Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To hope that the UK adopts sharenting laws.

84 replies

Traitorousurges · 01/11/2026 22:27

France and some other countries have made it a parental responsibility to protect a child's likeness and dignity. It means that parents can be challenged and legally held responsible for what they post online about their child. Their child's image is not theirs to use but a protective duty to the child.

Would you like to see the same here?

YABU - no harm in parents posting pics and vids of their child.

YANBU - some parents take it too far and a legal responsibility to protect their child's dignity is sensible.

OP posts:
LivelyAquaPoster · 02/11/2026 10:15

Traitorousurges · 02/11/2026 10:12

It can be a helpful thing for the adults but does that justify the intrusive kids and pics of children? Discussions happen here and communities can form without exposing people.

It's the false dilemma rhetoric that is so widespread in any discussion.

Absolutely, community can be had without exposing children online.

Traitorousurges · 02/11/2026 10:16

lljkk · 02/11/2026 09:05

Sounds like something to do with sharia law, bad name.

I didn't name it.

OP posts:
Lexibletheflexible · 02/11/2026 10:17

Traitorousurges · 02/11/2026 10:12

It can be a helpful thing for the adults but does that justify the intrusive kids and pics of children? Discussions happen here and communities can form without exposing people.

Adults raise children.

Would I share the day to day struggles of me rasing my children? No. Because in all honesty, the only stuff that would get views would be the times where I feel hard done by in some sense. We have our struggles as a family, but in many ways they are common ones with no extraordinary situations where I could really inform or teach anyone about something that lacks awareness.

I couldn't bring anything particularly new either in my ability to connect with a wider audience, nor in terms of visibility.

I think its different if you can do those things.

Traitorousurges · 02/11/2026 10:18

Lexibletheflexible · 02/11/2026 07:02

But who decides what is fine and what isn't?

When it comes to things like ND or dementia, I can see both sides. On one hand, yes, the person has a right to privacy. Some people overshare.

On the other, there are some people who are caring for people who have incredibly complex needs and lack the cognition to be aware of what other people might think of them.

I think in a global level, a lot of good has come from our ability to share stories in the way that we do, and yes that includes videos. For instance, people in less developed countries who are able to see what autism looks like in a verbal child with average educational attainment.

How much right does the adult/carer have to share their world of which the person being cared features heavily? What about when your caring duties have become your entire world?

I don't have an issue with sharing of your life but that is separate even if entwined with the vulnerable persons life.

Making a video saying I am exhausted or that x happened and it was hard to cope with fine. Why does the vulnerable person need to be filmed?

OP posts:
Traitorousurges · 02/11/2026 10:19

Lexibletheflexible · 02/11/2026 10:17

Adults raise children.

Would I share the day to day struggles of me rasing my children? No. Because in all honesty, the only stuff that would get views would be the times where I feel hard done by in some sense. We have our struggles as a family, but in many ways they are common ones with no extraordinary situations where I could really inform or teach anyone about something that lacks awareness.

I couldn't bring anything particularly new either in my ability to connect with a wider audience, nor in terms of visibility.

I think its different if you can do those things.

But does that over ride a child or vulnerable persons right to privacy and dignity?

OP posts:
Lexibletheflexible · 02/11/2026 10:25

Traitorousurges · 02/11/2026 10:18

I don't have an issue with sharing of your life but that is separate even if entwined with the vulnerable persons life.

Making a video saying I am exhausted or that x happened and it was hard to cope with fine. Why does the vulnerable person need to be filmed?

I think at times to show "this is what X looks like in this specific situation". I have some insight into how autism is becoming more recognised as a wide spectrum in the Caribbean and for a lot of parents there who have fought for their children to be diagnosed and supported, social media from the UK and US have been vital in the parents becoming informed enough to understand their child. Sometimes it has been key in them accepting an ND diagnosis from local professionals.

That's been especially the case when say the content is from a Black Caribbean family in the UK so it has a cultural context as well.

C8H10N4O2 · 02/11/2026 10:26

JustFrustrated · 02/11/2026 06:59

No. The PP is sick of the state removing free choice.

in the same way freedom of speech doesn’t mean freedom from consequence…

Given the fact the courts can’t keep up with actual crime… how is this going to be policed?

I don’t really use SM, and post even more infrequently, and whilst my children have it… they’ve never posted either…

I still think this is overreach. I also don’t agree with banning all SM for under 16s though, and even less so now I’m hearing how they plan on policing it…

Just on this point:

in the same way freedom of speech doesn’t mean freedom from consequence…

This is an argument which has been used by dominant groups to silence minorities and disadvantaged groups since forever. If you cannot speak for fear of consequences then you don't have free speech

The debate should be around the boundaries - eg your right to free speech classically does not extend to shouting "fire" for funsies in a crowded theatre but should enable you to express legal, if repugnant, views without fear of serious repercussions such as losing your job, being assaulted or being imprisoned.

Lexibletheflexible · 02/11/2026 10:26

Traitorousurges · 02/11/2026 10:19

But does that over ride a child or vulnerable persons right to privacy and dignity?

As I said, I think it's very individual. There are definitely times when I agree it is ethical despite the complexity. Other cases, 100% not necessary.

LivelyAquaPoster · 02/11/2026 10:32

Especially given AI technologies now, I'm surprised there doesn't seem more of a consensus on the seriousness of the subject here.

Anything can be done with images and sound (voices), anything! Without the affected person having any control over it. So, so scary.

JustFrustrated · 02/11/2026 10:55

C8H10N4O2 · 02/11/2026 10:26

Just on this point:

in the same way freedom of speech doesn’t mean freedom from consequence…

This is an argument which has been used by dominant groups to silence minorities and disadvantaged groups since forever. If you cannot speak for fear of consequences then you don't have free speech

The debate should be around the boundaries - eg your right to free speech classically does not extend to shouting "fire" for funsies in a crowded theatre but should enable you to express legal, if repugnant, views without fear of serious repercussions such as losing your job, being assaulted or being imprisoned.

Edited

I agree with you btw.

Traitorousurges · 02/11/2026 11:02

Lexibletheflexible · 02/11/2026 10:26

As I said, I think it's very individual. There are definitely times when I agree it is ethical despite the complexity. Other cases, 100% not necessary.

When would you feel it is ethical? I want to understand your stance as I actually am genuinely asking for opinions and to make me think of things I haven't considered.

OP posts:
Lexibletheflexible · 02/11/2026 11:13

Traitorousurges · 02/11/2026 11:02

When would you feel it is ethical? I want to understand your stance as I actually am genuinely asking for opinions and to make me think of things I haven't considered.

As I said, I think it's very individual. But if I was going to have to put some sort of guideline, I'd say that someone who maintains the ability to give or withdraw consent for themselves (or is likely to do so when they come of age) should be treated with extreme caution when it comes to this.

By that, I can give the example of a child with moderate support needs but has that capacity who wants their parent to remove YT videos of them as a baby showing "stimming" which was genuinely uploaded for educational purposes. The parent should always adhere to the child's request as being able to request that shows a level of capacity that I deem sufficient to decide.

Overall, I think all content of this nature should be decided by the question "what is this adding?".

I'll turn it back on you.

A 15 year old ND person is having a major conflict of some sort with their parents. Both the parents and the teen are filming with their phones.The teen wants to show how ND teens are misunderstood by their parents while the parents want to show their challenges with parenting an ND teen for educational and support building purposes. Both have pretty much the same intentions when it comes to why they want to upload their footage on SM.

Who is ethcially allowed to do so?

ExpectMore · 02/11/2026 11:25

JHound · 01/11/2026 23:31

I think this is just nanny state-ism.

This

Periperi2025 · 02/11/2026 13:49

What really annoys me is parents sharing their childrens confidential medical infomation publicly online. It is not there infomation to share and any decision they make in this context should be inline with best interest decision making.
Is it in the childs benefit?
Can it wait until the child is old enough to make that informed decision themselves?

I frequently call it out on news & social media articles.

I remember one recently about a girl with precocious puberty, her name, picture, talk about her periods at 4 years old, all plastered over the internet for all eternity - poor girl, as if her childhood isn't going to be hard enough already.

Snorlaxo · 02/11/2026 14:03

A 15 year old ND person is having a major conflict of some sort with their parents. Both the parents and the teen are filming with their phones.The teen wants to show how ND teens are misunderstood by their parents while the parents want to show their challenges with parenting an ND teen for educational and support building purposes. Both have pretty much the same intentions when it comes to why they want to upload their footage on SM.
Who is ethcially allowed to do so?

People who post this kind of content (arguments) are usually looking for strangers to say that they are right rather than posting for “educational and support building purposes.” (I am obviously assuming that the video is anonymised with blurred faces etc)

I imagine that a child (especially a teen) would be teased at school for kicking off at their parent with others repeating what they said, did etc Algorithms have a way of reaching local people and it take some person to recognise the child.

Taking a video as a personal record is acceptable. Sometimes people are gaslit with details that didn’t happen or they might have been so angry in the moment that they need to replay the video to remind themselves of details.

I think that neither should post. I’ve not been the subject of that kind of video but I can only imagine how it feels to read comments about yourself. IME videos with arguments often have comments like “If that were my child then I’d smack them” / “The parents should be reported to SS” There’s been lots of cases or concerned people reporting parents to SS because of people’s opinions of them.

There is a case for educational videos eg how to distinguish between a tantrum and autistic meltdown but it shouldn’t be monetised and used as entertainment (rage bait)

Traitorousurges · 02/11/2026 14:43

Lexibletheflexible · 02/11/2026 11:13

As I said, I think it's very individual. But if I was going to have to put some sort of guideline, I'd say that someone who maintains the ability to give or withdraw consent for themselves (or is likely to do so when they come of age) should be treated with extreme caution when it comes to this.

By that, I can give the example of a child with moderate support needs but has that capacity who wants their parent to remove YT videos of them as a baby showing "stimming" which was genuinely uploaded for educational purposes. The parent should always adhere to the child's request as being able to request that shows a level of capacity that I deem sufficient to decide.

Overall, I think all content of this nature should be decided by the question "what is this adding?".

I'll turn it back on you.

A 15 year old ND person is having a major conflict of some sort with their parents. Both the parents and the teen are filming with their phones.The teen wants to show how ND teens are misunderstood by their parents while the parents want to show their challenges with parenting an ND teen for educational and support building purposes. Both have pretty much the same intentions when it comes to why they want to upload their footage on SM.

Who is ethcially allowed to do so?

Neither. No one has the right to upload someone else's image without their consent, who can consent, would be my ethics.

If the person can't consent, a young baby for example, then I would say that images going to known people are acceptable as long as they do not invade privacy or dignity.

OP posts:
Lexibletheflexible · 02/11/2026 15:16

Traitorousurges · 02/11/2026 14:43

Neither. No one has the right to upload someone else's image without their consent, who can consent, would be my ethics.

If the person can't consent, a young baby for example, then I would say that images going to known people are acceptable as long as they do not invade privacy or dignity.

What if I feel the other person is somehow violating my boundaries or even committing a crime against me?

RedTagAlan · 02/11/2026 16:01

Traitorousurges · 02/11/2026 14:43

Neither. No one has the right to upload someone else's image without their consent, who can consent, would be my ethics.

If the person can't consent, a young baby for example, then I would say that images going to known people are acceptable as long as they do not invade privacy or dignity.

Not according to the law as I posted above. The image belongs to the photographer, not the model.

It goes back to the UN charter on human rights, freedom of expression.

Periperi2025 · 02/11/2026 16:17

RedTagAlan · 02/11/2026 16:01

Not according to the law as I posted above. The image belongs to the photographer, not the model.

It goes back to the UN charter on human rights, freedom of expression.

But the law also covers your right to privacy in a private place, so I think a photographer can take a photo in a public place and the image belongs to them. But in a private place it is a grey area, because they would only be able to take that image with your permission, and if the person is to young to consent to that then you get in to 'best interest' territory, and is it in the best interest of a anyone to have naked baby photos of themself on the internet forever?

Boomer55 · 02/11/2026 16:21

I would have thought that France, and other countries, have bigger things to worry about. 🙄

Traitorousurges · 02/11/2026 16:24

RedTagAlan · 02/11/2026 16:01

Not according to the law as I posted above. The image belongs to the photographer, not the model.

It goes back to the UN charter on human rights, freedom of expression.

I did say would be my ethics. I am aware this is not the law.

OP posts:
Floristian · 02/11/2026 16:26

OP can you post some details of this new legislation, I can't find it anywhere.

Traitorousurges · 02/11/2026 16:27

Lexibletheflexible · 02/11/2026 15:16

What if I feel the other person is somehow violating my boundaries or even committing a crime against me?

Sorry I didn't understand the context of that remark. Do you mean to ask if I feel you have the right to share video or images if someone is acting against you?

With the police sure. On the Internet no.

OP posts:
Traitorousurges · 02/11/2026 16:34

Floristian · 02/11/2026 16:26

OP can you post some details of this new legislation, I can't find it anywhere.

'Sharenting': Why is France trying to stop parents from oversharing their children's images online? | Euronews https://share.google/2KqSKvel6vNq9IruE

It isn't particularly recent might be why you are having trouble.

OP posts: