Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be upset that DH is prioritising a trip with his mate over a family holiday?

43 replies

frdrk · 01/11/2026 19:12

DH is currently on garden leave (for anyone unfamiliar, this is when you’re still employed and being paid during your notice period, but aren’t required to work). When we first found out he’d be on garden leave we’d discussed going away as a family during the early Christmas holidays (so after school holidays start but before around the 22nd, when we’d normally have family over or go to visit family etc). No specific destination agreed, just a chance to have a proper family holiday while he has the flexibility and we don’t have to work around his annual leave. However, one of his friends has since suggested a trip to somewhere DH has always wanted to visit. He’s now changed his mind about the family holiday, saying that everywhere would be too cold at that time of year and we’d be better off just doing a shorter break somewhere in the UK for one night, if anything at all.

I’m fairly sure the real reason is financial, although he says the trip with his friend would cost far less than the portion of the family holiday that comes out of his salary. I run my own business, which means I have complete flexibility over when I work and when I don’t. Our finances are separate, and I’m not going to go into the reasons for that or respond to questions or comments about how we arrange our finances. I’m just explaining the context. We split the cost of family holidays 50/50, whereas his trip with his friend would be paid for entirely by him.

I completely understand that he should be able to have time away with friends, and I’m not suggesting he shouldn’t. But what I find difficult is that the family holiday is lower down in priority than a trip with a friend, particularly when we’d already discussed going away together and he now seems to have gone off the idea because something more appealing has come along.

Am I being unreasonable, or would you also be hurt by this?

OP posts:
MyLimeGuide · 01/11/2026 19:18

You say the family holiday was discussed? Was it your idea? Did he agree to it? If it was a mutual plan then he is being unreasonable.

OffTheMap · 01/11/2026 19:20

I would be furious and upset

Why can’t he go with the mate at the beginning of December?

Is it a once in a lifetime opportunity or something?

Is the destination the mate suggested somewhere that you would want to go to as a family rather than with his mate?

These men and their mates, it’s so immature once they have family.

Well lesson learned about locking plans in fast.

I’d be tempted to go away with the kids without him.

PopcornKitten · 01/11/2026 19:22

Reading your post, it sounds like he was quite happy to go away with the family until this opportunity came up with his friend. Had he already committed to dates, location etc with you? Or was it just a general chat rather than specifics?

ShattonerfDaParp · 01/11/2026 19:24

It sounds like the 'family holiday' plan was still just a notion and not really a plan at all, so I wouldn't be too upset. Plus while a getaway shortly before Christmas sounds good on paper, in my experience they're actually a PITA when there's so much else in the calendar and so much else to be planned for. I'd let it go.

PollyBell · 01/11/2026 19:24

We decided on a family holiday or you decided?

frdrk · 01/11/2026 19:53

Just to clarify…

we had an initial discussion of “shall we go away somewhere in early Xmas holidays?” “Yes absolutely!” “Let’s do it”. No destination was agreed but the dates were agreed vaguely - after school term ends but before all of our wider family Xmas celebrations begin.

the mate holiday isn’t over the same dates. The reason it’s an “either this holiday or that” is because I think part of the reason he’s now saying he doesn’t want to go on the family holiday is financial ie it’ll be too expensive for him. The numbers I’m giving are made up (as I don’t 100% know the costs since neither holiday is yet booked and we don’t even know the exact location for our potential Xmas holiday) but to make it easier to visualise. The mates holiday will be £1000, family holiday will cost him £3000 (again, let’s not get into discussing whether how to make it cheaper, where we could go, what it would buy, if they’re too much etc, because numbers are for illustrative purposes only). Yes the 3K is more than the 1K but if you never spend the 1K then that could be put towards the family holiday to make it affordable if after already spending the 1K on mates holiday, spending 3K on family holiday becomes unaffordable. The other reasons he’s citing is that apparently weather isn’t too good that time of year anywhere abroad (realistically we won’t have more than a week so it’d be Europe) but it’s not like it’s great weather in the UK either?

OP posts:
Arbourimage · 01/11/2026 19:56

Is there even time for a family holiday between schools breaking up and the 22nd of dec?
Don’t most schools break up on the Friday so it would only be a long weekend anyway?

Whenisitsummer · 01/11/2026 19:57

I wouldn't want to pay 6k for a family holiday in Europe in December.
Perhaps he feels the same way ?

frdrk · 01/11/2026 19:57

@Arbourimagewe have around a week in the school my children go to

OP posts:
frdrk · 01/11/2026 19:58

@Whenisitsummer see above point about numbers being for illustrative purposes only

OP posts:
PopcornKitten · 01/11/2026 20:53

I understand what you’re saying OP. Before the mate mentioned a holiday your DH was happy with the financial commitment to your family holiday. Now the additional trip with his mate will be an added financial pressure and rather than say no to his mate he is choosing to say no to you.
quite simply, he should only go on the trip with his mate if there is enough money after booking the family trip away.
i still think YANBU

somanychristmaslights · 01/11/2026 20:58

You need to say that last paragraph in your opening post to him.

rookiemere · 02/11/2026 07:00

I get what you’re saying OP and I also would be hurt by his choices. However unless you’re going to Canaries which are hideously expensive in winter school holidays and not really worth the high price, most of Europe will be cold and possibly rainy.

Presumably he will get holidays in the new job. So why not get a week or fortnight locked in for the summer holidays now and organise a holiday for that ideally when Black Friday discounts arrive.

Moonnstarz · 02/11/2026 07:18

Hmm yes I think he should prioritise the family holiday, however as you have added the costs then maybe there is more to it and he feels he cannot pay the amount required for the family holiday.

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · 02/11/2026 07:20

This is the price you pay for having weird rules about separate finances.

Just go on holiday with out him 🤷

99bottlesofkombucha · 02/11/2026 07:22

Years of marriage have taught me not to cover up when I and the family are deprioritised, nor to let him put us last and expect us to wait for him, so I’d say to him what I thought, and before that conversation plan a feasible holiday with the dc at that time with just you. Then you I’d tell him: Dh, I think all your reasons for not doing a family holiday are just made up excuses, the reason is finances and you prefer your holiday with your friend. I’m hurt by that to be honest, and I take lessons for our marriage that I should probably prioritise me more, like you do. In my case it’s usually prioritising me and the kids. I hope this is the marriage you want, it’s not really what I wanted, but I’m taking the kids away for a few days anyway, I’ll have a family holiday with my children.

Lexibletheflexible · 02/11/2026 07:22

frdrk · 01/11/2026 19:53

Just to clarify…

we had an initial discussion of “shall we go away somewhere in early Xmas holidays?” “Yes absolutely!” “Let’s do it”. No destination was agreed but the dates were agreed vaguely - after school term ends but before all of our wider family Xmas celebrations begin.

the mate holiday isn’t over the same dates. The reason it’s an “either this holiday or that” is because I think part of the reason he’s now saying he doesn’t want to go on the family holiday is financial ie it’ll be too expensive for him. The numbers I’m giving are made up (as I don’t 100% know the costs since neither holiday is yet booked and we don’t even know the exact location for our potential Xmas holiday) but to make it easier to visualise. The mates holiday will be £1000, family holiday will cost him £3000 (again, let’s not get into discussing whether how to make it cheaper, where we could go, what it would buy, if they’re too much etc, because numbers are for illustrative purposes only). Yes the 3K is more than the 1K but if you never spend the 1K then that could be put towards the family holiday to make it affordable if after already spending the 1K on mates holiday, spending 3K on family holiday becomes unaffordable. The other reasons he’s citing is that apparently weather isn’t too good that time of year anywhere abroad (realistically we won’t have more than a week so it’d be Europe) but it’s not like it’s great weather in the UK either?

How many fanily holidays has he had in the past decade vs trips away with mates?

99bottlesofkombucha · 02/11/2026 07:24

rookiemere · 02/11/2026 07:00

I get what you’re saying OP and I also would be hurt by his choices. However unless you’re going to Canaries which are hideously expensive in winter school holidays and not really worth the high price, most of Europe will be cold and possibly rainy.

Presumably he will get holidays in the new job. So why not get a week or fortnight locked in for the summer holidays now and organise a holiday for that ideally when Black Friday discounts arrive.

He can do that organising for a summer holiday, I’d be planning the December trip without him, making it a bit shorter. Many men expect fun family life to happen magically and when suits them.

Celer · 02/11/2026 07:27

Don’t mean to sidetrack but, boy - you do know mumsnet so well! I love the way you have built in gentle guidance to keep the thread on track!

It’s the DC I’d feel for here - you could do tit for tat and take a holiday without him too at a different date but no one then takes the dc on holiday.

HelloCheekyCat · 02/11/2026 07:31

love the way you have built in gentle guidance to keep the thread on track!

And posters still ignore it.or don't read it 🙄

I think @99bottlesofkombucha post is really good, I think it's a really calm way of getting your point across and if possible I think you should take the DC on their own

Ophy83 · 02/11/2026 07:31

I can see your frustration as you were probably just starting to get excited about planning a lovely break. When did you last have a family holiday, do you go away regularly and when did he last have a trip with friends?

BIossomtoes · 02/11/2026 07:33

Thisusernameisalwaysavailable · 02/11/2026 07:20

This is the price you pay for having weird rules about separate finances.

Just go on holiday with out him 🤷

It’s not a price we’ve ever paid. There are many valid reasons for having separate finances. It’s not remotely weird.

ItsWoudHaveNotWouldOf · 02/11/2026 07:33

Tell him how you feel. That you'd been excited at the thought of getting away as a family, without having the usual challenge of managing around his annual leave and it's hurtful he's changed his mind for a better offer.

Question for you OP...who normally does most of the work around Christmas? The shopping, gift wrapping, cleaning, cooking, hosting etc? If you're doing the lion's share then it would be nice to have a holiday to recharge and have a bit of fun before all that begins.

If he's worried about the cost of both holidays, tell him he should consider the price of prioritising his friend over his family.

Theredjellybean · 02/11/2026 07:35

As he is on gardening leave I presume he's picking up the slack at home ? So I'd be telling him how very busy my business is around the proposed mates trip and what exactly is he going to do about his his responsibilities to the kids while he's away ? Because I'd be really cross and hurt too.
I like the post about being upfront about what you feel and how this kind of behaviour damages marriages.
And then start prioritising yourself occasionally

CorporalJohn · 02/11/2026 07:36

As explained, YABU. The family holiday was a suggestion. No decision seems to have been made as to destination etc. The holiday with his friend(s) is a concrete proposal.

Swipe left for the next trending thread