want to see it wasted is fair enough but to use it as an actual gift for someone to avoid having to put some thought into it and spending money is a huge NO for me. Just awful!

zingally · 03/11/2026 16:42

The last time I regifted something was a bottle of Disarono liquor. I'd tried it at a friends house perhaps a year before, and expressed to her then that I didn't like it. But then she weirdly got me a bottle of it for my birthday! I was confused, but never mind.
I decided to re-gift it to someone else for a 50th birthday party at her house. But I made sure I wrapped it up extra nicely, so as not to feel guilty!

Personally, I'm not massively bothered about a slightly shit gift... I just adjust my effort for next time! Case in point is my BIL, who earns a six-figure salary, last Christmas got me an £8 box of supermarket chocolates in a brand and type I'd never once expressed any interest in.
I earn probably a quarter of what he does, but had spent at least 3x what he did. But no problem, this year I've already bought him some chocs. Spent £5.

ClaredeBear · 03/11/2026 16:49

I regift but only as an additional gift, rather than then a the main affair. And I level the gift with the name of the person who gave it to me! I’d certainly be careful that it dated well and wasn’t half opened etc.

ClaredeBear · 03/11/2026 16:54

zingally · 03/11/2026 16:42

The last time I regifted something was a bottle of Disarono liquor. I'd tried it at a friends house perhaps a year before, and expressed to her then that I didn't like it. But then she weirdly got me a bottle of it for my birthday! I was confused, but never mind.
I decided to re-gift it to someone else for a 50th birthday party at her house. But I made sure I wrapped it up extra nicely, so as not to feel guilty!

Personally, I'm not massively bothered about a slightly shit gift... I just adjust my effort for next time! Case in point is my BIL, who earns a six-figure salary, last Christmas got me an £8 box of supermarket chocolates in a brand and type I'd never once expressed any interest in.
I earn probably a quarter of what he does, but had spent at least 3x what he did. But no problem, this year I've already bought him some chocs. Spent £5.

Oh I know what happened there. She just associated you with that drink because she remembered you saying something about it. Classic me.

MrsDeaconClaybourne · 03/11/2026 16:56

I genuinely wouldn't mind a regift if any thought had gone into it at all. If it had been we have X that Mrs loves and we don't want them win-win 😁

I work in a school and often get prosecco as a gift..I occasionally regift as it's not my favourite but always with, say a nice glass or fancy chocolate or something personal, and only to people who I know it's something they enjoy drinking. This was the equivalent of giving it to someone who mainly drinks beer and chucking in a best teacher mug.

OP posts:
WhatNoRaisins · 03/11/2026 17:07

I think when this sort of thing happens it's time for the "shall we stop bothering with gifts and just do xyz or even nothing at all?" conversation. Not all gifting brings joy to the people involved.

Rajjam · 03/11/2026 17:09

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.