Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To prefer my in-laws after having a baby?

7 replies

Babybear260 · 02/11/2026 10:38

Having a bit of a realisation about my parents and it’s making me feel quite sad, if I’m honest.
I’ve started to notice that a lot of what my parents say and do seems to be more about appearances than actually following through. I don’t doubt that they love me or their grandson, but I’m beginning to question how much of their apparent enthusiasm and support is genuine in practice.
For example, when we’re on the phone, they’re always talking about what lovely, involved grandparents they’ll be and how much they want to do with him. But when we’re actually here, my mum won’t really get down and play with him. She doesn’t really get involved with the feeding or bathing. She’ll say she can’t get back up again despite being perfectly healthy and going to Zumba classss?! My dad has arthritis, so I appreciate it’s a bit different for him.
I’ve noticed my mum also never offers to change his nappy. It sounds ridiculous to focus on something so small, but it was only when my MIL was visiting and I made a passing joke about my mum never having changed his nappy that she suddenly jumped up and did it. My MIL is very hands-on, and I almost felt my mum was conscious of how that looked in comparison.
It’s not just about the baby, either. Before I got married, my parents would regularly talk in front of other people about how they’d help us with the wedding and a house deposit. When it actually came to it, there was no real follow-through. I’ve started to see a pattern of big statements and promises, but very little substance behind them. My husband noticed before me.
What’s making me question things even more is that I’ve always found my MIL quite overwhelming. I feel guilty that I’d complain about her to my mother. She can message me about seemingly obvious things, remind me to do things etc, and I’ve sometimes interpreted that as her thinking I’m stupid or perhaps not liking me very much.
But I’m starting to wonder whether I’ve actually got her completely wrong. She is genuinely hands-on, thinks about us and our baby, wants to help and does things without needing an audience or anyone to notice. She doesn’t just talk about being a good grandmother, she actually makes an effort. But she IS incredibly overbearing (if I don’t message for a few hours she will phone me loads worried about us for example) but I’m starting to think that might be better than ‘fake’ parents
I almost feel guilty that I’ve gravitated towards staying with my parents on this trip rather than my MIL. Perhaps because my parents are my parents, I’ve always assumed they’d be the more natural source of comfort and support. But I’m beginning to question that.
I suppose I’m realising that someone can be an incredibly overbearing and still genuinely care, whereas someone else can say all the right things and not actually show up in the ways that matter. And as I’m reflecting on this, my parents have been this way my entire life.
Has anyone else experienced this? Am I being unfair to my parents, or is this just a case of finally seeing a difference between what people say and what they actually do?

Of course it doesn’t have to involve some big fall out and there are far worse grandparents out there but it’s just a reflection

OP posts:
Eggplant19 · 02/11/2026 10:49

My parents are the same!! It is a sad realisation…. It’s just ‘people’ in general I suppose. Don’t feel bad about your MIL, it is natural to ‘gravitate’ to your own parents but it doesn’t mean you can’t reflect and realise that actually maybe your husbands mother might be more helpful for you and your baby!

It’s incredibly common so don’t worry OP!

Lexibletheflexible · 02/11/2026 10:51

I think maybe you've realised that humans are multifaceted individuals and your parents and in laws are human

Kirschcherries · 02/11/2026 10:55

I think part of growing up is seeing your parents as human with failings. It’s not something you always realise when the indicators are very subtle so it can be a long time before things click into place.

Integrating two families often exposes differences and different approaches. Neither is right or wrong, just different.

Your MIL can be caring but also overbearing but understanding it comes from a place of love helps manage it.

Your parents in the other hand don’t always live up to their statements. Knowing not to believe everything they say helps to avoid disappointment.

WRT your parents I wouldn’t change what you do but as you found out saying Mums never changed a nappy in front of her yielded a change in behaviour. Subtle responses to your parents saying things they are unlikely to carry through may stop the over promising/failing to deliver.

ChocolateApples · 02/11/2026 10:58

"I suppose I’m realising that someone can be an incredibly overbearing and still genuinely care, whereas someone else can say all the right things and not actually show up in the ways that matter."

I think this is the crux of it. And it's not even necessarily wrong. People are different and their strengths - being caring and involved - will always have their downsides - being a bit overbearing. And when the latter frustrates you it can be good to remind yourself of the good side of it.

People talk about the village and it's real value, but often forget about the slightly claustrophobic aspect of it.

And I too would feel a bit disappointed in my parents talking the talk only.

Itsthewoluff · 02/11/2026 10:59

Perfection would be the middle ground.

Just as an aside though, I’m fairly fit and go to the gym but I do find it fairly difficult to get up off the floor. I’d prefer to sit at a little table or something.

Peachghost · 02/11/2026 11:01

I think youre being a bit silly about the zumba classes - there is no sitting/laying on the floor in a zumba class - so your mum doing zumba doesnt mean she's lying about being concerned at getting up off the floor.

As for the rest of it, it sadly sounds like your parents care more about how their are perceived by others and are then making commitments to you that they break. If your ILs are the type to get stuck in and deliver on their promises then its natural you would lean more towards them.

Tortephant · 02/11/2026 11:25

Embrace MIL support and show your appreciation too. Nothing wrong in feeling closer to her, or more respect for her, than your parents.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page