Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I let a man do this again. Someone tell me why?!?!

70 replies

Rainnsgyin · 01/11/2026 21:04

Late 30s, one DD age 7. Been single a few years after some shitty relationships. Met someone recently in ‘real life’ and not online. Thought it was very organic and natural. He’s in his forties, very respectful of my time with my DD, gave ALL the right signals, polite, good fun, you name it.

I was veryyyy cautious after being so happy with my life with DD but I had also begun to enjoy the affection and the interest in my day and so on.

Anyway… he was due to come round tonight (his request) just for an hug on his way home from a dinner. He’d been in touch today as usual this morning and let me know he was heading home after the dinner. No mention at all of stopping by as he’d said last night.

I probably sound clingy. It’s not so much him not coming round as it is that he said he wanted to, made a big thing of it, then ignores it like nothing has happened?! We were supposed to go for breakfast together tomorrow morning and I just messaged and said I would need to cancel and he said ok.

So that’s the end of that. I’m just ranting really. I can’t believe I got taken in by a man again, my first time getting back out that and why…! I feel hurt/upset just from how I feel I’ve been emotionally messed about. I’ll be fine, I’m posting as somewhere to vent and feel a bit miserable for a bit :)

OP posts:
Stormyrose · 01/11/2026 22:02

Rainnsgyin · 01/11/2026 21:56

It’s not the changing of the plan. It’s the fact he didn’t even say and then was completely not arsed about breakfast (I admit that was me testing the waters after the hug scenario).

He prob forgot and had other things on his mind.

Stormyrose · 01/11/2026 22:03

Rainnsgyin · 01/11/2026 21:56

It’s not the changing of the plan. It’s the fact he didn’t even say and then was completely not arsed about breakfast (I admit that was me testing the waters after the hug scenario).

What do you want, yoy said yoy need to cancel, he said ok, it’s not a big deal,

you are behaving oddly op.

ilbehonest · 01/11/2026 22:05

it's not needy and you have standards. you don't want someone who is flakey. he is flakey. you decided not to continue. sounds perfectly healthy to me. do what feels right and don't settle for anything less. good for you!

SunshineSpice · 01/11/2026 22:06

Get a bloody grip

Madamefroufrou · 01/11/2026 22:10

“stopping by?” for a hug? like a pitstop? he is in his forties?
when you are home alone with your daughter? When he has
been out to a ‘dinner’ and wants to come to your house to round
off the evening nicely by being physical with a lone woman

I wouldn’t say that was respectful, far from it

did you see him Friday or Saturday?

when he phones you OP you will not know where he is only
what he tells you

@smarmygram shrewd and prescient comment about manipulating
you into being
available is manifest in this aborted encounter - he didn’t need
to call in as now he knows you are available for late night hugs
he cn bide his time

You felt spurned and you were but tonight you are safe
No pointposters saying ‘trust your gut’ then lambasting you
for doing just that ?!?

No decent man would come to a woman’s house when she has
a child possibly not yet asleep for a ‘hug’
No decent man would compromise a woman in this way

No right thinking woman with a child in the house would phone
a man she hardly knows to ask “ hey where is my Hug?”

Personal safety, OP

remember the golden rules -
Words cost nothing - by his actions you will know him

PleaseDontStepOnTheDaisies · 01/11/2026 22:11

I think if this was me, and a new man had arranged to come round just "for a hug" after dinner (did he mean sex??) - I would've made as much effort getting ready as I would for a date. So I can see why you felt let down
But why didn't you just ask him? "Not coming round for a hug then?" - rather than just mysteriously cancelling breakfast to test him.
There could be numerous things at play here - maybe he's not serious about you, and you've done the right thing, but you could be better at communication too.

Druidsrealm · 01/11/2026 22:13

I understand the replies you are getting OP, but I am sure they feel harsh to you. You have clearly had difficult experiences with men in the past. Unfortunately, this can make new dating challenging.

Sometimes it can be helpful to think, am I reacting the way I am, because of my experiences in the past, or because of what is actually happening in front of me? I appreciate it sometimes it can be difficult to tell the difference between the two.

One of the most important things in any relationship or something that may be a relationship is communication.

When he said he wasn’t popping round, what could you have said, that felt right for you?
There is no wrong or right here, you are entitled to draw your boundaries where you like.

Options could have been –

– “I thought you were popping in tonight, everything okay”
– “no problem, see you at breakfast“
– “I am cancelling breakfast (unsaid -because I think you’re going to hurt me like men in my past). Current man will not know this is why you cancelled.

There are a lot of sub par men out there and it is good to have high standards.

Only you can know if you threw this one back a little too quick . . .

RochelleGoyle · 01/11/2026 22:19

People can be very harsh on here but I voted that YANBU. I understand why your feelings took a knock - you allowed yourself to enjoy it and relax a bit, and he let you down. Small things like this matter to me too. Having said that, if you like him, it's probably worth asking what happened - there may be a good reason, albeit I agree he should have acknowledged it. Good luck.

Uniqueusername3 · 01/11/2026 22:19

If someone said they were going out with friends and would come to my house after, at 9pm, for a hug on their way home. I'd think they were joking. It's like someone saying "I'll come over and warm you up" if you say you're chilly. And I'd be abit baffled if someone actually did it.

I'd assume that he didn't expect you to take him seriously.

Or you were driving it, he's a bit put out that you're being so needy to expect him to come hug you after he's had a night out. And now you're sulking and cancelling plans because he didn't and he's thought "fucking hell she's a bit much".

Yeah sorry I think this is a you problem, not a him problem.

DontyMon · 01/11/2026 22:20

Oh you poor thing. I think your reaction is due to your scar tissue OP. I wonder if you've had therapy to heal what happened in the past?
You cannot go into a relationship playing games or second guessing. It will fuck with your mind. So, when he's on his way home, you have to be completely open- "You said you were going to call- Has the plan changed?" No game playing, no drama.
And don't test him by doing stuff like cancelling on him, because he can't win. If he says he's upset because he wanted to see you, that's him putting pressure on you when you've been firm and told him your plans have changed. When he says that's no problem, you're a bit upset that he's respecting your boundaries! So you're setting up the drama there.
Loads of sympathy, I was like this for years. Totally messed with my head and heart. There's something terrible and addictive about dramas in a relationship and it's so unhealthy.

shhblackbag · 01/11/2026 22:24

Rainnsgyin · 01/11/2026 21:56

It’s not the changing of the plan. It’s the fact he didn’t even say and then was completely not arsed about breakfast (I admit that was me testing the waters after the hug scenario).

He accepted your decision. Was he supposed to moan about it?

He should have shown up as promised, or cancelled, but you're unreasonable for 'testing him'.

Rainnsgyin · 01/11/2026 22:25

I don’t know what to think now!!! I didn’t think I had over reacted. I don’t think there’s hope of it developing now after this anyway but perhaps it’s evident I’m not ready for a relationship

OP posts:
NotAnotherScarf · 01/11/2026 22:29

As a bloke I might not have come round because:
It was later than I intended it to be
It might have looked like I just wanted a shag when I don't want that type of relationship
I had dropped food all down me and looked dreadful
I was tired and wanted to get home
I forgot...I'm human
I needed to get home because I needed to do so and forgot to tell you

But why didn't you 'jokey' message me to ask why?

Rainnsgyin · 01/11/2026 22:32

@NotAnotherScarf is it fixable?

OP posts:
DewDropsAndCobWebs · 01/11/2026 22:32

Maybe it doesn't matter, but what were you hoping he would say when you told him breakfast was off the table (yes, bad pun intended!) ?
If he could have given the perfect reply, what would it have been?

Rainnsgyin · 01/11/2026 22:33

DewDropsAndCobWebs · 01/11/2026 22:32

Maybe it doesn't matter, but what were you hoping he would say when you told him breakfast was off the table (yes, bad pun intended!) ?
If he could have given the perfect reply, what would it have been?

@DewDropsAndCobWebs to ask if everything was ok and whether we could chat about it

OP posts:
PumpkinPieAlibi · 01/11/2026 22:35

Rainnsgyin · 01/11/2026 21:56

It’s not the changing of the plan. It’s the fact he didn’t even say and then was completely not arsed about breakfast (I admit that was me testing the waters after the hug scenario).

If you're going to play games like that (because that's what you cancelling breakfast was), then it's best you don't bother with dating right now.

DozyDumpling · 01/11/2026 22:35

You aren’t ready.

A simple “are you still popping in” would have given you a clear answer. Instead of that you cancelled a date in the hope he would ask you to reconsider. You’re playing games rather than being clear about what you want and need.

Cheeseplantalltheway · 01/11/2026 22:49

OP I understand that you felt hurt and let down. But you really don't know what was going on in his mind.

He's taken you at face value about cancelling breakfast. Probably has no idea that you were testing him.

I hope it doesn't sound harsh but I think that communicating openly would serve you better than cancelling out of hurt. I speak from experience!

Mossyfox · 01/11/2026 22:52

Chunkybabythighs · 01/11/2026 21:57

You cancelled breakfast! What's he meant to do, weep?!

Exactly. He's probably the one asking why.

Excellentsausages · 01/11/2026 22:53

If I'd cancelled plans with DH when we were dating, as you have cancelled the breakfast, as a test to see what his reaction would be, he would have said 'ok not a problem see you [date of next planned thing]'. He would have asked if I was ok but more that he would have been worried i had a family emergency/work problem etc, it wouldn't be a relationship check-in.

He wouldn't know it was a test, and he would never in a million years have replied with emotional reassurance about the relationship that he wouldn't have known was needed.

I think the most worrying thing is that you haven't just asked in a simple clear way 'aren't you popping round later'? If you had you'd know why he didn't.

Perhaps this is patterns of behaviour from previous relationships leaking in to this one? Maybe talking to a counsellor might help as it could give tips and confidence in communicating directly?

WitchesBritches · 01/11/2026 22:53

He was originally just popping in on the way home from his dinner, he phoned you to let you know he was on his way home. He was probably expecting you to say 'great. I'll see you in 10 minutes' or something, but you didn't so he went home and didn't go via your place. Then you cancel breakfast. He probably assumed something had come up with DD and it was no longer convenient. you have a child plans will get changed and he's OK with that. You're making a huge bloody mountain out of a molehill.. You asked the other poster if this was fixable, it was never broken in the first place, other than in your head.

just message him tomorrow morning and ask him if he wants to have lunch together/have dinner together, whatever works for your plans tomorrow.

& take it from there.

DewDropsAndCobWebs · 01/11/2026 22:54

It sounds like you feel he isn't engaged enough, is not reading your feelings, which made you feel uncertain?

DeadPlants · 01/11/2026 22:55

I'd be a bit miffed if he didn't tell me he wasn't coming, and I'd assume he can't be that into me if he "forgot". When you really like someone you don't forget; you're excited to see them.

aquashiv · 01/11/2026 22:58

I get you, Op. I don’t like it when people forget an arrangement either. My time is precious. Why didn’t you call him?

Swipe left for the next trending thread